Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCLD-001-15 Clarington Clerk's Report If this information is required in an alternate accessible format, please contact the Municipal Clerk at 905-623-3379 ext. 2102. Report To: General Purpose and Administration Committee Date of Meeting: January 5, 2015 Report Number: CLD-001-15 Resolution Number: G)P ° File Number: By-law Number: Report Subject: Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Status Report Recommendations: 1. That Report CLD-001-15 be received for information. Municipality of Clarington Report CLD-001-15 Page 2 Report Overview This report provides a status update of the tasks included in the Municipality of Clarington's 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan. 1 . Background In accordance with the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act(AODA), municipalities are required to establish, implement, maintain and document a multi-year accessibility plan, which outlines the organization's strategy to prevent and remove barriers and meet its requirements under the Integrated Standards Regulation. Clarington's Multi-Year Accessibility Plan was established in 2013 (Attachment 1). The AODA requires that organizations review the plan once a year. 2. Review The Multi-Year Accessibility Plan has been reviewed by Staff (Attachment 2) and posted on the municipality's website, www.clarington.net. It highlights activities in 2014 and sets out a timeline for completing future tasks. Although much was accomplished in 2014, it was not without its challenges. The Municipal Clerk is Clarington's Accessibility Coordinator. As such, most of the tasks are initiated and/or guided by the Clerk's Department. The Clerk's Department went through multiple staffing changes while preparing for the municipal elections. In addition, we responded to an Accessibility Directorate of Ontario (ADO) accessibility audit in August and as a result, we were issued with a compliance order, with a November 28, 2014 compliance deadline: • ensure that all employees, volunteers, etc. were trained in the Integrated Accessibility Regulations Standards and the Human Rights Code legislation • ensure that several new policies were implement With the assistance of all employees, we were able to pass the compliance order. However, this has been a wake up call that the ADO takes compliance very seriously. The Clerk's Department will be striving to meet the deadlines outlined in the attached plan and update and looks forward to receiving Council's support regarding accessibility initiatives in 2015. 3. Concurrence Not Applicable. NOTE: Once the new Clarington Accessibility Advisory Committee is appointed, the item will be placed on their meeting agenda. Municipality of Clarington Report CLD-001-15 Page 3 4. Conclusion It is respectfully recommended that the status update be received for information. 5. Strategic Plan Application Not applicable. Submitted by: �' Reviewed by: An reentree Franklin Wu, Municipal Clerk Chief Administrative Officer Staff Contact: June Gallagher, Deputy Clerk, 905-623-3379 ext. 2103 or jgallagher @clarington.net Attachments: Attachment 1 — Clarington's Multi-Year Accessibility Plan 2013-2017 Attachment 2 — Status Update to the Multi-Year Accessibility Plan, December, 2014 There are no interested parties to be notified of Council's decision. CAG/jg ATTACHNIE !T# TO REPORT# • Leading the Way 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan In Accordance With The Accessibility For Ontarians With Disabilities Act DECEMBER 2013 Alternative formats available upon request. INTRODUCTION The Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005 (AODA) received Royal Assent on June 13, 2005. This legislation builds on the Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2001, in ensuring a fully accessible Province of Ontario by 2025. The AODA includes accessibility standards addressing customer service, transportation, accessible information and communications, accessible built environment and employment accessibility. The first of the standards to be legislated was the Customer Service Standard which came into effect January 1 , 2008 and municipalities and other designated public sector organizations had to comply with the regulation by January 1 , 2010. The Integrated Accessibility Standard has combined the areas of information and communication, transportation and employment. These standards apply to the Government of Ontario, the Legislative Assembly, every designated public sector organization and every person or organization that provides goods, services and facilities to the public or other third parties and that has at least one employee in Ontario. Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 2 The standard specifies various timelines for the requirements to be met and addresses such items as the provision of accessible formats and communication supports for persons with disabilities, providing accessibility for people with disabilities during their employment life cycle and easy access to transportation services. THE ACCESSIBILITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE The legislation requires that municipalities appoint an Accessibility Advisory Committee (AAC). The Municipality of Clarington's AAC, in accordance with legislation, consists of a majority of members with disabilities, who work alongside staff to develop and facilitate strategies toward a barrier-free Clarington for citizens with disabilities. AAC Past Activities In accordance with the AODA, the Municipality adopted the Accessibility Policy which addresses the accessibility requirements related to customer service (ie, accessible formats, notice of temporary disruptions, use of service animals and support persons, feedback process and Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 3 assistive devices), Information and Communication Support (ie, Communication, accessible websites and web content, emergency procedures, HR policies and supports, accessible formats) and transportation standards. The Accessibility Committee continues to focus ongoing efforts in educating the public of accessibility issues within the community. Efforts to do so included the participation at Maplefest in downtown Bowmanville in early May to disseminate information related to accessibility issues and the committee as well as information published in the Wilmot Creek newsletter to advise the residents of that community of the existence of the committee and ways in which we can assist with identification and elimination of barriers. Concerns with respect to accessibility in public buildings are being investigated and addressed by the Committee, when brought forward by members of the public and members of the Committee. Recommendations are being made to the owners of the buildings for implementation. In addition, improvements in accessible features are being recognized by the Committee by way of congratulatory letter. Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 4 The Committee continues to work closely with counterparts throughout the Region of Durham. The Committee Chair participated in an Emergency Evacuation Exercise which was undertaken in Clarington and members of the Committee attended the annual Regional Forum where representation from all eight municipalities was present. A presentation was received from the Bowmanville Creek Anglers Association who was enthusiastic about erecting an accessible fishing platform on the Bowmanville Creek. In response to the presentation, the Committee provided funding for the project and also nominated the Association for an Accessibility Award through Durham Region. At the EmployABILITY Awards and Gala, the Committee was pleased to learn that the Association was the recipient of the award. Issues with respect to accessibility in all facilities, public and private, continue to be of paramount concern to the Committee and the members will continue to address issues as they become known to them. Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 5 Municipal staff continue to keep accessibility at the forefront when reviewing and/or implementing policies and when developing projects. The Emergency and Fire Services Department, together with the Ontario Fire Marshal and Grandview Children's Centre, has recently launched a new program called "Think Ahead". The program encourages Grandview clients to request a home visit from the fire services to educate the family in fire safety, fire prevention, emergency planning and escape planning. In so doing, the department becomes familiar with the family's challenges and the child's characteristics. The Treasury Department has undertaken a renovation of their Tax customer service area to address accessibility issues for the public and employees. This construction commenced in December and is anticipated to be complete in early 2014. In conjunction with the Human Resources Department, information was distributed to all employees regarding individual Employee Workplace Emergency Response Plans and responses received were followed up on. Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 6 In order to address training requirements of the AODA, a team of trainers completed "Train the Trainer" workshops regarding the Integrated Accessibility Standards Regulation. This team will be implementing and facilitating training sessions for staff, volunteers and suppliers of the Municipality. A working group representing all departments of the Municipality is commencing work on making all municipal documents accessible. This is a large project which will be ongoing throughout 2014. Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 7 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Municipality of Clarington Legislated Our Proposed Completion Date for General Deliverables Implementation Date Public Date Sector (January) Policies & Procedures 2013 2013 Create Policies with Statement of Organizational 2013 2013 Commitment in written form Approval and Sign off 2013 2013 Make available to the Public 2013 2013 Available in Alternative Formats - upon request 2013 2013 Accessibility Plan - Multi Year 2013 2013 Develop Accessibility Plan 2013 2013 Accessibility Plans- Post to web 2013 2013 Prepare an Annual Status Report and post 2013 2013 Review every 5 years Provide in alternative format 2013 2013 Procuring or Acquiring Goods or Services - 2013 2013 develop procedure for this If not practicable, provide an explanation. Create 2013 template. Accessibility Self Service Kiosk - have regard for 2013 2013 Training -All employees &volunteers, policy developers, those providing goods or services on behalf of organization regarding IRS and Human 2014 Rights Code Decide on training delivery Create schedule for current staff and new staff Training completed Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 8 Legislated Our Proposed Date of Date for Information & Communications Date for Completion Public Implementation Sector (January) Emergency Procedure Plans or Public Safety 2012 2012 Information - inventory and make accessible Feedback- is feedback system accessible upon 2014 request Accessible formats and communication supports upon request (timely manner, no cost charged to 2015 other persons) Create inventory of current documents Create document renewal plan Create Strategic Communication Plan -create processes for flow of documents, who creates source documents, who ensures pdfs are accessible, who checks for accessibility before posting to website, decide on corporate wide fonts, staff training on accessible document creation, analysis of website content and new content Website New Internet WCAG 2.0 Level AA (other 2014 then closed caption Live pre-recorded audio) All internet websites and web content WCAG 2.0 Level AA 2021 Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 9 Legislated Our Proposed Date of Date for Employment Date for Completion Public Implementation Sector (January) HR Staff to develop deliverables and processes for below Workplace Emergency Response - process 2012 2012 Recruitment- notify employees and public regarding availability of accommodation Notify applicant- availability of accommodation 2014 upon request for assessments or selection process Inform employees of policies regarding job 2014 accommodations Accessible formats and communication supports available to perform job 2014 Have a Documented Individual Accessibility Plan 2014 Have a Return to Work Process 2014 Performance Management takes into account 2014 accessibility needs Career Development and Advancement Process 2014 takes into account accessibility needs Redeployment process takes into account 2014 ,accessibility needs Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 10 Legislated Our Proposed Date of Date for Public Spaces Date for Completion Public Implementation Sector (January) Incorporate the Design of Public Spaces on newly developed or redeveloped recreational trails and beach access routes, outdoor public use eating 2016 areas, outdoor play spaces, exterior paths of travel, accessible parking and service related elements If developing Recreational Trails, Outdoor Play Spaces, Exterior Paths of Travel, Rest Areas, or On- 2016 Street Parking, consult with public, persons with disabilities and municipal AAC if there is one Provide maintenance and restoration of public 2016 spaces Develop procedures for preventative and 2016 emergency maintenance of accessible elements in Develop procedures for dealing with temporary 2016 disruptions when accessible elements under public, Report every three years as of December 31, 2013 2016 Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Page 11 Communication of the Plan This plan will be available on the Municipality's website and at the Municipal Administrative Centre. Every attempt will be made to have it available to those with disabilities. Questions related to this Plan should be directed to: Municipal Clerk Municipality of Clarington 40 Temperance Street Bowmanvi Ile, Ontario L1 C 3A6 Telephone: (905) 623-3379 E-Mail: clerksa-clarington.net , !�TTACNn,j'+RlT # ��� T0� Ri:�OgT # C �= C n ]a Leading the Way Status Report — December, 2014 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibilit y Plan In Accordance with the Accessibility For Ontarians With Disabilities Act This document is available in alternative formats upon request. 2014 Status Update to CladnCtOH 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way Table of Contents ContactInformation .........................................................................................................3 Introduction......................................................................................................................4 Obligations.......................................................................................................................4 Accomplishmentsin 2014................................................................................................5 GeneralRequirements.................................................................................................5 Accessible Customer Service Standard.......................................................................8 Information & Communications Standard.....................................................................9 EmploymentStandard..................................................................................................9 Goalsfor 2015...............................................................................................................11 GeneralRequirements...............................................................................................11 Information & Communications Standard...................................................................12 EmploymentStandard................................................................................................13 Design of Public Spaces Standard.............................................................................13 Page 2 of 13 • 2014 Status Update to Clarinaon 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way Contact Information Municipality: Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington Address: 40 Temperance St. Bowmanville, ON L1C 3A6 Website: www.clarington.net Key Contact(s): Anne Greentree, Municipal Clerk. B.A., CMO 905-623-3379 ext. 2102 agreentree(a-)-clarington.net Page 3 of 13 2014 Status Update to Clarinaton 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way Introduction This update to the Clarington Multi-Year Accessibility Plan outlines the commitment that the Municipality of Clarington has made to create an accessible organization by identifying, removing, and preventing barriers for people with disabilities. This document provides an update on accomplishments achieved and also adds information on upcoming plans. This plan will be posted on the Municipality of Clarington's website, www.clarington.net, and shall be made available in alternative formats upon request. Obligations Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2001 (ODA) The ODA was passed into law "to improve opportunities for persons with disabilities and to provide for their full involvement in the identification, prevention and removal of barriers to their full participation in the life of the Province." The ODA requires municipalities to prepare annual accessibility plans and to consult with an Accessibility Advisory Committee on the contents of the plan. The purpose of the plan is to identify, remove, and prevent barriers to accessibility in each municipality's by-laws, policies, practices, and services. The accessibility plan must be made available to the public, and in alternative formats, upon request. Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005 (AODA) The AODA includes accessibility standards addressing customer service, transportation, accessible information and communications, accessible built environment and employment accessibility. Page 4 of 13 2014 Status Update to Cladnaton 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way Accomplishments in 2014 Summary General Deliverables Legislated Date Training - All employees & volunteers, policy developers, those providing goods or services on behalf of organization 2014 regarding IRS and Human Rights Code Decide on training delivery Create schedule for current staff and new staff Training completed Information & Communications Legislated Date Feedback - is feedback system accessible upon request 2014 Website New Internet WCAG 2.0 Level AA (other then closed caption Live pre-recorded audio). (Currently under 2014 reconstruction, to be completed in 2015.) Employment Legislated Date Recruitment - notify employees and public regarding 2014 availability of accommodation Notify successful applicant - availability of accommodation upon request for assessments or selection 2014 process Inform employees of policies regarding job 2014 accommodations Accessible formats and communication supports 2014 available to perform job Have a Documented Individual Accessibility Plan 2014 Have a Return to Work Process (E-31) 2014 Performance Management takes into account 2014 accessibility needs Career Development and Advancement Process takes 2014 into account accessibility needs Redeployment process takes into account accessibility 2014 needs Page 5 of 13 2014 Status Update to Clarinaton 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way Details General Requirements Accessibility Advisory Committee: The Clarington Accessibility Advisory Committee (CAAC) has provided input and advice to Council on a broad range of matters in 2014, including but not limited to: • Workplace Scent-Free Policy • GO Bus Access • Multi-Year Accessibility Plan • Reviewed proposals from various organizations which have a view to improving accessibility in several aspects of life, with a particular focus on sports • Reviewed the Accessible Election Policies and Procedures • Reviewed the proposed expansion of the Courtice Library On an ongoing basis, CAAC participates in the Regional Accessibility Advisory Committee Chairs Group; provides an information card regarding CAAC to all recreational facilities; and advocates for increased awareness of accessibility. A sub-committee of the CAAC reviewed and provided comments on ten site plan applications during 2014. As well, in 2014 the role of this sub-committee was expanded to include a review and comment process for any municipal park or open space design or re-design work. Policies and Procedures: The Clerk's Department's Staff Training and Orientation Policy (H12-001) was updated to ensure that training of the all new employees, volunteers, etc., will be undertaken as part of their orientation. Training will include: • Accessible Customer Service Training • Human Rights Code as it pertains to accessibility • Integrated Accessibility Standards Regulation Policy Training The Municipality of Clarington is committed to ensuring that persons with disabilities have an opportunity to fully participate in the Municipal Elections with dignity and in a manner consistent with all Clarington electors. The Clerk's Department's Accessible Election Policies and Procedures (C07-011) was updated to reflect this commitment. A variety of voting assistive devices were available for electors to use at the Advance Page 6 of 13 2014 Status Update to Clatinaton 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way Voting opportunities and on Voting Day, including Magnifying sheets, Variety of marking tools, Audio/tactile voting assistive tool, large ballot images, etc. Special Mail-in Ballot opportunities were provided to those with a physical incapacity. Proxy voting was available to all eligible electors. Voting assistance, either by an election official or another qualified elector, was available. The Municipality of Clarington established the Corporate Policy, "Accessibility/Accommodation" (A15) which sets out the requirements of Ontario Regulation 191/11 — Integrated Accessibility Standards, Part 3 (Employment). The Municipality of Clarington expanded its existing "Fragrance Free Policy for Recreational Facilities" to apply to all municipal facilities. Accessibility Plan — Multi-Year: Clarington's Multi-year accessibility plan was developed in consultation with the Clarington Accessibility Advisory Committee and passed by Clarington's Council on April 7, 2014. The accessibility plan is available on Clarington's website. Procuring or Acquiring Goods or Services: Clarington's Request for Proposal documents now include weighted evaluation criteria taking accessibility into consideration. Changes were made to the purchasing procedure manual giving consideration to accessibility design, criteria or features when procuring. Tender documents are now being issued in a more accessible font and now include a contractor AODA Compliance Sign-off sheet. Training: In-person training, specific to procurement, was undertaken by all employees in the Purchasing Department. In accordance with the requirements under the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005 and Regulation 191/11, all Clarington staff, volunteers, people who participate in developing Clarington's policies, and all other people who provide goods, services or facilities on behalf of our organization, were trained on the requirements of the accessibility standards referred to in the Regulation and on the Human Rights Code as it pertains to persons with disabilities. The training was offered electronically, and for those who did not have access to the internet, they completed their training through the use of a workbook. Department Heads and managers were provided with in-person training. Page 7 of 13 2014 Status Update to Clarinaton 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the way As of December 20, 2014, 819 persons have completed training, including employees, Members of Council, crossing guards, Animal Services volunteers, and Clarington Older Adult Association vendors. The intent of the training was to provide an understanding of the requirements of the regulation as they relate to their duties and of the Ontario Human Rights Code as it relates to people with disabilities. Specific items covered in the training include: • Background on the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005 (AODA) • Disability types • Barriers to accessibility • The five standards under the AODA • Specific requirements of the Integrated Accessibility Standards Regulation (IASR): o Policy and plan o Procurement and self service kiosks o Training requirements o Information and Communication standard o Employment Standard o Transportation Standard (as applicable) o Design of Public Spaces Standard • Human Rights Code as it pertains to people with disabilities • Discussion on how this applies to individual employees • Where to get more information on organizational commitment and on the legislation Accessible Customer Service Standard Since adopting the Customer Service Standards Policy in 2009 (Policy F6), the Municipality of Clarington has continued its commitment to providing exceptional and accessible service for its customers. Goods and services are provided in a manner that respects the dignity and independence of all customers. The provision of services to persons with disabilities are integrated wherever possible. Persons with disabilities are given an opportunity equal to that given to others, to obtain, use or benefit from the goods and services provided by and on behalf of the Municipality of Clarington. Page 8 of 13 2014 Status Update to Cladn,2tOH 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way Information & Communications Standard General: We made strides into ensuring that all information has a note indicating that alternative formats are available. This includes each webpage on our website. Training: All Administrative Assistants were provided in-person training regarding accessible documents. This was provided with the view that the Administrative Assistants would be able to provide support to all those in their respective departments. The following support documents, for making accessible documents, were created and provided to those during training: • Clarington Accessible Documents Tip Sheet • Accessible Websites • Alternative Formats • Checking for Accessibility • Defining Accessibility • Presentations • Shortcuts • Spreadsheets Employment Standard Updated the Corporate Policy "Early and Safe Return to Work" (H31) to ensure that it complied with the Employment Standard. Advertisements and website advertising vacancies now include a notification regarding the availability of accommodation. All employment letters advise of accommodation opportunities. All employees are informed of policies regarding job accommodations. Durham Region Transit (DRT) Specialized Service Appeals Beginning in the last quarter of 2014, as accessibility coordinator for the Municipality, along with the other coordinators within Durham Region, began serving on the Appeal Panel for the DRT Specialized Service Appeals. This appeal process serves for an appeal panel to hear and make recommendations on appeal applications from individuals requesting review of a decision made by DRT Specialized Services establishing them as ineligible to receive specialized transit services. The appeal process is intended to ensure that applications are dealt with in a fair and independent manner, and decisions are made in accordance with established criteria. The appeal Page 9 of 13 2014 Status Update to C]aF!n,2tOH 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way panel, appointed by DIRT but operating independently, has the final authority on decisions regarding eligibility for specialized transit services provided by DIRT. The Eligibility Appeal Process complies with the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act (AODA), adhering to the process and timeframes established within the AODA and its regulations, specifically with respect to eligibility appeals. The primary responsibility of the Eligibility Appeal Process is to ensure the appropriate matching of transit service delivery options with the nature of the disability, for those individuals who have appealed the decision of DIRT Specialized Services. The appeal panel in hearing appeals bases its decision upon either new information provided by the appellant and/or a claim of misinterpretation of previously submitted information. Appeals based solely on compassionate grounds shall not be considered. Page 10 of 13 2014 Status Update to Cladnaton 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way Goals for 2015 General Requirements Clarington Accessibility Advisory Committee: The Committee plans to: • Review their Goals and Objectives for the Term, early in 2015 • Create a Site Plan Review Guideline document, to be given to applicants prior to submission of a site plan application • Create guidelines for members to follow when reviewing site plan applications, i.e. "Things to look for" • Physical inspection/review of municipal facilities • Ask Department Heads to make presentations to the Committee in order to gain a greater understanding of each department • Have a greater involvement in the ongoing goal of making documents and information more accessible • Consider hosting an accessible challenge Training: Training for new employees, volunteers, etc., will be undertaken as part of their orientation, in accordance with the Clerk's Department's Staff Training and Orientation Policy (H12-001). Continue to ensure that all new contractors and companies are trained. Provide members of Clarington's advisory boards and committees with training on Accessible Customer Service Training; Human Rights Code as it pertains to accessibility; Integrated Accessibility Standards Regulation Policy Training; and Making Documents Accessible. Purchasing By-law: By March 31, 2015, complete review of Purchasing By-law to include a section on Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act as well as incorporating accessibility criteria and features when acquiring goods, services or facilities. Page 11 of 13 2014 Status Update to Clarinaton 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the way Information & Communications Standard General: Continue to add information to our communications indicating that alternative formats are available. The Clarington website is currently under "reconstruction" and we expect that it will be WCAG Level AA compliant by the third quarter of 2015. Accessible Documents: Continue to ensure that all documentation uploaded to the Municipality's website and Intranet is in an accessible format, from 2012 and no later than January 1, 2021. Council. Create a Strategic Communication Plan which will describe the processes for the flow of documents, establish standards and templates, continuous training on accessible document creation, and analysis of website content. The development of the Plan will include an undertaking of an inventory of documents currently forming part of our public document repository and developing a go-forward approach for facilitating easy and readily available access. Emergency Procedure Plans: Conduct a review of the emergency procedures, plans and public safety information. Feedback: Appendix E of Clarington's Corporate Policy, F6 (Accessibility), contains the policy and procedures for customer feedback as it relates to the municipality's provision of all goods and services. The Municipality of Clarington plans to promote the availability of this feedback process in the coming year. Page 12 of 13 2014 Status Update to Clarinaton 2013-2017 Multi-Year Accessibility Plan Leading the Way Employment Standard Establish an Individual Accessibility Plan and ensure that: • performance management process • career development/advancement process • Redeployment process take accessibility needs into account. Design of Public Spaces Standard In preparation for the requirements of 2016, the Municipality of Clarington will consult with the public and people with disabilities to meet specific technical requirements when building any new or making any significant changes to: • recreational trails/beach access routes • outdoor public eating areas • outdoor play spaces • outdoor paths of travel (sidewalks, ramps, stairs, curbs, pedestrian signals) • accessible parking • or service-related elements (such as service counters, fixed queuing lines and waiting areas) Page 13 of 13