Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutFND-049-20Clarington Staff Report If this information is required in an alternate accessible format, please contact the Accessibility Coordinator at 905-623-3379 ext. 2131. Report To: General Government Committee Date of Meeting: November 30, 2020 Report Number: FND-049-20 Submitted By: Trevor Pinn, Director of Financial Services Reviewed By: File Number: Andrew C. Allison, CAO By-law Number: Resolution#: GG-455-20 Report Subject: Financial Update as at September 30, 2020 Recommendation: 1. That Report FND-049-20 be received for information. Municipality of Clarington Report FND-049-20 Report Overview Page 2 The COVID-19 pandemic has had a lasting impact on the Municipality of Clarington. It has changed the way in which we provide services (a strong movement towards online services), work, and live. The Municipality's most significant financial impact has been the reduction of services in Community Services. This continued to affect revenues in the third quarter even as programs and facilities began to open back up. The Municipality was able to mitigate these losses and at the end of September 30, 2020 we are trending positively despite seeing reductions in investment revenue. The attached report provides information on the variances by service area with anecdotal commentary where appropriate. 1. Background Quarterly Reporting 1.1 The Budget Policy outlines a requirement for the Treasurer to report to Council on a quarterly basis each year starting with the second quarter. This report fulfills that reporting requirement. New Format for Quarterly Report 1.2 To improve the usefulness of the information, and consistency of format with the annual budget, the quarterly report is attached to this report as Attachment #1. Each department is broken down by sub -department with the expenses grouped together like the requirements for financial reporting and the 2020 annual budget. 1.3 Where there are key variances, these have been identified and are expanded upon for Council's, and the public's, information. 1.4 This report is solely for operating expenses, Finance will be reporting separately in on the capital budget. The capital budget will be reported on semi-annually, once in the fall which captures the "construction season" to September 30t", and once in the spring which summarizes the prior year's activities. 2. Impact of COVID-19 2.1 Where appropriate, the impact of COVID-19 has been identified and discussed in Attachment #1. Municipality of Clarington Report FND-049-20 3. Concurrence Not Applicable. 4. Conclusion It is respectfully recommended that the report be received for information. Page 3 Staff Contact: Trevor Pinn, Director of Financial Services/Treasurer, 905-623-3379 ext. 2602, tpinn clarington.net Attachments: Attachment 1 — Financial Update for the Period Ending September 30, 2020 Interested Parties: There are no interested parties to be notified of Council's decision. Attachment 1 to Report FND-049-20 Financial Update Pit Mr at September 30,2020 ell Wil Financial Update for the period ending September 30, 2020 (unaudited) This report 'aims to provide Council with an update on the Municipality of Clarington's financial activity through the third quarter of 2020 and compare it with the same period in 2019. This report will provide a financial overview of budget variances as of September 30, 2020, and essential non -financial functions of the Municipality such as service level achievements or deficits that have been realized within the reported quarter, a review of COVID- 19 impacts and department initiatives. COVID-19 Implications In August 2020, the Province of Ontario announced funding for the Safe Restart Program. The Municipality was allocated approximately $2.1 million through phase 1 of this program. The receipt of these funds will be reflected in the fourth-quarter financial report. As of September 30, 2020, there have not been any updates on the funding announcement. Funding under this program provides support for expenses and revenue pressures associated with the COVID-19 pandemic. Suppose the Municipality is unable to account for all of the funds received. In that case, remaining funds must be put into a reserve fund and utilized in 2021 for eligible purposes. After careful consideration, the Treasurer's advice was that the second phase of the funding not be pursued.. The Municipality continues to experience the financial impacts of COVID-19. Affects on our revenues and expenses are highlighted below for each department. Taxes Receivable/Collected Taxes Receivable as of September 30, 2020, provides the status of the taxes billed and collected by the Municipality during the third quarter. A total of $24,044,928 remains unpaid which is similar to the same quarter in previous years. To provide COVID-19 relief to our taxpayers, the Municipality moved the June installment of the final tax bill to July. In 2020, two installment dates, the adjusted date in July and the regularly scheduled date in September fall in the third quarter. Grants Clarington received another installment of the grant from the Federation of Canadian Municipalities (FCM) to support 'participation in the Municipalities for Climate Innovation Program (MCIP). The MCIP supports municipalities in developing a response to climate change that protects residents, the environment and the economy. Funds received from the program are subsidizing the Climate Change Response Coordinator position, who is working with the Interdepartmental Climate Change Working Group to develop the Clarington Climate Action Plan and other climate initiatives in the Municipality. The initial installment of the grant for summer students was received in the third quarter and is used to subsidize student wages. Generally, the funding would be received in October or November; due to COVID, a July installment was made. This year's grant is lower than last year's grant by 47 per cent. Grant funding was received from the Tourism Industry Association of Ontario (TIAO) this quarter. The TIAO partnership through FedDev Ontario aids local Destination Marketing Organizations with the Regional Recovery and Relief Fund to help support marketing efforts during the pandemic. Due to COVID-19, TIAO pushed back the program end date from December 31, 2020, to February 28, 2021. Development Charges Collected Residential and non-residential development charges collected as of September 30, 2020, was $11,426,934. Residential municipal development charges collected were $10,680,150 compared to $2,388,914 in 2019 for the same period. The 2015 Development Charges Background Study forecasted that the Municipality would be collecting approximately 823 units in total for 2020, or about 617 units by the end of the third quarter. As at September 30, 2020, development charges have been collected for 737 units.. The development charges are significantly higher compared to 2019 due to the increased volume of permits issued in 2020. It was noted that deck and renovation permits had increased this year, possibly as a result of COVID-19. Staff attribute this increase to taxpayers wanting to improve their homes/yards as they are spending more time at home. There have been a few large permits issued for townhouses, stacked townhouses and single detached dwellings. Municipality of Clarington - Municipal Development Charges January 1 to September 30, 2020 i Residential Municipal Number of Municipal Development Units Development Number of Units Charges Paid Charges Paid Single/Semi- Detached New construction $ 4,499,854.00 249 $ 983,515 56 Additions Townhouse 5,181,866.00 373 854,264 64 Apartment 998,430.00 115 551,135 65 Total Residential $ 10,680,150.00 737 $ 2,388,914 1 185 Change in DC paid from prior year: Change in DC units from prior year: 347.1 % 298.4% Municipal Development Municipal Development Non-residential Charges Paid Charges Paid Commercial New construction $ 412,300.48 $ 358,795.79 Additions - - Industrial New construction 334,483.99 30,133.35 Additions _ _ Agricultural _ _ Government - - Institutional - - Total Non-residential $ 746,784.47 $ 388,929.14 Change in DC paid from prior year: 92.0% Municipal Development Charge Incentives In the 2015 Development Charges By-law 2015-035, there are several incentives to encourage development in Clarington. These incentives mainly relate to multi - residential, commercial and industrial development. Since July 2015, there has been a total of $1,555,277 in development charge incentives given to 15 properties. The split is approximately 37% and 63% respectively between residential and non-residential properties. Note that discretionary incentives are required to be covered by the Municipality's tax base. There are no new incentives in 2020, as of September 30, 2020. Property & 2015 2016 2017 2018i2020 Total Percentage Incentive .- of Total Mid -Rise $413,822 413,822 Residential Revitalization, 157,840 157,840 Mixed Use Residential - 413,822. 157,840 - - - 571,662 37% Medical Exemption 110,671 110,671 Revitalization, 3,636 938 974 5,548 Small Business Existing Industrial 22,983 22,983 Development Conversion Residential to 15,985 15,985 Commercial New Industrial 102,718 652,823 755,541 Development Revitalization, 72,886 72,886 Mixed Use Non -Residential 114,307 39,906 176,578 652,823 - - 983,614 63% $114,307 $453,728 $334,418 $652,823 $ - $ - $1,555,277. 100% Investments The Manager of Internal Audit provides a quarterly compliance memo to the CAO and the Treasurer. Below are the highlights of this memo for the period ending September 30, 2020. Investments by Institution The compliance calculations include the reserve fund bank account as it's not used for ongoing operations and is considered available for investing. The general fund TD bank account is used for the ongoing operations and is consider as "required immediately" and therefore is not eligible for investing; it is not included in the compliance calculations. Total Funds % of Total • - • - TD Bank - Savings $23,018,812 19.40%W%R 100% ONE - HISA 23,383,592 19.70% 0% 100% ONE - Equity 2,499,996 2.10% 0% 15% ONE - Bond 4,254,506 3.60% 0% 15% ONE - Corporate Bond - 0.00% 0% 15% RBC 15,153,314 12.80% 0% 20% RBC - HISA 75,459 0.10% 0% 100% National Bank 8,805,845 7.40% 0% 20% BNS 12,979,424 10.90% 0% 20% BMO 15,081,384 12.70% 0% 20% HSBC Total Funds 5,543,553 % of Total 4.70% 0% 20% TD Bank 7,841,449 6.60% 0% 20% $ 118,637,334 100.00% The Municipality was compliant with all restrictions on investment with individual institutions. Investments by Term Total Funds % of Total - • - - • - 90 Days $59,538,747 50.20% 20% 100% 90 Days to 1 Year 4,674,330 3.90% 54.10% 30% 100% 1 to 5 Years 36,624,485 30.90% 0% 85% 5 to 10 Years 8,479,731 7.10% 0% 50% 10 to 20 Years 9,320,041 7.90% 0% 30% $118,637,334 100.00% The Municipality was compliant with the stated term component that is less than 90 days; this is due to the length restrictions. There is a significantly high One Fund HISA and TD Reserve Bank investments, which are immediately accessible and thereby highly liquid. The investments in the 10 to 20-year terms are all bank bonds, which are considered to have adequate Investments by Type liquidity. There are uses for these long-term investments, but the specifics have not been clearly identified. Total Funds % of Total �� . - • HISA $46,431,372 39.10% 0% 100% Federal Debt - 0.00% 0% 100% Provincial Debt - 0.00% 0% 80% Municipal Debt 4,778,046 4.00% 0% 35% Financial Institutions 60,673,414 51.10% 0% 60% Corporate Debt (non -financial) - 0.00% 0% 10% ONE Investment Pools 6,754,502 5.70% 0% 25% $118,637,334 As of September 30, 2020, the Municipality is compliant with the investment types' restrictions as defined in the Municipal Investment Policy. Investments with financial 100.00% institutions do not include cash accounts; however, it does include GICs and bonds. At the beginning of the second quarter , in response to the global pandemic, the bulk of the One Fund HISA account ($23,700,000) was transferred to the TD General Fund bank account. There was some uncertainty in March whether the One Fund investments would remain accessible. This has been corrected in the third quarter, the One Fund HISA General Fund balance has been restored and is over $23 million at the end of the third quarter. Staffing Updates For the period ending September 30, 2020, there were 706 staff (including those on leave — not COVID related). Before COVID-19, there were 809 employees including Mayor and Council (seven), temporary staff, volunteer firefighters and employees on leave (this does not include Library or Museum). The quarter saw more part-time staff returned from the DEL, and crossing guards returned with new school year. There were two retirements during the third quarter. Municipal Operating Revenues and Expenses Overview - Financial Results This financial update report to Council has been redesigned to focus on (unaudited) overall budget variances for the period ending September 30, 2020. The reporting has expanded to show budget to actual variances by sub -department. The department summaries indicate the status of the Municipality's operating accounts compared to the approved budget as of September 30, 2020. Many of the operations of the Municipality are impacted by seasonal trends such as ice rentals and winter control The timing of other activities can fluctuate from year to year, such as legal and planning revenues. To best capture the trends, the budget is allocated on a monthly basis based on the prior year's actual monthly distribution. In cases where there is no prior history, the monthly allocation is divided equally over the twelve months. Due to timing differences, variations from quarter -to - quarter and year-to-year exist. Therefore, this statement cannot be used in isolation, nor can it be easily extrapolated to predict the whole year's activities. Each department is responsible for its budget. Financial Services provides each department monthly trial balances to assist with the management of their respective budgets. The Summary of Operating Revenues and Expenditures compares the Municipality's budget to actual transactions as of September 30, 2020, reflecting financial activity through the third quarter of 2020 and comparing it with the same period in 2019. The tables below reflect the Municipality's operating budget only and exclude the year-to-date financial activities of the library, museum and Business Improvement Areas (BIA's). It is important to remember that these are not the final financial figures for the year. Although these charts provide an overall representation of our current financial standing, there are many factors unaccounted for and the final financial figures could be vastly different at year-end. The following table summarizes financial results for the year-to-date by department. Please note that "Levies" reflects the fact that there was a 90-day deferral of payment to the school boards for their taxes, this will net to $0 by the end of the year. There are several year-end adjustments, particularly with capital and reserve transfers, which will be recorded at year-end. YTD YTD YTD Final Unexpended Description Unassigned ($59,600) ($40,550) $- $- Non -Departmental Accounts (72,015,891) (71,110,085) (75,302,433) (75,881,769) 6.3% Mayor & Council 808,090 558,609 630,315 817,063 31.6% Administrator's Office 1,570,215 1,599,903 1,846,761 2,296,338 30.3% Legal Admin 239,540 265,914 297,501 503,791 47.2% Corp Services 3,462,331 4,080,361 4,249,627 5,179,396 21.2% Legislative Services 1,855,408 1,418,703 2,341,387 2,926,353 51.5% Financial Services & Unclassified 6,493,271 3,611,102 3,530,818 3,987,193 9.4% Admin Emergency Services - Fire 9,032,616 9,239,286 10,387,185 13,210,861 30.1% Engineering Services 5,152,400 3,188,712 6,110,713 6,910,720 53.9% Public Works 14,523,048 14,560,375 16,300,958 21,153,493 31.2% Community Services 7,546,673 5,967,712 8,207,910 10,153,263 41.2% Planning Services 2,536,761 2,450,063 3,062,529 4,033,995 39.3% Levies (9,854,806) (18,187,872) (8,619,177) - - BIA Taxation - - - - - Libraries/Museums 3,378,585 3,883,364 3,755,775 3,755,775 (3.4%) Culture 525,403 214,784 219,366 219,366 2.1 % Extrnl Agencies 673,531 734,162 734,162 734,162 - Total Municipality of Clarington ($24,132,425) ($37,565,457) ($22,246,603) $ - Revenue and Expense Categories Revenues and expenses are categorized based on their purpose and similarities. Revenues '-eviec Estimated taxation, supplementary taxation, and payments -in -lieu of taxation received. These funds may be collected on behalf of the Region of Durham, the Province of Ontario or a school board and are remitted to the specific agency. -rovincial Grants and Subsidies Grants received from the Province of Ontario for specific functions such as the Ontario Community Infrastructure Fund or specific grant projects. -ederal Grants and Subsidies Grants received from the Government of Canada for specific functions such as the Federal Gas Tax Fund or specific grant projects. User Fees Fees for services including, but not limited to, facility rentals, cemetery fees, application for planning and building permits, recreational programming. Licensing and Lease Revenue Licensing fees such as taxi licensing and lease revenues for the long-term lease of municipal facilities and property. Investment Income All investment income earned by the Municipality through its investment holdings, bank account balances and investment in Elexicon. Contributions from Reserves Contributions from reserves and reserve funds for specific purposes, as identified within the budget. This is an internal source of funding and may be originally sourced from taxation, grants or user fees. Other Revenues Any revenue that is not otherwise categorized. Expenses Salaries and Benefits Compensation for all employees such as salaries, wages, benefits, overtime, allowances and statutory benefits. Materials Includes items such as office supplies, salt and sand, gravel, insurance costs, phone costs and other general expenses. Rent and Financial Costs Bank charges, debit and credit card charges, cost of rental equipment and facility rentals for the Municipality. Purchase/Contracted Services Items that are outsourced, such as professional services, winter clearing and IT software as a service. Debt Repayment Interest on debt repayments to external parties Grants and Transfer Payments Grants provided to community groups, external boards and agencies and levies from other organizations. Contributions to Reserves and Reserve Funds Contributions from the general fund for the Municipality's reserves and reserve fund Mayor and Council 100 Mayor Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 277,423 196,831 193,835 250,702 21.5% Materials & Supplies 38,916 14,643 47,122 61,867 76.3% 105 Council Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 446,663 309,681 333,751 433,124 28.5% Materials & Supplies 3,408 1,163 7,829 9,070 87.2% 106 Ward Council Expenditures Materials & Supplies 22,616 20,159 29,300 38,300 47.4% 107 Regional Council Expenditures Materials & Supplies 19,064 16,132 18,478 24,000 32.8% Total Mayor & Council $808,090 $558,609 $630,315 $817,063 31.6% Highlights There were no items of interest to highlight for the period ending September 30, 2020, for the Mayor and Council departments. Administration 000 Unassigned Expenditures Materials & Supplies 353,471 360,600 364,934 366,600 1.6% 130 Admin Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 409,480 438,967 463,195 594,903 26.2% Materials & Supplies 21,371 6,257 29,702 59,700 89.5% Contracted Services 31,472 37,251 68,802 90,000 58.6% 170 Communication Revenue User Charges (40,185) (15,809) (38,709) (45,000) 64.9% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 443,708 434,657 500,029 645,631 32.7% Materials & Supplies 74,409 70,078 91,336 124,400 43.7% Contracted Services 71,235 41,914 80,780 102,725 59.2% 171 Tourism Revenue User Charges (22,080) Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 168,386 176,505 189,185 244,544 27.8% Materials & Supplies 49,024 36,393 62,735 80,750 54.9% Contracted Services 18,312 4,084 25,294 32,085 87.3% 385 Environmental Revenue Highlights Administration There was an overall reduction in expenses as office work adapted to COVID-19 restrictions. Many of the office expense accounts are lower than is typical for this quarter (i.e. Printing, Office Supplies, Postage & Courier, etc.) with employees working from home. Tourism The Tourism Office was closed to the public due to COVID-19 at the end of the first quarter. As a result, many of their expenses are lower than expected for this period. Special events were cancelled, and the distribution of the maps was put on hold as all travel centers in Ontario were closed with the pandemic. Legal Services Highlights There were no items of interest to highlight for the period ending September 30, 2020 for Legal Services. Corporate Services 130 Admin Revenue User Charges (12,759) (10,488) (400) (12,000) 12.6% Expenditures Materials & Supplies 151,632 128,835 157,082 224,850 42.7% 160 HR/Payroll Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 1,215,814 1,224,711 1,292,838 1,542,249 20.6% Materials & Supplies 6,220 3,119 5,936 6,600 52.7% Contracted Services 56,073 34,582 45,285 81,500 57.6% Rents/Financial Expenses 84,793 71,080 97,497 130,000 45.3% 162 IT Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 997,540 1,002,735 1,101,440 1,417,707 29.3% Materials & Supplies 5,608 1,471 4,350 5,000 70.6% Contracted Services 7,156 2,852 6,154 15,000 81.0% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 110,000 670,500 670,500 670,500 Reclass: CF (NON-TCA) to GF 379,340 478,926 357,651 437,500 (9.5%) 163 Purchasing Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 456,386 458,533 489,678 632,025 27.5% Materials & Supplies 2,505 2,164 3,743 4,890 55.7% 165 Health & Safety Expenditures Highlights Information Technology (IT) Deferred expense entries have not yet been processed, which explains the overage of 9.5% in the table above. Human Resources/Payroll Legal expenses continue to be less than expected due to a general reduction in grievances. Upcoming CUPE negotiations may result in the use of these funds. Legislative Services (Clerk's Department) 000 Unassigned Revenue User Charges 130 Admin Revenue User Charges Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits Materials & Supplies Contracted Services Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 190 Animal Services Revenue User Charges Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits Materials & Supplies Contracted Services Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 191 Municipal Law Enforcement Revenue User Charges Fines/Penalties on Interest Expenditures (200) (200) 100.0% (93,797) (73,560) (101,690) (118,800) 38.1% 813,574 1 710,469 900,391 1,163,744 38.9% 54,874 49,406 67,922 93,910 47.4% 12,078 15,213 10,416 10,800 (40.9%) 15,000 19,500 19,500 19,500 (74,567) (76,251) (62,772) (87,800) 13.2% 295,524 275,935 335,925 433,420 36.3% 37,206 35,305 40,941 65,825 46.4% 36,887 49,398 34,006 55,000 10.2% 9,157 8,429 7,000 7,000 (20.4%) (36,124) (11,820) (25,432) (28,000) 57.8% (22,290) (13,777) (17,156) (25,000) 44.9% Salaries, Wages & Benefits 476,835 536,839 655,075 845,402 36.5% Materials & Supplies 10,519 9,361 25,156 33,700 72.2% Contracted Services 42,817 17,872 37,023 54,100 67.0% 192 Parking Enforcement Revenue User Charges (114,497) (33,736) (61,763) (80,000) 57.8% Fines/Penalties on Interest (320,830) (92,509) (178,822) (250,000) 63.0% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 259,003 280,922 312,606 409,462 31.4% Materials & Supplies 7,446 9,110 13,306 24,840 63.3% Contracted Services 6,040 3,933 7,070 10,000 60.7% Rents/Financial Expenses 8,316 5,062 6,980 10,000 49.4% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 435,327 126,245 330,000 330,000 61.7% 193 Election Revenue User Charges 529 Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 271 Materials & Supplies 1,721 Contracted Services 3,943 3,943 69,000 69,000 94.3% Rents/Financial Expenses 1,755 Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 125,000 125,000 125,000 125,000 230 Grants Revenue Grants (12,474) (6,758) (9,940) (22,000) 69.3% 250 Contributions Highlights Council Services (Administration) Council Services revenues are down due to COVID-19 except for Commissioning/Certification and Licencing revenue. $25,000 for the Uber license was collected which accounts for the actual to budget variance in revenue. Increases will be made for the 2021 budget. The Records Management Summer Student position was extended to work part-time until mid -October, which will increase the actuals in the Wages Temporary Part -Time account. There will be budget capacity for this addition. The Professional Fees account is over budget by 46% due to the high (and unanticipated) investigations' costs (i.e. Integrity Commissioner). Animal Services The Animal Disposal expense account is expected to go over budget, as at the end of the third quarter it only has 3% of the budget remaining. However, these expenses are offset by increased revenues in the Animal Disposal Revenue account. Fleet General repair and maintenance on the 2013 Equinox put one of the fleet accounts over budget for that vehicle. There was an accident with the 2018 Chevy Cruz, which incurred costs for the repair that was unbudgeted. Parking Enforcement Fines and Meter revenue is lower than expected for the period ending September 30, 2020, due to the refocus of officer duties and leniency provided throughout the pandemic from the beginning of the second quarter to the middle of the third quarter. The Small Equipment Purchases account is over budget by 34% with the purchase of a mobile printer for the MLEO offices. There is a potential cost recovery for part of this expense from OPG. Cemetery Cemetery revenue for Bondhead Cemetery has exceeded the budget by 75% at the end of the third quarter. There are currently no sales for the Hampton columbarium, putting this revenue account underbudget for the period ending September 30, 2020. Construction on the columbarium was initially delayed due to COVID-19, but it is now complete, and the results of the opening of the sale for the niches will be seen in the final quarter. Financial Services and Unclassified Administration 000 Unassigned Revenue Fines/Penalties on Interest (14,359) (28,525) (8,195) (13,000) (119.4%) 130 Admin Revenue User Charges (179,175) (171,935) (148,970) (178,000) 3.4% Fines/Penalties on Interest (1,003,298) (834,325) (884,762) (1,250,000) 33.3% 140 Internal Audit Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 111,335 117,766 151,831 26.7% Materials & Supplies 300 300 100.0% 210 Finance Admin Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 1,696,225 1,680,396 1,869,300 2,411,937 30.3% Materials & Supplies 77,695 67,694 90,431 106,400 36.4% Contracted Services 57,492 69,358 31,436 49,000 (41.5%) 211 Unclassified Admin Revenue User Charges (479) Expenditures Materials & Supplies 240,827 154,359 313,943 405,900 62.0% Contracted Services 1,197,696 656,075 1,155,332 1,285,600 49.0% Rents/Financial Expenses 343,100 123,701 182,012 205,000 39.7% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 4,077,547 2,502,842 812,225 812,225 (208.1 %) Highlights Unassigned Accounts receivable fines and penalties on interest are higher than budgeted and higher than the same period in 2019. Investement income is still down this quarter due to decreased interest rates from COVID-19 market impacts. Finance Admin The legal fees account continues to be over budget due to the increased involvement of the external solicitor regarding non-residential assessment appeals such as Loblaws, Walmart, Shoppers Home Depot and Canadian Tire. These appeals have been ongoing for several years and are being completed in 2020. The Municipality has been able to recognize savings in lost revenue higher than the legal costs; this benefits the Municipality in the past as well as going forward with protecting its commercial assessment base. Unclassified Admin The Transfers from Reserve and Reserve Fund account looks to be over budget by a significant value but that includes the 2019 Operating Surplus entry, which is not assumed at the time of the budget creation. The 2019 surplus transfer is about 54% less than the 2018 transfer; this decrease was primarily driven by a decrease in the equity share of net income — from Veridian Corporation of $1.2 million stemming from one-time costs related to the merger of Veridian and Whitby Hydro, lower building permit revenue in 2019 of $1 million due to decreased developer activities, and higher sand and salt costs of $0.7 million. These were partly offset by lower transfers to reserve funds of $0.9 million related to Building Inspection, lower operating costs of $0.2 million associated with the closing of concessions stands at community facilities and various other operating savings in 2019 totalling $0.3 million. Emergency Services 130 Admin Revenue User Charges (179,439) (299,029) (78,047) (105,000) (184.8%) Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 668,951 697,670 735,673 940,149 25.8% Materials & Supplies 140,539 103,014 178,529 239,650 57.0% External Transfers to Others 10,000 6,250 10,000 10,000 37.5% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 661,150 584,915 553,925 553,925 (5.6%) 280 Fire Prevention Revenue User Charges (45,930) (10,100) (43,687) (45,000) 77.6% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 472,849 519,910 568,338 735,643 29.3% Materials & Supplies 28,052 5,879 33,237 46,500 87.4% Contracted Services 92,700 92,700 100.0% 281 Fire Suppression Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 5,665,696 6,018,530 6,553,190 8,443,560 28.7% Materials & Supplies 31,609 34,126 55,680 92,500 63.1 % Contracted Services 42,482 50,050 43,053 70,000 28.5% 282 Fire Training/Technical Support Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 262,458 275,717 272,939 350,680 21.4% Materials & Supplies 3,409 3,213 3,687 6,500 50.6% 1• 2020 2020 2020 2020•, Budget Budget', 283 Fire Communication Expenditures Contracted Services 423,876 477,837 511,900 587,000 18.6% 284 Fire Mechanical Expenditures Materials & Supplies 75,345 49,652 76,298 120,000 58.6% 285 All Stations - P/T Admin Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 637,886 565,987 667,214 867,380 34.7% Materials & Supplies 23,979 34,743 31,420 45,700 24.0% Contracted Services 3,759 2,290 4,969 6,500 64.8% 286 Municipal Emergency Measures Revenue User Charges (10,000) (10,000) (10,000) 100.0% Expenditures Materials & Supplies 20,583 20,280 20,950 26,950 24.7% Contracted Services 287 Mechanical Technical Support Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 95,362 98,352 105,217 135,524 27.4% Total Emergency Services - Fire $9,032,616 $9,239,286 $10,387,185 $13,210,861 30.1% Highlights Administration User charges include an invoice to OPG for the 2020 annual payment as per the Memorandum of Understanding with the Municipality of Clarington and OPG. Transfers to the Reserve and Reserve Fund category look to be over budget however this is where the transfers of the Emergency Call revenue is transferred to the Reserve Fund. In previous years, this revenue was an unbudgeted item. Engineering Services 000 Unassigned Revenue User Charges (211) (300) (500) (500) 40.0% 130 Admin Revenue User Charges (278,304) (133,284) (47,946) (50,500) (163.9%) Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 1,703,836 1,669,809 1,949,710 2,513,421 33.6% Materials & Supplies 26,519 20,791 27,776 53,950 61.5% Contracted Services 70,297 155,478 110,124 150,250 (3.5%) Debt Services (Principle and Interest paid) 466,423 474,045 473,550 544,417 12.9% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 3,632,054 3,441,192 3,415,536 3,415,536 (0.8%) 250 Contributions Revenue Transfer between Funds (1,637,845) 321 Building Inspections Revenue User Charges (1,693,444) (1,813,692) (1,199,509) (1,554,032) (16.7%) Fines/Penalties on Interest (500) (500) 100.0% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 917,623 859,821 1,028,887 1,329,648 35.3% Materials & Supplies 55,499 35,325 64,439 102,930 65.7% Contracted Services 100,906 4,752 151,762 199,000 97.6% 324 Street Lighting 19 2020 2020 2020 2020•, Budget • • - ' , Expenditures Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 325 Parks Expenditures Materials & Supplies 1,143 151 450 500 69.8% Contracted Services 636 10,000 93.6% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 1,100 327 Parking Lots Expenditures Debt Services (Principle and Interest paid) (13,284) (14,990) 330 Roads & Structures Expenditures Contracted Services 9,512 8,245 21,000 100.0% 334 Safe Roads Expenditures Materials & Supplies 201 2,049 200 13,500 84.8% Contracted Services 12,806 21,308 19,777 50,000 57.4% 380 Road Maintenance Expenditures Contracted Services 39,326 6,500 6,500 100.0% 388 Fleet Expenditures Materials & Supplies 1,498 2,366 2,212 5,600 57.8% Total Engineering Services $5,152,400 $3,188,712 $6,110,713 $6,910,720 53.9% Highlights Administration Contracted Services have Studies rolled up into these categories, but there is no budget for 2020. This makes it look like the category is over budget, but it is not. Consulting expenses are low for the period ending September 30, 2020. Subdivision lighting review is being done in- house this year with fewer complicated subdivisions, reducing external consultants costs. This account will likely be under budget this year. Roads and Structures Consulting expenses are anticipated for the next quarter. The estimate for the work will likely have this account coming in under budget. Building Inspections As a result of COVID-19, an increase in building and pool permits revenue has been realized as people were spending more on improving their homes/yards. The Builiding Division also saw a reduction in expenses with the restriction from COVID-19. Many of the office expense accounts are lower than is typical for this quarter (i.e. Printing, Professional Fees, etc.) Operations 000 Unassigned Revenue User Charges (204,512) (16,517) (195,115) (208,800) 92.1% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 1,807 690 2,730 3,000 77.0% Materials & Supplies 78,562 52,355 57,689 107,400 51.3% Contracted Services (1,402) 2,854 2,274 3,000 4.9% 130 Admin Revenue User Charges (62,107) (51,104) (89,840) (125,000) 59.1% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 1,836,137 1,690,269 1,828,773 2,361,020 28.4% Materials & Supplies 55,276 48,557 54,231 74,700 35.0% Contracted Services 2,745 9,280 11,000 11,000 15.6% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 2,305,000 2,753,100 2,746,100 2,746,100 (0.3%) 250 Contributions Revenue Transfer between Funds (13,017) 324 Street Lighting Revenue User Charges (2,212) (1,359) (7,321) (15,000) 90.9% Expenditures Materials & Supplies 560,076 444,088 784,191 1,050,000 57.7% Contracted Services 195,114 127,323 231,890 330,000 61.4% Debt Services (Principle and Interest paid) (19,745) (22,281) 325 Parks Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 657,837 788,977 889,977 1,151,057 31.5% Materials & Supplies 389,691 388,584 378,860 515,750 24.7% Contracted Services 464,406 681,839 928,749 1,205,760 43.5% Rents/Financial Expenses 25,283 41,528 26,171 30,000 (38.4%) Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 100,000 225,000 225,000 225,000 326 Cemetery Revenue User Charges (121,858) (101,233) (112,504) (143,000) 29.2% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 120,563 126,101 175,149 225,854 44.2% Materials & Supplies 91,573 110,698 67,636 95,700 (15.7%) Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 50,000 5,000 5,000 5,000 350 Waste Collection Revenue User Charges (21,575) (6,183) (16,260) (22,500) 72.5% Expenditures Materials & Supplies 22,500 12,830 18,153 22,500 43.0% 351 Recycling Collection Revenue User Charges (2,290) (439) (1,235) (1,500) 70.7% Expenditures Materials & Supplies 2,547 385 1,500 1,500 74.3% 370 Building & Property Service Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 703,442 628,284 766,372 992,159 36.7% Materials & Supplies 352,902 325,582 331,005 549,265 40.7% Contracted Services 127,984 71,029 97,563 139,825 49.2% Debt Services (Principle and Interest paid) 100,844 101,019 100,979 107,799 6.3% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 954,250 1,325,000 1,325,000 1,325,000 380 Road Maintenance Revenue User Charges (18,624) (18,993) (15,871) (19,500) 2.6% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 600,827 438,983 492,905 597,700 26.6% Materials & Supplies 653,596 514,194 495,071 846,275 39.2% Contracted Services 386,769 263,233 538,747 785,700 66.5% 381 Hardtop Maintenace Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 256,134 314,403 336,816 429,000 26.7% Materials & Supplies 208,194 432,382 248,471 456,100 5.2% Contracted Services 37,139 70,983 68,500 160,000 55.6% 382 Isetop Maintenance Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 41,112 32,661 53,975 72,500 55.0% Materials & Supplies 125,752 142,587 135,396 342,000 58.3% 383 Winter Control Revenue User Charges (78,500) (4,832) (86,590) (90,000) 94.6% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 822,207 634,411 686,428 963,250 34.1 % Materials & Supplies 1,917,937 1,326,771 1,333,590 2,010,000 34.0% 384 Safety Devices Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 149,860 156,019 139,397 188,000 17.0% Materials & Supplies 203,810 170,214 166,273 349,400 51.3% Contracted Services 242 50,000 50,000 100.0% 386 Storm Water Management Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 3,505 7,044 9,677 20,000 64.8% Materials & Supplies 1,654 2,559 1,800 8,000 68.0% Contracted Services 14,231 92,000 92,000 84.5% 387 Regional Roads Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 7,321 6,690 6,517 9,000 25.7% Materials & Supplies 32,782 29,458 21,841 33,500 12.1 % 388 Fleet Revenue User Charges (1,132,075) (1,162,626) Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 391,646 470,413 618,169 766,037 38.6% Materials & Supplies 916,872 688,732 61,747 92,000 (648.6%) Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 134,500 185,000 185,000 185,000 440 Libraries Expenditures Materials & Supplies 2,073 894 1,822 4,450 79.9% Highlights Unassigned Unfortunately, the revenues are still low for sports field rentals due to COVID-19 restrictions. Administration Miscellaneous expenses have gone over budget by 35% at the end of the 3rd quarter. The overage is attributable to COVID-19 related expenses. Safety Devices The special event budget has not been used due to the cancellation of events to reduce the risks of COVID-19. Parks Fleet allocation for Parks increased as staff had to be assigned to individual vehicles due to COVID. Under normal operations crews would be assigned to ride together. The Parks Rental account is for the rental and cleaning of portable toilets in Parks, and due to COVID there was an increase in cleaning costs. Cemetery Fleet allocation for Cemeteries increased as staff had to be assigned to individual vehicles due to COVID. Under normal operations crews would be assigned to ride together. Waste and Recycling Collection No sales were made at the Hampton Operations/Public Works Centre during the COVID-19 shut down, resulting in lower sales than generally seen by the end of the third quarter. The expense for the waste and recycling supplies are lower as well, resulting from no inventory being purchased for that timeframe. Fleet The Fleet Miscellaneous Operating Supply account is rolled up into the materials and supplies category making it look like it is over budget however, fleet revenues offset this account's expenses. Community Services 130 Admin Revenue User Charges (43,354) (14,027) (33,800) (63,500) 77.9% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 665,404 524,392 743,107 958,743 45.3% Materials & Supplies 39,693 17,102 45,865 69,070 75.2% Contracted Services 15,173 Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 735,150 809,943 816,700 816,700 0.8% 250 Contributions Revenue Transfer between Funds (1,616,352) 420 Recreation Services Admin Revenue User Charges (2,745) (178) (1,168) (1,230) 85.5% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 650,938 561,739 793,922 1,020,506 45.0% Materials & Supplies 15,849 11,260 18,818 26,942 58.2% 421 Facilities Revenue User Charges (1,412,165) (824,276) (1,475,328) (2,357,646) 65.0% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 2,469,641 2,183,619 2,790,975 3,604,093 39.4% Materials & Supplies 1,858,410 1,509,646 1,790,568 2,641,186 42.8% Contracted Services 116,007 93,466 113,684 157,434 40.6% Debt Services (Principle and Interest paid) 2,031,328 1,906,828 1,904,315 1,957,836 2.6% 423 Concessions Revenue User Charges (26,333) (7,457) (40,418) (66,140) 88.7% Expenditures 424 Aquatic Programs Revenue User Charges (1,108,346) (287,377) (1,105,421) (1,172,741) 75.5% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 587,941 270,538 703,537 912,481 70.4% Materials & Supplies 32,172 10,373 40,209 61,830 83.2% 425 Fitness Programs Revenue User Charges (394,568) (216,552) (407,645) (532,295) 59.3% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 233,264 1101488 280,390 364,173 69.7% Materials & Supplies 10,412 4,904 17,814 28,850 83.0% Rents/Financial Expenses 1,050 1,235 2,000 100.0% 426 Recreation Programs Revenue User Charges (529,042) (99,062) (543,866) (566,015) 82.5% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 406,880 164,711 387,327 501,408 67.2% Materials & Supplies 67,885 6,236 65,940 68,830 90.9% Contracted Services 28,173 13,838 28,169 47,300 70.7% Rents/Financial Expenses 904 173 2,422 2,800 93.8% 427 Community Development Revenue User Charges (180,528) (114,105) (186,726) (191,903) 40.5% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 3,261 165 6,426 8,448 98.0% Materials & Supplies 146,183 94,368 163,576 197,675 52.3% Contracted Services 23,791 18,914 30,000 34,700 45.5% 428 55+ Active Adults Revenue User Charges (102,152) (43,611) (130,689) (162,231) 73.1% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 77,268 40,470 110,172 142,812 71.7% Materials & Supplies 17,682 7,819 16,730 25,400 69.2% Contracted Services 9,438 3,665 9,903 16,550 77.9% Rents/Financial Expenses 560 3,000 3,000 100.0% 429 Customer Service Revenue 1• 2020 2020 2020 2020•, User Charges (13,340) (19,589) (12,610) (15,675) (25.0%) Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 654,584 438,122 714,534 926,556 52.7% Materials & Supplies 100,397 52,289 97,234 132,736 60.6% 450 Client Services Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 262,134 276,895 345,017 444,740 37.7% Materials & Supplies 6,374 1,585 8,992 12,840 87.7% 473 Community Grant Program Expenditures External Transfers to Others 60,000 56,350 60,000 60,000 6.1 % 480 Municipal Sponsorships Expenditures External Transfers to Others 31,300 20,400 35,000 35,000 41.7% Total Community Services $7,546,673 $5,967,712 $8,207,910 $10,153,263 41.2% Highlights Administration With the reopening of facilities and the commencement of programs, Community Services expected to see improvement in revenues in the third quarter. Revenues continue to be lower than what is typical for this quarter with the continual impact of COVID-19. The 2020 budgeted revenues for the department will not be achieved by year-end. Planning Services 000 Unassigned Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 264,448 135,783 337,377 438,591 69.0% Materials & Supplies 16,620 32,427 119,498 238,750 86.4% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 696,728 634,717 634,717 634,717 130 Admin Revenue User Charges (441,429) (406,796) (684,619) (862,300) 52.8% Expenditures Salaries, Wages & Benefits 2,164,982 2,110,810 2,442,381 3,145,792 32.9% Materials & Supplies 54,755 32,598 62,715 114,750 71.6% Contracted Services 86,576 3,343 12,765 186,000 98.2% Transfers from RES / RF / CAP Fund 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 250 Contributions Revenue Transfer between Funds (123,695) 385 Environmental Revenue User Charges (585) (585) Expenditures Contracted Services 123,695 123,695 100.0% 430 Smallboards Expenditures Materials & Supplies 1,500 1,500 1,500 100.0% Highlights There were no items of interest to highlight for the period ending September 30, 2020 for Planning Services. Looking forward to the 4th Quarter 2020 Year End Financial Reporting (FS and FIR) Over the next few months, Financial Services begins the preparation of the final audited statements for the end of 2020. The statements will not be complete until the second quarter of 2021. They will be sent to the Audit Committee for review and approval. Continuous Improvement/Key Performance Indicators As this report is continually evolving and improving, we hope the subsequent quarterly reports will include upcoming continuous improvements within the Municipality and focus on key performance financial indicators that will be used to benchmark existing service levels.