The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutTR-45-00 " .,:. DN:TR-45-QO , THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON REPORT File # AfTJ::. RedC/Il- 53Y--co By-Iaw# JtJoo~J/f CL2000-4, NASH ROAD RECONSTRUCTION, COURTICE FILE #: Meeting: General Purpose and Administration Committee Date: Monday, July 3 2000 Report #: TR-45-00 Subject: RECOMMENDATIONS: It is respectfully recommended that the General Purpose and Administration Committee recommend to Council the following: 1. THAT Report TR-45-00 be received; 2. THAT Balterre Contracting Ltd., Peterborough, Ontario, with a revised total bid in the approximate amount of $993,349.83 (including G.S.T.), being the lowest responsible bidder meeting all terms, conditions and specifications of Tender CL2000-4, be awarded the contract for Nash Road Reconstruction, Courtice as required by the Department of Public Works; 3. THAT funds in the amount of $83 8,25720 be drawn from the Development Charge - Roads and Related Reserve Fund per approved September 1999 Development Charge Policy and Page 178 of 2000 Capital Budget; 4. THAT the funds in the amount of $178,461.00 be drawn from 2000 Public Works Department approved Capital Budget Account #7205-00002-0261; 5. THAT the remaining non development charge funds in the amount of $83,281.90 be reallocated from the deleted locations in the 2000 Public Works Hot Mix Paving Contract - Report TR-46-00. ($68,000 from Roads Contribution Reserve Fund for Green Road and Martin Road and $15,281.80 for Boundary Road, Pages 193, 198 and 188 of 2000 Capital Budget); and 6. THAT the attached By-law marked Schedule "A" authorizing the Mayor and Clerk to execute the agreement be approved. 833 . REPORT NO.: TR-4S-00 PAGE 2 BACKGROUND AND COMMENT: Tender specifications were provided by Totten Sims Hubicki Associates for the reconstruction of Nash Road, Courtice as required by the Department of Public Works. Tenders were advertised in the local papers, as well as the Daily Commercial News. Subsequently, tenders were received and tabulated as per Schedule "B" attached. The Municipality of Clarington's portion of the total project cost including Project Administration, as detailed in the letter from Totten Sims Hubicki Associates marked Schedule "C", is estimated at $1,100,000.00. Included in the total tendered price is work to be completed on behalf of the Region of Durham for which they will be invoiced separately. As the total Municipal required funds of $1,100,000 exceeds the budget allocation, the Development Charge financing ratio has been adjusted in accordance with the approved September 1999 Development Charge Policy to $838,257.20 and $178,461 from the tax levy as approved in 2000 Capital Budget on Page 178. It is recommended that the remaining non development charge funds in the amount of $83,281.80 be reallocated from the deleted 2000 Public Works Hot Mix Paving contract as outlined in Report TR-46-00. In accordance with Council's approval of Public Works Report WD-31-00 on June 26, 2000, the sidewalk on the north side of Nash Road was removed from the contract; therefore, reducing the total contract value by approximately $40,000. The cost overrun is addressed in the attached letter from Totten Sims Hubicki Associates. The low bidder has previously performed satisfactorily for the Municipality of Clarington in recent years. The Treasurer has reviewed the funding requirements and concurs with the recommendations. Queries with respect to department needs, specifications, etc., should be referred to the Director of Public Works. 834 < ,. REPORT NO.: TR-45-00 PAGE 3 After further review and analysis of the bids by Public Works, Totten Sims Hubicki Associates and Purchasing, it was mutually agreed that the low bidder, Balterre Contracting Ltd., Peterborough, Ontario be recommended for the contract for the reconstruction of Nash Road, Courtice. Respectfully submitted, Reviewed by, arieMarano, H.BSc., AMCT., Treasurer 2L~R~ Chief Administrative Officer ~v~ Stephen A. Vokes, P .Eng. Director of Public Works MM*LAB*jip 835 - SCHEDULE "A" THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON BY-LAW 2000- Being a By-law to authorize a contract between the Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington and Balterre Contracting Ltd., Peterborough, Ontario enter into an agreement for the Nash Road, Courtice, Ontario Reconstruction. THE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARlNGTON HEREBY ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: I. THAT the Mayor and Clerk are hereby authorized to execute, on behalf of the Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington with the Corporation Seal, a contract between Balterre Contracting Ltd., Peterborough, Ontario, and said Corporation; and 2. THAT the contract attached hereto as Schedule "c" form part of this By-law. BY-LAW read a fIrst and second time this dayof 2000. BY-LAW read a third time and fInally passed this day of 2000. MAYOR CLERK 856 JUN-27-00 rUE 03:59 PM rSH COBOURG FAX NO. p, 01 SCHEDULE "B" .. IIH ToLlen Sims HlIbicki Associates 513 Division Street, Cobourg, Ont<lrio, C(JnClda K9A 5G6 (905) 372-2121 Fax; 1905' :r12.3621 E-Illt''1il: clJbOlJtg@tsh,l':" www.l$h.co engineers architects planners June 27, 2000 Ms, Lou Ann Birkel!, CPP, AMCT Purchasing Manager Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington 40 Temperance Street BOWMt\NVILLE, Ontario. LlC 3AG Mail & Fax: 905-623-4169 Dear Ms. Birkell; Re: Contract No. CL2000-4, Nash Road Reconstruction, Conrtice Tenders for the above project were opene<! at tbe municipal oUices on Wednesday, June 14,2000, at 2:00 p.m. The bids received inclusive of GST are summarized a.~ follows: 8IDDE:~ TOTA~.IlU) AMOUNT $1.033.349.83 $1.047 000.00 $1.056.476.78 Baltene COnlTiletin. Ltd., Peterborou.h Ontario Miwcl COffil!tlCtiOll Limit." Stouffvilk. Ontuio R()ll Robi"~on LiInik:d Oshawa. Ontario Elima Construction & Materials Ltd. Pickerin.. Ontario $1,060,476.29 *' Ilard-Co Construc lion Lid.. Whi,by. Ont,uio B.N. Penton Construction. Courtice Ontario $1. t 10 616.94 $1,115 844.69 "Bill cunendcd ~ eJtlensioll enor The low hidder's submitted tender has been reviewe<! and is in order, Balterre Contracting reconstructed Wellington Street. Gcorgc Street, Ontario Street and Brown Street for the Municipality of Clarin/,'!on in 1998. Thcy performed to an acceptable standard. In 1999, they completed the reconstruction of Grand Road and County Road 30 in Campbellford and they are currenUy reconstructing George Strect in Cobourg. Tbese projects were similar in nature to Ule subject COlllract and references contacted indicated that their performance was gO<ld. We. therefore. recommend acceptance of the low bid on this contract. A cost apportionment is attached which summarizes estimated overall pmject cost.. based On the low bid. Tbe cost apportionment retlect.< the estimate<! $40,000 reduction in tender costs that will result from Council's deci"on of Joly 26, 2000 to uefer the construction of sidewalk on the north side of Nash Road. As reported to [he General Purpose and Administration Committee in Report WD-31-00 the Nash Road projcet j,~ projected to overrun original budget estimates. The cost Overrun is partially attrihutable to a general increase in C01l<truction costs of over 20%. These price increases are a direct result of the rise in fuel prices which not only impacts operating costs of contractors but has resulted in inflated prices for con~truction materials slIch as pye pipe, asphalt, concrete and granulars, 'rj5/ . JUN-27-00 TUE 03:59 PM TSH COBOURG FAX NO, p, 02 . CorfKlraTioll of the Municipa1hy of Clarington JUlie 27, 2000 2 Two projcct specific itcms have also contributed to Ule cost overrun for this project. A.. noted in Report WD-31-00, sidewalk on the south side of Nash Road which was originally designated to remain in plaee will IIOW he r~ll1()ved and replaced with a mueh wider sidewalk which will be supplemented with an asphalt bouJevanl in front of the schools. This work was included in the contract as a result of input received from the Puhlic at a project Information Centre. In addition. as a result of lhe recent Onlario Municipal Board Decision approving development of the Glenvicw Neighbourhood, stmm scwers on Nash Road have been oversized to accommodate the future reconstruction of Fourth Street, Westmore Street, Jane Street, Lynwood Avenue and G1enview Drive. The additional money required 10 fund the reconstruction of Nash Road will be obtaineti by reptioritizing other projects hudgeted for 2000 and by transferring savings from some previously tendered work. Deposit cbeques may he returned to all contractors except the low anti ~econd low bidders. Should you require any further intilrmation, please contact the undersigne<l, Yours truly, 'i!~: fi1/ ~ William McCrae. P.Eng. Senior Project Engineer WMc/jg 1!(:62113Jlfln?l'i(,l~ cne!. pc: S.A. Yokes, P.Eng, A.S. Cannella, CET K. Rand tIH ~)~ Municipalay of ClaringtonlRegion of CuTham Naslt Road Reconstruction ~ ApporwmnEnt E-3:sed on Low Bid From Batterre Co..,nc~ng Umi'ted ConfractCL.20(X)..4 Rev'.sed J "ne 27, 2000 T.S.H. Project 12.10966 = v.. Cascrlptlon Tata.r Cr.a,Tnglon Development Reg[on of Durtlam Comments Works Accourlt Number 7205-ll0001-ll261 969300004XX COnstructIon Costs Contract CUOOO4 Sedion lA $898,247.50 $861,989.20 $31,037.30 $5.221.00 Cost of Sidewalk on North S;d. of Nash Road De(eted from ClariT1!9'cn Costs Section 8 527,500.00 $26,389.85 $950.21 $159.84 Prorated Based On Low Bid Sutr.Total Construction $925,747.50 $sa8.379.15 $31.987.51 $5,380.84 TSH F'roject Number 12.106'2 PreJimil'Jary Design, D~tailed Design, Approvals an $52,10B.69 $52,108.69 $0.00 $0.00 Tender Documents (to May 20, 2000) Eslimated Construction Admlnistra.tlon 596.500.00 $92.800.00 $3,200.00 $500,00 Prorated Based On LO'."1 Bid [TSH#12-109661 Other Costs Hydro Relocation 525.000.00 $25,000,00 Estimated Sub-Total other Cosls $25.000.00 $25,000.00 SO.DO $0.00 Sub-Tolal Estimaled Project Costs (exc'~ 51.099.356.19 $1,058,287.84 $36.167.51 55.880.84 comlngeru::ies) Net G.s.T.13%) (..cl. conlingencles) $32,980,70 $31.74S,64 $1.065,63 $176.43 COnllngencles (.xci. GSIl $13,511.86 $9,963.52 $2,798.59 5849.75 lot.al Esflrnaled Project Cos.s $1,145,948.75 $1.100,000.00 $39.041.73 $6.90702 Budget Amo_ $7SO,IlOll.00 ClaJington Costs Only [Estimaled Bud~ DoneR -$350,000.00 Clanngloo Casts Only .......c, "- c :z I N --.I I = = --l C tT1 = ",. = = --a :=t --l '" ::I: o C) D:l C) C '"' Q "T1 :I> :x: :z 5=> '" '" :I: '" t:l c:: t-< '" :0 r1 = U,}