HomeMy WebLinkAboutPSD-025-02
'\, ...
Cl~-YJgton
REPORT
PLANNING SERVICES
Meeting:
PUBLIC MEETING
GENERAL PURPOSE AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
Date:
Monday April 8, 2002
Report #:
PSD-025-02
File#:
VD?OP
COPA 98-001, DEV 94-061
and ROPA 95-006
6fJ/1 - /b3-D:;Z
By-law #:~ OOc7 -:)'~
SUbject:
CROOKED CREEK GOLF COURSE
OFFICIAL PLAN AMENDMENT AND REZONING APPLICATIONS
RECOMMENDATIONS:
It is respectfully recommended that the General Purpose and Administration Committee
recommend to Council the following:
1, THAT Report PSD-025-02 be received;
2, THAT the Regional Municipality of Durham be advised that the Municipality of
Clarington recommends the approval of the Regional Official Plan Amendment
application (ROPA 95-006), as submitted and revised by Tunney Planning on behalf
of Crooked Creek Golf Course Inc, to permit the development of a 9 hole golf
course, club house and maintenance buildings;
3, THAT Amendment No, 26 to the Clarington Official Plan detailed in Attachment 7 to
this Report to permit the development of a 9 hole golf course be ADOPTED and the
necessary By-law be passed and that Amendment No, 26 come into force and effect
the date the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing approves the necessary
amendment to the Durham Region Official Plan amendment in support of ROPA 95-
006;
4, THAT the application for rezoning (DEV 94-061) be referred back to staff until such
time as the following conditions have been satisfied:
608
,
REPORT NO.: PSO-025-02
PAGE 2
a) The general form and content of the Site Plan development agreement is agreed
to and includes;
~ The conditions to implement the turf management report;
~ The conditions to implement the hydrogeological report;
~ The conditions to implement the EIS report as consolidated by Niblett and
Associates;
b) The applicanUowner agrees to conduct at least a 3 year post construction
monitoring program; and
c) Arrangements are made for the transfer of the provincially significant ANSI lands
to CLOC as part of the Stephen's Gulch Conservation Area,
6, THAT Durham Region and Durham Region Planning Department be sent a copy of this
report and all attachments,
7, THAT Durham Region Planning Department and all interested parties listed in this
report and any delegations be advised of Council's decision,
Submitted by:
Day. , rome, MCIP, R,P,P,
Director of Planning Services
Reviewed by: 0 (f{:b~)- ~
Franklin Wu,
Chief Administrative Officer
HS*SN*DJC*df
April 2, 2002
CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON
40 TEMPERANCE STREET, BOWMANVILLE, ONTARIO L 1C 3A6 T (905)623-3379 F (905)623-0830
609
"
REPORT NO.: PSD-025-02
PAGE 3
1.0 APPLICATION DETAILS
1,1 Applicant: Crooked Creek Golf Course Inc,
1,2 Agent:
Tunney Planning
1,3 Official Plan Amendment:
To redesignate a 41,9 ha parcel of land located Part of Lot 3,
Concession 4, former Township of Darlington to permit a 9 hole golf
course, club house and maintenance buildings (COPA 98-001),
An amendment to the Durham Region Official Plan has also been
received to redesignate the lands to permit this development (ROPA
95-006),
1.4 Rezoning:
To rezone a 41,9 ha parcel of land to an appropriate zone permitting a
9 hole golf course, club house and maintenance buildings,
1,5 Site Area:
The lands subject to the official plan amendment and rezoning
application cover a total of 41,9 hectares (103,5 ac) (Attachment 2),
2.0 LOCATION
The site is located in Part of Lot 3, Concession 4, former Township of Darlington
(Attachment 2), The property's northern limits abut Taunton Road,
3,0 EXISTING AND SURROUNDING USES
3,1 Site Characteristics
The lands are 41 ha in size, with almost half of the lands being environmentally
sensitive, Three watercourses traverse the site as follows:
610
"
REPORT NO.: PSD.025.02
PAGE 4
i) a deeply incised valley containing the Soper Creek crosses the northwest corner
of the property;
ii) the middle of the site is bisected by a tributary flowing into a man-made irrigation
pond that drains into the Soper Creek; and
iii) a wide valley area containing Crooked Creek consumes the south west portion of
the site,
The south end and the northwest edge of the site have been identified as a provincially
significant Life Science ANSI (Attachment 3), Past study of this area commonly referred
to as Soper Creek/Stephen's Gulch has found uncommon wildlife species and
substantiates that this area provides a wide range of habitat opportunities for species
such as mink, white tailed deer, broad-winged hawk and rutted grouse, In addition to
the wildlife features and functions of this area, seepage springs occur throughout the
valley slopes, providing contributions to the cold-water fisheries of the Soper Creek,
Uncommon herbaceous species such as orchids have also been noted within these
valley lands,
The Soper Creek and the Crooked Creek tributary have been identified by the Ministry
of Natural Resources as a provincially significant Life Science ANSI, recognizing the
wildlife significance of this area on a provincial scale, The lands south of the Crooked
Creek valley lands, and generally located on the lands south of the site, have been
identified as a provincially significant Earth Science ANSI, recognizing the relatively
undisturbed nature of the ancestral Lake Iroquois Beach formation at this location,
The tableland portion of the lands have been actively farmed with the exception of the
last year where the lands have been left to fallow, Along the Soper Creek Valley edge,
the fields have been planted and harvested up to the edge of the top of bank, As a
result of this agricultural activity, and the lack of an appropriate setback to the top of
611
REPORT NO.: PSD-025..Q2
PAGE 5
bank, excessive erosion of the valley back into the field and slumping of the valley
slopes have occurred,
3,2 Surrounding Uses
North - The lands to the north of the site are crossed by the forested Soper
Creek Valley, and are used in part for agricultural purposes. An existing
residence is located on the north side of Taunton Road across from
these lands,
West - The Soper Creek Valley runs through the lands to the west. These
forested lands are owned by CLOC and are referred to as Stephen's
Gulch Conservation Area,
East - To the east, the lands have been farmed,
South - South of the subject site is the provincially significant Stephen's Gulch
Earth Science and Life Science ANSI.
4.0 PLANNING LEGISLATION
The applications for this project were submitted under two different versions of the
Planning Act resulting in differing processing requirements, The Regional Official Plan
amendment application and the rezoning application were submitted under the Planning
Act, RSO 1990, The application to amend the Clarington Official Plan was submitted
after the revisions of Bill 20, The processing differences include notice period, timing of
the public meeting, the approval authority, the process for notice of Council's decision
and the means of appealing a decision,
5.0 BACKGROUND
5,1 The original application for rezoning and site plan approval (received on November 29,
1994) proposed an 18 hole golf course on 54 ha of land, In response to the inability to
612
REPORT NO.: PSO-D25-D2
PAGE 6
effectively mitigate the impacts of an 18 hole golf course, the application for
development was substantially downsized to a 9 hole golf course on 41 ha of land and
submitted in November 1999 (Attachment 1), The revised application buffers the
development proposal from the most ecologically sensitive areas of the site,
5,2 In support of this application the fOllowing technical studies were submitted:
. Environmental Impact Study, prepared by Bird and Hale and submitted in June,
1996,
. Turf Management Report, prepared by Kortekaas Lally Holmes Golf Course
Consultants and submitted in January 1997,
. Hydrogeological Assessment Report, prepared by Geo-Logic Inc, and submitted in
December 1997,
These reports are briefly summarized in Section 8,0 of this report,
5,3 On January 22nd, 1999, an application to close and convey part of the road allowance
between Lots 2 and 3 from Concession 4 to 5 was submitted to Clarington Engineering
Services, The need for this application reflects initial comments from the Region of
Durham identifying concerns with the location of the entrance, Due to the speed limit
and the hill on Taunton Road, the Regional Works Department identified the only safe
location for an entrance would be at the unopened municipal road allowance, The
application to close and convey the road allowance was submitted by Crooked Creek
Golf Course and Mr. and Mrs, Tax,
Engineering Services determined that the subject road allowance will not be needed as
part of the Municipality's future transportation system, and the road allowance was
considered surplus, On July 19, 1999, By-law 99-120 was passed authorizing the stop-
up and closure of the road allowance and conveyance to the adjacent property owners,
6.0 OFFICIAL PLAN
6,1 The Durham Region Official Plan designates the lands "Major Open Space" with an
indication of "Environmentally Sensitive Area", The predominant use of lands within this
designation shall be conservation, recreation, reforestation and agricultural uses,
613
REPORT NO.: PSD-025-02
PAGE 7
Section 14,3,2 of the Region's Official Plan requires an amendment to the Official Plan
for the approval of a golf course, Section 12,3.4 of the Region's Official Plan identifies 6
criteria that must be satisfied in order to consider a golf course application, Also
required is an Environmental Impact Study (EIS) that shall identify the natural features
and functions, the sensitivity of the features and functions, and recommend mitigation
methods that will protect the surrounding environment from the development.
6,2 The Clarington Official Plan designates the lands "Green Space" and "Environmental
Protection Area", Golf courses may be permitted on lands designated "Green Space"
by amendment to the Official Plan, Section 13,3.4 identifies criteria that must be
satisfied by a golf course application and are similar to the criteria contained within the
Durham Region Official Plan,
7.0 ZONING BY-LAW
The Municipality of Clarington Zoning By-law 84-63 as amended zones, the subject
lands "Agricultural (A)" and "Environmental Protection (EP)", Lands zoned "Agricultural"
do not permit a golf course, however within the Environmental Protection zone, a golf
course is permitted,
8.0 TECHNICAL STUDIES
In accordance with the requirements of the Region of Durham Official Plan and the
Clarington Official Plan, and to document and ensure that this application will not impact
the sensitive natural features on and adjacent to the site, a number of technical studies
were prepared, reviewed and accepted, An Environmental Impact Study (EIS), a
Hydrogeological study and a Turf Management Report have been prepared in support
of the application, An executive summary of each study is attached to this report,
8,1 Environmental Impact Study
Due to the ecological sensitivity of this site, the environmental impact study (EIS) has
been a critical component in the review of this application, The first EIS was prepared
614
REPORT NO.: PSD-025-02
PAGE 8
by Bird and Hale Limited and was submitted in June 1996, This original EIS determined
that the impacts of the proposed 18 hole golf course could not be sufficiently mitigated
to protect the natural features or functions of the provincially significant ANSI's, After a
number of iterations to the proposed plan and subsequent impact assessments, it was
apparent that the highly sensitive areas of the site had to be totally avoided and
buffered from impact. In response, the 18 hole golf course on 54 ha of land was pared
down to 9 holes on 41 ha, The revised plan no longer proposes fairways, tees or
greens to be located within the most sensitive lands, including the provincially significant
Life Science and Earth Science ANSI. An addendum to the EIS was prepared in
response to the 9 hole golf course,
In January 1999, Durham Region commissioned Niblett Environmental Associates
(NEA) to conduct a peer review of the environmental impact studies that had been
submitted in support of the application, NEA requested that a consolidation of all EIS
recommendations applicable to the 9 hole golf course be prepared, This consolidation
was not prepared and in order to move things along, the Region asked NEA to prepare
a list of conditions that would permit this application to proceed through the planning
process, A summary of this report is contained in Attachment 4 to this report.
NEA has proposed a 3 step process:
. identification and analysis of potential impacts of the development, mitigation
measures, and net effects;
. post construction monitoring and reporting requirements; and
. monitoring of mitigation measures and remedial actions,
The first step consolidates all recommendations made by the EIS consultant, modified
where appropriate to reflect the changes in the number of holes and the layout of the
golf course, This exercise describes the potential impacts of development of each hole
on the natural features and functions, how best to mitigate or avoid the impacts, and an
615
REPORT NO.: PSD-025-02
PAGE 9
analysis of the net effects of development of each hole and implementation of mitigation
measures (Attachment 4A),
The second step provides a schedule of monitoring and reporting to be conducted after
the golf course has been developed, It recommends monitoring the following
components; surface water quality, groundwater quality and quantity, erosion,
amphibians, survival of plantings and control of invasive species, For each component
a description is provided identifying how and where monitoring should occur, who
should conduct the monitoring, how often should the component be monitored and
frequency of reporting the data (Attachment 48),
Using these same components, the third step recommends monitoring of mitigation
measures, If the mitigation has not been effective, remedial actions are proposed,
It is incumbent upon the applicant, the Municipality, the Region and CLOC that the
recommendations of this EIS are satisfied,
8,2 Hydrogeological Report
This report was prepared by Geo-Logic Inc in December 1997 and describes the
existing hydrogeologic conditions and determines the suitability of the development of
an 18 hole golf course on 54 ha of land, Possible impacts this development may have
on the shallow groundwater regime and down-gradient functions have been identified,
A summary of this report has been provided in Attachment 5,
The conclusions of this report state that irrigation shall be provided by an on-site well
and that use of this well will have no impact on adjacent wells or the level of the existing
pond, There exists a deeper confined aquifer that provides little or no contribution to
localized baseflow, significantly reducing the potential of contaminants getting into the
watercourses, There will be no reduction of baseflow due to irrigational practices.
616
REPORT NO.: PSD-02S-02
PAGE 10
This report recommends that additional vegetative buffers be planted around the
tributaries and ponds to aid in absorbing excess nutrients and reduce soil erosion, It is
also recommended that an annual water quality monitoring program be conducted
ensuring good water quality is maintained, The collection of water level and
consumption data on a regular basis is also suggested in order to evaluate the
performance of the well and the long term impact on the aquifer.
The report was peer reviewed by Gartner Lee, After receipt of additional information,
the peer review concurred with the report's review of fertilizer impacts and the impacts
on groundwater and surface water of this proposal. Gartner Lee was satisfied that the
deep confined aquifer can sustain irrigation requirements for the proposed 9 hole golf
course without causing adverse impacts on the creeks or existing wells,
8,3 Turf Management Report
A Turf Management Report was prepared by Kortekaas Lally Holmes Golf Course
Consultants and submitted in January 1997, A revised report was prepared later and is
dated January, 1998, This report reviewed the site conditions and proposed best
management practices for the care of the golf course, A summary of this report is
contained in Attachment 6,
Due to the site's sandy soils, it is recommended that a careful approach to fertilizer and
pesticide application be implemented, Contained within this report are
recommendations regarding the planting of vegetation species including grasses,
fertilization requirements and application, stormwater management, irrigation and
protection of existing watercourses, In order to eliminate erosion and sediment
movement during construction, a detailed erosion control plan shall be developed prior
to construction, The report also recommends the adoption of an integrated pest
management plan in order to reduce the need for chemical control of pests,
617
REPORT NO.: PSD.025-02
PAGE 11
9.0 AGENCY COMMENTS
The original application and the revised application were circulated to agencies for their
review and comment. The following summarizes comments made by the agencies,
9,1 Clarington Emergency Services and the Building Division identified a number of
requirements, These include:
· a fire access route to the principal entrance of all buildings, This access route shall
have a minimum 12 m centreline and a turning radius having a minimum 6 m width;
· provision of turnaround facilities;
. require approx 20,000 gallons or more of on-site water supply storage for fire fighting
purposes, If on-site ponds are used as a water supply, the Ontario Fire Marshall
suggests the design include a 24 inch minimum ice depth, Supply tube connections,
location, size and signage is to conform to Clarington Fire Department guidelines,
. all buildings that exceed 600 sq, m in building area will require a fire access route
and water supply for fire fighting in accordance with the OBC,
The above items will be required to be fulfilled to the satisfaction of the Municipality of
Clarington prior to signing of the site plan agreement.
9,2 Clarington Engineering Services require that the applicant prepare a tree study and
landscape plan, Fulfillment of these conditions will be required prior to entering into a
site plan agreement. In addition, the applicant will be required to provide 2% cash-in-
lieu of parkland, Comments also identified that the applicant shall satisfy all
requirements of the Municipality of Clarington, financial and otherwise,
9,3 CLOC has reviewed the November 2001 peer review report prepared by NEA and
concur with the consultant's conclusions, The Conservation Authority is satisfied that a
9 hole golf course can be developed on the lands and they have no objection to the
official plan amendment applications to permit said golf course, CLOC notes that there
are a number of requirements that must be fulfilled prior to completion of a site plan
agreement including monitoring programs, CLOC will continue to be consulted during
the review of the site plan agreement and the fulfillment of the recommendations of the
technical studies,
618
REPORT NO.: PSD-02S-D2
PAGE 12
The applicant and CLOC have discussed the issue of dedication of the valleylands, The
lands possessing provincially significant Life Science ANSI designation will be ultimately
dedicated to the Conservation Authority, Dedication of these lands will occur at site
plan approval stage,
9.4 The Durham Region Health Department has no objection to the application based on
the hydrogeologic report prepared by Geo-Logic, They are satisfied that a private septic
system can be accommodated on the site,
9,5 The Ministry of Citizenship, Culture and Recreation confirm that an archaeological site
exists on the lands, A Stage 3 archaeological test was conducted and concluded that
further archaeological assessment is not necessary, It is required that if any deeply
buried cultural remains are discovered during construction activities, the Ministry must
be notified immediately,
9,6 The Ministry of Agriculture and Food note that the soils are Class 3 with fertility and
moisture holding capacity limitations, It was confirmed that the locational requirements
of the agricultural code of practice have been met. This Ministry has no objection to the
change in land use to permit a golf course,
9,7 The Ministry of Natural Resources notes that this site is "part of a very significant green
space feature which runs along the Lake Iroquois shoreline, and up and down the
Wilmot and Bowmanville Creek watersheds, This natural heritage system contains Core
Natural Areas, and regional corridors and linkages, which form a key component of the
overall Durham Region Natural Heritage System," The Ministry is satisfied that the land
use change to permit a 9 hole golf course will not have an impact on the integrity of the
natural heritage system, They note that where the holes cross the pond and tributary,
some local impacts may occur, but the function of the regional system will not be
impacted upon by these crossings, The Ministry is satisfied with the findings of the EIS
and concurs with the recommendations for an environmental construction management
619
REPORT NO.: PSO-D2S..Q2
PAGE 13
plan and monitoring program, This Ministry has no objection to the official plan
amendments,
10.0 PUBLIC COMMENTS
A total of three public meetings have been held since this application was received,
Some concerns regarding this development have been raised by residents, Originally,
the adjacent landowner expressed concern about the amount of water a golf course will
use and the impact these water takings would have on their well water and the
availability of water for irrigation of their crops, At a subsequent public meeting, the
neighbour expressed support of the development proposed, Concern was raised about
removing agricultural land from productivity, and a couple of residents questioned the
impact this development would have on the significant natural features in the area and
were opposed to the development of the golf course on lands described as provincially
significant.
11.0 STAFF COMMENTS
11,1 The applicant's original proposal of 18 holes on 54 ha of land has been revised having
regard for the sensitivity of the natural heritage features and functions found on this site,
The applicant's revised proposal for 9 holes respects the environmental significance of
the site and adjacent lands, In the words of the EIS peer review consultant, "with the
inclusion of a properly designed 30 metre buffer in what is presently corn field and by
implementing an erosion control plan, we believe that impacts to adjacent watercourses
and wildlife habitat can be reduced compared to existing conditions",
The golf course design will include a 30 metre buffer from the limits of the provincially
significant ANSls to the in-play areas and a 15 metre buffer from the limits of the man-
made pond and tributary, These buffer areas are restricted areas and golf activities shall
not occur within these areas, The Ministry of Natural Resources and CLOC are satisfied
that this buffer distance is enough to ensure the integrity of the natural features and
functions it is protecting, The applicant must provide additional information as required
620
REPORT NO.: PSD-025-02
PAGE 14
in the technical reports in order to satisfy the Ministry of Natural Resources, CLOC, the
Region and the Municipality, that implementation and operation of the golf course will
have no impact on natural features and functions, These additional requirements are
documented within the technical studies and in the summary provided in Attachments 4-
6,
11,2 There will be two significant crossings of environmentally sensitive lands, These occur
at Holes Nos, 5 and 9,
Hole No, 5 is proposed within the wooded area and is adjacent to, but separated from
the ANSI. The tee will be located on one side of the pond with the green located on the
opposite side, Access from the tee to the green will follow the existing farm path which
crosses the dam, Development of this Hole will proceed having full regard for the
sensitivity of the adjacent lands and the woodland itself, Golfers will be discouraged
from straying from the path, green or tee,
The tee, fairway and green are located outside of the buffer area for Hole No, 9, The
flyover connecting the tee to the green will cross the unnamed tributary that flows into
the man-made pond, The cart path will follow the existing farm path along the old road
allowance, Again, no access to the valley lands will be permitted, Some trees will
require removal to accommodate the f1yover. Like Hole No, 5 removal of trees will be
very specific and all groundcover and shrubs will remain as will the root mats of the
trees, These provisions will reduce erosion or the intrusion of non-native species,
Where trees are removed, the recommendation is that additional vegetation be planted
in areas like the hedgerow along the old road allowance,
Hole No, 4 crosses a very small treed swale, Only the cart path and the f1yover
clearance will cross the swale, The remainder of this hole is on the tablelands, The EIS
identifies that there are no species of concem in this small treed swale and that crossing
621
REPORT NO.: PSD-025-02
PAGE 15
this swale will not have a negative impact on the natural features and functions of the
ANSI lands or the pond area,
11,3 The applicant has agreed to participate in the Audubon Cooperative Sanctuary System
of Canada (Audubon), This is a certification process designed to recognize and support
golf courses that have worked to ensure a high degree of environmental quality on the
golf course, This program requires the full participation of the golf course owner as it is
the owner who must prepare and implement an Environmental Plan that meets the
requirements of the Audubon, Golf courses can receive certification in wildlife and habitat
management, integrated pest management, water conservation, water quality
management and outreach and education, In addition to approval of the Environmental
Plan, if the golf course receives certification for these 5 categories, the golf course
becomes a fully Certified Audubon Cooperative Sanctuary for Wildlife,
11.4 Given the environmentally sensitive features at this site, the process for monitoring is
critical to ensuring that the impact of this development is minimized, In addition to the
Audubon certification, the site plan agreement must incorporate mechanisms to ensure
that monitoring is undertaken, Municipal and CLOC staff will be requiring that monitoring
is undertaken for at least the first three years of the golf courses operation,
Subsequently, the Audubon certification will be the primary mechanism for ensuring
ongoing environmentally responsible practices on site,
11,5 The applicant has satisfied the requirements of the Provincial Policy Statements and that
of the Clarington Official Plan and the Durham Region Official Plan, The commenting
agencies are satisfied and are confident that the proposed 9 hole golf course will not
have an impact on the significant natural features and functions, The commenting
agencies do not object to the approval of the Official Plan Amendments for this
application, The comments of the public have also been satisfied, The technical studies
identify that there will be no impact on adjacent wells and that minimal removal of trees
622
REPORT NO.: PSD-025-02
PAGE 16
will occur, Any removal of trees will be compensated by replantings elsewhere on the
site,
11,6 At this time, the applicant is pursuing approval of the official plan amendment. It is
anticipated that the completion of some conditions identified in the technical studies
including an environmental construction plan and golf course routing plan will be
beneficial in establishing the limits of the active (in-play) area of the golf course, This
information will contribute to the determination of the various zones on the site, As a
result, it is recommended that the rezoning application be referred back to staff,
11,7 The proposed Amendment No, 26 to the Clarington Official Plan (Attachment 7)
proposes both a site specific text amendment and an amendment to Map A of the Official
Plan, The text amendment adds the Crooked Creek Golf Course to Table 18,1 in the
Official Plan and identifies it as "G2", Map A is amended by adding "G2" to the map on
the subject lands, Staff have no objection to this amendment and recommend that it be
approved,
12.0 CONCLUSION
It is recommended that Council adopt Amendment No, 26 to the Clarington Official Plan
and recommend approval of an appropriate amendment to the Regional Official Plan, It
is also recommended that Council at this time defer the zoning by-law amendment
application, referring if back to staff for additional implementation studies to be
completed in accordance with the recommendations of the EIS and other related studies,
Prior to site plan approval and rezoning, the applicant will be required to agree to
undertake monitoring and remediation program for the golf course,
623
REPORT NO.: PSD-025-02
PAGE 17
Attachments:
Attachment 1 -
Attachment 2 -
Attachment 3 -
Attachment 4 -
Attachment 4A -
Attachment 4B -
Attachment 4C -
Attachment 5 -
Attachment 6 -
Attachment 7 -
Crooked Creek Golf Course Master Plan
Key Map
Limits of Provincially Significant ANSls
Summary of EIS
Analysis of Potential Golf Course Related Effects on Natural Heritage
Features and Functions on Subject Lands and in Adjacent Areas
Schedule of Monitoring and Reporting Requirements
Monitoring and Remedial Actions
Summary of Hydrogeological Assessment
Summary of Turf Management Report
Proposed Amendment No, 26 to the Clarington Official Plan
624
REPORT NO.: PSD-025-02
PAGE 18
Interested parties to be advised of Council's decision:
Central Lake Ontario Conservation Libby Racansky
Authority 3200 Hancock Road
100 Whiting Avenue COURTICE, Ontario
OSHAWA, Ontario L 1 E 2M1
L 1 H 3T3
Johanna Tax
Peter Tax
2220 Regional Road 42
BOWMANVILLE, Ontario
L 1 C 3K5
Ministry of Natural Resources
Tim Rance, Aurora District
40 Bloomington Road W"
AURORA, Ontario
L4G 3H8
Crooked Creek Golf Club Ltd,
Kevin SewelllDoug Summers
837 Riverside Drive
AJAX, Ontario
L 1T 3R9
AI O'Donnell
563 Steerforth Street
OSHAWA, Ontario
K1K 2C3
Dave Fanthoam
R.R, # 5
BOWMANVILLE, Ontario
L 1C 3K6
Linda Gasser
7421 Best Road
P,O, Box 394
ORONO, Ontario
ZOB 1 MO
Tunney Planning Inc,
340 Byron Street South
Suite 200
WHITBY, Ontario
L 1 N 4P8
Kerry Meydam
3828 Trulls Road
COURTICE, Ontario
L 1 E 2L3
Evelyn Stroud
89 Little Avenue
BOWMANVILLE, Ontario
L 1C 1J9
Durham Region Planning Department
Barb Hodgins
Box 623,
Lang Tower West Building
1615 Dundas Street E, 4th Floor
WHITBY, Ontario
L1N6A3
Debbie Nixon
R.R. # 4
BOWMANVILLE, Ontario
L 1 C 3K5
625
626
ATTACHMENT 1
r-
LEGEND
,
I
CROOKED CREEK
GOLF COURSE
Reopon.e to the NEA INe P..~
R...-;.....afth.EIS,
:;:y;;
~
"Ppro>om.tellm~
01 "NSIMlPll'~~
<O~NRI
30mS,'~(Soper
1I.lIeyU'-ScI.nceANSQ
::;:::;l
NlP'O>Im..-Umltc!
HlghS8n.,tlllltv
ES/lMapping(CLOCA)
l~mSe\t>ack
Higl1Senoib"ly
ESAN8Fle~an~s
W.I.rcou'.....Pond.
,~
0-
;'.'rway
Pr.ctlceG'~n
""
I S"bieelPtoperty
-+- .
~
i
i Crooked Crook GOlf Course Masler
I Plan propared by Kevin Holmes &
I Associates TheMaslerPlanis
conceptual; tee, green, ,lfIdfairway
, siting and Sizing is to be confirmed
thrctIQh lhe Srte Planning Process
I
--"
CROOKJ:D CREEK
GOLF COURSE
I>tASTERPlA.......
ShadowlanJ
Inassocialionwith
Ke'lTln Holmes & A"oc,ues
,od
LGL Limited
''--------
(Projecl _Tmm FIGURE 1
1--' Augu,IHl9S1
Dale Re,,;.<<I1-__ ____,__
_~~mb@"gg~_ip'.Oa'll<lB\'CJA
Scale ;Cnec.edBv-JRN
13,200 K.101
ATTACHMENT 2
LOT 4
LOT 3
LOT 2
LOT 1
ROAD
4
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
II
II
II
II
II
'"
-g;l
DO
",I
!l~
..9~
Cl
<(
Q:
I.LJ
Z
~
Z
o
~
~
"'D
It
-"
~O
U
"
U'D
" "
DO
;l
O'i
<lI>
o
'DU
~
u
I
z
f2
"
z
~
Q:
C3
z
o
(/)
(/)
W
()
Z
o
U
........".........
...,................"......",.....
....................................
...,.....,........................".
."...."......"....................
..........".................".....
....................................
....................................
....................................
,;::::::::t:::;::::::;:::::::;:::::;:::::{::t:}{::::} I
::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::J I
~CN<' ":':'::::::::::::;:::::::::::if:::l::::::':II::I,:::I::
v ~LL ,......':':'::::::: I
I?O;l\D
I.LJ
::.::
ROAD 4
I
Dar1ington I Clarke Key Map
TAU
~
~~ ~
s;:
~
DEV.94-061
ROPA 95-006 and COPA 98-001
Crooked Creek Golf Club Ltd.
t;;
'"
~
~
'"
"
:J
CONCESS N R
~ Subject Site
l::::::::?;::::t::::::::] Other Lands Owned By Applicant
627
ATIACHMENT 3
TAUNTON ROAD
I
--
Soper Creek
-~
~ EARTH SCIENCE ANSI
~ LIFE SCIENCE ANSI
SUBJECT
SITE
81't;:'plt,
~t\l8 J!(/;:;: "
'<O-4D
628
ATTACHMENT"
SUMMARY OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STUDY
CROOKED CREEK GOLF COURSE
The original report was prepared by Bird and Hale Limited and submitted in June 1996, This
report and some of the subsequent addendums reviewed the impact of an 18 hole golf course
on 54 ha of land,
Purpose
The purpose of the report is to investigate the biophysical resources of the site and
surrounding lands and to assess whether any impacts of the proposed development would be
had on the environment. How these impacts will be mitigated are also to be assessed,
Reporting
A great deal of information had been collected and provided by the applicant's consultant, and
a number of addendums to the original EIS report had been submitted for review,
In January 1999, the Region commissioned Niblett Environmental Associates (NEA) to
conduct a peer review of the environmental impact studies that had be submitted in support of
the application, NEA asked for a consolidation of the EIS work be provided in a synthesis
report, The purpose of this synthesis report was to summarize all the EIS documents and to
provide a list of the impacts and proposed mitigation for a 9 hole golf course,
Eventually, the Region asked NEA to prepare a list of conditions based on the EIS reports,
conditions that would permit this application to proceed through the planning process, This list
of conditions consolidates all recommendations made by the EIS consultant, modified where
appropriate to reflect the changes in the number of holes and the layout of the golf course,
NEA has proposed other additional monitoring conditions that are required to ensure the
conditions are imposed and implemented appropriately and are effective in achieving a
reduced impact or an enhancement.
Environmental Construction Management Plan
An Environmental Construction Management Plan ECMP is required to be prepared prior to
site plan approval.
The ECMP must address and provide for the implementation of the following items,:
. Erection of temporary barriers or fencing along outside edge of buffer zones, preventing
construction equipment from entering the buffer and protected areas,
. There will not be any disposal, storage of materials or disruption of vegetation within the
buffer areas,
. All construction activities shall be scheduled to avoid impacts to fisheries and wildlife in
the pond or during bird nesting period, For vegetation, tree removal may occur only
during off-season periods,
. Bank erosion in the north west section of land requires stabilization,
. Implement recommendations of Turf Management Plan for stormwater management.
Summary of Environmental Impact Study
Crooked Creek Golf Course
62~
Attachment 4: Page 1
, '
. Clearing for cart paths on holes 5 and 9 shall be minimized and restricted to trees only,
Trees to be cut to ground level, leaving root mats untouched, Under story and
groundcover plants will remain untouched,
. Cart path for hole 9 to be located on the old road right of way,
. Cart paths to be covered by porous materials in woodland areas,
. No surfaces (parking lot, roads, etc) will be paved,
Fisheries
. Feasibility study that addresses potential impacts on fish habitat and productivity if pond
on the unnamed tributary is used as a source of irrigation water.
. Approval of CLOC and the DFO prior to any in water work to construct a bottom draw
outlet for the pond,
Buffer Creation and Rehabilitation
. Reforestation of the tributary pond edge, embankment and top of bank areas that are
currently unforested,
. Native shrub species tolerant of modified habitat conditions resulting from the crossing
of the unnamed tributary by holes 4, 5, and 9 will be planted to compensate for the
removal of over story forest cover,
. 30 m setback (buffer) will be created from all lands designated as ANSI, and the buffer
will be revegetated with species that enhance foraging and shelter opportunities for
wildlife, are non-invasive and compatible with existing native vegetation (applies to
holes 1, 5 and 9),
. a 15 m setback (buffer) will be created from all lands designated as ESA and this buffer
will be revegetated with species which enhance foraging and shelter opportunities for
wildlife, are non-invasive and compatible with existing native vegetation. This condition
applies to holes 2,3,4,5,6,7,8 and 9,
Veaetation
. a tree preservation plan and edge management plan shall be prepared as conditions of
site plan approval to address the removal and/or modification of affected areas for holes
5 and 9, These plans should include provisions for long term maintenance of these
areas,
. revegetation with trees and shrubs will be completed in the vicinity of the green for hole
6 and the tee area for hole 7 to compensate for the loss of vegetation in the hedgerow
resulting from construction,
. revegetation of the hedgerow between the 8th hole tee and the 7th hole tee will be
undertaken with trees and shrubs to compensate for the loss of vegetation during
construction of hole 8,
Operational Reauirements
. Signage to be displayed to inform players of the sensitivity of the area wildlife to noise at
particular sites, most especially hole 5,
. Signage and fencing will be used for holes 5 and 9 to inform golfers of prohibition of
entering valley lands and restricting access to cart path only,
Summary of Environmental Impact Study
Crooked Creek Golf Course
6.30
Attachment 4: Page 2
"
Monitoring
Establish a monitoring program to ensure the mitigation and rehabilitation measures are
effective in protecting the adjacent sensitive natural heritage features and functions.
. Monitoring and reporting schedule as identified in Appendix 2 to the
November 2001 report be implemented
Establish contingency actions if the monitoring program results indicate the environmental
objectives are not being met.
. Monitoring and remedial actions schedule as identified in Appendix 3 to the
November 2001 report be implemented.
Summary of Environmental Impact Study
Crooked Creek Golf Course
631
Attachment 4: Page 3
r
r
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
,
,
,
I
ATTACHM ENT 4A
Appendix 1
Analysis of Potential Golf Course Related Effects on Natural Heritage
Features and Functions on Subject Lands and in Adjacent Areas
A Summary table prepared by Shadowland and dated July 2000,
6.) 2
,..
ill
.,J
r:Q
~
I
I
J
t
I
I
,
,
,
ill
~
~
~
.,J
~
12
~
:2
o
~
(,)
~
lli
fil
.-;
ct
uj
D:
ill
CI)
!5
o
(,)
LL
.,J
o
~
.,J
:s
.-;
:2
~
o
Q.
LL
o
CI)
-
~
.,J
~
ct
CI)
iti
D:
ct
....
~
(,)
~
Q
ct
a:
Q
:2
ct
CI)
Q
:2
ct
.,J
....
(,)
!!::
~
CI)
:2
o
CI)
:2
o
j::
(,)
~
LL
Q
:2
ct
ID
!5
....
iti
lL
III
elll
.S! "0
..C:
U '"
Jlq;
CfJ
00 5
Ql.-
ao
.L: Ql
QlUl
c: .
,- CfJ
C:,_
_ CfJ
ro~
,SO)....;
co c:
O.L: Ql
E >. E
E.o c:
o cV.g
u - >
Ql 0 c:
~.L: Ql
'" '" Ql
-C:.L:
~o"'"
__c:
CfJ c: 0
oOJU)
<nEt)
a.a.Ql
E.Q'l::
,- Ql Ql
]!6;""ffi
c"O~
Ql "0 c:
15m2
a.CfJO
oa.
Ql a._
Ql 00
.c is..~
-QlCfJ
CfJ.L: ,.,
.........(ij
c: ~ c:
~.2ro
~ f/) Q,)
CLt) -=
<"'Ql
a.CfJ
C E ';::
0.- a.
:;::roE
(,).- 0
Go) C U
UlQl~
. . 15 Q)
~ 0.=
o ~ Ql
~mC)
U:= 0
QlE-
CfJ._
o CfJ
~-g
0'"
'Eo>
.- c:
""C 'C
Ql&
"0._
':;: ""C
~~
CfJ c:
.- Ql
~CfJ
Ql ~
:0 a.
'"
I-
W
ll:CI)
'l:w
55
~~
l::!~
00
If! 0
lfi~
..0
wCl
~w
<tal!:
:;;:~~
oo(::l
r-~
~Oo(
&l~E!
UlCl)"
Ei
:&0
~I
00
;::0
i!i~
...1Il
~~
ifi~
..11.
20(
:!
~
'" I!!
c "
m=J::
t(j ~
t!"C.$
:= c.-
......
- -"
j~=
....
'5,,"
.-.s::. 0
-f'-t;
$ 0"
1ii;~
:g'8.Q
",,1l
'" 0. c
$",2
~~~
'j ~ is .
~c41(;)
Q) cu g.x
c en 0 G)
'0.5 0 Z.
c~"'[ijc:
,2 ~.9 ~
Otcu;:'
='0-00
"C 0..'- 4l
e o..~ c
:E ~ 0. g
-
..
~
..
~
c
-a
.~
0(
"
1ii
l5
'"
~
ii
,ur
o c: ;:J (,/)
_ooe
fIlc8::J
Q)"OCU-
g~€.m
NcnCll_
.:.::: Q)J:: <<I
~'oo:a
,e:!t~..
4l (,/).- J::
Ul(llf?CU
.;..,. > Q) ~
C1J'- >-
ZmO:O
<C~4i~
"'00>(1)
C .--
ns0 III II)
~ .. "
<0>0
U),s.S 8
UJ tn C: C'a
E.5 g €
,g ~e~
~ Cl'l a:l '0
o"C.s::.c
mcum
..0 cu'-..Q
-..Jl2-ci
~";" '" :!t
~~.9!~.2
Q;J=M;:JID
.... ftl Q. 0 >
;..a II) 8~
mcu~roQ)
o.c.--2..o
ccunJ4lo
_nc..c:_
-
~ - '"'l'
:!
~
!
~
c
2
of
..j
eN Ul
1;i:S....= !
.~ a en ::S
-g .;: .9:! ....
..c CIl 0 Q)
.!~:S-s,~
=0(,/):::10
;>15~~1l
~~~;l
Q)CUl!!C
c ~ ;:J m
o 8 80>0
.2~~CO:.2
ts - cn.....1;i....:..
;:J J:: 0 .(0)
'0 g"-;;<<>!E'O
ge~.q:'8:i
.=:;~riEIll
I!!
"
~
;r
..
..
I!!
..
,5
2:-
"
2'
.!!
4)......
..",
~ 'g
02:-
1;i'E
'B~
.."
"'~
~.i
=S~
'i~
o~
,,-
"'0
.. -
~~
.=g
N
c-
:22
j:g
fI).9
,,-
'o.~
:!t.,
....
>0 I!!
",0.
o c
00
;a::zo
..
"'-
cB
....
..I!!
""
0",
8-
'"'"
eo5
1!-g
_<:I
oc
~'~ui
~.m lD
" 0. c
:68,2
" !'l il
.!::iti) IV
..",.0
"c-
a.!!m
E""
W"''''
--
N
633
c( .5
",'"
wl~.e
"'''8c
c CD .2
.. '" '"
_mmfl)
(I)~ € of! .
Z,_.. ..'"
<-.cZCD
.5~ollE
'" !! "," J!
o1:!_ C C
;ro~8~
~Sm i
.0 .. Q. i t:
ijgJ"1iiil
fii 0-5 c,Ul
.....;.:.s::.dl"C
>>(f.l D~ C
:'t:Z ~O_ al
.~ <( e c-;;
n "'....
if:i"C- t: 0
c c Ul._ 0
t: m"C Ul m
8 c( i.!R Ul
(I)-Om
'OW!!.!
~c5Ulm
c :c 8 >0"
:!! '8:t;
.!CD~Olt:
coO a:r: 0
oii-g lD-g~
:EmSm:::
"'0
co
'"0
~'"
.g~
.. "
",""
'"
..;
..,
.9l-
05
...c CD
r.n 1ii.c 0
"'::J-0
.8:2,5 I!!
E,~~E
::J"Co:r;: C'CI
c.5 Ul.e
.5!:,4l Q) CD
o 1a'o:t:=
= a; 8. ~
C'CI Co UllJ5
!~Ul"C
,a iii 5 :i
.!~8Q)
om:t:=
"CN€'P
~fj~s
1'""'1l
~c"
.. '" c
Bili.g8
"w ,,~
c $"
,2"'_:<,
e~o:r;:
Q)_fI) Ul
.:e (I) C) m
mz.5 CD
Q.l<(t:(ij
.!::i lID .m >-
E ... Co m
'c .s .c Q.
~~H
..;
~"
is'''
'ill
o-g
-'"
SJ!l
0"
e= en
ftlt!fi)
4l~=
.s::. CD'Q
-;; CD!..
1i.2 ..
ftl1;il;
......
lj"''''
c....
-"''''
>0
'"
;r
~
1ii
0.
,11
'ii
'j
-
o .
c .1
.2:t:=
-c
l'le
"'g,
'80.
::;0
'"
"
U
>=
o
Cl
'"
~'"
Uw
"''''
""
~.!!!
0>
- "
un:
N
..;
tl
...
o
:x:
...
~
~
is
~
l:!
o
it
o
~
il!
't
Q
1lI~
:!:~
00
j::!Il
oil:
U.lLU
lilt;
a:
!il
't
g
't
l:!!
i
~
o
~
I
...
i!
~
~
c -~-g
<lJ ~ ::i; \U
'E:::::.- "0
- ::l III us.:
~.eQ,)ZOCl
:ii ~ .2o;(~
EO en c ,...:
c-oJ!?(1)(l)
e~'O~.~
.~ (J),~'O~
ClJ'gilil'll>.
J!! Ul.~~.o
cu Q) ctH- CO
Q; ~ E . ~
-g52">-g~
E~~Ef3
~-5 g..~.=
";;:..; Q)~;
cu ~J: m-:;
.c_Q) >
Ul~.t:.~'C
('lICQ,:::c:2
coU)o~:E
&;-g~aE
.....!2 o'.c a
~~g~.g
...J l- .:..- ~ QJ
- (/) -
Q)wzUlQ)
€ g-ct -g 3:
m Q1 Q)~ E
(j:>-Sc~c
;c~o ~g.g
U"EcQio,!9
o Q) O.!::: 'E Q)
dE:eCQ)~
a.&.4)E>
~~ (Q--g 8, g
-g~.9~~~
_"O__ltl)(
~ "0 C:'u;j E Q,)
en Q) 8 U'l_ :>.
.- !II (tI'- 0 c:
~&.:oQJlIlctl
""00 mg.!!:! '0
.~o.'CN~rn
(tI Q) 2 TI a. >
~; rJ n:l ~ 0
l'lIt::o.ncE
Q):C-;1i.l~~
;:; ;'!::: ._ (J) a. Q)
.. ~ 1:::- Q) o.s::
'0 III cu..c c-
2.!!:! o.l-u~
~:g.E<Li~.~
"::J ~ c U'l U')
'SE.....oQ)U"I
u ... N .- ~
~g~~~Q)
C'3UE]gIll;:
~g~Q)~g
~~.!?~~::
t:QjO(/)=;::
a~J:Z.!~
.c>.....c{c:a
uo"iiQ)Cll..c:
r.c:E"i~,~
;::Q>3:E(l):=
~ffig6::o
c: Q) en ("') E" C
!!Gi-oQ) 0
c J: c:.c E .;::::
o~<<I""'::Ju
>.,=_EUl2
--J!!..c::~(ii
~~.=jC1la
c~f!:!-o:Eu
Q,)l'lI'OQ):CQ)
"CO) C\i......c
~=Sool-
03..12c.
g.'(5)~ ~ 16-g
....oii:(tI;!::!CI:l
~:Q.5c~!
._.0..... Q).c.-o
.... t:'~ ~ Q.l I'll
li5 g QJ cn.g~
.o-a."'OQ)
EZ'lI)~l1l~
Z:::l":;(ij >..~....
... -;:: cu .... 0
.9:! ~.$ ~ E.S:l
~~E~8~
~
o
:s.
~
..,
~
"
Q
,,~
00
:x: a:
.1:
C
"
<.>
C
o
'"
..
E
o
E
"
'"
)'I
W
:I:
~
"
1;;
Z
"
=
,.,
.0
'0
i!!
..
'"
C
..
'0
C
W
o
'0
"
C
~
..
i!!
.c
1-- >.
,,'"
:Om
.."-
:o:Q
CC
-"
5::E
"'m
"c
llQ
.5 g'
>'"
e "
Q..c
~:5
-.c
~j
'0 "
" ~
1;;"
c'"
"''''
'w.5
""
'0.0
"''''
.. ..
'0 fI)
~~
.~~
- "
i~
o
c-
8~
go
<'>6
"E';::
,,)'I
EC
..0
"'c
..'-
c"
..-
::E"
-'"
o '"
","
.3 Q'
":I:
c%~
Qj
o
Z
:l
~
" -
.c 0
~Qj
01;;
't:"'~
:lO-C
I-"C
Q) a. g
=.{; m
c'O C
.- $ 0
~J!.!!!
_"u
&-"
0"..
I!! "
"'''tl
.9 8 ~
1i:=i3
-g ~.:
,,- 0
qtl
8!E ~
ol:'C
~'!i'o
,,--
=.2-:;
-g~e
roc (G
Cf~fI)
~O..
",,,--
Ill,,""
iij=~
al1.l()
._ "0....
e ~ 2i
"i!!0
g. Co (f.)
.....1:0
o ..
c: a:: ~ .
.Q-$~
!:ii~c:
c: E en 2
""c
e "',- 11
Q) cu.:2: cu
Q. C 11 't:
.s~~~
-
"
a:
..
u
t:
.g
'g
't
"
t:
..
t:
.g
..
:
:il
"
'"
~
8
i-
:2:
16 '0_
:'!::"O cu==
~;-gQ)~cu
-c >- (U ~ en gj
Q)"'EI::l~J::
.go.282:_
Q)EI!:=:ggj
(iiEcuo-,o
z 0 0'J0l>-Q)
OQ)E~a.
~~~e.2-~
~....- 0 0
~o~!95~
<"51-:5 o.~
Q)'- cu -c (0
..c:3: O-c I: >
- ~.;:: cu co co
'Om~g~....~
Q)'_ I: Q)_ 0 c
Ol~O.... ~';.g
as ~.5! .5 .9!:g
Q)_Q):J-o~c
s; ~~2i:J 8
::..,.... ClJ - (U t:: 01
Q.Ol.....oOOC
~ 'E- ..... n:I en c..._
~ 'Q)~-oC.E
-OJ:::JI:O....
1:-~~Qi.1!!
.r:C'll.5=-o:>-
u"EJ:::tl:cal:
i-8j~:;~
~'~~2g;o
It....Q)~N....Q)
~:oi~~~=
~E31:Sm~:2
:OE"ii31-BfI):t
.S:~"O-~ciU;
-;;~ ; ~ in.5 'x
~~I:c(Z~~
32:20Q)<l:oo
.~ gr~= "'0 "": ~
'0 ~a:o,*~"'O
(b.oQ)enl):.;;m
Q"'O s:. I: en Q)'-
i$~'a.!!l! c~
..0 C.- r3 ' Q) ::I
~cu~en~"Ct::
1ii g. Q) -0 Q) 'S; 8-
'_I1.l:2C.l::Ea.
C.t: ~~I- 0.0
,'"
N
" ..-
1: ~ cl! _'0
&. ::I "E.9: .3 I: C'll l/J
~~~ ~~~ ~8.~.9
_OQ) cu enQ) I: Q)t:
~5".t:icuQ):R:;8.
~~.....gti.s'~ CD o~
~e~~~sg.~tsE
J!=~~(f.)~~~:mJ!
4)~Q)g~:!::!c-(IIQ)
.:2: C"'O Q).g Q).J:: !l}.J::
U 0 C'll= ells:: :J.!!! r!;
.. E E'j~.. g,5 ~_!:l
:Jl Eg i:O:J ~':::.E-o:S
III ECDa.>oU)"'OtU:J
J::.... :2 Ol"ii m 2-.= 2-
I- ::s.5=.5 0l....1!.::1:
C/i82--::g'j! ~1: ~ t:"
1:JOlllC.... (;Sea
c: U).:2:..2.2 m 0-", i!! a
IV III fI) 10 .- .0-
1:'0.2 0,2 og:J o-c
t: 8.~.2 ~8.-c en.::~
.!!UllllU)UlUlQ)O::-::::l
C:lll1;l:2=31til::lUl
owo-I: Q)-!IlQ)
.. " E - 0 Q) 0.:-::: l!?'-
~s:._<<IE~~:l:J~
;s-:..caOl....U)Q)Ega.
~C'.!2:.5Q)Eo..aQ) U)
::lo Q) .... en 0>- E:= ....
~ ~ ~ ~ 5 ~ m g. &~
_~o-oU)mE"iilllO
J!!'OE~Q)3m>=>-
:a C e,J::~.- Q)- C
(OtU~;:;~Go-co~
"'i!_C c'c !illl 11 0
~(IIg8'i:0lc.n~I:Ul
'_-U)Q).stU31g":Jl"
ari.E-g-csQ) lll'~
.EEeo~lll=15i5.~
't;I,g Q) ~ c ~o 01 III .l:
c:_-Co.O;;:lll~J::O
(0 en ~=:;.g E en.... ~
2':g~~""Ul..06ui_
,=.0 (j)_.2>._OO..c"O 0
't;j en"C CEO ~ c: Ul
Q)ecQ) 8.uiea~1:
~tica[.5t/Jgc"E~ .
oQ)l:o$:Q):,;;oCDea.!!
U} .::.2Q)'w~'C R o-:;'Ci)
II) 0 0)> Q)-o e o.!!lo.Q)
.9!&-8:5l8 e-g &.-5
..;
't: ;::
" 0>
I- '0'"
" c-
1:15 :5Q)~2_
Q) en .5 = :ii gm
~..Q j.5 E....lO')
OlcnOl...."O en 6:::.
CUQ)I:~I:UlQ)....
~~~o~~Q.~
E-c-fI)cU)t::Q)
_8gl:~~o....l
UlE'-.ga..52'E
..8 o.E~E'-a:-6
_iil1.ll:Q)~1:1:
I:I:EQ)EooQ)
~:8~E~~~:g
Q)l:!cuEmo::l<(
Q..Q)1:8cum"C
.{; g. E e ~ ~d:i ~
'0
C
~x Q) 1'0
cog~Q) g
!! ~ C 8 :5 ~:;
ii l) .2_ Z'tV.....
~~J!o a ~.g>
;!:(f.)Q)Ol-oE
Bz Olf1).S I:"E
'C c( !!l! :5 .!!! E:o
~~$:E.~.alll
Gi::'~.g:!: ~=
E 0 g.- . $ '0 I:
.2c....~>-tVQ)f;1
~ R< ~ ~:g tV
~ 0 tV lll'(O'= ~ 3l
Gio.€:5-35en
.:: C'll 3: I: 1?: "00)'=
Q).= f1) Q) tV s:. c "0
en-c c Q) cn._ III
~ja~j!e~~
.. :::
.S go ~
.~:e8~ 8
"'>..9! ~:l I:
.. .. ..
~ &~-8~~
8 :!.!l!', U)'0
1:.Q)~e8:o
tUcntUa.c,!!
Co:';; i.Ii' <G._
Slll~tU~:a
'~Q)o~:5l
E'. 0. <<I m Q)
o.g~ ~E=
.l:-~"'Ol
R ~g.=.2.E
~;.~,!! g'o .
Q)- 4)'-'- Q) f1)
,J:: Q)~:c.E~::I
~~~~jg~.~
:l
"
!
~
!
~
""
.... -
58:5~~ .
~~I:~~m
1d~~8.:e:2
ta::1:Q)o.!g
: oni~o gj
c.n"gEfI)cC.
~~~~g1?:
"Cf1)"OtUBm
tV1;jC~=Ul
~~C'll_g'~~
e"g:S:~C'll:!l
$5c8E-e
Q.o .... :J Q) E G>
cn........._..c
N
~ e6 is ~ ~ ~ .~
.;;::: l!c :J"C~-o- ~f1).-g.
~ 01:2 ..c.&"CoB .:::1::1::.-:r:
~~~*~~o~~~~ ~il~..-g
,2c~:J >~ '9. '''0
=~"gig ~~.g Ei o.~-g~! ~
::g'ii)C'll-.- -l'G lll_a.Omcfl)(,/)
., Q) _ C m:-::: c Olin m C'll'C ~ tU E CJ)
~~I:Q)llll'GenCC'll....OlllOOOlI:
o~~~~I~~~~~~~'~-o~
Q) enoUl:t::1:::J....eatO E.!!"O
g.~~~~8~~I~:otg<~~
~ t- ~ Ul I: I: E ..~ ~ ~ >'-0 .~ ..: e 01
"t:. 0).-.... a.lm (II >..9::!.a
.a 00 g'gcn-!~ ~'8 ';i3j-e dl~
.~z::la.zl'OcuEo .2:2>-cu~:J
Clc(l/JU)<Q)Q)Ol:l 'coQ)~.....o
N
6,) 4
'00
co
..0
'3'N
~~
.. "
.c""
(/)
.c
..,
Q) :2
= ~
C " '"
:2,CQ)....
j .s'~ ~
t/J U) ~~ .
-".... "'..
o .... 0l"O~
Q)m.Sc:-c
a.....-om=
U)Q):J CJl:l
-='Oc....
~ 0 .S '0.2
a.="-:'l! U)
\D-oi.g!
> I: a. .-
:;.er385
1:"Cc.nC't::
Q) Ol-c m 0
U) ::s c"C a.
::)E~~g.
..;
"'-
C ..
g>e
0.2
- C
'00
iii$
01=
c:2
't; 'j
,,-
co'
_'0
on; fa
~15~
.3~.!!
.0
"
<3
-
'0
t?
""
~(/)
<.>w
'0'0
" "
~.!!!
E~
<.>'"
..;
[fi
...
~
...
~
~
is
~
~
!.!
!;!;
~
II!
ore
is
~
e!
..,
~
lli
...
~
~
't
~
~
i
e!-
..,
~
~
.!!! 0
",.,
o.~
0,,-
'ii C:
>.-
'" "
~:5
"'-
"0
E"
c.",
o 0
~Z
" .
'0-
,,:;;
"'.0
7':E
-~
~ '"
g~
..0
!= .
-0"
1l,,'O
.- Q.J::
8' .Q ,~
:g~=
.0"'0
C: G)::s
0-_
cCCi)
-"",
~K8
~~2
"'>'0
"'''''
at "0 >
~~~
s-;;e
"'.-
~E 1l
c~E
e -g it
>::Jg
c.e ._
",,1;
.!lSGi
!!!", C>
lD_ ~
15 e 0
E.=Z
'" E .
U)1lI)~
:ggg
:g:2 N
a. -g ts
g8~
e-t)
-8.~ Ill)
.~ ~~
8aw
0_
<:cO
0'-00
O"z
...J"'<(
05",
'" ,-
" .'"
.-"0 _
'i"i
'" E"
'OJ:2Cii
;~N
-~-
5 z.~
alEE
rn~~
o~"
g.oo
-"'",
a..~ ....
"'''' 0
.- it-
0",'"
..!!2-o!
.. '" ~
"'.!Pm
--"
"0-
.0 _ ,.,
E -O.iS!
~"o.
ZCll,.!..
00
.J! a...!.
o e :::J
:I: 0. 0
...
~
~
l(
~
-@-
~
....
ii
'"
~
.Q
OJ
.!l
E
"
:2
~
~
'"
o
..
0.
.5
"
'"
"
=
.Q
tl
~
II
:l:
-
:;;
.0
E
~
'"
"
'0
E.
"
>
o
.0
..
~
'"
~
u
'"
'6
~
..
'"
u
i
'"
o
~
"
;;
'"
,,~
'" 0
...'"
'"
:s
8
c:
~
.~
't
~
Ii
.~
~
'"
ii
o,g
';~
~~
,Qu
<<1=
'00.
" 0.
","
-..::l>.
"'=
" ..
'O~
.- 0-
'" "
e e
~..
~-
"-
E "
.0
1i E
:; E
c>,,"
:200
::;:"''''
~
~ .~
.. '"
",- 0.
tl 0
..- :c
" "
I "'.0 "
'OE '"
'" ~ I-
""'''
~ <0"'"4>0
~oJ:
! !..c;:.~ ~
-'"
.f E.Q -.;
~~ :: Q,
.0 '" 'c:
t).t:: a:I "
.. U > ~
Q.Ul.!!
E " "
'0 _
'"
:;;
.0
E
~
'"
"
'0
'"
.e
'"
..
"
E
~
'"
"
=
"
:u
"
'0
'"
'"
;S
.e
"
0.
o
~
'"
"
E
"
E
0.
o
~
"
'0
al
'"
o
0.
o
C.
"
=
'"
~
i
'"
~
g
'6
'"
8
,,'"
~~
I
-
:;;
.0
E
~
'"
"
'0
'"
.Q
]
.'"
"
'"
"
'0
'0
'"
..
'"
';
.0
E
~
'"
"
'0
'"
'00
"'0
~o
3~
0,.,
'0-
..~
",""
en
~
.e
'0
.!!
o
'"
'"
..
"
'0
'"
'"
~
.Q
"
E
..
'"
"
=
~
..
tl
~
"
;;
z
"
"
1:
~
.~
't
~
"
..
c:
o
'"
&
..
ii
'0
"
O~
'" 0
",,,,
..-
".Q
~]
~'5
- '"
- "
.Q'O
,,'0
E:ii
:g",
,,-
=~
",E
.- ~
"''''-
,S! lU q;
Cio.c
g~ E
:E.Ei:
...-
tl
I
;;
'"
!
&
" -
:g .8
'" '" E
.- ... :::l
=.81.::
.eE~
,,~'"
E"'-
('I:I.J!J2
(I)~M
"_'0
=.E:i
!e.....
....'"
'" "'0
U"..
.. '" 0.
o.E ;; .5
-..-
.0
"
u
'"
o
Cl
'"
~!!1
Ow
n
oc::
6,) 5
<( '0
" I/) C
~ UJ -!!!
c:..c~ c_ ~
o ii 0 8U1"O ~
.sc.d,"OmZmm
t .... C ......<(..c >-
.~ca.... ra-g;::J(/):!::
>ocpc Q)>,C
:2Cl1(;aL~7ii.o~
/I).. ~.... _ c:.... E
c:"2-o 0).. 010 E
:g Q) C >.~-'Ui ..9:1 0
_!::sm Q)mu
j!CJ)e~_~I..!!:!
i >.C) "m III 0:: "C m
Em _--zr::::3:
~,; ." ~ " ~
g.6 0 m (ij':: 'C Q)
.:J! ~~3:Q.dJ:E
i;Gimm~~>-o
Q)S~""c_.orJl
.s-o,a.!!EttlQ)
cu"'....CQ.9:!oQ)Q)
G;!?~~.o.t:(ij';
"O.ao-o.f!tnQ;l'C
om>-tD-lll..c:::2
E.s!~C:'O""-u
Q)'(ij CI.l'ii) c co
~~='E1QES1ij
'>.S-8.ti~o'j Q)
!.f!.:;: E:;~"I::l:E
U)"iij e~~~~'O
"Ea.c:-ocQ)
< OG>!NQ)c:
()~_::s:.;:::::;.:.::::Eo
O'Eii~~az
-JCD5.t:_.co.
U::S~Q)U'l_"oQ)
>,C"'o..coQ)C1lro
.c~E::.!i~<;;"
-0.... ocv"'3:(/)
l>>.g1Jt:=!zc~
,l:! ,,=" ,,<( ~..
00.'-0. alQ)-
co==om.l:uQ)
Q)-..cz!-g:o
1i~.~ m'Oo.f!
o C.f: _.!Q Q)- Q)
m Q):r. >.1: "0 C..c
':::-m1:_.-Q)-
~i!8..S-5~'S
oEmE?lIloCJ)Ul
~o.~o.1JcnmQ)
s..2Eui!~~
"0. ~ :: .!!.:; Q) E"O
Q)a> .Qoe-Q)
j:'CQ):::::JnJ ot)
t:'C: "UJ~g ~~
J! ~.S..c m >0'- Q)
~o .... _UII)
_o.~-<($8.-
comOcnmf/)o
~a.!~UJ.~_g
a! l1).2! ~.f2~
U)~=5'- i5..a.~
-g:2~c.ajg-g~
.!!~::S~C:"O"OQ)
c..e_oll.lc'c
00..c~N-m-
>-.~ ; E ti ~ ~ :5
Q)"2 CD::S m..Q.u'~
.: ::::J 0.. o:! Ul Q) .
c:E.2Q)(l:I'-a.Q,l
(l:IECl:I=Ul~UlO
-8 > l:<(Q,l lV..l:
1/1 Q) ,_ VJ ... ;=: Ul
o "0 .l: UJ tn"O.-
E l: Q;l'~ <o:t==
ii.2.c 3: ~ ... 3:_
'CE=:Q'ii~cg
!!&:=~EE-8t;
~ Q;l i;' ru an :::::I '<ij C .-
o>~",,,,,,cQ;lOC
-oc:epCDQ)",u~
.El::e'E=.=4i.E1O:
g~Q)_c E'C'c:
(\S.sni:2n; E ~.~
"9.Q)OO3::t=='oU)
;n:Gi--:>>.cUlE'"
o.cRl(ij'CRI~epo
a.l-(1)=Q).r::.c...(1)
o ~E-lVlVlV'"
... ,R1._ 5 01:2 .0 ("(l
a.Uj"lVUlo-oUl_C:::
Ul C lV lV- lV lV= Q)
:;~;(ij!Ql;;:=.o
... ru .c ell _ .~ Z Co 0
Q) ep- Q)= a.. .--
.0'" Ol+; ~ E""';"'--o
E - C ._ ~ m Q)
::151$5:20 lilQj
c'51Q)t::ii u~ C'I:!;!
..!! 0 C 0 a..{g C ~ ell
ooca.t::c::IOC
::t::oS8-rJE!..8zS
i:
~
Q,
'~
"
~
,,'"
00
:>::2:
,!!l
"
~
llJ
;;
2:
c
o
"j!!
~u
-"
cOo
0"
't:~O
~ u "
I- ~:6
~.~ .5
-;; -00
.- lV_
~!i~
... lV .!:;;;:
,,~'O
Oo,,-
o ~ 0
Ul::l::!:;
C 0 ~
o u ~
:;~l!:!
-g g, C'II
"-c ~
E '"
l'l .
El;:-g
S'c: 00.
,,0>
....u;-o
" ~ c
~o"
;~ ~
C .~ tU
C'111:"5
~!!,Q
..... 0-=
'" 0.'0
CD lD CD .
C;j=E~
alV~c:
~"OC::l
~.:! ::I ...
Q5uQ)8
Q.l!:!..c en
o a.::: 't
'O~~~
.~~~ 0
s~~j
1:: E Ol en
~ ~.5~
Q) m,~ C
"5.lij86
.E~l!:!Ot
"
~
~
8
z.
~ .;;
10"0 13_
.~ c-o cu=
.amcQI:=5l
~~~~~~
lVCO::l...-
C'I~'= S.a in
alEJ!!,,:!:::g.~
0- U
~8~0li;'~
w:;=:-Ea.Ul
.ge,gto
~0!1U~Z-
lUtil-~6'~
Q):C . CU"O C'II
S~.2.cc>
.... "'Q)CUC'll
o~.BO)>>"'ui
Q)._c"Ocu.gl:
Q)UQ Q)a. Ul ,2
"0 8. C ... I lD:!::
II> eIl'-:! ,S:;; 'C
Q)_lV::::l"O,c:c8
slij~.o8.::::l
;:""od~~5-g 01
g.'e.!:: ~ ell 8:,5
"g"O~'5-g 0 E
C-UlCUQ3~
t5~:E:=;i;1:
:.c:c:!:::=c'=l!!
~~:c~:-oS
(i)'UleOC~O
C6e~~2Qj1?
:3a;3:o~~-
~E~~M1?~
iSEQ3'ii-BUlj:
c: =' Ul 4) .-
;':::'1Il-g<( Ul ~.~
.e~ tUU)<('c>>~
:.:::Q)cWU)(U_
;g~.24)wog
~(1)5r=~-.o
'0 ~a::oii ~"O
Q).olVO)41~~
O'C.cCOl4)'-
fa!! -;;.5. ~ c~
-e C.- rJ . Q) :::::I
:3~~Ule:25
-c-lV'C(Il>a.
'!!!(Il:2C.c2a.
a.:: 3: l!! I- a. 0
N
"
"
"
..
;tl
~
..
"
~
"
,!;!
1;;
~
i
t F:
~ 0>
I- '00>
" c~
-15 .c (Q-
~ 01 ~1?E ~Ol
Eo :O~EQ).3m
Q)- Q)'- IJ) oS
g>Ul~Gi~eIlll.l...
c~ii::t::(UQ)\.!)Q)
(U:::::I:3 0 _U'l_:t::
E~oellcgjt::lV
_occ.!!!_o...J
Ul 0'-.20. tU a.E
Q)o.~ii-.!:!:B:::::I
..0 e"O e 01'" "0
-niQ)eQ)ocC:
ccEIl.lEooQ)
~B~E~~i:g
Q)(UmEcuo::J<(
c..aicoc-O:(ii"O
~ g. ~ ~ ~ ~Jj ;
C8~-c
0(U-41 ui
rn'tcEE ."
U::::lom ~:2
lVUl~c;:eQ)o
tt:ClVC-N'~
~o11i2.:O;:~
~ -g.~ ~ g ij c..
Q)m~Q)a.--o
>...::Jii-ooc
-cQ)'O~c m
tOme (UCUl
~ ~ m.g'~~-8
1: "Ott:.s: (U 5'0
lV c 0.-......-.-
-gc:~.5a.-e
~o2~Eg-~
,!!l
"
..
I
1!
'i:
2
,f
t:: ~ ~~ -
&. :3E.23 cn;~
e-! 8 ~~-u:::::I..;..~ a C
iil - - 0-".- ~. 0 '0 2
_oQ)(Uo(llclDt::
U'l :J C)':: "0 cu .. Q) .... 0
-co 0Q) Q)UlCo.
lij~....._1J.s~Q)o'C
"i:5~~.s!ic:C.2~
t:....ccQ)_o.:ot:
J!;~~(/)~z.~~J!
<U~lD8u):t:E-(UlD
,l!:c'C lD.gG).J:;lD.l:
~ ~ E~ g.c 5-:~ ~i
Q)Ec:...e-fI!~E>=
U'l 0 <<I <u:3 (U .- 'C_
41oEQ)a.>>U'l"O<<I:J
'(:. i=t c: ~ g''&'; ~.S ~
f:S.;,:;:.o'.... :3~S ~
~oQice.s!!~CUlt:
c:: fn.;l!:.2.g m o~ l!! a
~.~ ~1j 0'0 o.o15.l:
~ 8.-e.2'"":&; ~.:~
'O.;;UlCDrnU'lell(ll15:S:j:
C::4)1D:2;mUc:=>oUl
~ m oE = a m 8.:= ~.~
~;._tGE.s~:=:::I~
~':-:6gQ;C4Q)E8;r
i Q; 0- :.= E 0..0 Q)_
Io,.lDtiUlee>>E"2iQ;
J2~E ~:::::I~ ~ g.Ol=
-:;:O'Cfne Q3~o
~-OE~Q):::::I~>-~
"2;; (Il,S;'3'o-8o cu
.c::~-51:g'.Y8.G)8o
~(U58ocmell~cUl
'61- en Q)-6 to S::::I8 ~.~
e~,E-g'CgG) Q)~
J2 E eo lij Q)=15 o.ft
"O"g Q) l!! c g>'O tn Q) .c
1:: --50..20 Q)'ct=. 0
COUl&=-_Etn :::::I
O):g!!J'i l! III 0 g ui!/!,
.$:.0 4)_o~,~(/).l:"O 0
1i] 01"0 cEo . ~ c U'l
Q)ccQ) ll.lell(U!!!c
.:~ t'CI [.5 fta ccB .
OQ)Co$(1)'-OQ)(U.!
CIl co2ii'u;~~ 8 g:;'u;
CIl 0 5r> Q)-C C 0......0.4)
.s ! a:: ~ -5 j S e ~ &.-5
M
ell 41"5>-
-gi3S~E..i5
cumc:::IcQ):.o::
ia.2So(iol!
....~1U:!::Ec.2"
~<(Q)g,'(iEE
oVJ 5rQ)~~"E
'~W>-5>.i:o
m~.!E~!!~g
Q; :::.~ 2.~.!!::: Ul
Eoa.-J!0I0:g
o g 5.~ "0 .S m en
';; :e a.w ; :s ~ ~
_ 0 cu (Il 'C'S'-
l! a..c.c~.c 0 i
Q) to:t::: - 4) Ol 4)
c 3: c ... ::::l 0'"
G).s<ufP.Ol2c..o
C'i.c c ~ ~ 'C"
Q):t:::oom~a.c
a:::t:NUl__Ult'CI
CU OlO Q) ~
'~:E 8 ge
en Q) C (U::::l
9? ii RI C U;
~Q)~l1l~ii
U ~u;:2'(ij Il.l
ClIc'->E:5
Cl'C e -0
8'u;~ a. o:S:
cU- .._:>>
~ e i gj ~~
.! Q)O e.c:-
c..a.CU._Cl
'(ijgQ)>>g~
E:c.s~IJ)~
Q)U'locella.
:;J!;'-~~
~~jj)~~"'11l
.cl1)~"Ot'CItt:::J
~Bg,j~~X~
N
'0
0>
.~
"5
e
'0
c
..
<;;
>
o
,.,
""
0>
C
tj
"
c
c
8
,.,
~
~
$
$
..
'8
E
E
@
..
.s
..
."
.c
..
~ .
.9lm
I~
!/!,'O
0..
c ..
0.2
B.i:"
!E~
'8"
::;l'l
...
ii
11l :c
;; ,.
c " ~
:E.cQ)'"
" o.u $
~;8.Q3
en(UU'l~a)
.8 ~ ~"O::=
8.~:o~;g
U'lQ)::JOl3:
--SUe'"
~ 0.5 '5l.E
0..5.....:: f! ;
?l-g~.g::::
'1ii.e~85
c.cU'lc't
410l-C~&.
~e~~g.
M
c ..
. l'l . '0"
.~ -gal ~,/lc 0,': ~E-'l e
..c~(UEtO 6 sQ)02...; .~:o':';= Ji
:!::c_Q)~c'C~-E'::4141""tO~~~
~.glijE<<loCUQ."O<( ..c.c Q) 3:0:3 0 Olti
~~:t:::::::l1ll8~.~4) .~lVU'l~Ul c-c~
=_'-e.~oo~o u;~J(u~~:::I~ru;~~~
..... _ _ . ~ co 0..0 C Ul e ... (Il c:
iti~'C 5 e'!~ ufa.e 2-:.;: ~-. "!"fi gcio
U(IlUl<( -:3Q)-CUl-co~Ul"'C EcE'
~~~ l~~~l~~~ ~~~~~.~ E8~ ~~
C .....eIlQ)CI)u '-OI'tOl.oQ)l;::c> 0 0
~ 5 Q; c = :; c i E. E g,g -o.st E rJ g'lii E ~ E
~~Emc"OQ; ~lV c"'j:m~-~~OQ)
.awEo~3U;~5U;~Q)~.2€Q)e~€~€
.~G:::I'E-~o~o~cu<<l~(UEQ3oE(U~oa.o
O=Ul :C.SCI)>eIlCi)SOl ~C<(~~CIllC
N
o5b
'"
u
..
.c
li
..
0;.
z~
<(;g
:5I
Eo;
,g~
"i.2
o~
q
11..
~B
Si
iii.e
~ "
J!t;
4)ii
(ij(ii
i~
,,$
o&.
lE
~l'l
:;~
"C.21
"..
....
'0 Q)
~:a
cn:o:;;
....
.. c
.!I! 8
.~ 0
u=
.. g
~ :;
~o
8 ..
-"
'Oc
Cl2
.,;
"'~
,S Q)
~E
.e.e
-gs
CU~
"'-
c:E
~-3:
.. ~
.:J2-g
o (;i cu
=:s~
.9~J!
M
~
o 'i
<(~ m
U)C('UlEui
~VJ55,~
~~8E~
~!~~~
ocn.l:Co
c..-o lV.2 0
.s~.~rg~
Q) _ a.(Il.c
-5 ~ E8 ~'J
'0 2 ~i
~ti~~c
o cecu
.-.. ~._-
Q.5~~g~
fnO-C'c
...
"
;;
'"
:E
o
,,-
~.c"
ol~l~
... C) Ul .::
.8 "C Q) 1? 'n;
EC~--
::::l 8;.5~
~~g~~
cv CJ) =' >:!::
55~~:C
<(g.-8~~
...
'00
co
"0
-N
~ .
'0""
.. ~
~~
I/)
."
"
'0
c
"
E
E
8
i!'
"
c
o
Z
.,;
c
:c
'"
,.
:1J
'!i
ji
'0
1l
c~
"I/)
.ez
~<(
c~
.c
~
u
'"
o
Cl
'"
"
i!'1/)
Uw
al'"
",:Jl
0'-
e~
ua::
.,;
fa
5
:J:
...
~
~
~
l?
o
it
o
~
'"
ll!
<0:
:J:
o
~
~
o
~
ll;
...
~
~
<0:
:t
o
>::
l!i
>::
i
~
o
~
I
...
~
~
~
e:
'" 0
c: 13 en
- al-c :::::J:::J
~ES.:.::~o
Ql.ge~c:~
(;j Q)~.o 8 ra
Q).c Q) Q) 4) € 9!
.l:-~.J:.!:Q)t=
I- :: e ~I-::
. In ca 0 .0 c
~ ~ II) 1ii Ln tii CD
.;!: (j e coR >0 I!!
:t:= :::I 'C 0 0)
~"51ii"iij J:: E.J:
CD:E~.&::..se;'!:!
~:l:c:'5<OQ):t
C'II-euo'O.J:::E
"Et5eCllc:~-
Q) oQlra.-C)
E~'C:5v3.5
cQ)cC:fI)U)O
eo aI o~ Q) CD
'>:Em"Co..':~ .
cCU_Gl.c=gN
Cb>CDBm:l: "C
OE~.2~~~~
~J!ui.!l!2.a'>""
tn"C~c:gcaftSJ!!
Q)C::::IG> .!! c:
-cal:el!:?"fic:8"Q)
.s:::. Ei:: 0)._ GIG) E
.21ma!l1ljl!:?>"fi
.c "C c: ...c::: C) CD ttI
cu"C.-- (1:1"0"0::::
cd5~4)'SC:.s<(
.Sa.Q):2em"Cc:
> _ U) Q) CO'-
C'lI~c:.c=Q)>"O
.C._01;::(Q-OC:
cn-;!;~o.goEC'll
cuoG)c(lScl!:?:r:
COG) 2'~ 0,9 ellS!
S;=.!!~!O~~
....>."'00-2="0
..,Q ~"O en '0 :r: G)
mUlcac~C:CI)CI)
-:-g~~'~8 ~ a
4).!!'- - E lD - en
cCi5s~g=i:ii:i
1:: Z'- - .~ CI.J III
~<(5si3.~-g~
::;Q)~xe~~.!!
....O"Cc:-::J:>O
U~o~EEl!:?~
0'0 E CD ra E ca (tJ
<3wo.c-OOQ.l
Q)_-cuocn,O
~!!::"C 8-= c:m=
...J:s -.- 0 lI)'i
"O>.om~;;G)
.!!~ 0."0 ~s 0..-5
~(ij oS.::. CD.2._
.~> c.~Jl ~:j
m8.m~~"O~:3
"Oo(ijVJ~~ '0'
alCJ) Q)'- 0 ui Q)
I!!..~ale:o":i:'
ra.c--t::r:Q.
"0-.5 Q)J! Q)..2E
-8EC~/1)=~~
g.g~ ,=,9 ii~
:r: "0 ~ "g E en "E C
cu.!!.21&.,g g Q):
.~e:G"C~~K,9!
,Ca)"OC:::3oo:'t:
j 2"< ra g!EQi 5
U)(I)U'lo-g>E
-i:iw8.U)E~E
...,OG.lo41 g
:0:: .'c"'Ji:; ~!
i.st- >--.-- c
_ . 41 <<:1:::3 C 0
"0 c U)'=.! rifr: ~:'""
mG.l"O<<:I4I...~m
o~'i!>U'l=3:il
g.~:: !! 3: c ~
... a) <<:1- _ - 0 >
a.cn:;>-ot'.,;
(/t.__,O-mmm
.- -'3'" U'l a."i)-5
10 0 0 III Ul c 0)_
... CU.;::.c !Q ,- Q) 0
G) Q.O)o l:S (/t">
,O.Ecu.ccu.t=.>-8
E-UlU.cni'8C
:::3.!!OCl:l1iiQ.o~
C"EG)Q)a.~:>'-
""e:E~<<:I::-~
'O-c cuo'C5
:I: &.8,guo ;;"V,j
i::
~
.g.
"
~
"on
'0 c:i
:J::t
Gi
~ (I)
, .."
.t=. -o~
i.G~ ~
"'C,,,!1
~~~ ~
-e:"
U'-: 13 '"
co E,~ fij
~1lU
::5co-
008,10
CI:l-o~
~:i5_0
mE~.t=.
ii Q.l c!
:.;::; Ol Q)-
i~iOO
_<<:141_
8.e:g ~
memm
=U'l'c"C
lIi,9!;:ii
eUc......::
; 8.~ii5
_Ul4:lZ
~E'o<c
:::.!!!ll"
<( a."C =
....:...2 i_E
0> x~
.5"fi m.t:::
~"'m3:....:..
~Zmo"'"
cUlCi~e
80..c:-co
-;~~~
,~;hi;l
~Ul(l)E!~
-g.9!,C a.<c
~t-Q)m
W:::3 .= Ul
c ECi)--
coEzOUl
:g 0 < G.i 5
00 c;
oc8"'(U
".gc8.~
.cni.!\!!> U'I
j ~~ ~ ~
5 ~ ~ !'Q;
:;Q)==~
.0=cm,C
g.~ ~ e~
U'l.........ra=
~{:ii 8.~
~e!.2~
:ii~~U'lra
-.:::: 0.- 41 Ul
~.s:2-5ca
'C "C 3:.S ~
~ ~E:€-g
~Q),g~~
0) 2: ... "C )(
m~m;;4:I
..... e'(ij::::;-gj
'o"""'~
3: >-z Ul
~_,O<("C
::1:3-gG.l;;
~ g.t::=-
,- 0; 8.5 -g
-gi!:~:€:.c
'; ~ vi.!. ~
.- ... G.l
:::-.g'oE!
l!!'E8.{!l::
=8U'1Q).e
:t ~! = '0
U') 8.cao=
...00::: _
! iii >- u; li
E-g~;Q.
::1 cu c i 0)
~ ~ ,~- ~
'0 e:! lP ~,~
::I: 0l9=.2Q)
"
~
I-
'"
e:
..
~
'"
..
~
'"
~
""
~
"
8
e:
g
,5
~
e:
~
'"
e:
.!!!
"
;;
'"
.c
'"
0;
'"
"
;;
.5
e:
"
'"
..
"
"
'"
e:
"
e:
"
il
"
..
~
~
'5
i
5
'0
'e:
8
'"
..
~
J!
..
a
e:
o
'"
..
e: '
n
" ..
"ii '0
",0
" ..
;;~
-g!
.. e:
e: "
~ ~
O),g
-g~
..w
j~
~~
U
"..
B'"
,,~
~"
'58
0>"
~:€
'" ~
~-g
1-'"
"
"
".2
'0""
C'o c:
~ 8. ';'
'll"""
",' e:
...1:::1
~B~
J!~8
!~.S!2
- ~
"'-
-g i.5
"'e:"
~.2 G.i
'0 III
al~ ..
-,,-
"'~"
,,- ~
,,- "
oOll
~~o
0.""
,,~e:
~oo
_"N
~.~ 8-
ti 8..2
",,"
e:_",
e:e:e:
gB'"
GJ!E m
:ic",":
o'~.c
~'" -
=~~
mCit::
0.'0 '"
"e:"
B'> "
Q)E!=
~ Q. e:
; >-:E
e:e:",
....'"
,,""
" O.!!l
_ 0."
" 0. "
~"o.
-""
mom
~e:~
; 0'::
,,'" 0
e:"'=
I:e:"
",,,,~
e: ,.,-
8 ,t::: ~
e:"
H5
.- E
8'go::
- Z
ge:::;;
wBo
i.! ...
,OI:P.e
~ ~"C .
o>!lD
O"Ecu5
>-raO-N
.c"l!!u
c !E a. tQ
II) C t:: a.
~,~ 8.,5
" "
Q)<<Ia::!
"'3j--
5 .c(l) E
-!! ~~,g
~g.!8
"C--C
- 0 c: co
! c'--
o Cii.S!2
11)"0 Ul"C
=-'ili
o.a~'C
II) c >- c
:I::l.!!.cca
~1:~~
I!! 8.. .5
~:s-16 e
t- co J2 c.
~
t
.!l
CD 10 fi QI
ocifS'tl
:t:e:z:u;
s:
~lt'i
ill""
~"
'8';;
o I!!
0>",
e:"
i-~
1iie:
~i
" >
0>0
"E
~I!!
-"
~.c
j.s
Gill
0>"
.. 0
,~ g.
l!!(;,
..-
,,~
,.,.c
0'"
~5
0;'"
1iie:
E'"
._.c .
~-N
ECii-
0.- e:
a."',,
..I!!E
.S!2S"fi
",,,,,
I!!U
"'~
-e:
0_._
,- 0
;...i
.S ~ 'g
1JEo
e: " c
S C'-
U'l1! -!!!
u;oll
~->
0"0
-~ E
~ t- !
igB
=Eo
llE-
Eg~
q::!-
e:"'"
g,,~
-~i5
:1,,_
c.- Ul
(l).c .-
E~<
e:,,"
o ~ '
.!:: !
>"",
.n~::
w-o
o(.~ t
,.,'0 B
~~!E
1I)t: ~
~~'0
",- I!!
~etQ
e:"..
,,'" e:
-!!~"
~ii
11.."
::Efl)
o.!!l "
".c "
:I::lE=
" 0._
:.c 0
~~ Q)
"..e:
~"O
I-:I:Z
N €
~ '" 0
.e QJ _" CD 'fi c
ll;;"'15:<:..;
U)oo-j: 5
08-1"0.
~-i.2'8~
'i~~'H~
l! CD m
..' tl e:"
Q)-g;;ca~:a
~ 0 0.
I- ~j.5~~
U'I..c:c: CDc: 0
--'-.c 2 ttl
:i'Oc~'OJ~
Q.IIDQ)_CD_
m'CE-e:O:c
i::'ij QJ _0
!!.c ff5!eca
... 1: c.!!.@!
.eg<<liq5ca
ii"E".."
~ ~ '0 o.~ i'
m- 0- Q.
3j15 ,; 0'0 al
.s~~!~ttl
, 0.- 0 16
-g!$-OU'l-
ca E - .- ca
"'E;8;~
~ 8~;'2!5
E CDZ; Q.~
e=.1ii:OJ
g'O~ll:C~
c!"c""c
o ,-
.,.a ,C CD o~
S ca"t:: E C.
lID c: g G'C
~~~~~j
~~ B ~ 3
"sol:..~ g
.~ (1)1:-8 i
./jU8.{l1!!
l!! e:.g,,~ "
ca80~G.l$
iiii'-e:""
0:E-i5=-~
= ~ e>~ ~ 8.
B e:'.!!l.S!I!\'''
'o,,2"fi (I) e.!!!
.2 J! ,- -"';;;;
g " H €'O
~f~,2e~
.. 016',- 2
,g-gNa::":-
'8",e:'al:l
o~.2CDtsfl)
"S=acaCii
>-3:I!!..a.:;
,0 OJ~m.~ 0
i-=G.l;;;QJf!
>-1;"- ,O~
~~i!gJj
: ~-g =6,' ~ -:
flI!!:~ (IJ
~cieo!~
>-c: OJ- ....
;::~ QJalCDG
ra 0 ca..c: fI).J:: c:
="'ll~;C-o
.5.b,g.5l-.5 N
fI) G.l._~,...:..c 'tS
-,"'li' e:'l;!",
!jli"'1;!S::E
l!! I!!~ l!!" !!!'-
QU)- II)"C' Q)
;-i0C.m~S
I!! 'e:~ " O>"'E
.. 0.0 8~.c p
QSfI)cj-gol:
.5811:'01:::;-
~~H~~~
~ 0>11,",.21!!-g
GJ Q) o-51ii aI
~=Ui.et;lo
~
'"
,g.
~
..~~~
1506_
:J::t"''''
oj
e: I!!
-'"
.. "
~:c
js
-ll
all
~E
"I!!
::;;il
!.s
~ll
""
-g8.
co e
,,0.
0> I!!
~ca
0._
lll:fi
='"
~5
:'"
H
'a=
E ~
g~
,.,I!!
- 0>
,,-
e>"
.!!!~
"'-
e:",
"'-
:!l-
00
l!!1ii
",'0
~-
0<(
N'
"
1J2
~~
'"
.!!! c
ca';
I!!~
'" '"
.. "
,_ e:
~"
-;; .5
:g~
:I"
..~
-"
,,'"
I!! "
2""
,,1
:5=
-'"
l!~
-'"
II € '
",-I!!
,,>..
o.c'"
e: 0> ~
8" 0
0-
CD~ ~
'8 "',!E
a::.~.~
:i~!
"'8'"
.c "
!:! f-
oe:s
~,- 5l
,S!l1!! "
-~ "'~
",-
ceo
,- "!!
j,ll 0
(1)=2
"'0
e:o
..0
!iN
.g;i.
.. ~
~..,
'"
637
.c
"
<3
""
o
Cl
i",
<>w
n
8'>
~"
00::
tl
~
....
:!!
~
~
e
(J
a:
o
~
..
~
'll:
~
e!
(J
~
lli
~
~
'll:
g
~
i
Ii
(J
~
I
....
~
l!!
:r
.!!
~
~
c
o
"J!l
'" "
-"
c'"
0"
't:$u
~ " "
..... to.=
" c."O
.:= ,5's
~'Oo
.- Gl_
~.E~
... Q).=
,,~"O
"',,-
o ~ 0
cI):J~
CO"
o,,~
:;:=~
"00..
cO>
,,- ~
E c ..
.. -
!5~-g
" c 0
~.~~
" ~ "
"'0"
;~ ~
c.~ cu
..--
c "
"'",c
It ---
~o'"
'" c."O
CD Q) lI.l .
as;SE:g
:s m ~ C
:.o="OC:J
e..2:J.....
Cl) CJ CD Q)
Q, l!:! .l: 0
o c.::: ~
....cO::J
o~ U'I U'l
c: a. .... ....
.~ _~ 0
-ecu.....
.sQ.l~2
c: E 0) t"O
~ ~.= ~
~ ~ .~ 3
~..~o
..=::El!:!~
..
U
c:
ill
'~
'll:
..,
c:
..
c:
~
..
iF
1Ii
'"
.91 ~
o~
:.E
-"
.."
u.91
:l,g
.5.2
Ci.s!
- ,c
"0"
Q).~
~8:
~ cu
" ~
"0 --
,,;:C
o ~
'ai~
.21 E
~~
tl
!
~
I
CQ)l-o
o~_Q) vi
~'E6EE _w
....... (lJo~"'E
:mCll~c:::....Q.lO
Q)525:::'~t:j
Q) (l) _'0.- lLl
t!!-g.S~6'iia.
Q) <O~ Q) Q.--C
>.....::Jiti"ooc:
i.; -g ;= ~ c :
]!~C'll_g'~~~
_"0",__ 1j--
ii59'~5;::~
-oco.ae.....
~rn2l!:!Eg.~
'"
..'"
ii
E ~-2' Q)8g.~~
o _oQ):;ru~Q)..Qc
.:= 'E.S :5:6 l!:!..c: -e ru ~ lj
:!::::11)-cRc(Q~...""",
:::I ...... ... 0) ~
~~~~i!!~~-g~
~~a.i5f/);.!!!.Q .=0
~Q.lQJ"'''C uc.-:..'O-
-E.o ::OO,2.5! lID CI) co '0
~E >-.0 ~~U'I gt-gni~
~~E~ -licg.5~:C
E:o::. El/lIoQ)'-(/)CI)Q)
U c: m._:; (Q"O; "0 Q) 0.
EfU-8.s Q)~ fij"m::i2 MC
.- III U) ..... (Q cI)
-o:{lc~iijE......2iiQlc
c: ..... CI] t- E :J Q) 11)..... :; ~..-
CU"C C3> .2:= E ~ ~ ni (D Q.l
~$'E--u 0 E c t.: Q)ID....
~~-tl g 8;l f! :::IS';; iP =
....- cI)= c:~ CD 0).0'-
g rtI_.~'O Q) co:!;;: CD e=
>n;~o::iCl)Q)-oc,::lC
~...!!:! :8..,-l!:?~ ga'O c'-
c c 0 tI)~ c.cu.-g c cuJ:!
en.! 2t- a cu '- ~Q) tOo:g
~~tI):mUlt=~!:1Vcu.c:=
1: rn..Qfi o~.a$E3:
'(ijl.()~~ 4l....:...41:E!:O~0'iij
E....c_'-cut:..c:rom.t:o
Q)~oo,~ns)(.c:,'!::'tI)O
'O..Q Q)CD'Oo410.co=
c:El1lod=ns_0_~<<I0
ns::::lOlc:__'O.9!'O a.0
0C:~CUO:gQ)OCDJ:!EC:
1:aJ '-aJ 08.'0=.-0
~"OQ)t'II'CE.- ep'OQ);;
_.c:'~cu~~~;~l,!l!g
~'E E~ 5 m a.g CU1: g.a
.2 cu 0 o-lG'O 0~ co'iij.!!
oooC:'C._c>. 0._0
> c >.'; ,2 :rl 0 c >.!E C ~
Qi ~ ~ e Qi 0.'- ns Em 5.!
~aJOl'-c.wl!!E .-0J:!
0-........ ::::1_000.=
a.~ !!! ..9 'iij ~ 0 m CU c CD C
-rotl)mE:r;..c:~'oO.c:cu
t3 E.~ E.2 ~ 51 m 8.n.... 1:
!O'C~:.o::;'C_....Q)(fJco .&.
Q,ffi Cl.ei? 0 5= Q) o.~ E
.~ Q) CJ) E-bO.5 E.~.2:':
Q) CJ) ~ '<- Ol';:: C)'O g 0 ~ Q.
~ ~ ~ m .2 '~'e 5'0 4l -g 2
~ :S '3: rn .g E .g .g ffi:ii 8 :5
N
'C .- '0 'E
cU) -go c:....
.." ~ "If) co lP:B
_0 U ~"'5-Q)'O-
"{ij'O '- cu'g.... cu 0 O..c::'--
E'OoU:tI)Q)tI)lIlc3:lIlCf)
wc-CU.c:.c:....::::IO-.c:Z
>.~~ cu'O'O~ 2-E woe(
~rn O~.Q >.0 ts Q).Q2'c ~
>~'flcoc.co. Iii Cc
;;:CcooQ),,-Q),;:;.c:ocu
.!!!<<I::::I_'-C~=41Ill'Zi'O
G;l.c:- coo Q).c:..c:: Q)._Cf)
;;; Q) >. ::::1:2 N c: a.... ~ e Q)
,_~;Ol::'CQ)::::I ,ns8,-
m~6~8~i~~~Q)~
....~cu--JI).....-w-O'
cu_ a.1ij ~~ 0 Q)..o'3:.26
"O"caJEEm~.2:cuUlIll.c:
-rJ~UlaJQ)::::IOQ)OlQ):t::
:rl!E:2lP>SOCUft;,563:
-.c'-.c:ow.c:_ - w
m as: - E Ul a III l!! C C "0
.- O_OCOQ).!!!Oc
~ ~ ui-J!! t;!E E~ a./A.!!!
.... 0 cu :?c <<I 0 Q) o'iij g -
.:g'O'i.!c~rn3:ct5~
~E~oOQ)o2:-8Q)Ec:C
oeenala.Ec1ijc .2~
g E~:US ~~ E ~i.~~
::=JE.-=c:::!:og-::::I.2:::::I
~8ccuQ) _ Cen'o_
'tl ~ ~:2 a) '0 :G'1i '0 Q) 0
$; c 07ii 3:- Q).- E c: C Q)
"'0'- ..0'00 cuea
16 i; E C iE 9E & -g.c: 8 ~
:t::::_~J!S-enenco~ C
.QCDo.UlIll~CUQ)Ulf;JIl=
~i'c.g~c'-m:u~:s~
_">1j"o~~",,>= ~_
:!:ECIj:'ONCU=::&.g_g'
;g rJ'c ciS Ul ~ 0 c.c~'c ui
~!E.2l!~:g~?:-Q) Ul_'{ij.9!
"Oc:~cuQ)..oG)'gi-g~cg
c:: .~ Q) Ul fII c: ~'Ci . cu ::::I'm a.
ttJfII.:.!<(O!!!El!!'-~EII)
55!~l!U)enen :::J~Q)_'iij
:;::';:: Ul.ClW'O.~ Q) 0 0=-0 ~
~ Q.'C.@cuiot==u'jC 0
8,ES ffi Q):iUJ 8. . ~-g-&.€
!tI >_ en cu '-:::J G) Q) <<I
::), _ '0 'iij 0 >-'iij"O :::J O,rn C a
"'- 0 ns ,- OJ Q).-.c: U .... ;:: = c:
oc,:::d::;e~~lnoaa.c:.o
tflwcu:::g>:::cc:8..eo.a
:g:go ~.!!!~ ~=-g.Q Rl? ~
-.J 'C e _ 0._.... cu rtI en <<I _ Q)
M
~ :c ~
-C''!::' ::
~c Q) ~'O 0
:J ",.'!::' IV C E
04P"'Q):::Jm
'" '- 0 c.... e G)
4l .c: '0 0 C>> en '-
'Si m'2-go-~"
e~..~inm~
,c~ <<Is'"
r;~4P~<<I~'O
~J!F~~!!!-g
ll:ij . 5 rJ 0 nl
",=:lle _EE
,,3~ $-"
t'lJo~ES-E~
C"'tu CU:J:en
$~~",c'6g.
....QQ):!:~-
en cD ~'O ,:oi
'2S8~~:g'N
~.5_c~C5.0
~~"O-8U) >'0
~ '" ~'iij w:ai -g
l!:?~$~!~.!!!
a.E: 0 ... - t'lJ c:
8.!C~o:!1
oiS~Et:::::J.!
~f!.8iil~~!
Q)_<<I~t'lJ-
s E ~ i en &.;
U'lns-'Onlmo
:Do;.s 'iij ii ~ 8-
,C,c-~"'S'"
E:;;.~ lD~ ~
:::J C~ t.! Q) C;:.-
cco~~-g~€i
~XJ'O:S:J~E
,C.... C >0,"'0-
_.2J!!:;::;Cc::ft
0<<1'0 C ,2 Q) 0=
EJ:! 8~~~.e
Q) CD ~=..'- nl
E:CO&IIl~'O
Q...c: .- Q) 4l e
.Q-c"'~1<m
~ e ,2 m._ Q) en
cu~~5~o.5
'0 .! > c. '0 c'ii .
~.8:sg.8.l!?i;~
'-_o",enm.=..c
'" >- ..
~ i ! eni =
Q) 0 _ 'C m e ._
.c::Cc1J c a.:;;i~
.5i~~~~'~~E
35 &SC 0 Q;1io.E
" .l!" if c.,c " S
lD c.cc_-~
.....5 <<I 0'- 0 l!-'O
:= <<I:E'-'O (I):::J:=:: C
iE_l,c""".!!!
nscu'" _::Ic..c:'O
l!?.Q-f =~ Q).!.2 8
..~",~"=~l~
-g ~ei-g'Oenc
.!!!~~5:t5m;'~3
'8:::JencaSen cum
o1i~.g.~:s-e~iJ
~o!! ,- .. ~ ".. ..
lDQ)io~c0.5.s
:; = c.9!....l!:?S....rn
C.J:'- t'lJ <<1- 4l
:c .... -g -g E o.,g ~ :c
.. ,'" E .. !!! "'" -
:!I:enCE'C"S~CD
'" ~"@ Q) <<I & o.~
e.2 e S,.: -,,:;
:::J<<IentQ",o.!._>
m.!!.!!:= ~ 3~~.5
~'I:'5jf5c:t::.':Q.c
C .a ,- 0 ca co 'E >0, <<I
l'2iil=i~~~
C>>~ ~ cu C C 0=' '"
'0 B'; l!!~'ii ~J!! e
lic:Q.~rJE!E~fit
CD ns- In Q) co....
'" E l!! ~ tl = ,Ql'ij 0
;a).2-ge,,~cC
=,2:l!.!!!~ ;J.2.g
-1Vcu'Em ~en"en
OcC.O.o.=$'ij1iCD
:s cO;:: CD ii'c en~
ijg~416E.sl!c
2'O:::J~.2~e.alB
'iiicu8.C:"'amc,
l5 g:= ~e=.5~'O
o :H &.!! en:l g ~ Ii
Q)G)Q)~'C1:''I:-CD
t= C5.:5Ui i rJ ~~.!!
"00
<:0
..0
'3N
.g~
.. "
,c-'
"'
- '0 "i
tl)G)iig~Q) Q)
.!!-SO._OI.f.: .!l!
:::J en.!!t rn '(ii.2: QJ 0 ...
eUl-giiiQ)'~..oe~
.c: e a.c e'C '- Q)
....OEQ)"ClIl-.ge
l! CU e > "'5 Ul 5 >.~
t.:.:::-.!lOlllO~==
to U"C C'll 0;= ll= U'l
O~Q)';::cu"Cm~co-
'O-ca.Q)::;-OQ)
c E Q) 0 .... == en Q) '-
cu"'~o.C'll08cCU
lI)~oo.~""ccu.~
QJQ)encu_l!!cu..c.c
.3=~~.:S~ fii;.~
mOlc:1:'iijoE'-c.
J!! .5 ns tI) C 01._ j 0 J!:!
'0 0"" 01:: m_..o=:.o
5:l::l-~:~Q)Ego'(ii
Q)uE:O"Cm'O.c:.g1ll
~g.g~~.8;~l!?&.
.5 CI 8
Xl:eo 2j~
:e.!!~ c:::€
.~ <<I C m::l
u,,€m aiUi
ns~:::JQ)c:S
B c: 'Zi:2 'm CD
~ .~:c ~ E ~
ii 'Oii a.o~
- QJ- .~-
,5G.i~~0I~
Ec'OI!!'~-
oo.r:u._CI
'O:c Q) :>.l!.5
.c:Q)-1J
a ~ _.:.::: Ul Q)
.5-oeUla.
"'5~-;;'- ~ III
iQ)....~~l!:?a)
.cE.!!:Cm'=:::J
~::&l ~~.;a
. 'OQ) m Q) cD en C
>o,~ e~.c:- Ul =Q) Q) ~ ~c ~
ia~ Q)'-;~~ ~$ ~~ ..c:: =Q)5cu ~O~""'''
'~:::J .I!!Eo - ....m'OS_c-o>lDo.QC~ ~
cuns Ula'C 0> ....Ec:::eno- > '00- ms1:'
.c:~Q)~ .-Q)G)e~ COCDC~S~c-;;~'~",~_"_,,,"
Q)....en~~'CEoa.o~mc-~O'o:::J.c:<<Icu~~~E
~- -_c..c:: :::JQ)O~'o_00e,-s en ~ ..c:C
_9c~mm~",~2enQ)e2~'Ol!:?m~~ &=!-~J::I
~~Q)E .!!m=:CG)~3c,~~Q):::J~l!:?C.s~lDg-:l~ ~
Sm Ulc___~-o Q)Q).c:ii-oQ)o>_"'1:'Cl)'O
en 1i.i lIl.9! Q) _ 3: _ c c::: - CD > '0 - '- j.:E... i2 '0 e.g rJ - cD E:
~ co g'~ ~~:s ~ 0 ~ o=.s!5 g~ fd"2~~~ '" e ~ .~E E ~
_.c:e~m~;;'OaQ):2='O 0....Q)~mo8111~mtl) m'"
m ae III Q) a.~ Q).51!! t:'j 3'cic rn III ,.:c ..Q ..oS ~";.~
.!!5_~S1:m~rn-8cueQ)~'ciQ)'O~3:1i~.~ns~e;0
C'-0-'OmQ.Q)Q)S lDm'cQ.Q)en C:::",~.~_IIIt::O~N
Q)=Q)Q)co~Q)o -S- o_>Q)~~9!.Q~mtQ<<Ia.t:':':::
!'C a..~ m 0 0.-5 ,~i:2 cug 5 ~ ~S ~ E'o m oz'O O:>':::J g
ClQ)'O~Z-Q)Q)&U==-S5~S s~E~.c:.s .Q)'O..QO~
~.5.!>_Cl~omE~no:::J l!:?>.~80~~:ft~~~0Q)
emeC:::Q).e_:::JOIII~Q)Q)CU~Q)a.Q) ~Q)';:;~_E'00
CUcm~.c:iUlallllemc~~c.Qo1VQJ.Q. _nsc'OQ)cc
ti~cDg""Q)"C~-g ~c==5_c:::~~2~ffi~~0=~w
~E~zgGig.!!!~~8'i'j~g~en~iEo.SE~~oW
N
M
e~ 5..c:: '- 0 ~~ 'C ...,:": i _-g ..;
$""!l~"S~~ C-: e~l!:?m'OrnG.i'iii~~ '0
_011I G)O" _S~Q)m......__OG)_menc CD
::::I ~~uG) .~ Ul ~ ~o - 2~
OOi~Ul-~CDa.5:l~~:UO~<o~~&~~aB!.c:~' m
12 :: e:= Q) ,5)( 'ii en._ C\I ~. E 'E- j C/) -= tI) = en j,? __- ~..o..... ns 15 '-- e
_=.!==~_lDen~gen~E UJ_~S>.mQ)==>.lDen3:<<I~=
m<<lc:_g~'iijc~'01:~:::J-giQ)o~Q)~~to~!~,-~-e,
m~mm_~~0&c~oU)mc6~""5m~~'C'iii~g<<l..:~~
_mEoo_Q)enmm.c:m~_Q)ccuSo"';.c: ~m _c'2~~+=
lPO~:cco'01J w~E~ffiE~Ei-~3:~....R3:~~€C~
~1~~li:f!.~:~~~~j~'O~~.~~1g~';l!
"Cc'CCii 'c'_'iij>Q)<<IQ)>'O"C:::Jc,'!::' :::J cuoc -:::JR
~~~!~'''''~i~~jill~il!~~~~8..~li~~~~
/A Q)_ 0110..; Q)" E 0 c.2'C 0", _ 0 ,-.c:.'O Q) ~..c: <<I c '-
Q)Q)~- l::~>... en'-o.'-Q) -Q)SEQ)1:~OE~oenOQ)cu
~~&~la~~slmE~~~~~~~8~g~~CEi~~~~
N
638
'5
"
~
~
'"
"
..
"
.g
......
-..
,,-
:il':ii
> ..
_,c
OO!!
en=
","0
0=
.....3
,c
~
U
>=
o
Cl
'"
~"'
Uijj
il'"
t~
eii
UO:
M
I
i
>-
.0
.S ~ ~
",.."
.1:::U)~
~.~ '0
~~~E
13:) 12) ltI
o E E,!;
-E~E
! 8 ::Lg
ltIc:::'Ccn
:CB~6
:;1!J:~
'(QCPEro
oS! g>" €
>'>OCll
(1)oc.t:
9-~_8o
.5 al E 2i
alE""
" Eo
'iiJ!&a.
-Q)cg=
c"'cro
'ij tll C1I E
E~E(f.l
>>1: - t'lI
;~~o
~a'8 5
e ~ 1l.a
CDccn8
;2.!!x
- :'::Q)
ot5:2 Q)
~ ra 'i:s
o~1::5
.: III G) 'i
I'D <(:g _
~CJ)U)Q)
~w!o
g-gQi~
Q.ruE:r
~iii~u
a>z en:::l
C1l<~~
~mC:U'l
-.t:CI)c
.t:-:28
"'''~
~c...o
.. cu 0"""
""Q)c~
'C a. .. :>
Co - 0
CUG) ~ E
:;;~-i~
..!I:! G).c: l1)
OCQ)..Q
.c(l)~=>
cEQ)~~
o Q..Q) cO
'9. 0 en 0 .
l!!' 'ii,c.. c:::
:> C. tV CD
.!!"E;;u
c: 'C 8 C) c:
8~1Il~0~
CO'C _
: g.fiz<
:g a.~ ~ i
;!z..!!~
Ol-<(~...
- -OQ)
~~8iE
~ 5.~t5J2
'rJJ ~i~!
e?(JQ)..._
ro ro.t: 0.5
cn.c.... .0.;,
c41 .!!:;:
.2 cn u:i ro ;>
~c(a1::r:-;
-gCJ)~-g;'.::
8w aJ al"c
COdl~-e~
"'::~m ~
1: 0 - >.:.;:::
E(i).E.ce
gzi Qj"~
G)<(N.~&
o~O~!
:I:__
I
I
I
I
ffl
~
...
~
~
Cl
!
e
I.!
!;!;
u
~
Ul
ll!
oq
o
~
e!
u
Ie
III
~
~
oq
i'3
J::
oq
~
:II
~
:
!
I
I
I
I
...
~
~
~
i::
o
l
't:
u
~
,,'"
"00
:z:'"
t!
~
~ "0
..cE~.!!
ro ~.......~
.t: 1::'0 g
285m
.1:_;,;:;"
~~eg
~ E.E ',OJ
OQ)U)cu
~O)~Q)
l'G ~ "0 C)
-ecvc:::~
Q)E~'O
~o:5:fI)
~:Gq~
'g"iJO::fij
e? e8.G>E
ro 0 cn;'c
(.) 0 C:.-
gC:.cE
n-gl!
2....-
...... al 010
Ul41c:_
c.....G)
8:iii"c
.-- cn Q)
i=a..cQ)
l!!' r::: .8..(>>
0:; ~ E (0
... e?o 0....
.E 41 . ~!
'OEa::==E
~:::IQ)~:::I
o8:5.gz
~i~~:5
JJ~~'llo
-:S:Oall:
l Ul Q.~ .2
.s::..!1!.~ 3l '02
uU"'<
'-8.~U)ti
i 0'-W g
l:.ei"Oo
B=5OiQ)
ru:;:I:_:5
"ii:=ooecn.s::.
"'~"ZO;;
~~:S:<(:=oo
"
"0
'"
..
~
.2
"
E
..
..
"
oS
M
"
"
'"
N
~
..
~
0.
,g
"
"0
'"
.2
"
>
o
.0
'"
'"
"
..
..
~
u
..
'5
..
ti
:2!
"
Q5
"
"
'"
I-
...
..
u
~
.~
oq
~
..
a
i
ii
,,0
a;:'
"'-
0.
~ 0.
.2..
~~
i''''
,,-
E'"
Ei'
8"
!N.
..~
"..
3~
"0.
mE
E,=-
"
~
""
u
..
-gc~
al Q) m
4l ..c e <(
~ 2 ~U)
o.s::..c:w
0:'::"0
1:'::01:
.2.~ b~
'5 c.'c (/)
c.e.oz
'0 R.> ~
I: ru G) 0
~:5 =_1:
;!.i .5B
4:1 . Ul f! .
5r;:.8.s ;
=ro!; g
~a::Ull1::N
,,~
o~..
+:::Illo
".0",
.0) E Ul
.'!: ~:E
::;,,-
...
t!
a
.5
~
!
~
CI) Q).5
l!:! .Q) = Iri g'-g
o u"Oo'O'_ru
.s::.-g 1ii!1: I:E
~.!!l ru"O E CI) cu ~CU:::l"2
,g= ~i E'Eu; cuE.q-_~~
......ru"O:::Iruz _ 0
.g .g "5 I: Ul 0.<( Q) Ul c;, S
'C~~ ~"i'E G)-gj,!.5..c .
J?..c_':'::Q;I =uo~'O.c
;~'Om:2"'OI:I:.c:~ellO
I: :.: ell ... 'Ul i :E .- .E .g g' ~
~ 2:~'::~q i'l"1JH!
(")rul:!5ru CUQ)_"c:n
N- ~ !S 0 'i3.~ j.59 g.9 ! ~
_ruellU)>->1:5 1:"':0
..........~...I-~Q)l:mO..sh::
Ul ... :t:.g . ell E. '0 ~ € Q)
tiJJ""'<-"';1": "".. E
"'E,C .Uj....U)Q.",<(
a. :::IEcn4:l.gW0CU...
E ~.!l..c.W...
"
"'"
,,--
".otao
"'-'8
~~E1ij
OEE~
._ 0
EniSo
:::I"i) tal:
~ g> 29
~ ~ig .
Cii$':>'=1:
E .0.. ~
..0 E "8 ~
<Ii! 0)
...
" 0
"0
..0
~':
-g-s
",'"
(/)
.c
~
u
'"
o
"
""
~!!l
Ow
al~
~.ii
0'"
639
I
~
.~ 'E
~ ~m (\'l
: 8~o
"0 . e c
'" ell ~ ,g
~w.c:g
- CD '0...
c.c.!!u;
o-cc
II) 'C IV 0
II) cEo
>=(\'l::)CD
';(i)g:5
J!Z"C~
~<(e<<J
0~"'8
C)=~E
."'EE
3:,gB8
O:::lCu
"lj 8"
a::.E_.s
'" ,C
G1U)4)-g
~~tl!E
... g 01'0
CD_egO
ECcE
,2~~2J
CD'-__
.c"20j
;; --!l .
:2~'os:
'" 0 ~ci
:J: II) (/) .
'D:R_a::
CD;:c"C
[;H,1j
0._ ... a::
;8'0~
.c(5Ul:5
:-:c.~ C
!ii .!: ~:c
1:!g(/)j
~-~-
E .f!J ~
~~'i 8
::ICc..o
ca 5l ~ 2
J:! 1i 'iij "5i
mEe:!Ui
-G)...::J
G>EG.lo
"'cEB
~eEas
ll.s; "€
S::5i~~
c c_
J!'scuc
>- f! ~ ,2
~~e!i
eOo4l
~ EZ ~
"", >
(I),E ui'O
'2iQ-gE
cu,cS::J
-;;""S::o
ocate
>-.:( J! ra
-u..._
:!to me;
~..J E E
.!!!uou)
'C >>-.0{
~.o ~ .
nii-g
emG.i~
Q.cc~
0l~0
<11,- 2>'" '
'0; ~ t'a C
II) 't:J .c ~
Ci{:-g~Cl
""'Cftl.QQ)
GiSmo:5
.oc.'t:! -0
Eo-g.!!
::l'O.c(Dc
C CD CD:r.2
~gf~i
J:_
I
I
I
I
I
J
~
'"
Q,
'~
"
~
,,'"
00
:1:2:
. '
<Ii
c
o
N
13
.,
.0
;;
~
iii
z
<(
~
:;
E
o
ol=
~
~
ii
E
al
>0
Q;
<;;
E
.x
e
0.
0.
.,
]
[;
.5!
.!!!
M
~
'0
'"
f.-
~
'"
I-
!2
"
~
UJ
~
c
o
raG>Cl)-g~"a
c:55nJ~a.
.s.Eo~I1l.!G
&.:.E.cO.~:5
>.~gEQ)_E
C"EEo.",
., ~ 8 <II "
Q) >:; J:! Q;
~Eoo"'C:.::_
o .c CD "C c::
~ e ~E l 5
:::wes;:g
O.o.c:(I)Q.lCll
~~ :;i3u. e
C'GJ::-geciQ)
o ~ CD t'O'C ~
Ul:Cx-5l!E
{g;:41:.co~
C C J:::t c
.!!g.~ <II E 8
~ -(tIj.oQ.l
I1l OOQi--2:51:
t5 Z Q) >..c ::J CI)
<tI <( ell.1::' II) 0 E
c. cu>5"C~&
.~ =4iE;'-nJ
E ~ E Ul" e :ii
e~8€.cE
-: ~ 0.2 3: '0
~u;.g u)~ ell
>-z <u -e CD CD
E<e Qj <ll '0 '0
<llOC.l:c8.
'Q;'~'O~(/)
tg'$~'~.Qg
UlU AI E ~'A
~RlXlma::~
lj ~.~~~ AI
o::s a.'O_.~
-;n8E$'5=
.- 8 cv 0 c
~:a ..~ ~i ~
~~~.gecq
.!o '--Scoer
lD.t:: a:: s:: >0 E <ll
.!!mio.Qi 13-s
<ll<llo .:go'O
t=.fia::a:::t-c
~
o
~
'"
5
,2
~
E
.,
~
~
:;
I!!
.,
'"
"
C
rn
N
-
~
.0
E
o
C
~
'0
'"
,g
~
>
o
.0
.,
."
~
~
"
u
~
'C
~
1:3
~
~
;;
C
~
~
I-
..
~
C
{J
.~
'<
~
C
.Q
~
~
~
~
~ ~
-~
0_
~o
0;'
;'5.
,,0.
." rn
Co
""
Em
E -~
0'" _
" -"
"N.o
"'''':E
<II-a
~ Ul C
~~~
., 0. 0
~E'"
E ._ c
C _ 0
0_<11
~~tl
.2' E ~
.- ::J E
::2 t: ._
..
<II ~
~'"
~ '0 '::0
.~
o a..l: <(
0:::'5(1)
<llG)OW
..c <ll Ul '0
- ... '0 C
--C:<<I
0'0<<1_
en c >oW
g cv,,!:::z
:e.g.S<(
0...0_
a.a " ~
O$*.Q rIl
g'~:Oe~
:;:g.~g2
~ Ci E Xl.:.!:
~li';ll: ~
~.l:-SaitJ
~1.C:$ (/)
<II
'"
C
.,
~c
<( ~
~ ~
m'Q.
~gai
.:~ ~
co.- Rl
.l: :t .~
t.,,,,
,,~-
:: Ci.s
~.!!2 m
l1.l-=::::
:S,E'~
N_t
TI.~ 8-
~ ~ g.
- '"
~1i)~
-I!!.,
~.Ez
<(:t~
J!~~
::'O:t
oc~
1: .Q g
~m~
en!!c:
" ""
enQ)Qj
'1ii.l:.l:
.,I-t
~ >..2
'5'$-g
~ is (Q
~:-g
- rIl~
'0:5'8
coo
,Q~ ~
mo ~
o en:;:::
1i) E .!!2
~.g~
~>-
;;.0
jo
o.g,
c.,
. - J:
-g",
., C
-.,
E",
C;j.~
~cc
ii~
E rn
.g~
Olrn
C<II
:;::::.c
~~
c.-
""
",~
~e:
~ ~
<liE
.;:: ;:,
c."
EO
0'"
"I!!
~~
'c;; E
1iiB
rn C
.!..8
h
~"
",E
-~
0",
-.,
-c
Beti
rn_ C
:Oa,,!!!
rn ~ ~
Ul.~ .g
"".,
C~'"
~ g.(I)
-:-Xl aii
4l <( C~'O.Eo:o
l1.l -...(/) '-08.->0.
'0 :E.Ew '0'0. ttleD 8"t5
..cw-"C4l_-C$a::Q)'O J!!
"'trljgC'5CAlC'OttlCH.a
,2,g00"'''''''"0''g>,,,
'0 - $ a.1;;:a (Q 5 0 -= ~'i C
lD a 'O.c Ill''!::: o:a::-"'lt b AI
ts-lDC::Ji::rIlO'Oo --
i5m'OmUl_~'Oc.......:O'ii
W:::.l: ~'O rJe: en (Q.8 ttl';Z
o._~"!!2$ ;j'Q.lD.!&!:=!t E~.l: m
M Ul ..c::s . >0:2 O'n ::1 0 _.:.!:
. ~ ~ ,g ~..... ":3 8.!H.. c: ~ .s c: .
~ClI.E-lD"";""'enrCJRlocrJo
'"'"....'Oiuc;; dlc!-8:;:S':ii~
2~.21E-ZEe".2~'cEg
0.0:.; AI 8.<( E 0l!!2 u 0"'0..... 0
n; E c: co... ::1'EJ::: c c <<1_
~i?~ scn.E III _,_
'"
<;
~
<;;
~
~
~
~-
"'.0"
~::'8 :ll
O::~E-
-cE~
000_
e: '-; l3 '5
::1'i1<<1c
00')00
E<ll_:;:::
ca > '00
iJ~~.5
E "0 Ul
lIlq ~ 5
<(0:::...0
..
"'0
co
.,0
'i~
0>0
j:;
,C""
Ul
.c
"
u
-
'0
Cl
'"
"
~~
uw
ll'll
'" ~
~.~
Uo::
640
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I ~
""
-@-
~
I I
..
~o
:1::2:
I
~
~
....
~
~
3!:
e
e"
it
~
'"
II!
~
5
~
~
~
lli
...
!l!
51
~
2:
g
~
~
i
'E
" "
-C:'OQ,l
eO"jjj :5
CD >. 4) Q)
'8~::1O
E:;::;Q.l;'!::
C'I;E:2
" E"
'S: "0 ::J 0
cu.!!cnQ)
..c: ~~ c:
= .Q ~"j
",.-
<C ,_ ""I!! ~
C)" 0
o l: 0-'=
...J O"'Z '"
C) ,_
>dS -0 :5
.cCUC:o
altl~5
.!::! en;:o
041_::J
O)J::... ...
l1lt-CDt)
10 . E "
0"08
I!!"-
- S C'lG)
'. "'"
cn':'::..1-
'Co"
C:~G:i""O
cu_ c: C
-; :s 8..!!!
~ c( IV ~
..c:cn....g
-w'Om
'0 CD:ic5j
<it;>>
. E:s~
~ll)tlIo
.......c: CD
q! &1i
D::-"'OJ:
i.S :"g
~jl~ ~
!ii al E iii 8
E c; 8 >-~
o :J_.D 2
-.1l: <C Q)
CDcnU)Gi~
:5l!W.cCi)
.5 ctI ~~ g
-cQ)__m
.'!;' (5 Ole: 0
,"'ccl1lm
"0 11)'- E-e
:i5-gG~
.- go>.
t'o_"'C_
~~~e'~
5~:g H
'OolllEQ.
:i Q.:E; Q) :
-0_ o~
alZSSci
Eui'~c:a:
J! :5 :6 Q) ~
>- Ill...... E 0
~ mi &0::
l!!'" en cu CD
S~-g~:5
~'o>j E.S
"O~ .o~
:i.-"O cn ~
--9l1lCDc
c: C E'o 0
~gJ!8.~
i;:~~&
Q.:s; RI c: Q.l
.5._ >d!! >
-:a; = a. C'I
iiiio~
~ U) ~ III.!!!
OCio.9!~
--.co
.!!!;y8.'O
"E:':",..
oC~.2>
.cecn=o
.!!! 'S: -g;g ~
~i3;=...
e!
e"
~
.
....
i:'i
~
2
:l
~
g ~
CJl (1)'(1)
l! :5 C:
.aoO
"-"
Q)Q)'C~
O-~:2
.c ~ ~ 'i
.2c.Q(s
'C~"'_
" 'C '"
., ""
';:: C1l .!!! :e
0.0 Ole:
'" ,,~
Q) -g.- 1::
"0 fa! 8-
l!!oClla.
<<I-co
=~ ~"i)
Q.lOl!!i;
E '!!"E ~
~!8-g
Q.l . <<I tv
=~~~
l!!qEGi
- ftlO::OJ::
Ul :> '0 J:: 11.I.
~ ::a:<<I>-C'I
a. 0 O~.5
.s a: ~ is ~
.... 'C-Calo
aI-(Il_
~'O~c1
" ~ "
'008:0
,,'" "
o s:= e
:.;:::; U'l &.0
fJ I!! ~ ~
!E.E(Il(ll
. &,= c::
~"~c1
41 r--:'i e
=-g$~
'0 ro "C'i
-o~;-g
41"'", ro
l;: .8 U'l ~
(IlE(Ilt;
Qi~oro
Zc::.c(ll
"
'0
.c
'"
~
.E
"
E
"
..
"
=
I!!
"
M
'C
"
"
'"
'li
2:
4;
.,
E
~
"
"
'0
'"
.E
'C
~
E
'"
"
o
u
'"
U
~
Ql
"
"
.c
f-
...
"
"
~
.~
~
."
~
!l
1
""
i
"
":0
:g .~
~o.
.Eo.
"
je
-g"
,,-
EM
E-g
8"
~~
"':::'
~ '"
~u
'" "
~ 0.
~ E
E .- cU
c::.....O
O~'"
jij.8 .!!!
.Q) E -5
.~ ~ 0
::;;,,-
"
"
i
.,al
~~
'0
0",
a::~
al"
0=
"''C
""
.c ~
:: ~
0_
.Q~
~.c
.s~
"'"
"",
"'-
o
"
~
~
o
7;j
&!
~
"
:a
'l\
~
.,
'$
<I:
(/)
W
...
:l
"
~
..
""
i
&
4; 'C" h
.2l'Cal E 'Co S,-_.,_~
EWE oe"'C:::(Il .g.....'EQ.
~uro...-~c:::(tSE (Il"C:Sell
l:::O C ~<( ell f!<( o.?:-fIJ ~ Ol.c
41 41 c::: 0 CI) . Olcn fIJ fIJ 0 C (IS
-... ~CI)WE'EW G) ~.cCD:i2 c
,g:;$~,,~ --g'~;''''Elij
'0 ma.EE'ij)-g eo j!!D U'l.! ~
- o"U'i-g;;::::l e~ ca.S Q.~~ fd U'l
-g~..oOB"iiCell~~c.ccu-g
Ottl~c.~og:23:. .ooca
----"0 0.a-f/l.... ,,_...
alM ~ "'0 >-''>.50 8.~'E" i
a.-g 0 tlJ ~~~ 0" 0.!2 8~ II)
(lI.c ~ -'-:"4l,!!" 11: ca:o ttI
j~Hlliii~ 8.!l,g Hu
c..........c...~j!!0O::_
.s;'.e:50
1
~g
"0
"i~
0>-
'C-
,,~
",""
(/)
-
-g >-
-oO~ ~
(0- Q) _
>'~i Q) U'lJ!! _
gQ)€;~~-gl
~'" E $-" 0
,,:5 l!:! ... inl!!- al E
c.c.8 CI) - e
:l=~~!B
5 s'i O.e c=
2ljijs: ~ >-1'3
~ Ql . R ~ :il
€ 0>0 i:S ._ ..
:!~O::(lSJ!
.,
~
C3
'"
o
Cl
l!ll
uw
:n
~'~
u'"
...
641
I,
-
~
o
:I:
...
~
~
~
e
!::!
!!i
~
II!
~
~
~
J!!
o
~
:Ii
~
i
~
~
~
i
Ii
o
~
!!!
...
;!!
~
~
. .'
-
" _ 0
~:B(;j:5
~~ ~ ~
:!:a;Et
Ulc:mlU
4>1::0=.0
....(U4)CI)
:Q.=;
e <( e.e
=U"3J2
COO U::
.!!~l!:!::6
c(J=-
~~i~
0." .!! .l:
"O..!.!! tJ <Ii
cm>:ECI)
M&~~~
,",,- ~ .-
~$iii3:3:
--'0_0 .
J!!.~ 0 .0
~ ctI - a:: Ii
:B e ~i >.
-ce-a!:
~.!a~a::~
t-~oG;~
G) . S E ~
c: >"cn 0 0
oj!!,s- E
NcaolDQ)
is > .... J:: ....
C'II ~o. ~ lU
:3alctio:5
51'5"15.2
<(:@~ B..m
C/J->xU)
W-g-oCDUl
.!~~~.~
- c:: U)~ c:
'0 g.!! &0
CD :::I.... l:
:2~:g.g=
.n-= >;~
::JUl(U4)\I')
o 2.E~ 1::
-go~>B
t'l:l ~ .! ~~
< il c J! 0>
000:::1....
W 0 .2'€ .E
4)= Q)- en
::"i ~~-g
o >..!!! E t'lI
lI)C'II"Cm-:
~.~ 3l2~
"5J!!~:::JO
o~ Oi.!a::
-g~_5~G)
_",,,,_.c
rl.$ c -
o ei'O
- m >.:2 Q)
!-:!: >0"
ca CD.=:!....::J
O)=~ c.~
Ii g. fii'!! I-
.o.~ en Ul
E1l-~":>'
:::J CD.!! ttI
c: C r::: ~
CD c: (Il <<1.-
_oEo.!
"gUl:ZI1:l
'5 -c .g ui :5
Ul~~~-g
e t: Q) P1 m
.aJ'!!S!-;Q)
m ~ e g..!!
-r:::a:I_Q)
"..il".c
G>t: -c-
.S: 13 E ~ fii
~ IU tI)
.s.agi.!
aI C:._ ';:: 4l
E.!!!~~.o
.2' c:.s::. ';:: 6
cOUl"O..
Q)~mQ)o
::::ll!:!$'ts~
c-:z: I'-- ~ c:
l!:!COlQJO
u..Q:I....UlU
&
'"
.g.
~
.....
Cid
:I::t
...,-
"
~
o
~
"
.~ -~
""
".c
lF3
,",0
" ~
m.g'
3 c
'" 0
.l8 m
0.0
E '"
o~
" 0
'"'~
4i~
!!,c
.!l!8
~1!c5
O:;:g
'" Q. 8-
~ ..
.. " -
E'~ ~
.2E~
~8~
-"'..
.5 $ ~
.r:. .....-
--..
'i .5~
'"',,-
-2~ :E
",,-
Ec"
E" ..
0""
ug.1!
~~.5
o _..
~!=
"".c
-g ~ ~
~ge
.c o..c
t-~;
. l!!
'iii, m (Q
.~._ a.
0>"'"
0"",
"8 &t';
WC5
c.!! N
.. 0. C
:g ~ .~
0._ ai
0"'0.
" ~ 'C
~,s~
,~-g ~
,_ c:o.-
~~:E
.-t:=.. ~
" "c
~ cr,2
ala:;
....c:€!
..--
c o,~
~c"
"'.2 cu
..",..
:5 &~
a e c
" 0. 0
cu..c...
co>"
'e :c ii
alc:05r
w '"' >
.. .0 "
" " "
~~e
(O'~~
I!!_c
C'lI ~ 8
.~ CU"U
.c~c
1-"..
"
o
.. g,
=
c,s
o I!!
5"
"..
"I!!
0..
~,~
ai:5
o c
:c=
-..
,s Iii
j&
Oc
E'-
!!:g
.. I!!
.0-
0";
-..
-g '0
'" ..
00.
0.'"
e~
0...
.."
(ij~
gj
0_
,,0
I!!c
-0
~:a
::8
o w
~:
0=
'(ij'~
E."
..3:
.c
1-..
. I!!
8l'"
~-g~
_C'lI~
oE
z.oO
~15"E
c.o rl
=~s=
.5-~
~,S;'in
~ -g e
0....
,= UJ "0
i; 8. ~
Woo
wUiE
<(41!!
'"'= ..
.oc.o
"00=
~ 5 'i
~8-5
"10'-
~f/lj
'"O.sUJ
c..c
'" " ..
"..E
(&) (&) '0
1l" iii
8.~UJ
~e41
,- 41:5
"'E-
~E~
0" c
","'0
m 8. ~
.....Q Co
.... UJ,_
C'lI >.:!:::
(&)~-g
t=~8
('oj
"
c
..
"
E
..
E
.c
"
..
,.
<
'0
",
..
0.
'"
'"
'"
",
o
0.
..
'"
'"
5
s
"
..
"
c
..
0.
0.
'"
.!!1
..
I!!
..
'"
5
,5
"
I!!
..
E
"
8
c
..
'"
..
'ij
iii
..
E
..
Q.
'0
~
<
!l
~
~
:8
E
"
c
..
150
.cc
.E 'j
Q)g
>0
0-
.e..
".c
,,-
""
",,,
" ~
ag
"',-
:OUJ
..1l
li!
ti~
.- ..
'J.:
","
1ls
~'"
lb:g
;;<
c .
...!!
.co
I-.c
~
c:
{l
'~
~
"
c:
..
c:
.g
I
s
..
,,:c
'Orl
..c=
~o.
42i
'lll!!
"..
"0
G~
,!it! tV
,,-
",'"
I!! "
~fij
"N
.. '
E~
c~ .
o ~ ..
i.8:g
,~E UJ
~E5
"
5
~
.2
"
:c
.11
Q.
0.
..
I!!
..
M
"
c
..
N
..
>.~ 1ii:5
- "'O>..c
l:g (&)~g>
..~ "'C~G)o
-m'Eiii:a:j..c:.....
"'flE"OnI...;c
.~--= f/l lb CD 0 > cu
C'lI'2 ~tJ:5 f!!a~
CUC)CD!Ul:::Jmnl
(a'in:: C'lI ~~1ii!
'CuiOC'lloC)oC'll
~!';!!I'lJ~Ef!!
CD'c c C'll 1:15! III
II: :::J,2'O CD CJ)(li!:
'"E1l E "
4lEcECDa~~
F8..:Hc:!8
'c~EE~5fij
q;: 0 ~ C'Il ,.- C C
:!::.....c=.s!o 41
.Q..5'1iC'll,.g-UJc:
C1J(llc.Emi'~'-
.1::0) "'=tJo(O
..!~~O)~'J::&E
~_:2:5cc;;ctl'O
:-C'-o!Um41C
il'lJ~_""~0m
~ y CJ)C'll Q)~ l!!
o!E ,cctl.o_lb
c en,:;:'E__~
c: 0>." > ,- = 0 0
~'u; ~ 0.0 ~ 1::0)
~ ~ i ~ a ~'~ ij
!t:: Q) _ G) en O)'(ij'.f:
~'5i ~~~1! e 3=.
E ... '2 >.l:C en Q) e
b 0 (QliW,~..c:::J
C:~...= ,0'-2
C1J'c~;m8. '_
Cii'c.cUi8~~ ~
lBE..!!.QoC'll..c'"
... 8 c. =' cu'C ctl ::J
_ _ '" ...Ui,-o
-C-m41..co
c:: g fl O!E t:':: c
~ =COCUftJ'O
Q:lUl=CUC)__C
.....8cCiic...ocu
2."0,21 o!c...
~ ctlenc_CDcu
:>>"O....!! 0 0...-:;
~COC'll,_>.cao
o~1ii..c:S.o!!en
~(ij:s~s::!~ a
oEC'll4d?00~
-JUJ..c>o.NO)O
!!?
...
6.
,~.:
." 0
1l..
"0>
c: '"
c'"
8",
,!1.1!
Ii
_c
~s
_c
I!!.iii
"E
.. ,
c"
"c
=0
.- 0.
3..
.cc
n
-0
0>..
.e.c
2-
i'O
,,::J
i:2 ...:
_"'Ill
...cZ
>'0<(
8.e 8
-gsij
:::J -;;;'0
~'i!!'"
iii 1Ii:5
0" ..
:!5:5
oe..c
8 ~j
C.c '"
"-"
c c c
,S0C'll
.~ ~ ~
E,2 (l)
'0:0
"c..
t:.2a
enG)~
~o.o=~
-- 2 C'-
.9i'5';:ii
m:g-g ~0Q;
- _ ca .0
CUUl... _
:5!4I.2:C
_ >0::1'
01:8"2
5:='"0:5 (QE
,- ~ C C
MftJgo(5
g!a~e
8,; l11~ ~
.....cG)cu_
.E~.t;Q)"1:J
~';'~~ :i
'C cutJ 0>0,
ca~G)c,Sl
,Sl'-Qi:=iV
t)~en~>
<0
J! 4i cu G)~
"'2< E ~_ litO
~=~~a;~E:~8c~!
'5lij.c:!g.""l!!= .IIi'-:tc
C >;'C(/) c,~oa:: 0:g 2 ~
G)..!!c::J...~E-"Cd)150Q)
3i! !:S!.E'u;"Oi ~~.c c..c
("')d):!:::-"O~~Ea::=f,/)o.s
'OCii1;;"Oa__cu'C_gEB
;......g:i c.,~ ~ ~:i ~'> E8~
NQ)$Ci5"OC.~oenc! ~
-.0 c>..-o"Ocac.oo
.....eaizcat->"OcE...-=
~:::J""<(~ ,~en..!!QJ.ec'i";
uc~G)",~Q.l.9!~'O'O.2 ..s!
~.s! e -5 :i :B :2 g == -fi d) :g ~ €
.5~ ESsC:; ~ ft!.s gal ~ ~
tl
i
1ii
'"
J
~
~
"E >.:i
,5~'~
~~<E~,g.
Ol..!!! en.g ~lI)
Q) ~L1J Ul.5;
:5CD~:::J::JC
'O~~8€:E
,,~.a..;;j
a:2 g -e CD "0
,- UJ ,- cu E c
t _ u;.c cu ca
8.S~-g28.-ci
'O'O.aC'll::l.,g.!!
ciCUen41en:o
0- G) cu..c ~.-
,_ 0)- c - ..c
Ei-gSo'OK
&-,S~~enen
IU t1I,S l,) 0 4,1)'-
> ~ C C'Il,_ 1Q 41
, :::J'-;3 '0 c:s: C
~8~*~..tS
~
....
642
s
'll_
oS; 0
..5~
';3 '
q~
".c"
.e,,'12
-"'..
=Q)C
3,,0
CG:t:=U)
1!!"'1l
ca i CU
00 E
~'liQ;
8-.!:l
... ~.S
~ 0.5
o Q. E
~.8=
.. 3
..c=_
~'i ~
5-;0
'",," E
::I' -i l!:!
'" .c "
iii-I!!
0"-
->-
(1)842
~"'C0
'f: 5 e
~ e C'lJ
Eo>!,
E" 0
8c-
.. "
~"'c
.eo
_2-l!
IIl.c~
-'"
0"
"'8
Hc
--..
.."c
~~.!!
~u.5
w ..
..E
<0
'0
.8'"
..
H
.."
" c
:;; ..
" '"
,- "
.c 0
-.C
,5 iii '
- ..
1!:2~
~o=s
~~l
o.9~
c" ..
0..9:1 U)
z;::J:::J
""",
4i d) cu
~-5(l)
<..0.
;;
"
"
U
.5
,!1
'2
'i
'0
c
o
'L
!E~
il:a
:;:1
C
,2
~
~
'0
'"
"
.s
tl
..
0.
,5
'iii
c
o
:.2
"
"
<
...
"0
co
..0
'iN
.g~
.. "
.c~
III
"..
c,,,
....
!,3
oE
u;E
'08
c"
Oc
"'co
rl-
!Eg
H
.0
~
13
'"
o
Cl
'"
~IIl
Ojjj
'll"
",51
8'>
-"
00:
ori
<0
'"
II
II
II
II
l. I
III
,.
--
.'
ATTACHM ENT 48
Appendix 2
Schedule of Monitoring and Reporting Requirements
Recommendations of Niblett Environmental Associates August 2001
643
----
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
,
.
.
.
..
II
II
Qj
OIl
'"'
=
Q
U
eo-
-
Q
C
~
Qj
Qj
'"'
U
"C
Qj
~
Q
Q
'"'
U
N
1"1
.-
"C
=
Qj
Q.
Q.
-<
..
OIl
....
=
Qj
e
Qj
'"'
.-
=
C"
~
~
~
=
~
Q
Q.
Qj
~
"C
=
=
~
=
.-
'"'
Q
....
.-
=
Q
~
eo-
Q
Qj
-
=
"C
~
.c:
Cj
00
00
\::
't
o
0-
C!)
"'
'0
u
o
...
o
...
c...
Q
\::
\::
o
;JJ
...
C!)
c...
'"
...
00i'3
\:: >-.
.- --
0...5
E \::
'" 0
VJ E
\::
o
.~
u
o
..J
f"
Q
...
(l)
E
'"
~
c...
...
<8
>-.c!)
;::: C!)
tIl ...
;:l...c:
i::: ...
i::: -
tIl ~
It.+::
>-.i:::
"O>uo
... ;> i::: ,-
.~.~ Q) ~ Q) bl)
't:l :> ::l .... ~ I::
1-; CL) CT ::s ~.-
ma)....a)"O,ai5.
aQ:::::ar.l::"O....~
~~~'Oa<8~
,.....
0,
00
0,
;::, 0.0 ~
I:: 0
~:..= u
o 0- 0
""'8-0
~ tIl....
I m 0-
....
o
<;j
u i:::
,_ tIl
00'-
o .~
- i:::
.9...c:
.D ~
I ...
a)
u
i:::...c:
tIl ...
i::: .-
E ~
.5 ~
tIl tIl
8 ti
00
i:::
'2
.;;;
t:
...c:
00
>-.;:l
_ 0
...c: ... ...
......c: a)
\::....D
0>-.0
8 tIl U
,~O
"0
i:::
o ...
o-m
a)
C!) 0-
.~ (1) ~
m C!) i:::
i::: "0,-
0... 0
tIl 0-
_ i-l.
Z8o<l
,~ a)_
.... <- .-
E-r"0
-0 -
c...,...,:t
E-...... 0-
4-<
....
;:l
"UmE-
i:::-
tIl tIl ...
l1) .~ c.S
::38"0
W a) C!)
~...o f:I)
00 u ;:l
...
i:::
a)
i:::
o
P.
E
o
u
.0
,-
-
tIl
;:l,.....
Cia)
... u
a),s
... ...
tIl ;:l
~~
...
i:::
a)
8
C!)
00
tIl
a
~
li
a)
>-.m"O
... tIl a)
ml::"O
.:= a) C!)
.........c:C!)
,_ i:::
m
tIl a)
"Ow~
~ 0 s
C!) "'" ....
d)~<1)
8 [) (;j
I 0- ~
a)
u
a
I::
a)
...
i:::
.-
till::
S tIl
...
I m
>-.
-
._.
tIl
"0
I
0-
S
;:l
0-
-
-
a)
~
,.....
a) 00
SB
;:l >-.
--
o .-
:> '"
"0
I '-'
C 'i:'
.- .0 a)
"'; 0';:: ~
;:l a ~
CI;:l"O
...,-,;i:::
a)\J;:l
(;j"O 0
:>1::50
;>'tIl,-,
644
.s - >-.
i:::;:::
.0 Otll
.... en o+:: ::s V)
i::: a i::: u i::: ...
~ a)'- ;:l I:: ~
O">-.~.E:tIla)
a)_O;!lI::I::~
r.I:: ~;::: 0 a) ... '"
It;:l<8U.5<8~
-
'~
a)
0-
-
tIl
1il
'S;
I
a)
~
I::
E
.- !+-<
tIl.....
S tIl
lti
00 a
I:: i::: a)
I::'c 0 >-.
._ ::so';::: ~
e"O 2 ...
....~+Jc.S
~5~"O
tIl :> 0 c
I Q) U Cd
V'l
"0
P. .0&1
a) -
_Q) ... <<S .....-l
m .-
rJ:I \U to) 00
_o..CL)QJ
- 0 0..-
~_U)o
I ma)...c:
m
~.
o
- .-
tIl -
;:l U
m g,
os: 00
I'S
I::
o
.-
m
o
....
W
c
o
.-
...
U
g
_ m
fB a
P.U
..
.'
<r)
>-. ~ C
=~Q)
<<1_ ;>
;:I '" <l} '"
~ a ~ a
I ~<9 ~
co
s::
.~ 8
~.~ ~;::-
'" s:: co-
a 0 ~,
"",,,,,,80\
~~~:::,
"0
<l} ......
l;::: '"
.- '00
c;j 0
;:1-
0" .2
I .D
I
"0
's "0 <l}
>-. s:: s::
<l} <<I ;:I
>--'
~ ';:: ~
;:I 0.,-
'f' <r: 8
"0
s::
o
0.
<l}
......
'r;j
s::
o
<l} '"
"
~ <u </)
'u ...... s::
0
"0 <l} <<I ,-
s:: 0...":::: .t::
;:I "'.D"O
.D "0 <<I s::
<<I s:: ..c 0
I <<I , OJ
'"
~
:.E
,-
..c
0.
8
<r:
-
....
<B
~ ~
...::::.'M
- I
<<1-
;:I '"
s::
s::
<<I
.
c;j
;:I
'"
;>
,
....
<l}
0.
<l}
<l}
..>:i
'"
s::
<l}
<l}
...."0
~~
<r)
c
<l}
;>
<l} '"
S<! ~ a
:>"<9 ~
<l}
OJ
s::
<<I
s::
<l}
......
.S ~
<<I <<I
8 ti
b
..c co
E co ,5 s::
80 ,5 ~ Sl
.... 0 <<I
;:I .... <l}
I "0 co '"
s::
o
.~
......
'"
<l}
....
<8 '"
<l} <<I
.... ~
I <<I
"0
s::
<<I
-"",
~ 0
'- ..c
~.:=
;:I <<I
'" <l}
...c
<r:
s::
o
'p bO~
<<1.5 ~
...... ..... ~
v c'-
co <<I ~
<l}_ ;:I
> 0. '"
'"
co
s::
'';::
s::
<<I
0..
....
<8
>-. M"
- .
c;j-
;:I '"
s::
~
I
-
<<I
;:l
'"
';;
I
<r)
c
<l}
;>
<l} '"
.... s:: ....
~ <l} <<I
:>..<9 ~
....
<l} <l}
0. OJ
<l} s::
<l} <<I
..>:i s::
'" <l}
s:: ......
C1) .s~
~"O _-
~" s:: w <<I
'f'o:lEti
>-.
:a co
E co.5 s::
0.5 ~ Sl
8 ~ 8 i1
I "0 co '"
s::
o
.~
......
'"
~
<8 '"
<l} <<I
.... <l}
, a
~
o
....
&"0
"0 s::
<l} 0
..co.
, ,
<l}
co
<l} f <l}
OJ <l}.::::
~;>ogj",
'" " ;> ,2:!
<l} ~ s:: OJ
I-l "'0.- C1)
0. s:: s:: 0.
I (lj._ tn
co
s::
o
.~ ~
...... .-
<l) '"
co <<I
<l} ;>
> .5
'"
<l}
,-
OJ
<l}
0.
'"
645
I
I ~ . f
I
...
.'
Appendix 3
Monitoring and Remedial Actions
Recommendations of Niblett Environmental Associates August 2001
646
ATTACHMENT 4C
-/ .'
II
II
II
'"
II =
Q
.-
.....
(J
Q,l 00(
'"
I 10. -
= ~
Q .-
U "C
Q,l
II .... =
-
Q Q,l
r;;l c=:
.. ~ "C
Q,l =
f: ~
u t)()
=
"C .-
10.
Q,l Q
~ .....
Q .-
Q =
10. Q
U :;
..
~
~
.-
"C
=
Q,l
Q.
Q.
00(
r/l .
..... I:lO ....
U Q)
oo~'-' 0
o 0.. t:: r/l
~ 0.5 ,9 t:: gg
B:;3:"Ot;i OQ)
ro Q)~ U"Jrn
;..i:l-;..Q) .....Q)
Q) ~ eo,-., CJ _
~;..Q)Q)Q)~o~
I:lO 0 r/l ;.. t<l ..... 0..-
';:: .D.D t:: I:lO E"O ::l
.. ro 9 0 ~ .7 .;g ~
~
>-. .~
.~ >
Oj~"O
::l 0 C
0-..... t<l
[) 1:: ~
~ ~~-
r/l t<l o..::l
Q).D :> ~ r/lQ)
~ ~ ;.;- 0) $..0
c:
o
';::
U
<t:
Q)
r/l
::l ;>..
.... t<l
Q) ....
,~ ~
'-2 g
~'+-<
"0 0
t::~
t<l.!5
Q) .-
:S! ~
U ....
.- Q)
tJ~
Q) ::l
0...D
Q) Q)
r/l r/l
t<l t<l
Q) Q) r/l
.... .... Q)
U U ~
Q) c: ~
"0._ 0
, I N
OJ
"0
Q)
E
QJ
C!:
;>..
U
C
C)
U
,-
-
u
C
'0
....
.....
c:
o
U
;>..
-
"0
Q)
.....
:.a
Q)
....
U
U
t<l
.....
t<l
""
::;
C'
I:lO
c:
(3
.....
~
(3
::?:
r/l
QJ
P..
E
t<l
r/l
....
QJ
.....
t<l
~
-
t::
0)
t::
o
c..
~
~
(3
U
;>..
,-;::
OJ
::l
0"0
.... t::
QJ 0
t;i 0..
:;3: ,6
"0
t::
""
r/l
Q)
'So
Q)
.....
f:!
.....
r/l
.....
t::
Q)
E
Q)
I:lO
<<l
t::
<<l
E r/l
....
~~
Q)'i-<
t:: ::l
I .D
r/l~ r/l
~....Q)"", Q)
o ~ 'S .~ g
:::8:;3:~~ f:!
o ';:::>;:l1l ~
~_.-,..J_~o
t<l0 t<l
Q) .- ;..;>.. .....
8 g o~ t<l ~
0...-:.:: CJ ~:.::
E~t<lQ)t<l"O
O .... ;:l ~ 0::::
ui:l-Ol':E~
o
.....
..Q
0..
0..
;:l
r/l
....
Q)
.....
<<l
~
~
o
.....
r/l
Q)"O
.... Q)
o .....
..... U
"O~
Q)'i-<
.... <<l
.3 ~
o-r/l
~.8
, .....
Q)
U
..s
....
;:l
r/l
~ ....
1:lO~
.- <<l
-9 ~
"0
630
"-5 00_
," ....-
C I:lO <<l I:lO
- r/l ::l t::
. E .... cr' ,-
c:e Q) .....-
.....1:lOQ)0"
C 1:lO..... E
o ,- <<l <<l
U .l:l ~ r/l
E
"0
Q) ti
~ 060
0.. 0
Q) -
...."0 0
0..Q)Q)
t:: t+:: I:lO
00- 8
0.. OJ "0
Q) ::l ;>..
'i' cr'~
r/l
-
QJ
;..
~
-
-
Q)
~
I
;>.. 'i:'
.~ ;>-.~
C3.'t:: ro
;:l E ~
o-t<l"O
.... ;:l C
Q) cr' ::l
t;i"O 0
:;3:~~
647
C
o
'm
o
....
Q)
.....
U
QJ
t:
o
U
o
.....
I:lO
t::
'i:
Q)
Q)
t:: r/l
'So E
C Q)
Q)-
.9.g
.D i:<
I .....
t::
o
.-
r/l
g
Q)
"0
Q)
r/l
<<l
Q)
....
U
t::
.-
I
.....
r/l
<<l
0..
~
.....
.~
Q)
....
t<l ~
S'QJ
o i::
u ::l
I r/l
r/l
;>..
Q)
i::
::l
r/l
I
t::
o
.-
r/l
o
....
~
III "
.-
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I I
.
.
.
.
..
III
-
.
.'
s:::
.-
1il
....
~
~
C1)
>
o
....
S
,-
s:::
0.9
~~
o <Jl
OJ <Jl
'"
<Jl C 8
~so.
._.- i:-
t: ~.-
0:I<U-
_ cIJ ~
0. '" 0-
ta8'-
s::: s::: B
000:1
00 '';:._ :;;;. (1)
"'0'- tll ..... ;>
s:::"'O<Uo
o ~ .... <U.D
~"i"~tf~
o
....
<Jl
s:::
o
.-
....
0.
o
<Jl
<Jl
<U
<Jl
<Jl
0:1
,
s:::'"
.- a
C1) <Jl
<Jl ....
0:1 <U
~.D
OJ S
C1) ;:I
"'9 s:::
s::
.... .9 S >>
o ........
o 0:1 0:=
0.'0 Sc<l:: g
~ 5 ~.~ S ti 0-
'u 00 ~ Q)'- ~ [)
C1)<JloOO"'s....
~ 0 .... C1) <U 0:1
~ 'I en;> t{l'1 ~
-
0:1
~ootU
s::: .... ....
~"3:E
<U ~ 0:1
~....~
o.>>gJ
S C1) C1)
8 ~ ~
I <Jl ,
-
0:1
s:::
o .... <Jl
00 ~.....
0:1 0:1-
<Jl 1il ~;l
c..... .... QJ
o 0 .... 0 ....
.,;:....... CI)....., ~
:.a '2 -5 '2 .~
o 0:1 0-
8 s C1) s ~
OJ I ~ , 0-
<Jl
>>
C1)
,
;:I
<Jl
I
<Jl
a
is
:.a
0.
s
<r:
....
OJ
<U
0.
<Jl
0:1
'"
..:.:: ~ <Jl
OJ C1) C1)
o ....._
.... ;:I OJ
<Jl .... C1)
~.~ 0.
C1) 0 <Jl
s:::s'O
~ _"' c.
'-'- 0
:> 0 ,_
;;> <Jl ....
<U :> 0:1
OJ ;;> OJ
0:1 C1) 0
-'- -
0.>",
C1) <U s:::
~ 'i ~
....~
~ ~
<U C1)
6iJs:::
,-
i:-~
._ 0
- Vl
~N C1)
o ~ c
S ~ 0
I .... N
'"
~
~
.::
0:1
]....
o <Jl
.... - 00
B 0:1 C
.- ;;...-
s:: .- .......
o , ~
~;lo..
<Jl
~
.,;;.
1il
,
C1)
<Jl
.D
o
I
<r:
c
o <Jl
.p en
~'E
~~
>0..
~ 00
gj .S S
j;. c C1)
.D 2tS
oil 0. ....;:1
C '"
._ c OJ
'" 0:1 0
~ oo~ ....
:>S:::C1)2
;>...-l rJ:l \J
'" C ;:I'u
~2e:.s
~ 0. 0 ....
>>"'~]
.D~~>>
<U ~ OJ-
> .... ;:I 0.
00.Dg.
~~.8-g
I tI.l I i:d
li)0:I....
1il ~ 0 <Jl
<U 0:1 .... <U
6iJ '0 ] 'u
~~ E ~
~ 0 C C
C1) - ~.-
~ ~ ,!:!l~
C?..s~ 8
<Jl
0:1
c"'~
<<j:.a~0:I
(1).t; ~ ~
.... :> 0 ~
<<S .....p :s
.... ~~ s "'"
o \oIU tfJ-
.~ e OJ ~
C C1) .... ~
0><8....
E 0 C1) 0:1
, OJ .... C
<Jl
C
o
.~
,
C1)
<Jl
.D
o
,
l:J:l
C
o
,- C1)
g .~
C1) <Jl
000:1
C1) ~
> .-
<Jl
C1)
,-
OJ
C1)
g.
648
.'
ATTACHMENT 5
SUMMARY OF HYDROGEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT
CROOKED CREEK GOLF COURSE
This report was prepared by Geo-Logic Inc in December 1997
Purpose and Methodoloav
The report describes the existing hydrogeologic conditions and determines the suitability of the
development of an 18 hole golf course on 54 ha of land, Possible impacts this development
may have on the shallow groundwater regime and down-gradient functions shall be identified,
The consultant conducted a review of existing background information and a well inventory
survey, This included interviews with neighbours to confirm and supplement Ministry of
Environment well water information.
On site, 13 test pits were excavated to determine shallow overburden and groundwater
conditions and Piezometers were installed to monitor hydraulic gradients and determine the
hydraulic conditions of the subsoils, In addition, 4 test wells were drilled on-site to decipher
availability of groundwater and to evaluate potential impacts of the proposed development on
the local groundwater conditions, Analysis of this well water was also conducted,
Site Conditions
It was found that the site is comprised of sandy soils and has relatively good drainage, Surface
water infiltrates into the shallow sandy soil and slowly recharges towards the adjacent creek,
Infiltration does not appear to have access to the deeper aquifer due to a silt or clay layer, It
was found that the shallow groundwater flow generally conforms to the ground surface
topography generally flowing in a westerly direction towards Soper Creek, The hydrogeologic
information revealed the existence of 3 principal aquifer systems being a shallow aquifer
separated from the deeper aquifer by a silt or clay layer and lastly an aquifer appearing within
fractures in the bedrock,
The majority of private wells in immediate area are drilled wells (65%), No shallow wells are
hydraulically downgradient of the site,
AQuifer Performance Testina
Pumping tests were conducted on one of the test wells and during pumping, 2 other test wells
on site were monitored as well as the nearest off-site bored well and drilled well. During
testing, 1,670,000 Iitres of water was removed in 24,5 hours, The consultant concluded that
the test well, in conjunction with a properly designed and constructed water supply system, can
provide the necessary quantities of potable water while preserving the long term water quality
of the aquifer,
Well monitoring during and after the pumping tests revealed that there was no impact on the
neighbours well or on the man-made pond, No significant changes were noted in the on-site
bored well and the well that supplies water to the existing adjacent house, The pumping test
Summary of Hydrogeological Assessment
Crooked Creek Golf Course
649
Attachment 5: Page 1
determined that "The water quality and quantity suggest that the aquifer has a minimal
connection to the base flow of the creek or infiltration from the site",
Nitrates
The fertilization of the fairways and greens is anticipated to have a nitrate loading of 354 kg of
nitrate fertilizer a year, Based on site infiltration, projected nitrate concentration at site
boundary will be 1,7 mg/L, The receiving pond and tributaries are not anticipated to be
adversely effected, Present nitrate levels in the pond is 1,Omg/L and Soper Creek is 1.6 mg/L.
A negligible impact is anticipated on the watercourses from fertilization practices,
Waste Disposal
Site can facilitate a Class 4 or Class 10 type waste disposal system, The report provides 11
recommendations regarding the proposed waste disposal system including recommended
setbacks between system, buildings and property line, For review of these recommendations,
refer to the consultant's report,
Conclusions and Recommendations
The report concludes that:
· Irrigation of the site can be facilitated by the on-site well.
. Use of this well will have no impact on adjacent wells or on the level of the man-made
pond,
. A deeper on-site aquifer complex prevents migration of potential contaminants into
groundwater. This aquifer is confined and it is expected that the aquifer provides little or
no contribution to localized baseflow,
. During summer months, as a result of irrigation, an increase in baseflow may occur,
. It is expected that during irrigation a marginal flow increase in the discharge of the pond
to the creek may occur,
. No adverse effects on down-gradient watercourse due to irrigational practices are
anticipated,
. No adverse effects on down-gradient flow will be noted during the peak flow periods that
occur during spring and fall months,
. Use of fertilizers is not anticipated to impact water quality in Crooked Creek,
. Cumulative impact of golf course on off-site groundwater baseflow is expected to have a
positive affect.
. Potable water is available on site,
It is recommended that:
. I rrigation be discharged in the areas of the tees, fairways and greens.
. Irrigation be directed towards areas of low runoff and aided by installed underground
drainage,
. Recommend limit use of fertilizers around watercourses,
. Recommend additional vegetative buffers and infiltration strips around tributaries and
pond banks to aid in absorbing excess nutrients and reduce soil erosion,
. Recommend to pump water from well at 100 igpm and any excess water is to be
obtained from the pond when short term requirements are needed,
. Maximum water taking is 655,000 L1day,
Summary of Hydrogeological Assessment
Crooked Creek Golf Course
650
Attachment 5: Page 2
.
. Central water supply system incorporate use of existing drilled water well.
. System may require use of a storage facility (pond) to lower the quantity of water used
during peak demand periods,
. Place flow control devices on equipment to avoid over pumping,
. The area around the well be identified as a Zone 1 well head protection area, The
installation of guard posts will ensure potential contamination including application of
fertilizers, pesticides or herbicides in surrounding area will be avoided,
. An annual water quality monitoring program be conducted to ensure maintenance of
good water quality,
. Collect on a regular basis, water level and consumption data to evaluate the
performance of the well and the long term impact on the underlying aquifer,
. Require a full-time water taking permit.
Peer Review
The report was peer reviewed by Gartner Lee and was received on February 8, 1999, More
information about the aquifer was requested to assist in assessing the long term sustainability
of the aquifer. This included identification of adjacent land uses, It was also suggested that
other on-site wells and two off-site wells be included in the monitoring program and that the
man-made pond be monitored if it is to be used for irrigation,
Geo-Logic Inc provided the additional information and in April 1999, Gartner Lee was satisfied
that the deep confined aquifer can sustain irrigation requirements for the proposed 9 hole golf
course without causing adverse impacts on the creek or existing wells, Gartner Lee also
concurred with the report's review of impacts from fertilizer and impacts on groundwater and
surface water, and that the site is suitable for a subsurface septic disposal system,
Summary of Hydrogeological Assessment
Crooked Creek Golf Course
651
Attachment 5: Page 3
.'
ATTACHMENT 6
SUMMARY OF TURF MANAGEMENT REPORT
CROOKED CREEK GOLF COURSE
This report was prepared by Kortekaas Lally Holmes Golf Course Consultants and was
submitted in January 1997, A revised report is dated January, 1998,
Purpose
The purpose of the report is to review the site conditions and prepare a report that identifies
best management practices for the care of the golf course, Included within the best
management practices is the identification of grass species that would be hardy, and generally
drought tolerant and recommendations regarding the application and amount of fertilization
needed, Lastly, the report examines stormwater management, irrigation and the existing
watercourses,
Both reports were prepared in anticipation of a 18 hole golf course on 54 ha of land,
Turf Fundamentals
The consultant reviewed the design, construction, fertilizer needs and seed selection for the
greens, tees, fairways, and roughs, Generally, using a grass species that is drought resistant
and tolerant to disease is recommended,
In order to lower the concentration of fertilizer and pesticides, underdrains in the greens will be
installed to collect excess runoff and any fertilizer and pesticide contaminated leachate, Drains
and leachate will go to water quality basins having a sand-peat filter,
The amount of area allocated to fairways has been reduced and the first 100 yards from tee
areas will not be actively maintained,
Two types of rough are proposed, A Maintained Rough and Naturalized Out-of-Play Rough,
The Maintained Rough will be seeded with drought resistant and pest/weed resistant strain of
seed, There will be minimal harsh measures taken to control weeds within these areas,
The Naturalized Out-of-Play Areas will be visually distinct from the fairways, in part due to the
reduction of maintenance within these areas, and in part due to the species to be planted
within these areas, It is intended that these areas will provide food and shelter for wildlife and
provide wildlife corridors functions, Opportunity exists to create wildlife habitat structures in
these areas,
Water Fundamentals
All greens, tees, and fairways will be setback a minimum of 30 m from the centerline of the
watercourses or 15 m from the defined top of bank, These setback areas will be maintained in
a natural state to permit the natural heritage features and functions associated with the
watercourses to be maintained,
The setback zones will consist of areas of unmaintained, native grasses, aquatic plants,
shrubs and trees,
Summary of Turf Management
Crooked Creek Golf Course
652
Attachment 6: Page 1
"
Changes to the site will "result in the establishment of a high quality turfgrass on well-drained
tees, greens and fairways, This will result in a decrease in peak stormwater runoff flows and
increased groundwater recharge across the site", All stormwater from parking areas and
other highly maintained areas will be directed to stormwater storage facilities, All runoff from
the golf course will be collected by swales and directed to water quality basins, ensuring that
no stormwater runoff will be conveyed directly into the natural areas,
Irrigation
Irrigation water will be taken from the existing pond, The pond will be fed by an on-site well.
An efficient irrigation system is proposed that will monitor existing conditions and irrigate only
when necessary eliminating overwatering and reducing the potential of nutrient movement and
leaching,
Integrated Pest Management (IPM)
Goal is to reduce need for chemical control of pests, Biological controls or agents which
include fungi, bacteria, nematods and insects will be used wherever possible, If necessary,
and pests persist, spot spraying of chemicals that are the least toxic and have shortest residual
activity will be used,
Recommendations
Plantings
. Specific recommendations for planting and fertilization are contained in the report.
Setbacks and Buffers
. All greens, tees, and fairways will be setback a minimum of 30 m from the centreline of
the watercourses or 15m from defined top of bank,
. All setback areas will be maintained or enhanced in a natural state, sufficient to ensure
that the natural heritage features and functions within and associated with the
watercourses will be maintained,
. Naturalized setback zones or other erosion control measures will be maintained and
created, protecting surface water resources and environmentally sensitive areas,
. Habitat for wildlife species will be protected or created in out-of-play areas,
Nutrients and Integrated Pest Management Plan
. Recommends that a careful approach to fertilizer and pesticide application and control
be implemented due to the sandy soils,
. Use integrated pest management plan including non-chemical control measures, If
these are ineffective, only then will chemical control strategies be utilized,
. No chemical use permitted within 30 m of watercourse,
. Store chemicals in a location that is safe for employees and environment.
. Only nutrient products and practices that reduce potential for contamination of ground
and surface water will be used,
. Owners will maintain excellence in the continuing education of applicators including
licensing, training and certification,
. Signage will be erected indicating area of restricted chemical applications and to inform
golfers and remind employees of environmentally sensitive buffer areas,
Summary of Turf Management
Crooked Creek Golf Course
653
Attachment 6: Page 2
~. .~
Stormwater Management
Ponds proposed to be built will serve as stormwater storage facilities. Drainage from
golf course will be directed to these ponds wherever possible,
Recommend appropriate buffer features and infiltration strips be installed wherever the
golf course crosses or comes in contact with the watercourses,
Erection of erosion control sediment fence between all locations of grading operations
and environmentally sensitive areas, All fences to be erected at the top of bank and
remain in place until the grass has established,
. All greens will be constructed with underdrainage as per the USGA Green Construction
specifications, These drainage tiles will be directed to a Water Quality Basin located
near the green which will filter runoff and any possible nitrate leachates,
. Swales will be provided along the boundary areas between the manicured portion of the
golf course and the preserved natural areas, Runoff from the golf course will be
collected in the swales and taken to water quality basins, ensuring that no stormwater
runoff will be conveyed directly into the natural areas,
Stormwater from the impervious parking lot and clubhouse will be directed to on-site
ponds/stormwater storage facilities,
.
.
.
.
Additional Information Required
. A detailed erosion control plan based on the golf course routing plan must be
development prior to construction, This plan shall identify areas requiring silt fencing
and other erosion control methods,
Implementation
. Site specific mitigation measures will be developed at the golf course construction
drawing phase,
. Utilize integrated plant management incorporating integrated pest management and
best management practices,
. Use of qualified contractors with experience in special environmental requirements of
golf course construction will be used during construction,
. Qualified golf course superintendent will be hired early in design and construction
process,
. Grass clippings will be collected and com posted in an area that is not environmentally
sensitive,
. All mowing machinery must be properly maintained with suitable mufflers to reduce
noise pollution,
Conclusions
Based on implementation of the above recommendations, the development of a 9 hole golf
course on the subject lands can be achieved having little or no impact on the environment.
Summary of Turf Management
Crooked Creek Golf Course
654
Attachment 6: Page 3
~ ~.
ATTACHMEINT 7
AMENDMENT NO. 26
TO THE CLARINGTON OFFICIAL PLAN
PURPOSE:
To allow a 9 hole golf course, club house and necessary maintenance
buildings on Part Lot 3, Concession 4, former Township of Darlington,
Part 1 on 40R-14585 and Part 1 on 40R-19013
BASIS:
An application to amend the Official Plan to permit a golf course on lands
designated "Green Space" and "Environmental Protection Area" and
further described as Part 1 on 40R-14585 and Part 1 on 40R-19013 in
Part Lot 3, Concession 4, Former Township of Darlington was received,
An amendment to the Clarington Official Plan is necessary to allow the
proposed golf course, club house and necessary maintenance buildings,
A number of studies including hydrogeological, turf management and
environmental impact studies were prepared in support of this application,
Reflecting the conclusions of these reports and agency concerns
regarding the impact an 18 hole golf course would have on the site's
natural heritage features, the application was revised substantially,
reducing the number of holes from 18 to 9 and decreasing the land area
from :1:54 ha to :1:41, The studies conclude that the proposed 9 hole golf
course will have no significant impacts on the natural heritage features,
ACTUAL
AMENDMENT:
The Clarington Official Plan is hereby amended by:
a) by adding the flowing exception to Table 18,1 as follows:
Table 18.1
Golf Courses
Area Area
Identified Name and Type of Golf Course Legal Description (ha)
On Map A
Crooked Creek Golf Course Part Lot 3, Concession 4,
G2 (9 holes, club house, maintenance buildings) former Township of 41 +/..
Darlington
IMPLEMENTATION:
The prOVIsions set forth in the Clarington Official Plan, as amended,
regarding the implementation of the Plan, shall apply in regard to this
amendment.
INTERPRETATION:
The prOVIsions set forth in the Clarington Official Plan, as amended,
regarding the interpretation of the Plan, shall apply in regard to this
amendment.
655
1. ,..
SCHEDULE "A"
AMENDMENT No. 26 TO THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON OFFICIAL PLAN,
MAP A1, LAND USE, DARLINGTON RURAL AREA
ENNISKILLEN
HYDRO
.....
'"
Add Symbol for
"Golf Course"
656