HomeMy WebLinkAboutFND-010-04
~
.
C:!fJl-!lJgron
REPORT
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
Date:
GENERAL PURPOSE AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
/1 f)1 'oX' LI
Resolution #: (-:1~rr'Y'x:.I/C I
MONDAY, APRIL 19,2004
Meeting:
Report #: FND-010-04
File#:
By-law #:
Subject:
PROVINCIAL SALES TAX
Recommendations:
It is respectfully recommended that the General Purpose and Administration Committee
recommend to Council the following:
1. THAT Report FND-010-04 be received;
2. THAT Council endorse the resolution of the Council of the Regional Municipality
of Durham that the Provincial Government give consideration to a zero-rate (tax-
free) Provincial Sales Tax for municipal purchases of goods and services;
3. THAT the Province of Ontario be requested to dedicate a portion of the Provincial
fuel tax to help improve roads and transit infrastructure in the Province; and
4. THAT a copy of this resolution be forwarded to the City of Sarnia, the Ministers of
Finance and Municipal Affairs, the local MPP and the Association of
Municipalities of Ontario.
/?
, ') ~ (? , tl.:;t.~
Reviewed by=--..../ . . '----' ,
Franklin Wu,
Chief Administrative Officer.
NT/hjl
~
1301
REPORT NO.: FND-010-04
PAGE 2
BACKGROUND AND COMMENT:
1.0 At the Council meeting of March 1, 2004, Clarington Council referred
correspondence received from the City of Sarnia to the Director of
Finance/Treasurer. The correspondence indicated that the Council of the City of
Sarnia passed the following resolution on January 26, 2004:
"THAT Sarnia City Council supports the efforts being made by the Mayors
of some of the larger Canadian cities to realize full municipal rebates of
the GST, and a 5 cent per litre share of the Federal Gas Tax; and
That a similar position be adopted by other municipalities with respect to
PST; and
That the City of Sarnia believes that a percentage of the revenues realized
by the 8 percent PST, and 7 percent GST, imposed on goods and/or
services in the various municipalities within the Province of Ontario, and
collected and remitted by the organizations and businesses within said
Province, be negotiated between representatives of all governments, and
that the agreed upon figure be remitted by the organizations and
businesses directly to the municipality based upon the time schedules now
implemented; and
THAT this motion be forwarded to the usual municipalities, to AMO, to our
local MP and MPP, and to the Mayor of Toronto."
2.0 At the Region of Durham Finance and Administration Committee of Wednesday,
February 25, 2004, the Committee approved Report 2004-F-15 (Attachment A),
requesting the Province to exempt municipalities from paying PST on municipal
purchases of goods and services. This would provide municipalities with much
needed assistance in reducing expenses in the same manner as the Federal
government has announced the elimination of the GST for municipalities.
3.0 As the two resolutions deal with essentially the same issues, they are dealt with
together in this report.
4.0 The City of Sarnia appears to be proposing, in addition to a full rebate of the
PST, a share of the revenues generated from PST and GST from organizations
within their municipality. They further suggest that this be remitted directly to the
Municipality by the affected businesses and organizations.
5.0 From a practical perspective, municipalities do not have the mechanisms in place
to enforce collection or audit the value of amounts remitted. There would, as a
minimum requirement, be staffing and expertise developed, as well as an
interface to the Ministry of Finance. This could be a costly exercise that may not
1302
REPORT NO.: FND-010-04
PAGE 3
be feasible for many smaller municipalities. It would also represent a duplication
of effort. Municipalities collect property taxes on behalf of the upper tier
municipalities and school boards and remit the amounts to them for exactly this
reason.
6.0 There is a more compelling case for requests to receive a share of gasoline tax
as there is a direct correlation to the costs of construction and maintenance and
repair of roads. Even in this case, it would be recommended that the upper
levels of government continue to be the collection agent, with remittances to the
municipalities based upon an agreed upon formula.
7.0 As mentioned in the attached report, a PST rebate is an efficient means of
generating revenue for municipalities that is tied to the amount of purchases a
municipality makes in a given year. The Association of Municipalities of Ontario
estimates that municipalities in Ontario would save approximately $180 million if
the PST exemption was adopted.
CONCLUSION:
8.0 While savings from a PST exemption may not be equivalent to the savings
anticipated from the GST exemption, it would still provide much needed
assistance to municipalities in either reduced costs or making available financing
for infrastructure needs. It is therefore recommended that Council endorse the
request by the Region of Durham that the Provincial Government give
consideration to a zero-rate (tax-free) PST for municipal purchases of goods and
services.
9.0 It is also recommended that Council formally request that the Province of Ontario
give consideration to AMO's request to dedicate a portion of the provincial fuel
tax to help improve roads and transit infrastructure in the Province.
Attachments:
Attachment A - Region of Durham Report 2004-F-15
~ 1303
REPORT NO.: FND-010-04
PAGE 4
Copies to:
City of Sarnia
Margaret Watson, City Clerk
P.O. Box 3018
255 North Christina Street
Sarnia, Ontario
N7T 7N2
Hon. Greg Sorbara
Minister of Finance
Frost Bldg. South
ih floor, 7 Queen's Park Crescent
Toronto, Ontario
M7A 1Y7
Hon. John Gerretsen
Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing
1 ih Floor, 777 Bay Street
Toronto, Ontario
M5G 2C8
John O'Toole, MPP
75 King Street East
Bowmanville, Ontario
L 1 C 1 N4
Association of Municipalities of Ontario
393 University Avenue
Suite 1701
Toronto, Ontario
M5G 1 E6
CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON
40 TEMPERANCE STREET, BOW MANVILLE, ONTARIO L 1 C 3A6 T (905)623-3379 F (905)623-4169
~ 1304
-
Attachment A
The Regional Municipality of Durham
Report to: Finance and AdministratiL..._ ~
From: R.J. Clapp, Commissioner of Finance
Report No.: 2004-F-15
Date: February 25, 2004
SUBJECT:
REQUEST FOR PROVINCIAL SALES TAX (PST) RELIEF ON REGIONAL
PURCHASES OF GOODS AND SERVICES
RECOMMENDATIONS:
The Finance and Administration Committee recommend to Regional Council that:
1. The Provincial Government give consideration to a zero-rate (tax-free) Provincial
Sales Tax for municipal purchases of goods and services, thereby providing
municipalities with much needed assistance in reducing expenses in the same
manner as the Federal government has announced the elimination of the GST
for municipalities.
2. A copy of this report be forwarded to the Ministers of Finance and Municipal
Affairs, the local MPP's representing Durham Region and the Association of
Municipalities of Ontario.
1.0 INTRODUCTION
. On February 2, 2004 the Federal Government's Speech from the Throne
indicated that the Government of Canada would provide all municipalities with
full relief from the portion of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) that they
currently pay. According to the Speech, this measure will provide municipalities
with approximately $7 billion in GST rebates over the next decade. The GST
rebates .for municipalities began to accurnulate on February 1, 2004.
. Just as the Federal Government has recently provided Canadian municipalities
with full exemption of the GST for the purchase of goods and services,
municipalities are requesting that the Province of Ontario act in kind and provide
a zero-rate Provincial Sales Tax (PST) for municipalities. Such taxation relief
would provide municipalities with a much needed assistance through reduced
expenditures.
2.0 BACKGROUND
. The Retail Sales Tax Act (the Act) imposes a general sales tax of 8% on the
retail price of most goods and services sold to final consumers. The Act also
levies sales tax at variable rates between 4% (for example, on automobile
insurance) and 12% (on alcoholic beverages).
1305 90
REPORT #2004-F-15
2.
. Provincial receipts from PST for the 2001-2002 fiscal year totalled approximately
$14 billion and represents approximately 20% of the Province's total revenue.
. Currently, municipalities in Ontario must pay PST, for which they receive no
rebate at all. In 2002, a Special Report commissioned by TD Economics
estimated that all Ontario municipalities pay approximately $275 million in the
PST to the Government of Ontario. The GT A share is estimated to be around
$150 million.
3.0 STRUCTURE AND APPLICABILITY OF THE PST
. The PST is imposed on the sale, or on the gross receipts from the sale, of a
wide range of commodities and, sometimes, of services. The main difference
between the PST and GST is the manner in which the taxes are collected.
While the GST is collected at every stage of the production process of a
particular good or service, the PST is collected at the retail stage and no input
tax credits are issued.
. Currently, the PST applies to a host of municipal goods and services which
are eligible under the Act, including but not limited to the purchase of capital
for construction work, office supplies and fleet vehicles.
. The Region estimated that approximately $3.2 million was spent on PST for
related municipal purchases in 2003.
4.0 THE CASE FOR PST RELIEF ON MUNICIPAL PURCHASES
. A PST rebate on municipal purchases represents a reduction of costs for
municipalities. A PST rebate represents a quick, efficient means of generating
revenue for municipalities and the amount of relief provided to municipalities is
strictly related to the amount of eligible purchases a municipality makes in a
given year.
. In most cases, the applicability of the PST to municipal purchases represents
an additional cost to the taxpayer, since the tax burden is almost always shifted
to and borne by the taxpayer. In essence, this raises the issue of double
taxation. For example, it does not make sense that municipal tax dollars used
to purchase a police vehicle be increased to send sales tax dollars from one
level of government to another. By exempting the PST at the municipal level,
greater equity to the taxpayer would be achieved. The Association of
Municipalities of Ontario (AMO) estimates that municipalities in Ontario would
be permitted to retain approximately $180 million in collected property tax dollars
(there would also be a benefit in reduced costs funded by other municipal
sources of revenue (e.g. user revenue)).
130691
REPORT #2004-F-15
. During the 2004 Speech from the Throne, the Federal Government announced
that it would forgive the GST on municipal purchases of goods and services,
effective February 1, 2004. If the Province were to also consider providing
taxation relief via a zero-rate PST for municipalities in addition to Federal GST
exemption, AMO estimates that a combined $330 million in property taxes would
be retained by our communities.
5.0 CONCLUSION
. The Region endorses the recommendations outlined in AMO's 2004 Pre-Budget
Submission and would welcome a commitment from the Provincial Government
to provide the municipality with PST relief. A PST rebate for the Region
represents an estimated minimum amount of $3 million a year in reduced costs,
depending on the amount of purchases made by the Region in a given year.
Combined relief from the GST and PST would avoid the issue of double
taxation, which is incurred on the purchases of goods and services at the
municipal level.
~ ~-<:.., ~p.
R.J. Clapp, CA
Commissioner of Finance
Recommended for Presentation to Committee
G.H. Cubitt, M.S.w.
Chief Administrative Officer
dlk\2004reports\pst report
1307 92
3.