Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004-047 , .~ , .~ THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON BY-LAW 2004 - 047 Being a by-law to authorize the execution of an agreement between the Municipality of Clarington and the Clarington Professional Fire-fighters, Local 3139. NOW THEREFORE THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON HEREBY ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. THAT the Mayor and Clerk are hereby authorized to execute on behalf of the Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington, and seal with the Corporate Seal, the Collective Agreement between the Clarington Professional Fire-fighters, Local 3139 and the Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington for the term covering January 01, 2004 to December 31,2006. 16 By-law read a first and second time this day of 16 By-law read a third time and finally passed this February ,2004. Februar'y day of , :l004. cJ1. -uIJ~~ John "_,Ma"". :.: , Municipal Clerk Appendix B Annual Return Sick Leave Plan Eli!!ibilitv . All existing employees at July 1, 2004 shall have the option of remaining on their previous existing plan or switching to this Annual Return Plan. . All existing employees as stated above shall be given a single opportunity to switch plans and must put their request to change in writing to the Fire Chief, copied to Human Resources. All employees hired after January 1, 2004 shall have the opportunity of enrolling in the Annual Return Sick Plan or Short Term Disability Sick Leave Plan. . All employees shall have completed five (5) years continuous service with the Corporation to be eligible for any return for accumulated sick days. Rate and Rules of Return . Employees who have completed sixty (60) days employment will be entitled to one (I) day per month accumulative sick leave, retroactive to date of hire at his/her regular rate of pay. . A sick leave day shall be calculated at the rate of 1/182 of the annual salary as it applies to the individual employee. . In order to receive the annual retum for unused sick days, employees must have forty (40) unused accumulated days in their sick banle. . Employees not having the minimum forty (40) days in their bank shall continue to use the portion of unused accumulated days needed to bring them up to the required forty (40) days before being eligible for any return. . Employees shall not be permitted to accumulate more than forty (40) unused days in their sick bank after returns are paid, unless those employees are awaiting their five (5) year eligibility date, at which time the excessive days shall be paid out. . , . Having met the criteria for eligibility, each employee shall be paid an amount equal to exactly one-half (112) of their unused sick days not required to top up to the 40 day base or contributed to the bereavement fund from the prior calendar year at hislher regular rate of pay on the last day of the year calculated to a lifetime maximum of91 days. Payment is subject to any statutory deductions that may be appropriate and paid through the Municipal payroll. . As soon as possible, upon resigning or retiring from employment, exactly one- half (112) of remaining unused base of accumulated (maximum 40) days shall be paid at hislher regular rate of pay on the last day of employment, including those days remaining in the sick bank. Paid out as a retiring allowance as appropriate. . Employees may use vacation entitlement which may still be due them, while absent because of illness when hislher sick pay is exhausted, or on the approval of the Chief, the sick pay shall be interrupted in order that vacation entitlement may be completed before the end ofthe year. . In instances where a member is off sick due to injury or illness and does not have sufficient days in hislher sick bank to fulfill the waiting time for Long Term Disability, such information may be filed with the Chief, and members of the Local 3139 will be advised that they may make a voluntary individual contribution in such cases, on the understanding that decision to contribute is the responsibility of the individual member. A maximum of one (I) sick day per month of sick leave, donated by each member, is to be applied to the sick bank of the deficient member. . At the end of the Elimination Period in accordance with the LTD plan, all sick leave claims are automatically referred to LTD. . If an employee dies before retirement, one-half (112) of all unused vested accumulated sick days will be paid to hislher beneficiary as soon as possible, following the members death. MEMORANDUM OF SETTLEMENT Between: The Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington Hereinafter referred to as "the Municipality" and Clarington Fire Fighter's Association International Association of Fire Fighters Local 3139 Hereinafter referred to as "the Association" Whereas the collective agreement between the parties expired on December 31 st, 2003; And whereas the parties wish to amend the collective agreement; Now, therefore the parties agree to the following basis of settlement of all matters in dispute and agree to recommend its acceptance unanimously to their principals for ratification. I. The term of the collective agreement shall be from January 1st, 2004 to December 31 st, 2006. 2. All Language submissions agreed to by the parties prior to the date hereof shall be incorporated, as set out in Appendix "A" attached hereto. 3. The Annual Return Sick Leave Plan agreed to by the parties prior to the date hereof shall be incorporated, as set out in Appendix "B" attached hereto. 4. Wage grid - Appendix "c" attached hereto. 5. The Municipality agrees to recommend to Council the addition of up to 4 additional suppression staff in the 2004 budget. 6. Article 9.01 - Hours of Work - add: "Regular hours of work for Prevention staff under the current shift system shall be 10 hours per day, 4 days per week, for a total of 40 hours per week." Page # 2 7. Article 10.03 - Training- add: "Corporation required training, as determined by the Corporation and excluding Fire College courses, shall be paid at time and a half." 8. New Article 14.0Hb) - Meetings: Meetings will be scheduled and compensated according to the following: 1. Municipality called or Mutually agreed to meetings: scheduled when one (I) employee on shift, two (2) members paid at time and a half (11/2), with no minimum hour constraint. 2. Joint Negotiation Meetings: maximum of three (3) Association members plus Association President to be paid at straight time, with no maximum. 3. Grievance Meetings requested by the Association is without compensation. 9. Article 14.04 - Sick Leave: add" Paragraph (a) through (f) only apply to Firefighters hired before January I't, 2004. Existing employees have the option to remain on the existing sick leave plan or may elect to participate in the Annual Return Sick Leave Plan. Those employees opting to switch plans may only do so once in their careers. (Article 14.05). This article will be included in the Collective Agreement under the appropriate sick leave article. add: Note: It is agreed that firefighters will not be pressured to choose one plan over another. It is further agreed that there will be no pressure in future negotiations to change from choice of Sick Leave Options." 10. Article 14.04 fbl- add: "A sick leave day for Prevention staff will be calculated at the rate of 10 hours in accordance with their schedule." 11. Articles 14.05 through 14.08 will be re-numbered Articles 14.07 to 14.10 respectively. 12. New Article 14.05 -All firefighters hired after January 1st, 2004, who may elect within 60 days of hire to be covered by either of the following provisions: New Article 14.05 - The Annual Return Sick Leave Plan >>>See Appendix "B" New Article 14.06 - Municipal funded Short Term Disabilitv Plan: This article applies to only firefighters hired after January 1 't, 2004 who elect within 60 days of beginning employment to be covered by a short-term disability plan as set out below: 14.06 (a) The provisions of a short-term disability plan, on completion of a 60 day eligibility period, is set out below: Page # 3 (b) Length - 120 Calendar Days (Elimination period for L TD as set by plan provider) (approximately 56 working days) (c) Coverage - 100% wages for the first 5 days of illness per year _ 75% wages for the remaining days. (d) Short term sick leave 100% wage provision will be pro-rated for eligibility based on the date of hire and termination. (e) If an employee is absent more than 56 working days, or LTD plan dictated elimination period, on a continuous and related illness, the short term claim will be automatically referred to the Long Term plan. (f) Application - First day of illness or non-compensable injury (g) Top UP - from 75% to 100% on the sixth (6th) day (i) A maximum of 5 vacation days may be used to top up short term sick leave days, however they are not to be used to extend the short term sick leave claim beyond the 56 working days on anyone claim. (h) No accumulation of unused sick days. (i) If no sick days are used at the end of any calendar year, the employee will receive two (2) day's pay. There will be no pro-ration of the (2) two days. Article 14.08 renumbered Article 14.10 - Educational Courses: add: "Requests for courses to be taken which will have a budgetary impact, must be received by the Chief by October 1st of the year prior to the course being taken." 13. Article 15.01- Vacations- add: "Vacation days are charged at 8.4 hours per day/42 hour per week as per the current practice, for the sole purpose of calculating payroll." Article 15.03- amend as follows: "Vacation scheduling shall be on a seniority basis. Requests must be made prior to December 1 sl of the prior vacation year and seniority shall be applied only within platoon/crew and station. Vacation requests that are not made prior to December 1 sl must be applied before November I st, but seniority only applies to vacation requests made prior to December 1 Sl. Summer vacation allotment shall be distributed using a Prime Time three (3) month schedule, prime time months being June, July and August. Page # 4 Each platoon member will be entitled to a two (2) week vacation in prime time based on seniority. 14. Article l6.02(a) - add: "Observation of Statutory holidays by Fire Prevention Staff and the Training Officer will be on the day it occurs." 15. Article 17.01 fal- amend as follows: "Group life insurance, based on two (2x) salary to a maximum of $175,000. and Accidental Death and Dismemberment (AD&D), based on two (2x) salary to a maximum of $175,000." Add: "Spousal Life Insurance: $20,000 plus $4,000 for each dependent child" Article 17.01 fbl - add:" Coverage for Paramedical services to a maximum of $300 a year per person per specialty upon Doctor referral, as required by the Policy. Paramedical as provided for in the Plan; for example chiropractor, speech pathologist, massage therapist, osteopath, podiatrist, chiropodist, and naturopath." Article 17.01 fcl- amend as follows: "Prescription glasses to a maximum of $300 per person ever two [2] policy years;" "Policy year is dermed as the timeframe set out by the plan providers and it refers to 24 months from the date of use, not calendar years. Article 17.01 f dl- add: " Orthodontic services for dependent children with a fifty (50%) per cent reimbursement to a maximum of $4,000 per lifetime." "Major services with an eighty (80%) per cent reimbursement to a maximum of $1 ,000 per calendar year." Article 17.01 fel- LTD amend as follows: "commencing after 120 days at 70% of salary to a maximum of $5,000 per month to retirement" New Article 17.04 (b) - Retiree Benefits: Life, dental and extended health retirement benefits to age 65 provided: 1. Available from 1 st day of retirement 2. All benefits terminate at age 65, any conversion options available under any plan are the responsibility of the Member to investigate and implement, 3. Employee must have 15 years of vested service 4. Employee must be in good standing* with the Municipality at the time of retirement. 5. Employee must be at least 55 years of age, or; Page # 5 6. Employees who qualify for early unreduced OMERS pension with 15 years of vested services will be eligible for benefits at age 50. * Good Standing is defined as - remains in the employ of the Municipality who is not currently in a litigation proceeding, or involved in a malicious act against the Municipality. Article 17.07 - Mileage - add: Transfers that are considered permanent, including any longer than 30 days duration are not eligible for mileage reimbursement. New Article 17.08 - Canadian Pension Plan - agree to review options available, if legislation changes which allows for increased contributions to CPP at the rate of 2.33%, during the course ofthis agreement. 16. Article 18.01 (a) -Uniforms and EQuioment - amend as follows: "The Corporation shall supply all full-time fire fighters with the necessary uniforms and safety equipment. All full-time fire fighters will be issued a full dress uniform and an all weather jacket that will be replaced on a "as required basis, as well as 3 work shirts, 2 trousers and I pair of safety shoes annually. Current issue will be reviewed with the Association on an annual basis and any changes shall be made after being mutually agreed to by both parties. New employees will receive the full issue as soon as possible following their date of hire." delete: Listing of articles of Uniforms and Equipment. 17. Article 20 - Wages : - amend See Appendix "c" - Wage grid. Summary: Increase First Class Fire Fighter base rate to average of Pickering, Whitby, Oshawa at December 31 st, 2003 - $64,045. Increase to First Class Fire Fighter rate to be set as follows: Effective January 1 st, 2004 - 3.2% Effective January IS', 2005 - 3.2% Effective January 1 st, 2006 - 3.2% Add: Acting Captain reference in Wage grid with notation "while acting in that Capacity" Training Officer referenced in Wage grid. Page # 6 This agreement shaH expire on December 31 st, 2006. Dated at Bowmanville, Ontario this 5th day of February 2004. On Behalf of: On Behalf of: Clarimrton Fire Fil!hter's Association. Local 3139 The Corooration ofthe Municipality of Clarinl!ton C ''') ,caJKS2~ ~ cl!tffJ Bob Mc utcheon, President, Local 3139 Frank Wu, Chief Administrative Officer ~~ Ron Klosinski, Negotiating Chair ~. ~ !j6CT . Marano, egoti ting Chair \ ~ ~v~ Negotiating Team Member Mike Creighton, Negotiating Team ~ Tim Calhoun, Negotiating Team Member Sheila Schweizer Negotiating Team Member Appendix A Language Only Submissions Art 1.01 . Change FDA to FPPA Art 2.02 . Change to" Emergency and Fire Services Department" Art 3.02 . Eliminate all " fourth class probationary firefighter" language and replace with "probationary firefighter" . Add "no reduction in the dispatcher's salary will result upon moving to the probationary firefighter's level" Art 3.03 . Change Clarington Fire Department to "Clarington Emergency and Fire Services" Art 5.01 . Change words "department at" to "departmental" Art 7.02 . Change "provision" to "agreement" Art 7.03 . Change "Deputy Fire Chief' to "Divisional Fire Chiefs" ( in three instances, one in each of the three paragraphs outlining steps 1 and 2) Art 8.01 . Change "Section 7 of the Fire Departments Act, R.S.O. 1990, c.l64 as amended" to" Part IX Section 53 of the Fire Protection and Prevention Act" Art 9.01 . Add "Regular hours of work for Fire Prevention staff under the current shift system shall be 10 hours per day, 4 days per week, for a total of 40 hours per week." Art 9.02 . Change FDA to FPPA Art 11.01 . Change "Clarington Fire Department" to " Clarington Emergency and Fire Services" Art 15.oI . Change "Fire Department" to " Emergency and Fire Services Department" Art 16.05 . Change". . ..in the event of an emergency as defined under the Departments Act" to "....in the event ofa major emergency as defined under the Fire Protection and Prevention Act" Art 17.07 . Change to Article 18 and renumber following and index accordingly Art 18.01 . Correct spelling to fire "retardant" hood Art 18.02 . Change "Clarington Fire Department" to "Clarington Emergency and Fire Services" and delete "( formerly Newcastle Fire Department)" Art 19.01 (d) . Change "Section 6 of the Fire Departments Act, R.S.O. 1970, c. 169 as amended." to "Part IX Section 49 of the Fire Protection and Prevention Act" . Change "The time limits in Section 5.49 shall apply" to "The time limits in Part IX shall apply". . ! COLLECTIVE AGREEMENT FIREFIGHTERS 2004 - 2006 , . THE CLARINGTON FIRE FIGHTER'S ASSOCIATION, LOCAL 3139 2004-2006 INDEX ARTICLE 1 - SCOPE AND RECOGNITION................................................................................................ 1 ARTICLE 2 - MEMBERSHIP AND DUES CHECKOFF .............................................................................1 ARTICLE 3 - PROBATION.............................................................................................................................1 ARTICLE 4 - MANAGEMENT RIGHTS........................................................................................................2 ARTICLE 5 - RULES AND REGULATIONS................................................................................................ 3 ARTICLE 6 - MEDICAL EXAMINATIONS ................................................................................................... 3 ARTICLE 7 - GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE .................................................................................................. 3 ARTICLE 8 - ARBITRATION .........................................................................................................................4 ARTICLE 9 - HOURS OF WORK..................................................................................................................4 ARTICLE 10 - EXTENDED HOURS OF WORK/OVERTIME................................................................... 5 ARTICLE 11 - SENIORITY ............................................................................................................................ 5 ARTICLE 12 - LAYOFF PROCEDURE ........................................................................................................ 5 ARTICLE 13 - PROMOTIONS....................................................................................................................... 6 ARTICLE 14 - LEAVE OF ABSENCE .......................................................................................................... 7 ARTICLE 14.04 - SICK LEAVE PLAN A- EXISTING..............................................................8 ARTICLE 14.05 - SICK LEAVE PLAN B - ANNUAL RETURN SICK LEAVE PLAN......... ...............9 ARTICLE 14.06 - SICK LEAVE PLAN C - MUNICIPAL FUNDED STD PLAN..............................11 ARTICLE 15 - VACATIONS ........................................................................................................,................ 12 ARTICLE 16 - STATUTORY HOLIDAyS...................................................................................................14 ARTICLE 17 - HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS .............................................................................. 14 ARTICLE 17.04(B) - RETIREE BENEFITS.............. .......................................... ............... ...16 ARTICLE 18 -MILEAGE .............................................................................................................................. 17 ARTICLE 19 -UNIFORMS AND EQUiPMENT...... ......... ......... ...... ......... ..................... .........17 ARTICLE 20 - TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE........................................................................................... 18 ARTICLE 21 - WAGES ................................................................................................................................ 19. ARTICLE 22 -INDEMNIFICATION ............................................................................................................. 19 ARTICLE 23 - LATERAL TRANSFER POLICy...................................................................................... 20 ARTICLE 24 - DURATION...... ..................... ...... ............... ......... ...... ............ ............ ........20 MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING dated October 16,1995........................................................22 LETTER OF UNDERSTANDING dated October 16,1995......................................................................23 COLLECTIVE AGREEMENT BETWEEN: The Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington - and - The Ciarington Fire Fighter's Association International Association of Fire Fighters Local 3139 ARTICLE 1 - SCOPE AND RECOGNITION 1.01 The provisions of this Agreement shall apply to all full-time fire fighters of The Municipality of Clarington Emergency and Fire Services, as defined by the Fire Protection and Prevention Act of Ontario, and all members who are covered by the classifications listed under the wage schedule forming part of this agreement. The provisions of this agreement exclude the Chief, two Divisional Chiefs, and their designated secretaries. 1.02 The Corporation will recognize up to three (3) members duly elected or appointed to the Association's bargaining committee and the Association President, as the sole bargaining agent for all full-time fire fighters of The Municipality of Clarington and all members who are covered by the classifications listed under wage schedule of this agreement. The Corporation will deal with this committee in respect to matters which may properly arise from time-to-time during the terms of this Agreement. ARTICLE 2 - MEMBERSHIP AND DUES CHECKOFF 2.01 All full-time fire fighters who are now members of Local 3139 shall remain so and any new full-time fire fighter of the department shall become a member of Local 3139 within thirty (30) days of completion of the probationary period. 2.02 The Corporation shall deduct from the wages of each employee of the Fire Department to whom this Agreement applies, an amount equivalent to the Association dues of a member of the Association and shall remit monthly to the Treasurer all amounts so deducted with a list of names of employees from whom such deductions have been made. Association dues will be deducted on the first regular deduction date of the month following the date of hire of an employee. ARTICLE 3 - PROBATION 3.01 An employee shall be considered on probation until he/she has worked a total of twelve (12) months and during this time, he/she shall have no seniority rights. It is expressly understood by both parties that during this probationary period an 1 employee shall be considered as being employed on a trial basis and may be discharged at any time at the sole discretion of the Corporation. 3.02 One completed year of dispatch service will provide a three (3) months' credit towards a probationary fire fighter's probationary service. Two (2) completed years of dispatch service will equal six (6) months' credit towards a probationary fire fighter's service. Three (3) completed years of dispatch service will equal nine (9) months' credit towards a probationary fire fighter's service. This will apply to existing and future dispatchers. 3.03 Upon successful completion of the probationary period, the employee's name shall be placed on the appropriate seniority list and his/her seniority shall date back to his/her last date of hire as a full-time employee with the Clarington Emergency and Fire Services. ARTICLE 4 - MANAGEMENT RIGHTS 4.01 The Association acknowledges that it is the exclusive function of the Corporation to: 1. Maintain order, discipline and efficiency and to make, alter, and enforce from time-time-time rules and regulations 2. Hire, fire, promote, demote, classify, transfer, suspend or otherwise discipline any fire fighter provided that a claim of discriminatory promotion or a claim that a non-probationary employee has been discharged or disciplined without just cause may be subject to a grievance and dealt with as hereinafter provided; 3. Generally to manage the Fire Department, and, without restricting the generality of the foregoing, to determine the number of personnel required from time-to-time, the standards of performance for all fire fighters, the schedules of operation and the assignment of work, the methods, processes and means of operation, and all other matters concerning the department's operations which are not otherwise specifically set out in this Agreement; 4. The Corporation agrees that these functions shall be exercised in a manner consistent with and subject to the express provisions of this Agreement. 2 ARTICLE 5 - RULES AND REGULATIONS 5.01 It is understood that the Chief of the department may make such general orders and departmental rules as may be desirable or necessary for the care, protection and general efficiency of department at operations and that policies and procedures may be established or determined from time-to-time to assist him/her in his/her duties. 5.02 It is understood that all full-time fire fighters shall be governed by the rules, regulations, and by-laws of the department and the Corporation. ARTICLE 6 - MEDICAL EXAMINATIONS 6.01 All employees appointed for fire fighting duties will be required to undergo such medical examinations or tests at such times as the Chief of the Department may reasonably require. 6.02 (a) The Corporation reserves the right to request a second opinion from a physician who is mutually agreed to by both parties. (b) If the Municipality requests a second opinion, the Corporation will reimburse the employee for medical costs related to the issuance of a doctor's certificate only. ARTICLE 7 - GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE 7.01 The members of Local No. 3139 of the International Association of Fire Fighters shall, from among their members, appoint a Grievance Committee of three (3) employees and shall forthwith notify the Fire Chief and the Chief Administrative Officer of the names of the members of the committee and of any changes made from time-to- time in the membership of the said committee. 7.02 A grievance shall be defined as a written complaint regarding the application or alleged violation of an express term of this agreement or, in the case of an employee who has acquired seniority under this Agreement, a complaint that he has been discharged or disciplined without just cause. All grievances shall bear the signature of the employee and shall state the Article of the Collective Agreement which is alleged to be violated and the remedy sought. 7.03 Step 1 Grievances shall be presented to the Fire Chief, or in his/her absence, to the Divisional Fire Chiefs, within seven (7) calendar days after the 3 circumstances giving rise to the grievance. Any grievance which is not presented in writing within such time need not be accepted or considered by the Fire Chief or Divisional Fire Chiefs. The Fire Chief, or in his/her absence, the Divisional Fire Chiefs, shall respond to the grievance in writing within seven (7) days after the grievance is submitted to him/her. Steo 2 The griever may appeal to the Chief Administrative Officer within seven (7) days of the decision of the Fire Chief or Divisional Fire Chiefs and the Chief Administrative Officer shall respond in writing within fifteen (15) calendar days of the date he has received the written grievance. Failing settlement at this level, the matter may then be referred to Arbitration within seven (7) days of the Chief Administrative Officer's response. 7.04 All members of Local 3139 shall be advised of their right to have a representative of the Executive Board of Local 3139 present at all disciplinary hearings with management after a formal written reprimand has been issued. ARTICLE 8 - ARBITRATION 8.01 Properly constituted grievances which have proceeded through the grievance procedure outlined above may proceed to arbitration as provided by Part IX Section 53 of the Fire Protection and Prevention Act. Written notice of Arbitration shall be forwarded to the other party within thirty (30) calendar days of the decision rendered under Step 2 of the grievance procedure. ARTICLE 9 - HOURS OF WORK 9.01 Regular hours of work for dispatchers and fire fighters under the current shift system shall be on average forty-two (42) hours per week as scheduled by the Chief. Regular hours of work for Fire Prevention staff under the current shift system shall be 10 hours per day, 4 days per week, for a total of 40 hours per week. 9.02 It is understood that the Corporation reserves the right to introduce a shift system in accordance with the provisions of the Fire Protection and Prevention Act at such time as it considers desirable and that, in such event, the regular hours of work would be modified. 9.03 The Corporation will provide a minimum of thirty (30) days' notice prior to implementation of a change of shift schedule except where the shift rescheduling is required as a result of an emergency. 4 9.04 Employees may be permitted to exchange shifts or days off with employees of the same rank with prior approval of the Chief and with the understanding that such an exchange will not affect the efficient operation of the department. ARTICLE 10 - EXTENDED HOURS OF WORK/OVERTIME 10.01 Fire Fighters who are called back to fire fighting duty outside of regular working hours will be paid at the rate of one and one-half times their regular rate of pay times the number of actual hours worked, with a minimum of three hours. 10.02 Overtime will be paid at one and one-half time (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay where the employee continues to work beyond his/her regularly scheduled shift or where the employee is called in to replace a regular full-time fire fighter who is absent from active duty. Employees shall be permitted the option of accumulating time in lieu at the overtime rate as an alternative to taking payment for overtime hours worked. It is understood that the scheduling of accumulated lieu-time is subject to the approval of the Fire Chief or his designate. 10.03 Corporation required training, as determined by the Corporation and excluding Fire College and education courses, shall be paid at time and a half. ARTICLE 11 - SENIORITY 11.01 Seniority shall be defined as the employee's length of continuous service since his/her last date of hire as a full-time employee with the Clarington Emergency and Fire Services. 11.02 Employees shall not accumulate credited service for the purpose of progression through the ranks or classes nor for the purpose of accruing vacation entitlement during periods of absence from active duty which exceed ninety (90) calendar days. ARTICLE 12 - LAYOFF PROCEDURE 12.01 A layoff shall be defined as a reduction in the fire fighter workforce and the layoff shall commence with the fire fighter with the least amount of seniority provided, however, that the more senior fire fighters remaining are able to perform the required work. 12.02 Fire fighters so laid off shall retain, but shall not accrue, their seniority while on layoff for a period of up to one (1) calendar year. Laid off employees will not be entitled to the benefits under this Agreement. 5 12.03 A fire fighter shall be deemed to have resigned his/her employment if he/she fails to report to work within ten (10) days after notice of recall has been issued by registered mail at his/her last known address. 12.04 layoff. In the event of recall, employees shall be recalled in the inverse order of 12.05 Except in the case of an emergency, and except to the extent of the current practice, including current practice as it relates to volunteer firefighters, and except to the extent and to the degree agreed upon by the parties from time to time, no work customarily performed by an employee covered by this agreement shall be performed by any employee or other person not so covered. ARTICLE 13 - PROMOTIONS 13.01 All promotions shall be based on skill, knowledge, ability and physical fitness, but in competition for promotion when these factors are relatively equal as between candidates, preference shall be given to the fire fighter with the greatest se n iority. 13.02 In determining skill, knowledge, ability, physical fitness and competence, consideration shall be given to the results of such written and practical examinations as may be developed and implemented by the Chief or his/her designate. 13.03 Recommendations for promotion of fire fighters shall be based upon an evaluation of the following elements: 1. The results of examinations taken by the fire fighter; fire fighters must obtain a minimum passing mark of sixty-five percent (65%) except that candidate for Captain must obtain a minimum passing mark of seventy- five percent (75%); 2. The reasonable physical fitness of the fire fighter based upon the Canadian Standards for Physical Fitness; 3. The relevant experience and the fire and station record of the fire fighter. 13.04 Every applicant for promotion shall take such written, oral or practical examination as may be required by the Chief of the Department and such examinations shall be based on the Department's Training Manuals and Policies. No salary increase shall be made until such time as the examinations have been successfully passed. 13.05 When a new rank is created, other than those presently covered by the Collective Agreement, notices shall be posted in each fire station setting out the duties of the rank and the salary rate. When such a position is posted, the Association will be given an opportunity to meet with the Administrator and the Chief. 6 13.06 Persons selected for promotion to the position of Captain will be subject to a trial period of six (6) months and during this time his/her performance will be reviewed and assessed by the Corporation. Where the candidate fails to complete the trial period or chooses to return within the trial period, the candidate will return to his/her former classification and any affected employee will also return to his/her prior classification. ARTICLE 14 - LEAVE OF ABSENCE 14.01 Leave for Association Business Up to 3 designated members of the Association will be allowed a total of six (6) days with pay and a further six (6) days without pay in anyone (1) contract year to attend to Fire Association business provided that the Fire Chief is advised of the intended absence at least fourteen (14) days prior to the occasion and is able to adequately staff the department during the proposed absence at no additional cost to the Corporation. 14.01(bl- Meetinas: Meetings will be scheduled and compensated according to the following: 1. Municipality called or Mutually agreed to meetings: scheduled when one (1) employee on shift, two (2) members paid at time and a half (11/2), with no minimum hour constraint. 2. Joint Negotiation Meetings: maximum of three (3) Association members plus Association President to be paid at straight time, with no minimum. 3. Grievance Meetings requested by the Association is without compensation. 14.02 Bereavement Leave An employee shall be granted time off without loss of pay, upon approval of the Chief, for the purpose of attending or making arrangements for the funeral of: (a) an employee's spouse, son or daughter - up to a maximum of five (5) consecutive scheduled working days; (b) an employee's father, mother, father-in-law, mother-in-law, sister or brother - up to a maximum of three (3) consecutive scheduled working days; (c) an employee's grandmother, grandfather. son-in-law, daughter-in-law, sister-in-law, brother-in-law, or grandchild - up to a maximum of two (2) consecutive scheduled working days; 7 (d) an additional two (2) days travelling time, without pay, may be granted by the Chief to permit the employee to attend a funeral of the family that is to be held at a distant point; (e) an employee will only be entitled to bereavement leave where the arrangements or funeral are necessarily conducted on a scheduled working day. 14.03 Jurv and Court Dutv Leaves An employee who is called to jury duty or is subpoenaed as a witness to court on a work related matter will be granted leave of absence without loss of pay for the duration of such duty less any fee paid for the service and subject to the Clerk of the Court certifying the time. The member will however, retain any fee paid to him/her for mileage. Off duty court time shall be paid at the employee's regular hourly rate but not less than two (2) hours. Court time shall be defined as any time spent at court, trial or coroner's inquest proceedings. 14.04 Sick Leave Plan A only applies to Firefighters hired before January 1S\ 2004. Existing employees, at January 1S\ 2004 have the option to remain on Plan A or may elect to participate in Plan B, the Annual Return Sick Leave Plan. Those employees opting to switch plans may only do so once in their careers. PLAN A -Existina Sick Leave Plan at January 1st, 2004 (a) An employee who has completed sixty (60) days of employment will be entitled to one (1) day per month accumulative sick leave retroactive to date of hire at his/her regular rate of pay. Sick leave will accumulate to a maximum of one hundred and eight-two (182) days. (b) A sick leave day will be calculated at the rate of 1/182 shift equivalent (12 hours) effective September 18th, 1992. A sick leave day for Prevention staff will be calculated at the rate of 10 hours in accordance with their schedule. (c) One-half (1/2) of the unused accumulated days, not to exceed one hundred and eighty-two (182) days, will be paid to the employee upon resigning or retiring from employment, subject to the employee having completed five (5) years of continuous service with the Corporation. 8 (d) Employees may use vacation entitlement which may still be due them, while absent because of illness when his/her sick leave pay is exhausted, or on the approval of the Chief, the sick pay shall be interrupted in order that vacation entitlement may be completed before the end of the year. (e) In instances where a member is off sick due to injury or illness and does not have sufficient sick days to his/her credit to fulfill the waiting time for Long Term Disability, such information may be filed with the Chief, and members of Local 3139 will be advised that they may make a voluntary individual contribution in such cases, on the understanding that the decision to contribute is the responsibility of the individual member. A maximum of one (1) day per month of accumulated sick leave, donated by each member, is to be applied to the sick member credit. (f) If an employee dies before retirement, one-half of the unused accumulated days will be paid to his/her beneficiary, up to the maximum allowed by the Municipal Act. All firefighters hired after January 1St, 2004, must elect within 60 days of hire to be covered by either Article 14.05 (The Annual Return Sick Leave Plan - Plan B) or Article 14.06 (Municipal Funded Short Term Disability Plan - Plan C). 14.05 PLAN B . Annual Return Sick Leave Plan (i) Eliaibilitv (a) All existing employees at January 1, 2004 shall have the option of remaining on their previous existing plan per 14.04 Plan A or switching to this Annual Return Plan (Plan B). (b) All existing employees as stated above shall be given a single opportunity to switch plans and must put their request to change in writing to the Fire Chief, copied to Human Resources. All employees hired after January 1, 2004 shall have the opportunity of enrolling in the Annual Return Sick Plan (Plan B) or The Municipal Funded Short Term Disability Sick Leave Plan (Plan C). (c) All employees shall have completed five (5) vested years of continuous service with the Corporation to be eligible for any return for accumulated sick days. 9 (ii) Rate and Rules of Return (a) Employees who have completed sixty (60) days employment will be entitled to one (1) day per month accumulative sick leave, retroactive to date of hire at his/her regular rate of pay. (b) A sick leave day shall be calculated at the rate of 1/182 of the annual salary as it applies to the individual employee. (c) In order to receive the annual return for unused sick days, employees must have forty (40) unused accumulated days in their sick bank. (d) Employees not having the minimum forty (40) days in their bank shall continue to use the portion of unused accumulated days needed to bring them up to the required forty (40) days before being eligible for any return. (e) Employees shall not be permitted to accumulate more than forty (40) unused days in their sick bank after returns are paid, unless those employees are awaiting their five (5) year eligibility date, at which time the excessive days shall be paid out. (f) Having met the criteria for eligibility, each employee shall be paid an amount equal to exactly one-half (1/2) of their unused sick days not required to top up to the 40 day base or contributed to the bereavement fund from the prior calendar year at his/her regular rate of pay on the last day of the year calculated to a lifetime maximum of 91 days. Payment is subject to any statutory deductions that may be appropriate and paid through the Municipal payroll. (g) As soon as possible, upon resigning or retiring from employment, exactly one-half (1/2) of remaining unused base of accumulated (maximum 40) days shall be paid at his/her regular rate of pay on the last day of employment, including those days remaining in the sick bank. Paid out as a retiring allowance as appropriate. (h) Employees may use vacation entitlement which may still be due them, while absent because of illness when his/her sick pay is exhausted, or on 10 the approval of the Chief, the sick pay shall be interrupted in order that vacation entitlement may be completed before the end of the year. (i) In instances where a member is off sick due to injury or illness and does not have sufficient days in his/her sick bank to fulfill the waiting time for Long Term Disability, such information may be filed with the Chief, and members of the Local 3139 will be advised that they may make a voluntary individual contribution in such cases, on the understanding that decision to contribute is the responsibility of the individual member. A maximum of one (1) sick day per month of sick leave, donated by each member, is to be applied to the sick bank of the deficient member. (j) At the end of the Elimination Period in accordance with the L TD plan, all sick leave claims are automatically referred to LTD. (k) If an employee dies before retirement, one-half (1/2) of all unused vested accumulated sick days will be paid to his/her beneficiary as soon as possible, following the members death. 14.06 - PLAN C - Municipal funded Short Term Disabilitv Plan (i) Eliaibilitv - This article applies to only firefighters hired after January 1S\ 2004 who elect within 60 days of beginning employment to be covered by this short- term disability plan as set out below: (a) The provisions of a short-term disability plan, on completion of a 60 day eligibility period, is set out below: (b) Length - 120 Calendar Days (Elimination period for L TO as set by plan provider) (approximately 56 working days) (c) Coverage - 100% wages for the first 5 days of illness per year _ 75% wages for the remaining days to LTD. (d) Short term sick leave 100% wage provision will be pro-rated for eligibility based on the date of hire and termination. (e) If an employee is absent more than 56 working days, or L TD plan dictated elimination period, on a continuous or related illness, the short term claim will be automatically referred to the Long Term plan. 11 (f) Application - First day of illness or non-compensable injury (g) Top UP . from 75% to 100% on the sixth (6th) day 1. A maximum of 5 vacation days may be used to top up short term sick leave days, however they are not to be used to extend the short term sick leave claim beyond the 56 working days on anyone claim. (h) No accumulation of unused sick days. (i) If no sick days are used at the end of any calendar year, the employee will receive two (2) day's pay. There will be no pro-ration of the (2) two days. 14.07 When claiming sick pay, an employee will, if re~uired to do so by the Chief, promptly furnish a Doctor's certificate after the third (3' ) day of illness. The Corporation retains the right to request a Doctor's certificate for less than three (3) days illness if there is reason to believe the use of sick days is questionable. If a Doctor's certificate is requested in these circumstances, the Corporation will pay for the necessary certificate(s). Note: It is agreed that firefighters will not be pressured to choose one plan over another. It is further agreed that there will be no pressure in future negotiations to change from choice of Sick Leave Options 14.08 Parentinq Leave Leave for reasons of maternity or parenting shall be provided in accordance with the terms of the Employment Standards Act and Unemployment Insurance Act. 14.09 Fire Colleqe Employees detailed to attend courses at the Ontario Fire College will be paid $10.00 per day to a maximum of $50.00 per week. 14.10 Educational Courses The Corporation shall pay full course fees to a member who is requested by the Chief, or as requested by the member and approved by the Chief, to attend an educational course(s). Requests for courses to be taken which will have a budgetary impact, must be received by the Chief by October 1st of the year prior to the course being taken. ARTICLE 15 - VACATIONS 12 15.01 Vacation entitlement shall be earned on the basis of employees' accumulated length of continuous service as measured at their anniversary date of employment with the Emergency and Fire Services and in accordance with the following schedule: YEARS OF SERVICE VACATION WITH PAY LENGTH OF 1 year of completed service 2 weeks 4 years or more of completed service 3 weeks 10 years or more of completed service 4 weeks 19 years or more of completed service 5 weeks 25 years or more of completed service 6 weeks Vacation days are charged at 8.4 hours per day/42 hour per week as per the current practice, for the sole purpose of calculating payroll. 15.02 Employees with less than one (1) year of service shall be entitled to accrue vacation entitlement on the basis of one (1) day per month of service, to a maximum of ten (10) working days. No annual vacation may be taken until the employee has successfully completed sixty (60) calendar days of employment. 15.03 (a) Vacation scheduling shall be on a seniority basis. Requests must be made prior to December 1 sl of the prior vacation year and seniority shall be applied only within platoon/crew and station. Vacation requests that are not made prior to December 1st must be applied before November 1st, but seniority only applies to vacation requests made prior to December 1st. Summer vacation allotment shall be distributed using a Prime Time three (3) month schedule, prime time months being June, July and August. Each platoon member will be entitled to a two (2) week vacation in prime time based on seniority. (b) Once each platoon member has had two (2) weeks prime time vacation approved by the Chief, the remaining prime time vacation time will be distributed on a seniority basis providing the vacation request is made prior to December 1sl. Vacations will be approved by the Fire Chief in accordance with adequate staffing of the department. 15.04 In an exceptional circumstance, an employee will be eligible to carry over one (1) week of vacation entitlement to the following year subject to the prior approval of the Corporation. 13 , 15.05 An employee who is admitted to hospital or confined to his/her residence as a result of illness or injury occurring immediately prior to his/her scheduled vacation may have his/her vacation rescheduled. ARTICLE 16 - STATUTORY HOLIDAYS 16.01 The following days are recognized by the Corporation as Statutory Holidays: New Year's Day Victoria Day Civic Holiday Thanksgiving Day Boxing Day Good Friday Easter Monday Canada Day Labour Day Christmas Day Remembrance Day One Floating Holiday and any other holiday proclaimed by the Federal or Provincial Governments. 16.02 (a) In lieu of time off on the above Statutory Holidays, each employee shall be entitled to twelve (12) shifts off with pay. Lieu days are accumulated on a day for day basis; i.e. one (1) lieu day is equal to one (1) full shift off. Observation of Statutory holidays by Fire Prevention Staff and the Training Officer will be on the day it occurs. 16.02 (b) Employees will be able to schedule their lieu days by the first of the month prior to the month they intend to take the lieu day. If accumulated lieu days are not scheduled by October 1st of the calendar year, the Chief will then designate the schedules for which the lieu days shall be taken. 16.03 The time off referred to in Section 16.02 shall be scheduled by the Fire Chief, after consultation with the employee concerned. 16.04 Scheduled lieu days may be cancelled by the Chief in the event of a major emergency as defined under the Fire Protection and Prevention Act and may be rescheduled at a later day in accordance with the normal scheduling practice. ARTICLE 17 - HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS 17.01 The Corporation agrees to pay the full premium cost of the following benefits to employees who have completed sixty (60) days of employment with the Corporation, in accordance with the terms and conditions of the master insurance policies: (a) Group life insurance based on two times (2x) salary to a maximum of $175,000.00 14 (b) Accidental Death and Dismemberment (AD&D) based on two (2x) salary to a maximum of $175,000; (c) Spousal Life Insurance: $20,000 plus $4,000 for each dependent child (d) Extended health benefits, major medical benefits with prescription drug plan and semi-private hospital coverage; Coverage for Paramedical services to a maximum of $300 a year per person per specialty upon Doctor referral, as required by the Policy. Paramedical, as provided for in the plan, includes for example, chiropractor, speech pathologist, massage therapist, osteopath, podiatrist, chiropodist, and naturopath. The parties agree to implement a warehouse maintenance drug purchasing plan and generic drug dispensing unless otherwise directed by a doctor. (e) Prescription glasses to a maximum of $300.00 per person every two (2) . policy* years; * Policy year is defined as the timeframe set out by the plan providers and it refers to 24 months from the date of use, not calendar years. (f) Dental plan equivalent to Blue Cross #9, major restorative, and orthodontic for children. The O.DA Fee Schedule shall be the schedule of the year prior to the current year; Orthodontic services for dependent children with a fifty (50%) per cent reimbursement to a maximum of $4,000 per lifetime. Major services with an eighty (80%) per cent reimbursement to a maximum of $1 ,000 per calendar year; (g) Long Term Disability - commencing after 120 days at 70% of salary to a maximum of $5000.00 per month to retirement. Benefit changes should be effective the first of the month following the date of ratification of the current collective agreement. 17.02 (a) In cases of absence due to illness or injury the Corporation will continue to pay the premium cost of the employee's health and welfare benefits for up to twenty- four (24) months from the first day of absence. 15 (b) The Corporation shall maintain the existing conversion privileges on health and welfare benefits for the duration of the contract in accordance with the provisions of the master insurance plans of the Corporation. 17.03 The parties will participate in the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement Plan as provided by the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement Systems Act. 17.04 (a) The normal retirement age for fire fighters shall be sixty (60) years of age but nothing herein shall prevent an employee from retiring at an earlier age in accordance with the provisions of the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement Systems Act. 17.04 (b) - RETIREE BENEFITS Life, dental and extended health retirement benefits to age 65 provided: 1. Available from 1st day of retirement 2. All benefits terminate at age 65, any conversion options available under any plan are the responsibility of the Member to investigate and implement, 3. Employee must have 15 years of vested service 4. Employee must be in good standing* with the Municipality at the time of retirement. 5. Employee must be at least 55 years of age, or; 6. Employees who qualify for early unreduced OMERS pension with 15 years of vested services will be eligible for benefits at age 50. * Good Standing is defined as - An employee who, is not currently in a litigation proceeding, or involved in a malicious act against the Municipality. 17.05 - WORKPLACE SAFETY AND INSURANCE BOARD (a) An employee prevented from performing his/her regular work with the employer, on account of an occupational accident that is recognized by the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board and is compensable within the meaning of the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, shall receive from the employer the difference between the amount payable by the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board and his/her regular net salary. Such payment shall be charged against and be limited to the amount of accrued sick leave credits. (b) In the event an employee is found not to be entitled to workers' compensation payment, the Corporation will be entitled to full reimbursement of monies paid to the employee by the Corporation by way of deduction of the appropriate amount from the employee's subsequent earnings. 16 17.06 EMPLOYMENT INSURANCE (E. I.) It is agreed that the full employee's portion of any reduction in unemployment insurance commission premiums resulting directly from E.1. approval of the existing indemnity plan is included as part of the improved benefits contained in the Collective Agreement. 17.07 - CANADA PENSION PLAN The Municipality agrees to review the options available, if the legislation changes which allows for increased contributions to CPP at the rate of 2.33%, during the course of this agreement. ARTICLE 18 - MILEAGE 18.01 (a) When an employee uses his/her own vehicle when directed from one fire station to another or for any other fire department or Corporation business, he/she will receive mileage for the distance traveled at the Corporation's prevailing rate. (b) Transfers that are considered permanent, including any longer than 30 days duration are not eligible for mileage reimbursement. ARTICLE 19 - UNIFORMS AND EQUIPMENT 19.01 The Corporation shall supply all full.time fire fighters with the necessary uniforms and safety equipment. All full-time fire fighters will be issued a full dress uniform and an all weather jacket that will be replaced on a "as required basis, as well as 3 work shirts, 2 trousers and 1 pair of safety shoes annually. Current issue will be reviewed with the Association on an annual basis and any changes shall be made after being mutually agreed to by both parties. New employees will receive the full issue as soon as possible following their date of hire. The requested issue, where approved, will be ordered as soon as possible following budget approval. 19.02 A service bar shall be granted to a member for each five (5) year period of employment with the Clarington Emergency and Fire Services. ARTICLE 20 - TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE 20.01 (a) At least ninety days (90) prior to the introduction or implementation of substantial technological change or substantial changes in mechanization affecting employees, the Corporation shall by written notice, furnish the Association with the full information of the planned change or changes. Such prior notice shall contain relevant 17 information respecting the nature and degree of change and date or dates on which the Corporation plans to effect the change; the location or locations involved. (b) Within fifteen (15) days after the foregoing notice has been given, the Corporation shall make disclosure to the Association of the effects of the change or changes to an employee. (c) Following the said disclosure, representatives of the parties shall meet forthwith for the purpose of negotiating with a view to resolving any issues which may concern the employment status of any employee. (d) If agreement has not been reached within fifteen (15) days after disclosure by the Corporation of the effects of the change or changes to any employee, either party may submit any outstanding issue to a Board of Arbitration which shall be constituted in the manner provided for by Part IX, Section 49 of the Fire Protection and Prevention Act, as amended. The time limits provided in Part IX shall apply. The Board of Arbitration shall have full remedial powers to deal with any unresolved issue. (e) No change shall be made in the employment status of any employee consequent upon the introduction or implementation of substantial technological change or substantial changes in mechanization, until either the parties have reached agreement through negotiation, or the Board of Arbitration constituted hereunder has issued its award. (f) The introduction of this Article should not be interpreted as a manning clause. 18 ., . CLASSIFICATION Januarv 1, 2004 Jan uarv 1, 2005 Januarv 1, 2006 FIRE FIGHTER RATES Rate % 3.2% 3.2% 3.2% ~003 Rate 62,500 Captain I FPOfTraining Officer/Acting Captain' 115% 76,009 78,441 80,951 c;'?' .. ',", I ~,> ,. 1 st CLASS FIRE IFPI 100% 66,094 68,209 70,392 ~nd Class FF/ FPI 90% 59,485 61.389 63,353 3rd Class FFI FPI 80% 52,876 54,568 56,314 Probation Fire Finhterl FPI 70% 46,266 47,747 49.275 DISPATCHER RATES 18 Months 73% 48,249 49,793 51,386 12 Months 69% 45,605 47,065 48,571 (; Months 68% 44,944 46,382 47,867 Start 63% 41,639 42,972 44,347 Actina Caotain Rate aoolicable when actina in that caoacitv onlv. ARTICLE 21 - WAGES WAGE GRID FPO - Fire Prevention Officer FPI - Fire Prevention Inspector Evaluations for progression through the classifications will be conducted annually in accordance with the procedures and criteria established in Articles 13.02, 13.03, and 13.04 prior to the employee's anniversary date. (b) Fire fighters who are required by the Chief to perform the duties of a higher rank (that being the rank of Captain or above) for a period of one hour or more shall receive the rate of pay of the next higher classification for all hours so worked. ARTICLE 22 - INDEMNIFICATION 22.01 The Corporation agrees to maintain public liability and errors and omissions insurance coverage for damages and costs and legal expenses in accordance with the prevailing Town policy and to the limits determined from time-to- time by Council and shall include in the definition of insured under said insurance coverage all full-time fire fighters while acting in the course of their employment. The 19 '. . protection provided shall be governed by the terms and conditions of such insurance policy. ARTICLE 23 - LATERAL TRANSFER POLICY 23.01 An employee who has been injured and disabled while engaged in active firefighting duties in the course of employment with the Municipality of Clarington, may request a temporary transfer until he/she is able to return to active firefighting duties. The Municipality shall consider such requests in accordance with its obligations under the Ontario Human Rights Code. It is understood that such a transfer to light duty work and any resulting reassignment shall not result in a wage adjustment for the affected employees. ARTICLE 24 - DURATION 24.01 This Collective Agreement shall remain in force and effect from January 1 s\ 2004 to December 31 st, 2006 and from year-to-year thereafter until replaced by a new Agreement or award; provided however, that either party may terminate this Agreement or indicate an intention to re-negotiate its provisions by providing notice in writing to the opposite party not less than thirty (30) days and not more than forty-five (45) days prior to the 31st of December, in the applicable year. IN WITNESS WHEREOF THE PARTIES HERETO HAVE SET THEIR HANDS AND SEALS THIS 30th DAY OF April ,2004 SIGNED, SEALED AND DELIVERED IN THE PRESENCE OF THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON THE CLARINGTON FIRE FIGHTER'S ASSOCIATION INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF F~a LOCAL 3139 BOB McCUTCHEON, ASSOCIATION PRESIDENT, LOCAL 31:-g ~ RON KLOSINSKI-CHAIRMAN, 3139 NEGOTIATING COMMITTEE 20 ~/ '. . ~'CK~~t~isuRER AND MEMBER OF 3,~ NEGOTIATING C MrlTTEE l I ~ TIM CALHOUN - MEMBER OF 3139 NEGOTIATING COMMITTEE 21 .~ <. MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING dated October 16, 1995 22 , ". . LETTER OF UNDERSTANDING dated October 16, 1995 23