The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutPD-278-90 TOWN OF NEWCASTLE .y COMADJ.GPA t' REPORT File Res. # By-Law # METING: General Purpose and Administration Committee DATE: Monday, September 17, 1990 REPORT # PD-278-90 FILE #, A90/43 - A90-55 inclusive CT. MONITORING OF THE DECISIONS OF THE COMMITTEE OF ADJUSTMENT RECOMMENDATIONS: It is respectfully recommended that the General Purpose and Administration Committee recommend to Council the following: 1. THAT Report PD-278-90 be received; 2 . THAT Council concur with the decisions of the Committee of Adjustment on Applications A90/43 to A90/55 inclusive, save and except A90/47; and 3 . THAT Staff be authorized to appear before the Ontario Municipal Board to defend the decisions of the Committee of Adjustment in the event of an appeal. 1. BACKGROUND: 1. 1 The Committee of Adjustment heard applications on July 5, August 2 and August 30, 1990 . The Committee dealt with a total of thirteen ( 13) applications during the three (3) meetings. Application A90/48 was DENIED as the. Committee did not considered it to be minor in nature; Two (2) applications (A9.0/51 and A90/52) were TABLED to the next available meeting date at which time A90/52 was APPROVED and A51/90 was TABLED again at the request of the applicant. The balance of the applications were all APPROVED as applied for save and except application A90/47 . . . .2 REPORT NO. : PD-278-90 PAGE 2 1.2 Application A90/47 was APPROVED by the Committee subject to conditions. The applicants for A90/47 did not believe the Committee dealt with the application as filed and have APPEALED the decision of the Committee to the Ontario Municipal Board. The application proposed to construct a second dwelling on a lot having 15 . 8 Ha instead of the required 20 . 0 Ha. The Committee approved the application subject to the existing seasonal dwelling use ceasing to continue upon completion of the new dwelling (becomes inhabited) . Staff would concur with the applicant's comments and cannot support the Committee's decision and as a result will not appear before the Ontario Municipal Board to defend the Committee's decision. 1.3 Staff have reviewed the balance of the Committee's decisions and are satisfied that the decisions conform to the general intent of the Official Plan and the Zoning By-law and that the variances sought are minor in nature. I 1.4 Council 's concurrence with the Committee of Adjustment decisions is required in order to afford Staff's official status before the Ontario Municipal Board in the event of appeal of the decisions of the Committee of Adjustment. i Respectfully submitted, Recommended for presentation to the Committee Franklin Wu, M.C.I .P. L'awrenc. Kotseff Director of Planning Chief A inistrative and Development Offic�r CP*FW*jip *Attach 6 September 1990 --------------------------- --------------------------- 9/05/90 C OF A MONTHLY REPORT Page 1 --------------------------- --------------------------- FILE NUMBER A90/043 LOCATION TWNSHP BOWMAN APPLICANT NAME : EDMONDSON HAROLD OWNERS ADDRESS : ROLL NUMBER : 020100095000000 STREET 00039 DUKE ST AGENT AGENT ADDRESS: ZONING : R1 LEGAL DESCRIPTION : PLAN GRANT BLK 14 PT LOT 2 APPLICATION DATE : 6/05/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 8/04/90 HEARING DATE 7/05/90 REASON FOR DECISION : THAT AS THE VARIANCE IS CONSIDERED TO BE MINOR IN NATURE AND IN KEEPING WITH THE INTENT OF THE OP AND BYLAW THE APPLICATION BE APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR. MINOR VARIANCE : EXEMPTION OR PARTIAL EXEMPTION FROM THE PROVISIONS OF ZONING BY-LAW 84-63 TO ALLOW THE APPLICANT TO CONSTRUCT AN ACCESSORY BUILDING WHICH WOULD EXCEED THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE REQUIRE- MENT OF 40% OF THE MAIN BUILDING TOTAL FLOOR AREA ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/044 LOCATION : L28C003 TWNSHP : DARLING APPLICANT NAME : WM. KONOPACKI OWNERS ADDRESS : ROLL NUMBER : 010090167000000 STREET 3100 COURTICE ROAD AGENT AGENT ADDRESS: ZONING : R1 LEGAL DESCRIPTION : PLAN 632 LOT 25 APPLICATION DATE : 6/05/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 8/04/90 HEARING DATE 7/05/90 REASON FOR DECISION : THAT VARIANCE IS MINOR THE APPLICATION BE APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR PROVIDED THAT THE EXISTING 9 X 12 ACCESSORY STRUCTURE BE REMOVED. MINOR VARIANCE : THE APPLICANT TO CONSTRUCT AN ACCESSORY BUILDING WHICH WOULD EXCEED THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE REQUIREMENT OF 40% OF THE MAIN BUILDING TOTAL FLOOR AREA ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- �� / cl 9/05/90 C OF A MONTHLY REPORT Page 2 --------------------------- --------------------------- ******************************************************************************* FILE NUMBER : A90/045 LOCATION : L35C002 TWNSHP DARLING APPLICANT NAME : FOLEY JOHN OWNERS ADDRESS : ROLL NUMBER : 010070189000000 STREET 00021 TOWNLINE RD S AGENT S . MASTRANGELO AGENT ADDRESS: 1920 STEPHENSON RD. N. , OSHAWA ZONING : R1 LEGAL DESCRIPTION : PLAN IOM796 LOT 14 APPLICATION DATE : 6/05/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 8/04/90 HEARING DATE 7/05/90 REASON FOR DECISION : VARIANCE IS MINOR THE APPLICATION BE APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR MINOR VARIANCE : THE APPLICANT TO CONSTRUCT A DUPLEX ON A LOT HAVING A FRONTAGE OF 18 .41M (60 .4 FT) INSTEAD OF THE REQUIRED 20M (65 . 6 FT. ) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/046 LOCATION : L33C002 TWNSHP : DARLING APPLICANT NAME : TONNO RUBY IN TRUST OWNERS ADDRESS : 0650 KING ST. E. SUITE 215 OSHAWA ROLL NUMBER : 010060139000000 STREET 01531 NASH RD AGENT D.G. BIDDLE & ASSOCIATES LTD. AGENT ADDRESS: 096 KING ST. E. , OSHAWA ZONING : R1 LEGAL DESCRIPTION : NOW RP 1OR3630 APPLICATION DATE : 6/15/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 8/04/90 HEARING DATE 7/05/90 REASON FOR DECISION : THAT AS THE VARIANCE IS MINOR AND IN KEEPING WITH THE O.P. AND ZONING BY-LAW THE APPLICATION BE APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR MINOR VARIANCE : THE APPLICANT TO CONSTRUCT A DWELLING ON A LOT HAVING AN EXTERIOR SIDE YARD OF 4. OM (13 . 1 FT. ) , MINIMUM REQUIRED 6 . OM ( 19 . 7 FT. ) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ") 99 --------------------------- --------------------------- 9/06/90 II C OF A MONTHLY REPORT II Page 3 --------------------------- --------------------------- FILE NUMBER A90/047 LOCATION : L21C005 TWNSHP CLARKE APPLICANT NAME : BOURKE JAMES JOSEPH OWNERS ADDRESS : 1205 WILSON RD. N. OSHAWA L1G 7T2 ROLL NUMBER : 030050086000000 STREET JEWELL RD. AGENT AGENT ADDRESS: ZONING : A LEGAL DESCRIPTION : CON 5 S N PT LOT 21 APPLICATION DATE : 7/04/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 9/01/90 HEARING DATE 8/02/90 REASON FOR DECISION : APPLICATION FOR MINOR VARIANCE BE GRANTED CONDITIONAL UPON THE SEASONAL DWELLING USE CEASING TO CONTINUE UPON COMPLETION (BECOMES INHABITED) OF THE NEW DWELLING TO THE NORTH. DECISION APPEALED MINOR VARIANCE : THE APPLICANT TO CONSTRUCT A SECOND DWELLING ON A LOT HAVING AN AREA OF 39 ACRES ( 15 . 8 HA) , MINIMUM REQUIRED 50 ACRES (20 HA) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/048 LOCATION : L29C002 TWNSHP : DARLING APPLICANT NAME : KIDDICORP INVESTMENTS LTD OWNERS ADDRESS : 1748 BASELINE RD. , BOWMANVILLE ROLL NUMBER : 010050178000000 STREET : HWY 2 AGENT : D.G. BIDDLE & ASSOC. LTD. AGENT ADDRESS: 96 KING ST. E . , OSHAWA, ONT. ZONING : D-G LEGAL DESCRIPTION : NOW RP 1OR2447 PART 7 APPLICATION DATE : 7/08/90 DECISION : DENIED APPEAL DATE : 9/01/90 HEARING DATE 8/02/90 REASON FOR DECISION : THAT THE APPLICATION IS DEEMED NOT TO BE MINOR IN NATURE. DECISION WENT TO A VOTE WHERE THE MOTION WAS LOST. TIE VOTE MINOR VARIANCE : THE APPLICANT IS SEEKING RELIEF FROM THE TOWN'S ZONING BYLAW IN ORDER TO CONSTRUCT A TOWNHOUSE COMPLEX HAVING A O . OM SET BACK FROM THE "EP" ZONE AS OPPOSED TO THE REQUIRED 3 . OM SETBACK ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 599 Ul --------------------------- --------------------------- 9/05/90 C OF A MONTHLY REPORT " Page 4 --------------------------- --------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/049 LOCATION : L13CO02 TWNSHP BOWMANV APPLICANT NAME : HUXTER RUBY VIOLET OWNERS ADDRESS : 60 JACKMAN RD. , BOWMANVILLE ROLL NUMBER : 020010140000000 STREET 00060 JACKMAN RD AGENT AGENT ADDRESS: ZONING : R LEGAL DESCRIPTION : CON 2 PT LOT 13 APPLICATION DATE : 7/17/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 9/01/90 HEARING DATE 8/02/90 REASON FOR DECISION : THE APPLICATION FOR MINOR VARIANCE IS DEEMED MINOR IN NATURE AND KEEPING WITHIN THE INTENT OF THE ZONING BY-LAW AND OFFICIAL PLAN, THE VARIANCE BE APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR. MINOR VARIANCE : THE APPLICANT TO CONSTRUCT AN ACCESSORY BUILDING WHICH WOULD EXCEED THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE REQUIREMENT OF 40% OF THE MAIN BUILDING TOTAL FLOOR AREA ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/050 LOCATION : L28CO01 TWNSHP : DARLING APPLICANT NAME TRUSTEES OWNERS ADDRESS R.R. #2, BOWMANVILLE ROLL NUMBER : 010050050000000 STREET RR#2 AGENT GEORGE MOORE AGENT ADDRESS: 9 CHURCH ST. BOWMANVILLE ZONING : A LEGAL DESCRIPTION : NOW RP 1OR2734 PART 1,2 APPLICATION DATE : 7/19/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 9/01/90 HEARING DATE 8/02/90 REASON FOR DECISION : THAT AS THE APPLICATION IS DEEMED TO BE MINOR IN NATURE AND KEEPING WITHIN THE INTENT OF THE ZONING BYLAW AND OFFICIAL PLAN THE APPLICATION BE APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR MINOR VARIANCE : THE APPLICANT TO CONSTRUCT AN ADDITION TO THE CHURCH ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 599 0 '? --------------------------- --------------------------- 9/05/90 C OF A MONTHLY REPORT Page 5 --------------------------- --------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/051 LOCATION : L24CBFC TWNSHP CLARKE APPLICANT NAME : WIGMORE DONNALU OWNERS ADDRESS : 31 ELGIN AVE. , TORONTO, ONT. ROLL NUMBER : 030020026000000 STREET : LAKESHORE RD AGENT : BARRY JONES AGENT ADDRESS: 76 BALDWIN ST. , NEWCASTLE ZONING % A & EP LEGAL DESCRIPTION : CON BF PT LOT 24 APPLICATION DATE : 7/19/90 DECISION : TABLED APPEAL DATE : 9/29/90 HEARING DATE 8/30/90 REASON FOR DECISION : TO ALLOW APPLICANT TO CONTACT G.R.C.A. MINOR VARIANCE : TO PERMIT AN EXTERIOR EXTENSION TO LEGALLY NON-CONFORMING BUILDINGS OR USES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/052 LOCATION : L18C TWNSHP : DARLING APPLICANT NAME : MADSEN KENNETH EARLIN OWNERS ADDRESS : RR6 BOWMANVILLE, ONT. ROLL NUMBER : 010030047000000 STREET MAPLEGROVE RD AGENT AGENT ADDRESS: ZONING : A & RH LEGAL DESCRIPTION : CON 2 PT LOT 18 APPLICATION DATE : 8/02/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 9/29/90 HEARING DATE 8/30/90 REASON FOR DECISION : APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR, DEEMED MINOR IN NATURE AND IN KEEPING WITHIN THE INTENT OF THE O.P. AND ZONING BYLAW MINOR VARIANCE : THE APPLICANT TO LEGALIZE AN EXISTING BARN HAVING A SIDEYARD SETBACK OF 6 . 28M (20. 6 FT. ) MINIMUM REQUIRED 15M (50 FT. ) AND FOR EXEMPTION FROM THE 300M AGRICULTURAL SETBACK ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 599 03 -------------------- --- 9/05/90 ' y C OF A MONTHLY REPORT " Page 6 --------------------------- --------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/053 LOCATION : 31CO03 TWNSHP DARLING APPLICANT NAME : DOWSETT GAIL ELIZABETH OWNERS ADDRESS : 29 ALDERBROOK DR. , BOWMANVILLE ROLL NUMBER : 010100040640000 STREET 00029 ALDERBROOK DR AGENT AGENT ADDRESS: ZONING : R1 LEGAL DESCRIPTION : PLAN 1OM783 LOT 87 APPLICATION DATE : 8/07/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 9/29/90 HEARING DATE 8/30/90 REASON FOR DECISION : APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR, DEEMED MINOR IN NATURE AND KEEPING WITHIN THE INTENT OF THE O.P. AND ZONING BYLAW MINOR VARIANCE : THE APPLICANT TO CONSTRUCT A DECK ON A LOT HAVING A REAR YARD SETBACK OF 5 .5M ( 18 FT. ) , MINIMUM REQUIRED 6 . OM (20 FT. ) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/054 LOCATION : L31CO04 TWNSHP : DARLING APPLICANT NAME : KENTISH JEAN VALERIE OWNERS ADDRESS : BOX 116, OSHAWA, ONT. L1H 7K8 ROLL NUMBER : 010140025000000 STREET 00046 FIRNER ST AGENT AGENT ADDRESS: ZONING : RH LEGAL DESCRIPTION : PLAN 648 PT LOT 21,22 APPLICATION DATE : 8/13/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 9/29/90 HEARING DATE 8/30/90 REASON FOR DECISION : APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR AS IS DEEMED TO BE MINOR IN NATURE AND KEEPING WITHIN THE INTENT OF THE ZONING BYLAW AND THE OP MINOR VARIANCE THE CONVEYANCE OF AN EXISTING LOT HAVING A FRONTAGE OF 21. 5M (70.5 FT. ) , MINIMUM FRONTAGE REQUIRED 30M (98 .4 FT. ) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 599 04 --------------------------- --------------------------- 9/05/90 C OF A MONTHLY REPORT Page 7 --------------------------- --------------------------- FILE NUMBER : A90/055 LOCATION : L31CO04 TWNSHP DARLING APPLICANT NAME : MCGREGOR SHIRLEY ANN OWNERS ADDRESS : R.R. #1, HAMPTON, BOX 43 ROLL NUMBER : 010140024000000 STREET 00042 FIRNER ST AGENT AGENT ADDRESS: ZONING : RH LEGAL DESCRIPTION : PLAN 648 PT LOT 21,22 APPLICATION DATE : 8/13/90 DECISION : APPROVED APPEAL DATE : 9/29/90 HEARING DATE 8/30/90 REASON FOR DECISION APPROVED AS APPLIED FOR AS IS DEEMED TO BE MINOR IN NATURE AND KEEPING WITHIN THE INTENT OF THE BYLAW AND O.P. MINOR VARIANCE : THE CONVEYANCE OF AN EXISTING LOT HAVING A FRONTAGE OF 21.3M (70 FT. ) , MINIMUM FRONTAGE REQUIRED 30M (98.4 FT. ) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 599 OD