Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPDS-033-21Clarington Public Meeting Report If this information is required in an alternate accessible format, please contact the Accessibility Coordinator at 905-623-3379 ext. 2131. Report To: Planning and Development Committee Date of Meeting: June 7, 2021 Report Number: PDS-033-21 Submitted By: Ryan Windle, Director of Planning and Development Services File Number: ZBA2021-0008 Resolution#: PD-185-21 Report Subject: Rezoning application to permit commercial uses on a residential property within the Hamlet of Newtonville Purpose of Report: The purpose of this report is to provide information to the public and Council. It does not constitute, imply, or request any degree of approval. Recommendations: 1. That Report PDS-033-21 be received for information only; 2. That staff receive and consider comments from the public and Council with respect to the above referenced application; and 3. That all interested parties listed in Report PDS-033-21 and any delegations be advised of Council's decision. Municipality of Clarington Report PDS-033-21 Report Overview Page 2 The Municipality is seeking public input on an application to amend the Zoning By-law to establish commercial uses including a general store and an eating establishment within a proposed addition to the existing single detached dwelling on the property located at 4504 Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville. The site plan details will be addressed concurrently through the ongoing Site Plan application. The Zoning By-law Amendment has been deemed complete. 1. Application Details 1.1 Owner/applicant: Darryl Kerswell 1.2 Proposal: Zoning By-law 84-63 Amendment To rezone the lands to permit commercial uses including a general store and an eating establishment within a proposed addition to the existing single detached dwelling. 1.3 Area: 0.1 hectares 1.4 Location: 4504 Highway 2, Newtonville 1.5 Within Built Boundary: Yes 2. Background 2.1 On May 5, 2021, Darryl Kerswell submitted an application to amend the Zoning By-law to permit commercial uses including a general store and an eating establishment within a proposed addition an existing single detached dwelling. On May 17, 2021, the rezoning application was deemed complete. 3. Land Characteristics and Surrounding Uses 3.1 The site is located on the north side of Regional Highway 2, just east of Newtonville Road (Figure 1). There is approximately 19.5 metres of frontage along Regional Highway 2 and the property is 0.1 hectares in size. The site currently has a single detached dwelling and a detached garage. Municipality of Clarington Report PDS-033-21 f� 2 091 14 J i +'1� 24fi3 10 fi O 2h li LU z C►'►.. C _ R 2048 243 p tiC,r ly •�,�. � � .' - '� +r5} }+'fir 4 45Ia d52n I. AA88 "94 ' 280i 4042 #SY6 ' #51# 4516 ' I 4492 488i 4M. r — -1519 �. HILL STREET `► +91i - 1JV Aa�a 4909 4513 } 4499 4505 1 4486 ¢497 4503 44R7 -- ��� � + r 1700 l r t3 Figure 1: Site Location Map z 1 1g ROSE ORES 4� I U Page 3 Municipality of Clarington Page 4 Report PDS-033-21 3.2 The surrounding uses are as follows: North: Single detached residential dwellings East: Single detached residential dwellings South: Durham Regional Highway 2 and single detached residential dwellings West: Existing commercial mixed -use property containing the Newtonville General Store and Cafe 3.3 The Zoning By -Law Amendment has been deemed complete. A corresponding Site Plan Application has been deemed incomplete at this time as Staff await additional materials. 4. Provincial Policy Provincial Policy Statement 4.1 The Provincial Policy Statement (PPS) policies direct growth to settlement areas and promote compact development forms. Planning authorities are to facilitate development of a variety of housing forms and promote residential intensification to achieve efficient development patterns. The definition of `intensification' includes the development of underutilized lots within previously developed areas and infill development among other uses. Recent changes to the PPS policies state that planning authorities shall also consider market demands when evaluating proposals. 4.2 The site is located within the Settlement Area of Newtonville. New development is to use existing infrastructure and public services appropriately, having regard for the site's surroundings. Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe (Growth Plan) 4.3 The Growth Plan is a long-term planning framework that manages growth, mainly within the urban areas of the Greater Golden Horseshoe. It provides policies to encourage complete communities, which includes a diverse mix of land uses, a mix of employment and housing types, high quality public open spaces, and convenient access to local stores and services. The objective is to protect the natural environment and near -urban agricultural lands by making efficient use of existing public infrastructure and encouraging compact development within the already built-up areas of the Municipality. 4.4 The site is located within the Settlement Area of Newtonville. The policies within the Growth Plan encourage complete communities that offer an appropriate mix of employment opportunities, local stores, and different services. Municipality of Clarington Report PDS-033-21 The Greenbelt Plan Page 5 4.5 The Greenbelt Plan identifies where urbanization should and should not occur in order to provide permanent protection to the agricultural land base and the ecological and hydrological features, areas and functions occurring on this landscape. Settlement Areas, identified as Towns/Villages and Hamlets, are areas identified for development. 4.6 This site is located within the Settlement Area of Newtonville. The Greenbelt Plan policies support a strong rural economy by allowing for commercial uses needed by the current and future population within the Settlement Areas of the Greenbelt. 5. Official Plans Durham Region Official Plan 5.1 The Durham Region Official Plan designates the subject lands as "Hamlet". Hamlets shall be the predominant location for residential and social, commercial and employment development serving the needs of the surrounding rural area. Clarington Official Plan 5.2 The Clarington Official Plan designates the subject lands as "Hamlet". The policies permit, in addition to residential uses, other uses such as general stores provided the use is compatible with the current surrounding uses and does not detract from the character of the hamlet. 6. Zoning By-law 6.1 The site is zoned "Residential Hamlet (RH)" which does not permit the proposed use of a commercial establishment. The Zoning By-law amendment application is seeking to permit limited commercial uses (retail and restaurant) on the subject property. 7. Public Notice and Submissions 7.1 On May 18, 2021, public notice was mailed to each landowner within 120 metres of the subject lands. In addition, a Public Notice sign was installed on the property. 7.2 At the time of writing this report, Staff had received one written piece of correspondence supporting the rezoning application. Attachment 1 provides a detailed collection of the submitted support. Generally, the support revolved around the proposal to provide an accessible commercial space within the Hamlet of Newtonville. Municipality of Clarington Report PDS-033-21 Page 6 7.3 At the time of writing this report, Staff had received 66 written pieces of correspondence objecting to the rezoning application. Attachment 1 provides a detailed collection of the submitted objections. Generally, the concerns from the public are as follows: • Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; • Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; • Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; • Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; • Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; • Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intend of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan; • Adverse effects on surrounding properties; • Limited parking, accessibility, and safety of loading spaces in right of way; • Overflow of parking onto existing commercial property and not meeting parking requirements; • Lack of parking causing traffic issues and potential for accidents; and • Concerns with two convenience stores side by side. 7.4 Comments received from the public at the Public Meeting and during the review of the application will be considered and included in a future report. 8. Agency and Departmental Comments 8.1 At the time of writing this report, the applications have not been circulated to the applicable commenting agencies as Staff are awaiting the submission of a complete Site Plan Application. At the time a complete Site Plan Application is received, Staff will circulate the applications concurrently to the appropriate internal and external agencies. 9. Discussion 9.1 As detailed in Section 7 of this report, at the time of writing this report, staff had received 67 written pieces of correspondence regarding this proposal. 66 in objection and one in support. The comments are detailed in Attachment 1. 9.2 At this time, the corresponding Site Plan Application has not been deemed complete. As a result, Staff are not satisfied that the site is appropriate for the proposed uses. Until such time that a complete Site Plan Application has been received and circulated for comments, it is premature to proceed with a recommendation report to Council. Municipality of Clarington Report PDS-033-21 Page 7 9.3 Staff will continue to review the application. Comments from external Agencies and other Departments, along with concerns from the public, will be addressed in a subsequent report. 10. Concurrence Not Applicable. 11. Conclusion The purpose of this report is to provide background information on the proposal to amend the Zoning By-law for the Public Meeting under the Planning Act. It is recommended that staff continue to review and process the application and prepare a subsequent report for Council's consideration. Comments received at this public meeting will be considered and included in the future report. Staff Contacts: Amanda Tapp, Planner II, 905-623-3379 ext. 2427 or atapp _clarington.net Carlos Salazar, Manager, 905-623-3379 ext. 2409 or csalazar(c�clarington.net Attachments: Attachment 1 — Comment Summary Table Interested Parties: List of Interested Parties available from Department. Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object 1 Frederick Menezes Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 2 Joseph Menezes Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 3 Jus Rolle Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 18, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 4 Preston Joseph Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 5 Sara Bachan- Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X Thomas Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following May 19, 2021 reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 6 Serena Rolle Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 18, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 7 Stella Menezes Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 8 Todd Barrett Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 18, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 9 Samantha Joseph Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 10 Dora Lassalle Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 11 Rizmina Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X Samarasekera Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following May 19, 2021 reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 12 Jennifer Alvarado Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 13 Amanda Cilla Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object 14 John Lewis Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 15 Cassandra Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X Sheppard Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following May 19, 2021 reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 16 Sandra Davis -Cyril Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 17 Melissa Menezes Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 18 Franceska Medina Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 19 Sabrina Coultis Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 20 Megan Ratcliffe Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 21 Rebecca Lovelace Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 22 Mark Lathangue Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 19, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 23 Jamie Lunan-King Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 24 Cheryl Boe Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 25 Tanya Gonzalez Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 26 Domenique Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X Gibson Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following May 20, 2021 reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object 27 Krystal Menezes Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 28 Maira Jacob Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 29 Ivin Benedit Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 30 Kathleen Nicoll Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 21, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 31 Daniel Melendez Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 21, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 32 Jacqueline Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X Melendez Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following May 21, 2021 reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 33 Irene Quon Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 21, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 34 Kaiser Thomas Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 35 Robert Gibson Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 36 KB Paulino Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 37 Unknown Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 38 Unknown Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 39 Jomo Richardson Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object 40 Edwin Berroa Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 41 Geri -Lee Chung Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 42 Lisa Rolle -Burch Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 43 Mellinda Pinto Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 44 Lisa Scarogni Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 45 Fay Goveas Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 46 Michelle Hardy Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 47 Daphne Benedit Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 48 Raphael Menezes Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 49 Jose Reynoso Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 50 Ken Payne Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 51 Cheryl Nobile Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 52 Ti Long Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object 53 Dbey 1321 Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 54 Maisie Menezes Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 20, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 55 Frank and Anetta Letter in objection from the new tenants of the existing Newtonville X Hill General Store located at 2053 Newtonville Road, Clarington. May 21, 2021 Email Having two convenience stores side by side will create problems for both the community and our business; • The subject property does not meet commercial parking requirements .Potential that their parking will overflow onto existing commercial property; • This lack of parking can cause traffic issues and an increased potential for accidents. 56 Samantha Smith Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 21, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object 57 Crystal Martinez Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 21, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 58 Sonja Johnson Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 21, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 59 Danielle Kane Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 21, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: d a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 60 Ani Nersessian Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 21, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 61 Richard Mazar Retained by Artgrow Inc. Concerned about limited parking and X (emailed by Dana accessibility. Safety issue by having a loading space on the road Kunath; letter on allowance. Having two convenience stores located side by side in a small behalf of Artgrow community like Newtonville is not appropriate. Inc.) May 21, 2021 Email 62 Dedra Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X Cunningham Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following May 21, 2021 reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object 63 Selean Jones Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 23, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 64 Isaiah Primus Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 24, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 65 Howard Barton Letter in support of the rezoning proposal. The new store will have an X May 25, 2021 accessible street level entrance, washroom and parking. This will provide Email services to the existing population in Newtonville. There are several handicap people living in Newtonville. 66 Christine Stewart Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 25, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarin ton Official Plan. 67 Jessica Ennis Correspondence from a neighbouring property owner requesting X May 26, 2021 additional information regarding the proposed location of parking and the Email proposed eating establishment. Expressed concerns with the proposed rezoning and how this may adversely affect the surrounding properties. 68 Karen Pais and Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X Dwayne DeSa Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following May 26, 2021 reasons: Attachment 1 of PDS-032-21 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object 69 Eireni Girgis Concerned about the rezoning application for X May 26, 2021 4504 Highway 2, Newtonville, Ontario file Email number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 70 Melodie Minus Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 26, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 71 Maria Spathis Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 27, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 72 Elizabeth Foley Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 27, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 73 Gord Robinson Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 27, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008. Did not understand the Phone Call need for two stores side by side. Concerns with potential hazards including congestion and parking. 74 Susanne and Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X Michael McEvoy Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008. Comments and May 27, 2021 concerns related to the proposed eating establishment and the potential Email negative impacts on the neighbouring properties (outdoor storage, noise, parking, etc. 75 Debra & Nestor Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X Silveira Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: May 27, 2021 a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; Email b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 76 Deanna Reesor Requested details on how to attend the online meeting. May 27, 2021 Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received Email 77 Dustin Petherick Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 27, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. g) Potential sight lines and safety issue with the location of the loading space. 78 Sharon Graveran Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 27, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received g) Potential sight lines and safety issue with the location of the loading space. 79 Chris Kaunch Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, May 27, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic facade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. g) Potential sight lines and safety issue with the location of the loading space. 80 Stephanie Marino Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 27, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarin ton Official Plan. 81 Antonio Cassone Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 28, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; and e) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarin ton Official Plan. 82 Tessa Trueman Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 28, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. g) Potential sight lines and safety issue with the location of the loading space. 83 Jon Labalestra Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 28, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic facade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. g) Potential sight lines and safety issue with the location of the loading space. 84 Robyn Bakerman Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 30, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 85 Ramon Kumar Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 30, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 86 Lilly Singh Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 30, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarin ton Official Plan. 87 Abhishek Sahi Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 30, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 88 Denise Petherick Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X May 30, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. g) Potential sight lines and safety issue with the location of the loading space. 89 Greg Lewis In opposition to the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, Newtonville, X May 28, 2021 Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion; and b) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses. Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received 90 Mike Gimblett Supportive of the Application. Is registering to speak as a delegate at the X May 31, 2021 Public Meeting. Phone Call 91 Jon Hamilton Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X June 1, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; and e) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 92 Jon Hebert General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X June 1, 2021 community. Email 93 Cinette Ricketts General support for the application. X June 1, 2021 Email 94 Jamie Stewart & General support for the application. X Stephan Lott June 1, 2021 Email Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received 95 Franklin Barrett Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X June 2, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: Email a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 96 Crystal Howell General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X June 2, 2021 community. Email 97 Denika Jones General support for the application. X June 2, 2021 Email 98 John and Lilian General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X Bouma community. June 2, 2021 Email 99. Darryl Kerswell Applicant provided the Municipality with a copy of a Petition with 1292 X June 3, 2021 signatures in support of the proposed rezoning entitled "S.O.S, Save Our Paper Submission Attachment 1A of PDS-032-21 Comments received since finalization of Report PDS-032-21 to June 4, 2021 # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object Store". The petition to show there was community support to rezone the property at 4504 Highway 2 from Residential to Commercial/Residential. 100. Unknown Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, x June 4, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following reasons: E-mail a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Pedestrian hazard as a result of increased traffic with limited space and parking on the subject property; c) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; d) Ability of the site to meet the accessibility standards set by the Province; e) Reduced landscaping that will adversely impact the public realm; and f) Altering the historic fagade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarin ton Official Plan. Attachment 1 B of PDS-032-21 Comments received from June 4, 2021 to June 7 at 3 p.m. # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received 101 Bridget General support for the application. X June 4, 2021 102 Melanie Antaya General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X June 4, 2021 community. Email 103 Morry Weisfeld Concerned about the rezoning application for 4504 Highway 2, X June 6, 2021 Newtonville, Ontario file number ZBA 2021-0008 for the following Email reasons: a) Potential road congestion along Regional Highway 2 in Newtonville; b) Ability for the site to provide sufficient parking for both the commercial and residential uses; c) Altering the historic facade is not in keeping with the intent of developing a heritage district as per the Clarington Official Plan. 104 Lydia Wilson General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X June 6, 2021 community. Email 105 Joanne Gillan General support for the application. Small, local businesses are needed in X June 6, 2021 Clarington. Email 106 Jenna Thompson General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X June 6, 2021 community. Email 107 Mike and Sarah General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X Cowley community. June 6, 2021 Attachment 1 B of PDS-032-21 Comments received from June 4, 2021 to June 7 at 3 p.m. # Name Comment Summary Support Object Date Format Received Email 108 Shelley Allin General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X June 6, 2021 community. Email 109 Hollie Spratley General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X June 7, 2021 community. Email 110 Stephanie General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X Dvernichuk community. June 7, 2021 Email 111 Viviana and General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X Kimberley community. Marinacci June 7, 2021 Email 112 Dianne Phillips General support for Darryl Kerswell and his presence in the Newtonville X June 7, 2021 community. Email 113 Dana Severn General support for the application. X June 6, 2021 Email Attachment 1 B of PDS-032-21 Comments received from June 4, 2021 to June 7 at 3 p.m. # Name Date Format Received Comment Summary Support Object 114 Sandy Wiseman General support for the application. X Colleen Hamilton Liam Wiseman Madeleine Wiseman June 7, 2021 Email 115 Karen Saltmarsh General support for the application. X June 7, 2021 Email