HomeMy WebLinkAboutEGD-004-20Staff Report
If this information is required in an alternate accessible format, please contact the Accessibility
Coordinator at 905-623-3379 ext. 2131.
Report To: General Government Committee
Date of Meeting: March 9, 2020 Report Number: EGD-004-20
Submitted By: Ron Albright, Acting Director of Engineering Services
Reviewed By: Andrew C. Allison, CAO Resolution#: GG-165-20, C-131-20
File Number: R.40.14 By-law Number:
Report Subject: Servicing of Industrial Lands in South Courtice - Courtice Court
Update
Recommendations:
1.That Report EGD-004-20 be received;
2.That Council approve the use of an additional $130,000 (including net HST) from the
Strategic Capital Reserve Fund to pay for the local servicing costs of the two
additional properties that declared they are unable or unwilling to participate in the
servicing costs at this time (revised total amount of $710,000 (incl. net HST));
3.The Mayor and Clerk be authorized to execute the agreement on the Municipality's
behalf;
4.That staff report back on the award of the tendered work pending execution of the
agreement between the Municipality of Clarington and the participating landowners
of Courtice Court and Progress Drive; and
5.That all interested parties listed in Report EGD-004-20 and any delegations be
advised of Council’s decision.
Municipality of Clarington Page 2
Report EGD-004-20
1.Background
1.1 As an update and follow-up to Report EGD-009-19, and resolution #GG-243-19 which
states:
Staff have had the design work completed and tendered. While reviewing the tendered
amount and associated cost sharing arrangement totals with the original participating
landowners, two landowners decided they were not able to participate.
1.2 The total project costs associated with these two additional properties are $150,000
(incl. net HST), bringing the total required amount to fund the non-participating
landowners share to $710,000 (incl. net HST). The tender came in slightly lower than
was estimated providing a $20,000 (incl. net HST) reduction for the original non-
participating lots resulting in a net additional amount of $130,000 (incl. net HST).
1.3 In order to ensure that the terms of the use of this funding are met, namely that the
funds be repaid, staff have requested that the Region of Durham seek approval for
including an Endeavour to Collect clause in the Regional Servicing Agreement with the
Municipality of Clarington for the lots that are not participating. The amount of this
Endeavour to Collect is estimated to be $710,000 (incl. net HST) but will be updated to
reflect the final actual total project costs for the works.
1.4 For the non-participating lots that are not yet developed, there is an additional
opportunity to ensure collection of these funds. The Municipality, when considering a
site plan application from these lands, will make it a condition of the site plan agreement
that servicing costs for water and sanitary sewer associated with that lot are repaid to
Report Overview
This report outlines the basis for recommending the use of additional funding from the
Strategic Capital Reserve Fund to assist the existing landowners and businesses with
sanitary sewer and watermain servicing on Courtice Court. Additional funding has been
requested as two properties have withdrawn their commitment to participate. This economic
development initiative is very important to incenting new development in the area as well as
allowing existing businesses to expand.
Municipality of Clarington Page 3
Report EGD-004-20
the Municipality in full plus interest at the Prime Business Lending Rate as reported by
the Bank of Canada at and from the date of Substantial Completion of the works to the
date of site plan approval.
1.5 Clarington staff have been meeting with the participating landowners over the last 10
months through the completion of the design, approval by the Region of Durham,
tendering and acquiring the necessary Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and
Parks certificate of approval (C of A). During this time, we have developed a cost
sharing agreement with the participating landowners (Attachment 1). Staff are seeking
approval in principle of this agreement from Council, and authorization that the Mayor
and the Clerk be able to execute the agreement on behalf of the Municipality of
Clarington. This request is being moved as part of this report in order to expedite
execution of the agreement, and in turn, preparation of the report to Council for approval
to award the servicing contract to the successful bidder.
2. Next Steps
2.1 Once the agreement is signed by all parties, staff will report back to Council seeking
approval of the award of the contract for the Courtice Court works.
3. Concurrence
This report has been reviewed by the Director of Finance who concurs with the
recommendations.
4. Conclusion
In order to support economic development and the ability for existing businesses to
grow, it is respectfully recommended that the Strategic Capital Reserve Fund be used to
fund the cost share of the additional non-participating lands to provide local sanitary and
water servicing to Courtice Court. All funding will be recovered as per the requirements
of the Strategic Capital Reserve Fund.
Staff Contact: Ron Albright, Assistant Director of Engineering Services, x2302 or
RAlbright@clarington.net
Attachments:
Attachment 1 – Courtice Court Servicing Cost Sharing Agreement
Not Applicable
List of Interested Parties available from Department.
This COST SHARING AGREEMENT made this XX day of XX, 2020
B E T W E E N:
THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON
(the “Municipality”)
- and -
IGRACKI INVESTMENTS INCORPORATED,
9417818 CANADA INC.,
2537613 ONTARIO LIMITED,
MARIA GRACIETE OLIVEIRA,
JOSE OLIVEIRA,
DAVY HOLDINGS INC.,
1073933 ONTARIO LIMITED,
AWC REALTY LTD., and
765345 ONTARIO LIMITED
(collectively the “Participating Owners”)
WHEREAS the Participating Owners are the registered owners of the Participating Lands
depicted on Schedule “A”;
AND WHEREAS the Municipality intends to undertake the Works;
AND WHEREAS each Participating Owner is prepared to fund their Proportional Share
of the Costs;
THE PARTIES agree as follows:
DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATION
1. In this Agreement, including in the Recitals and Definitions:
“Agreement” means this Agreement;
“Costs” means the total actual costs to complete the sanitary sewer and
watermain components of the Works, including the costs of materials, labour,
design, engineering, professional services, inspections, contract and
administration, contingencies, maintenance, and all such other items as
reasonably required;
Attachment 1 to Report EGD-004-20
“Project Area” means the area of Courtice Court and McKnight Road shown on
Schedule “A”;
“Proportional Share” means the fraction of the Costs attributable to a specific
Participating Owner in accordance with the tables included at Schedule “C” of this
Agreement;
“Region” means the Regional Municipality of Durham; and
“Works” means the works described in the Courtice Court Watermain, Sanitary
Sewer, and Road Reconstruction plans attached as Schedule “B” to this
Agreement.
2.References in this Agreement to legislation, including by-laws, shall be deemed to
include the words “as amended, revised, re-enacted and/or consolidated from time
to time and any successor legislation thereto.
GENERAL MATTERS
3.The statements contained in the Recitals, which are to be read as an integral part
of this Agreement, are true and correct. Schedules, section, subsection or clause
numbers referred to herein shall mean schedules, section or subsection or clause
numbers contained in this Agreement unless otherwise specified.
WORKS
4.The Municipality acknowledges and agrees it shall tender and construct the Works
and shall enter into such arrangements as are required by the Region to activate
the sanitary sewer and watermain components of the Works, and to maintain those
components until such time as they are assumed by the Region.
CONTRIBUTION BY THE PARTICIPATING OWNERS
5.Each Participating Owner individually acknowledges and agrees to pay the
Municipality their Proportional Share of the Costs.
6.Prior to the issuance of a purchase order by the Municipality for the
commencement of the Works, each Participating Owner agrees to advance to the
Municipality their Proportional Share of the estimate of the Costs for the sanitary
sewer and watermain components of the Works, as reflected in Schedule “C”.
7.If the Costs exceed the estimates reflected in Schedule “C”, the Participating
Owners shall advance their Proportional Share of the revised Costs within 30 days
of receipt of an invoice from the Municipality showing the revised amounts.
8.If upon completion of the Works, the Costs are less than the estimates reflected in
Schedule “C”, the difference shall be refunded to the Participating owners
according to their Proportional Share.
9.The Municipality agrees that it will use its best efforts to manage and mitigate the
Costs.
10. The Participating Owners acknowledge and agree that the Municipality is only
responsible for the construction or installation of the Works and this Agreement
does not contemplate any additional servicing improvements that may be required
by the Participating Owners.
11. The Participating Owners acknowledge and agree that they are solely responsible
for any fees or charges that may be assessed by the Region as a condition of
service connection with respect to the Works, and they are solely responsible for
any and all sanitary sewer or water billing in relation to their lands.
PERMISSION TO ENTER
12. The Participating Owners each agree to permit the Municipality, its agents or
contractors, to enter upon and have access to their lands as necessary for the
purpose of construction, inspection, or maintenance of the Works.
DEFAULT
13. The Participating Owners acknowledge and agree that until every Participating
Owner’s Proportional Share has been advanced to the Municipality, no
Participating Owner shall be permitted to connect to the Works.
DISPUTE RESOLUTION
14. The Parties shall use their best efforts to settle any disputes arising out of or in
connection with this Agreement or its interpretation. If a Participating Owner shall
choose to challenge any determination made by the Municipality or, if any claim or
dispute shall arise with respect to any of the provisions herein, the Municipality
may require that such claim, matter, or dispute be submitted to and settled by a
single arbitrator pursuant to the provisions of the Arbitration Act, 1991, whose
decision shall be conclusive and binding upon all the Parties, and judgement shall
be rendered thereon, provided, however, that the Participating Owners shall
continue their performance of the terms and conditions of this Agreement before
and during any such arbitration proceeding, and provided further that all costs,
charges, and expenses arising therefrom and in connection therewith shall be
borne by the Party against whom the arbitrator shall decide to rule, or by every
Party to the dispute in the case of a mixed result.
WAIVER
15. The failure of the Municipality at any time to require performance by any
Participating Owner of any obligation under this Agreement shall in no way affect
its right thereafter to enforce such obligation, nor shall the waiver by the
Municipality of the performance of any obligation hereunder be taken or be held to
be a waiver of the performance of the same or any other obligation hereunder at
any later time. The Municipality shall specifically retain its rights at law to enforce
this Agreement.
ADJUSTMENTS TO SCHEDULES
16. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Agreement to the contrary, it is
understood, acknowledged and agreed by the Participating Owners that the
Schedules appended hereto that detail the Works and the Costs are
approximations and they have been inserted only for the purpose of illustrating the
methodology to be employed by the Municipality in determining each Proportional
Share. The information contained in the Schedules is intended to be updated when
more precise information becomes available.
ADMINISTRATION
17. Any notice, demand, acceptance or request required to be given hereunder in
writing, shall be deemed to be given if either personally delivered or mailed by E-
mail, registered mail, postage prepaid, at any time other than during a general
discontinuance of postal services due to a strike, lockout or otherwise, and
addressed to the Municipality or the Participating Owners at the addresses set out
below:
The Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington
40 Temperance Street
Bowmanville, Ontario
L1C 3A6
Attn: Director of Planning Services
Tel: 905-623-3379
Fax: 905-623-6020
Igracki Investments Incorporated
1 Progress St.
Courtice, ON
L1E 2T3
2537613 Ontario Limited
8611 Weston Rd.
Suite 21A
Vaughan, ON
L4L 9P1
Maria Graciete Oliveira
21 Courtice Ct.
Courtice, ON
L1E 2T4
Jose Oliveira
21 Courtice Ct.
Courtice, ON
L1E 2T4
Davy Holdings Inc.
1307 Wharf Rd.
Pickering, ON
L1W 1A5
107933 Ontario Limited
701 Rossland Rd. E.
Suite 370
Whitby, ON
L1N 9K3
AWC Realty Ltd.
60 Courtice Ct.
Courtice, ON
L1E 2T3
765345 Ontario Limited
93 Sunset Trail
North York, ON
M9M 1J7
or such change of address as the applicable Party has by written notification
forwarded to the Municipality and the other Parties.
Any notice shall be deemed to have been given to and received by the Party to
which it is addressed on the date it is personally delivered, or on the fifth (5th)
business day after the mailing thereof, whichever is earlier.
18. This Agreement is binding upon and shall be enforceable by and against the
Parties, their heirs,executors, administrators, successors and assigns.
19. If any provision of this Agreement is determined by a Court of competent
jurisdiction to be illegal or beyond the power, jurisdiction, or capacity of any party
bound hereby, such provision shall be severed from this Agreement and the
remainder of this Agreement shall continue in full force and effect and in such case
the parties shall negotiate in good faith to amend this Agreement in order to
implement the intentions as set out herein. It is agreed and acknowledged by the
parties that each is satisfied as to the jurisdiction of each party to enter into this
Agreement. The parties agree that they shall not question the jurisdiction of any
party to enter into this Agreement nor question the legality of any portion hereof,
nor question the legality of any obligation created hereunder and the parties, their
successors and assigns are and shall be estopped from contending otherwise in
any proceeding before a Court of competent jurisdiction or any administrative
tribunal.
20. This Agreement shall be interpreted under and is governed by the laws of the
Province of Ontario.
21. The Parties shall execute such further documents and cause the doing of such
acts and cause the execution of such further documents as are within their power
as the Parties may reasonably request be done or executed, in order to give full
effect to the provisions of this Agreement.
22. Time shall be of the essence of this Agreement and each of its provisions.
23. This Agreement may be executed in counterparts, each of which when executed
and delivered shall be deemed to be an original, and such counterparts together
shall constitute one and the same Agreement. For the purposes of this Agreement,
the delivery of a facsimile or e-mail copy of the shall be deemed to be a valid
execution and delivery of this Agreement, but the party delivering a facsimile or e-
mail copy shall deliver an original copy of this Agreement as soon as possible after
delivering the facsimile or e-mail copy.
24. Any reference in this Agreement to a person, entity or object in the singular shall
be deemed to include the plural; some apostrophes to indicate the possessive
have been omitted.
LIST OF SCHEDULES
25. The following schedules are attached hereto and form part of this Agreement:
SCHEDULE “A” Project Area Map
SCHEDULE “B” Courtice Court Watermain, Sanitary Sewer, and Road
Reconstruction Plans
SCHEDULE “C” Costs
The Municipality has executed this Agreement by the signature of its duly authorized
signing officer on this ____ day of ____________________, 2020.
THE CORPORATION OF THE
MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON
Per: ______________________
Name:
Director of Planning Services
I have authority to bind the municipal
corporation
Authorized by By-law No.2018-046
Igracki Investments Incorporated has executed this Agreement by the signature(s) of its
duly authorized signing officers on this ____ day of ____________________, 2020.
IGRACKI INVESTMENTS
INCORPORATED
Per: _____________________
Name:
Per: _____________________
Name:
I/we have authority to bind the corporation
9417818 Canada Inc. has executed this Agreement by the signature(s) of its duly
authorized signing officers on this ____ day of ____________________, 2020.
9417818 CANADA INC.
Per: _____________________
Name:
Per: _____________________
Name:
I/we have authority to bind the corporation
2537613 Ontario Limited has executed this Agreement by the signature(s) of its duly
authorized signing officers on this ____ day of ____________________, 2020.
2537613 ONTARIO LIMITED
Per: _____________________
Name:
Per: _____________________
Name:
I/we have authority to bind the corporation
Maria Graciete Oliveira has executed this Agreement on this ____ day of
____________________, 2020.
__________________________
MARIA GRACIETE OLIVEIRA
Jose Oliveira has executed this Agreement on this ____ day of ____________________,
2020.
__________________________
JOSE OLIVEIRA
Davy Holdings Inc. has executed this Agreement by the signature(s) of its duly authorized
signing officers on this ____ day of ____________________, 2020.
DAVY HOLDINGS INC.
Per: _____________________
Name:
Per: _____________________
Name:
I/we have authority to bind the corporation
1073933 Ontario Limited has executed this Agreement by the signature(s) of its duly
authorized signing officers on this ____ day of ____________________, 2020.
1073933 ONTARIO LIMITED
Per: _____________________
Name:
Per: _____________________
Name:
I/we have authority to bind the corporation
AWC Realty Ltd. has executed this Agreement by the signature(s) of its duly authorized
signing officers on this ____ day of ____________________, 2020.
AWC REALTY LTD.
Per: _____________________
Name:
Per: _____________________
Name:
I/we have authority to bind the corporation
765345 Ontario Limited has executed this Agreement by the signature(s) of its duly
authorized signing officers on this ____ day of ____________________, 2020.
765345 ONTARIO LIMITED
Per: _____________________
Name:
Per: _____________________
Name:
I/we have authority to bind the corporation
SCHEDULE “A” – Project Area Map
SCHEDULE “B” – Work Plans
SEE ATTACHED
(NOTE DESIGN DRAWINGS NOT PROVIDED AS PART OF COUNCIL REPORT BUT
WILL FORM PART OF AGREEMENT)
SCHEDULE “C” – Costs