HomeMy WebLinkAbout2006-171
CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON
BY-LAW NO. 2006 - 171
being a by-law to enter into an amending agreement between the Corporation of the
Municipality of Clarington (Clarington), the Corporation of the Municipality of Port Hope
(Port Hope), and Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada as represented by the
Minister of Natural Resources (Canada).
WHEREAS the Agreement for the cleanup and long-term safe management of low-level
radioactive waste between Clarington, Port Hope, and Canada (Legal Agreement) must be
amended in order for the Port Hope Project to proceed;
AND WHEREAS Port Hope Council approved the necessary amendment, being Amendment
No.2, to the Legal Agreement, on July 18th, 2006;
AND WHEREAS the terms of Amendment NO.2 to the Legal Agreement are attached hereto
as Appendix "A";
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT the Council of the Corporation of the
Municipality of Clarington enacts as follows:
1. THAT the Agreement to amend the Legal Agreement between Clarington, Port Hope,
and Canada, being Amendment NO.2 and attached hereto as Appendix "A", is hereby
approved; and
2. THAT the Mayor and Clerk be hereby authorized and directed to sign the said
amending Agreement and any related documentation to carry out the purpose of this
by-law.
BY-LAW read a first time this 11th day of September 2006
BY-LAW read a second time this 11th day of September 2006
BY-LAW read a third time and finally passed this 11th day of September 2006
JOhnCl~~
/~
/
""'"'
i
AN AGREEMENT FOR THE CLEANUP
AND THE LONG-TERM SAFE MANAGEMENT OF
LOW-LEVEL RADIOACTIVE WASTE
SITUATE IN THE TOWN OF PORT HOPE , THE TOWNSHIP OF HOPE
and THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON
AMONG
THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF PORT HOPE,
A Municipal corporation pursuant to the Ontario Municipal Act
(hereinafter referred to as "the Town of Port Hope")
OF THE FIRST PART
THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF HOPE,
A Municipal corporation pursuant to the Ontario Municipal Act
(hereinafter referred to as "the Township of Hope")
OF THE SECOND PART
THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON,
A Municipal corporation pursuant to the Ontario Municipal Act
(hereinafter referred to as "Clarington")
OF THE THIRD PART
AND
i
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN RIGHT OF CANADA
as represented by the Minister of Natural Resources
(hereinafter referred to as "Canada")
OF THE FOURTH PART
*As Amended October 2006
-2-
INTRODUCTION
Since the 1930s, radium and uranium have been processed in the Town of Port
Hope and a byproduct of this activity has been Low-Level Radioactive Waste.
Over these many years, some of the Low-Level Radioactive Waste has been
deposited in the Welcome Waste Management Facility in the Township of Hope, and in
the Port Granby Waste Management Facility in Clarington, two waste management
facilities licenced by the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission as successor to the
Atomic Energy Control Board.
In addition, Low-Level Radioactive Waste has been known to have been
deposited in various locations in the Town of Port Hope.
There is a need to address the cleanup and the better long-term safe
management of this Low-Level Radioactive Waste.
Extensive efforts to relocate the Low-Level Radioactive Waste to a long-term
management Facility outside of the Municipalities have not succeeded.
Clarington, the Town of Port Hope and the Township of Hope have now each
proposed, subject to certain conditions, their own alternative solution to the cleanup and
long-term management of the Low-Level Radioactive Waste located within their
respective Municipalities and have submitted to Canada conceptual designs for new
waste management facilities for each of the Municipalities.
The submissions were intended to present a potential solution to an ongoing
problem and in doing so to strive to minimize the impacts on the communities and the
residents, especially those in the vicinity of a proposed waste management Facility.
Canada accepts that the proposals can form the basis of a long-term solution,
and, in consultation with Municipalities, and with the Municipalities' assistance and
support, is prepared to proceed with the work necessary to submit the matter to the
environmental assessment and regulatory review processes.
i
Upon the completion of the environmental assessment and the regulatory
reviews of the proposals; the concurrence of the relevant Party or the Parties to
continue; and, the acquisition of the sites for the facilities, Canada will proceed with the
cleanup and construction work provided for in this Agreement.
Canada is prepared to mitigate the effects on the Municipalities and the property
owners within the Municipalities of the work to be undertaken within each community.
In order to be able to proceed with the construction of the new facilities, Canada
will have to conclude agreements to acquire the lands for the proposed sites.
I
-3-
Canada will also continue to support, either through the Low-Level Radioactive
Waste Management Office or a successor organisation, an Environmental Monitoring
Program, a Construction Monitoring Program and a Property Compliance Program.
The Parties have negotiated Principles of Understanding which the Parties
initialled on October 6, 2000 and are now desirous of entering into this Agreement.
THEREFORE, in consideration of the covenants hereinafter contained and other good
and valuable consideration, the Parties agree as follows:
ARTICLE 1
INTERPRETATION
1.1 Definitions
In this Agreement, the following terms shall have the meanings set forth
below:
Agreement", this Agreement", the Agreement" means this Agreement, inclusive of
all recitals, Schedules, and every other document specified or referred to in the
Agreement as forming part of this Agreement, and all instruments in writing that by their
terms expressly amend, waive or vary the provisions of this Agreement;
"Atomic Energy of Canada Limited (AECL)" means a corporation continued pursuant to
the Canada Business Corporations Act having its headquarters in Mississauga, Ontario.
"Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission" means the commission created pursuant to the
Nuclear Safety and Control Act, S.C. 1997 C-9 and means the "CNSC".
"Cameco" means a corporation incorporated pursuant to the Canada Business
Corporations Act having its headquarters in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan.
"Cameco Decommissioning Waste" means the Low-Level Radioactive Waste that
comprises approximately 150,000 cubic metres of Cameco-owned materials situate in
the Town of Port Hope at the time of the signing of this Agreement and as more
particularly described in Schedule 1 of this Agreement.
"Cameco Waste - Port Granby" means all the Low-Level Radioactive Waste and the
marginally contaminated soil at the Port Granby Waste Management Facility at the date
of this Agreement.
-4-
"Cameco Waste - Welcome" means all the Low-Level Radioactive Waste and the
marginally contaminated soil at the Welcome Waste Management Facility at the date of
this Agreement.
Cleanup" means the removal and management of Low-Level Radioactive Waste and
any other waste which is specifically identified in this Agreement.
i
"Construction Monitoring Program" means the program operated by the Low-Level
Radioactive Waste Management Office (LLRWMO) under an agreement between
AECL and the Town of Port Hope dated January 11., 1989, for the purpose of
minimizing the spread, during construction activities within the Town of Port Hope, of
soil that is contaminated with Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste, and to minimize
the permeation of radon and radon daughter products from such soil into newly
constructed structures within the Town of Port Hope.
"Decommissioning" means the actions taken to retire the Cameco facilities in the Town
of Port Hope from service and decommissioning includes, inter alia, the dismantling and
removal of all process equipment and buildings and the cleanup of the property on
which facilities were located.
"Eldorado" means Eldorado Nuclear Limited, a Canada corporation having offices in
Ottawa, Ontario, and its corporate predecessors in the Town of Port Hope.
Element" means any of the New Welcome Waste Management Facility, the New Port
Granby Waste Management Facility or the New Town of Port Hope Waste
Management Facility and includes the cleanup, consolidation and site stabilization work
referable to a particular Facility as set out in Schedule 1 and the performance of all of
the obligations provided in this Agreement related thereto.
"Environmental Monitoring Program" means the activities performed by the LLRWMO in
the Town of Port Hope to routinely monitor conditions at background locations and at a
number of specific unlicensed sites known to contain Historic Low-Level Radioactive
Waste.
"Environmental Assessment and Regulatory Review" includes the activities necessary
to the reaching of a required determination and the acquisition of an approval, permit,
licence, or other such authorisation under applicable federal or provincial legislation,
including, without limitation, the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act, S.C. 1992
C-. 37, the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999, S.C. 1999 C-33, and the
Nuclear Safety and Control Act, S.C. 1997 C-9.
"Facility" means a facility designed for the long-term management of Low-Level
Radioactive Waste so that it may be licenced by the CNSC and includes the New
Welcome Waste Management Facility, the New Port Granby Waste Management
Facility nd the New To 0
y Town of Port Hope Waste Management Facility.
Y
-5-
"Federal Operating Agency (FOA)" means an organisation which may be established by
Canada for the purpose of performing some of Canada's obligations pursuant to this
Agreement.
Herein", hereby', hereof", hereunder" and similar expressions, when used in an
Article, shall be understood to relate to the Agreement as a whole and not merely to the
Article in which they appear;
"Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste" means the Low-Level Radioactive Waste other
than Cameco Waste - Port Granby, Cameco Waste - Welcome and Cameco
Decommissioning Waste currently situated in the Town of Port Hope, Clarington or the
Township of Hope for which the original producer cannot reasonably be held
responsible and for which Canada has accepted responsibility.
"Industrial Waste" means the approximately 40,000 cubic metres of non-radioactive
contaminated materials, including soils, found at a number of sites in the Town of Port
Hope as more particularly described in Schedule 1 of this Agreement.
"Low-Level Radioactive Waste" means any of the radioactive waste products resulting
from the processing of radioactive materials in the Town of Port Hope by Eldorado now
situate in the Municipalities, including, but not limited to, chemical process wastes,
contaminated industrial trash, building materials and industrial equipment employed in
the processing activity as well as any soils that have become contaminated with
radioactivity, all of which, for regulatory purposes, do not fall into the category of high-
level radioactive wastes and, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, depending
on the context in which it is used, can refer to Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste,
Cameco Waste — Welcome, Cameco Waste — Port Granby and Cameco
Decommissioning Waste.
Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Office (LLRWMO)" means the division of
AECL responsible, inter alia, for the management of Historic Low-Level Radioactive
Waste in Canada.
"Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Project" means all the work necessary and
incidental to the completion of the design, Environmental Assessment and Regulatory
Review, construction, deposit or consolidation of Waste, closure and ongoing
monitoring of the New Town of Port Hope Low-Level Radioactive Waste Facility, the
New Welcome Waste Management Facility and the New Port Granby Waste
Management Facility and the cleanup work in the Municipalities associated therewith, all
of which is more particularly described in Schedule 1 to this Agreement.
"Municipality" or "Municipalities" mean the Town of Port Hope, the Township of Hope
and the Municipality of Clarington.
-6-
"New Welcome Waste Management Facility" means the activities and structure
contemplated by the conceptual design approach referred to as Conceptual Approach
1-C in the Township of Hope Ad Hoc Committee's report titled Report on Concept
Design Options for a Low-Level Radioactive Waste Storage Mound at the Welcome
Site, dated September 10, 1998, which Report was considered and approved by the
Council of the Township of Hope for further review and discussion with Canada
(Resolution 437/98 dated October 20, 1998).
"New Port Granby Waste Management Facility" means the activities and structure
contemplated by the conceptual design approach referred to as Conceptual Design B,
Option 2 in the Port Granby LLRW Advisory Committee's Report titled Report on
Conceptualization of On-Site Low-Level Radioactive Waste Storage Facility Designs for
the Port Granby WMF dated June 28, 1999 (Report PD-95-99) as received and
approved by the Council of Clarington for referral to Canada (Resolution dated August
30, 1999).
"New Town of Port Hope Waste Management Facility" means the activities and
structure contemplated by the conceptual design approach referred to as Approach 3 in
the Port Hope LLRW Management Policy Review Committee's Report titled Report on
Conceptualization of Low-Level Radioactive Waste Storage Facility Designs in the
Town of Port Hope, dated March 1999, which Report was considered and endorsed by
the Council of the Town of Port Hope for forwarding to Canada for further consideration
(Resolution No. 88/99 dated March 22, 1999).
Port Granby Waste Management Facility" means the 18 hectare radioactive waste
management property in Clarington and occupying parts of Lots 2 and 3, Broken Front
Concession A in the former Township of Clarke, which parts are between Lakeshore
Road and Lake Ontario of which Cameco is the owner and licenced operator.
I
"Property Compliance Program" means activities performed by the LLRWMO at
properties in Port Hope to correct any cases of non-compliance with the criteria set in
1977 by the Federal-Provincial Task Force on Radioactivity or with current federal
regulations administered by the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission.
"Proponent" means proponent as defined in the Canadian Environmental Assessment
Act, S.C. 1992 C-. 37, and includes an applicant in a matter submitted to the CNSC for
its consideration or approval.
"Project" means the Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Project
"Town of Port Hope and Hope" means the combined geographic areas of the Town of
Port Hope and the Township of Hope as they existed on October 6, 2000.
"Waste" means Low-Level Radioactive Waste and Industrial Waste.
I
-7-
Welcome Waste Management Facility" means the 36 hectare radioactive waste
management property in the Township of Hope and occupying parts of Lots 13 and 14
between Marsh Road and Highway 401 of which Cameco is the owner and licenced
operator.
1.2 Geographical Boundaries
Unless otherwise expressly stated, any reference to the Town of Port
Hope, Clarington and the Township of Hope shall refer to the geographical boundaries
as they existed on October 6, 2000.
1.3 Headings
Headings, recitals and the provision of a Table of Contents are inserted
for convenience of reference only and shall not affect the construction or interpretation
of this Agreement.
1.4 References
Unless otherwise expressly stated, reference herein to a Schedule or to
an Article or a Subarticle, paragraph, clause or other subdivision is a reference to such
Schedule to this Agreement or to such Article, Subarticle, paragraph, clause or other
subdivision within this Agreement.
1.5 Statutes and Regulations
Any reference in this Agreement to all or any part of any statute or
regulation shall, unless otherwise expressly stated, be a reference to that statute or
regulation or the relevant part thereof, as amended, substituted, replaced, or re-enacted
from time to time.
1.6 Monetary References
Whenever an amount of money is referred to herein, such amount shall,
unless otherwise expressly stated, be deemed to be Canadian dollars.
1.7 Accounting Terms and Principles
Unless otherwise expressly stated, all accounting terms and principles
applicable to this Agreement shall be interpreted and applied in accordance with
generally accepted accounting principles.
-8-
1.8 Authority
Where reference is made to a direction, response, act, decision,
determination, consent, waiver, approval, notice, request or other communication of any
Party that is required or that may be done, performed or carried out by the Party
pursuant to this Agreement, it may be so done, performed or carried out by such person
or persons as may be authorised by a Party to act in its stead and any such person or
persons or any other persons may be designated from time to time as the Party's
representative by notice to the other Parties to this Agreement in accordance with this
Agreement.
1.9 Governing Law
This Agreement shall be deemed to have been made in the Province of
Ontario and shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws in force in
the Province of Ontario.
1.10 Discretion
Where reference is made to a direction, response, act, decision,
determination, consent, waiver, approval, notice, request or other communication of a
Party, to matters which must be satisfactory to that Party, then, unless otherwise
expressly stated, that matter is to be conducted or carried out at the sole discretion of
the Party acting reasonably.
1.11 Enurement
This Agreement shall be binding upon and shall enure to the benefit of the
Parties hereto and their respective successors and assigns.
1.12 Amendments in Writing j
Except as otherwise expressly provided for in this Agreement, no
amendment, variation or waiver of the provisions of this Agreement shall be effective
unless made in writing and signed by each of the Parties hereto, either individually by
counterpart or collectively. Any amendment,.variation or waiver shall take effect on the
date specified in the amendment, variation or waiver or, if not so specified, on the date
on which the last Party executes and delivers the amendment, variation or waiver.
1.13 No Waiver
Any waiver by any Party of all or any part of any provision, or the breach of
any provision of this Agreement or any other related agreement, shall affect only the
matter specifically identified in the instrument granting the waiver and shall not extend
to any other matter, provision or breach.
-9-
Any waiver by any Party of all or any part of any provision, or the breach of
any provision of this Agreement or any other related agreement, shall extend only to the
Party to whom such waiver is expressly granted and shall not be construed as a waiver
in favour of any other Party in respect of such provision or breach and shall not
prejudice the rights of any other party from insisting upon performance of such
provision.
Unless otherwise expressly stated herein, the failure of any Party to give
notice to the other Party, or to take any other steps in exercising any right in respect of
the breach or nonfulfillment of any provision of this Agreement or any other related
agreement, shall not operate as a release or waiver of that right or as a release of the
other Party from its obligations and liabilities nor shall any single or partial exercise of
any right preclude any other or future exercise of that right or the exercise of any other
right, whether in law or in equity or otherwise.
Unless otherwise expressly stated herein, acceptance by any Party of
payment or performance of any obligation after the breach or nonfulfillment by the other
Party of any provision of this Agreement or any other related agreement shall not
constitute a waiver of the provisions of this Agreement.
1.14 Severabilitv
If any provision of this Agreement shall be held invalid, illegal or
unenforceable, the Parties shall consult and determine whether the other provisions of
the Agreement shall remain in full force and effect and any dispute may be resolved in
accordance with Article 10.
1.15 Number and Gender
Wherever the context so requires, a term used herein importing the
singular number only shall include the plural and vice versa and words importing any
gender shall include all other genders.
1.16 Language
This Agreement is drawn in English at the request of all Parties hereto.
Cette entente est redigee en langue anglaise a la demande de toutes les parties.
1.17 Schedules
The following Schedules are attached to and form part of this Agreement:
Schedule 1 - Description of the Project
Schedule 2 - Cleanup Approval Process and Methodologies
Schedule 3 - Property for the New Town of Port Hope Waste
Management Facility
Schedule 4 - Geographic Scope of the Property Value Protection Program
-10-
Schedule 5 - Map of the Area of Application of the Property Value
Protection Program
Schedule 6 - Terms of Mediation or Arbitration
Schedule 7 - Town of Port Hope Fund
Schedule 8 -Township of Hope Fund
Schedule 9 - Clarington Fund
1.18 Other Documents
Any documents referred to in a Schedule, or otherwise referred to in this
Agreement, shall form part of the Agreement and are incorporated into the Agreement
as if they were fully set forth in the Agreement.
1.19 Priority of Documentation
In the event of conflict or inconsistencies between the provisions of this
Agreement and its Schedules, the order of precedence in descending order shall be as
follows:
- the Schedules attached to the Agreement
- the Articles of the Agreement signed by the Parties
ARTICLE 2
THE WORK PROJECT
2.1 Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Project (Project)
2.1.1 Canada agrees to perform all the work necessary and incidental to the
achievement of the Project, and the Elements thereof, which is more particularly
described in Schedule 1 to this Agreement, in accordance with the terms of this
Agreement and subject to all the applicable federal, provincial and municipal laws.
2.1.2 The work shall be undertaken in the following three phases:
(a) Upon Canada's signature of this Agreement, it shall commence and carry
out, at its expense, the first phase which shall consist of all of the work for,
and necessary and incidental to, the Environmental Assessment and
Regulatory Review of the Project.
(b) Upon the completion of the Environmental Assessment and Regulatory
Review, Canada shall undertake, at its expense, the second phase which
shall consist of all of the work necessary and incidental to the actual
development of the Facilities, the Cleanup in accordance with Schedules
1 and 2, the consolidation of Waste, and the closure of the Facilities.
-11-
(c) Upon the completion of the second phase of the Project, Canada shall, at
its expense, maintain and monitor the Facilities in accordance with the
terms and conditions of the operating licences therefor.
2.2 Timelines
2.2.1 Without intending to fetter in any way the proper undertaking and
completion of the Environmental Assessment and Regulatory Review, the Parties
record their expectation that the first phase will take approximately 5 years from the
signature of this Agreement to complete the Environmental Assessment and Regulatory
Review and agree that they will act in good faith in pursuing this expectation.
2.2.2 The Parties record their expectation that the second phase will take
approximately 3 to 7 years to substantially complete a Facility, depending on the
Facility, from the date on which the CNSC issues a licence for its construction and
agree that they will act in good faith in pursuing this expectation.
2.3 Staginq
2.3.1 Elements of the Project may, for a wide variety of practical reasons,
proceed on different time lines or schedules and it is agreed that when it is appropriate
in order to achieve an Element as soon as.possible, Canada may proceed with
Elements of the Project on varying time lines or schedules.
2.3.2 In the event that any Element is delayed or for some reason halted, it is
the intent of the Parties that the delay shall not interfere with or limit the completion of
any other Element and that Canada shall continue to proceed expeditiously with the
other Elements, unless it is impossible to do so.
2.4 LLRWMO's Programs
2.4.1 The LLRWMO delivers among other things an Environmental Monitoring
Program, Construction Monitoring Program, and Property Compliance Program, and
until Canada establishes an alternate way to deliver these programs, nothing in this
Agreement is intended to derogate from, or replace the ongoing-work of the LLRWMO,
and Canada agrees that it shall continue to honour its commitments to AECL and the
Town of Port Hope regarding the delivery of the work of the LLRWMO. More
specifically, nothing in this Agreement is intended to inhibit or prevent the LLRWMO
continuing with interim cleanup activities in the Town of Port Hope and the temporary
storage of such waste.
-12-
ARTICLE 3
PERFORMANCE CRITERIA
3.1 Criteria for the New Facilities
3.1.1 Any work in Clarington, the Township of Hope or the Town of Port Hope
in regard to the establishment of the New Welcome Waste Management Facility, the
New Port Granby Waste Management Facility or the New Town of Port Hope Waste
Management Facility shall be done so that the Facilities will meet or exceed the
regulatory requirements that apply at the time when the work is undertaken.
3.2. Completion of the Surface of the New Facilities
3.2.1 With respect to the new Facilities in the three Municipalities, Canada shall
construct and operate the Facilities so that save for areas which may be required to be
set aside for water management and monitoring activities and therefore access to which
may have to be restricted, the surface area will be able to be used for active or passive
recreational purposes as provided for in this Agreement.
3.3 Cleanup Criteria
3.3.1 Contemporaneous to the construction of the new Facilities, Canada shall
clean up contaminated sites as follows:
(a) Canada shall clean up properties contaminated with Historic Low-Level
Radioactive Waste so that all such properties will be able to be used for all
current and foreseeable unrestricted uses.
(b) Through the cleanup process, other contaminants may be found
commingled with the Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste, and in such
cases, Canada shall clean up the commingled waste material. In
circumstances in which the other contaminants cease to be commingled
with the Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste, Canada shall not be
obligated to remove the non-commingled other contaminants.
(c) In addition, Canada shall clean up the approximately 40,000 cubic metres
of Industrial Waste on the properties identified in Schedule 1, Part B,
Section 3 (non-radioactive wastes) to this Agreement which cleanup will
meet the applicable Ontario Ministry of Environment regulations and
guidelines as determined by Canada. The aforesaid guidelines will be
determined, in consultation with Port Hope, within approximately two years
from the execution of this Agreement once the wastes in the relevant sites
have been characterized and the volumes determined.
-13-
3.4 Notification Regarding Other Contamination
3.4.1 As a result of Canada's cleanup activities, it is understood that Canada
might identify or encounter contaminants, other than the contaminants which it is
required to clean up pursuant to this Agreement, and in that event the Parties agree that
Canada shall immediately notify the property owner, the appropriate regulatory agency
and the;_Municipality in which the contamination is situate in order that the property
owner may be able to address the matter in a timely manner.
3.4.2 For the purpose of fulfilling the cleanup of Port Hope contemplated by this
Agreement, the Proponent will advise the Canadian Nuclear.Safety Commission staff of
any property owners in Port Hope who resist having their properties cleaned up
pursuant to this Agreement, with a view to having a CNSC inspector inspect the
property and make an order pursuant to section 35 of the Nuclear Safety and Control
Act, S.C. 1997 C-9, if appropriate, and/or take other appropriate action.
ARTICLE 4
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND REGULATORY REVIEWS
i
4.1 Environmental Assessment and Regulatory Review
4.1.1 The Proponent will consult regularly with the Parties throughout the
Environmental Assessment and Regulatory Review until final decisions are reached by
the relevant authorities.
I
4.1.2 The Parties acknowledge that in proceeding through the environmental
assessment until final decisions are reached, the Proponent may identify and assess
alternate ways of carrying out.the Project, or an Element of the Project, that the
Proponent considers to be technically and economically feasible. The Municipalities will
be consulted regarding any such alternate ways and their input will be given full
consideration.
4.1.3 The Proponent will submit documentation related to the environmental
assessment of the Project for final review by the relevant authorities, only after
consulting with, and reflecting any concerns of the Municipalities regarding, among
other issues, alternate ways of carrying out the Project, or an Element of the Project,
which have been considered. The Proponent will not submit a preferred option to
decision makers without consulting with and obtaining the written consent of the
Municipalities to that option.
4.1.4 The Parties agree that a preferred option involving the movement of waste
from the geographic area of any of Clarington, the Town of Port Hope or the Township
of Hope to another of those Municipalities or the selection of an alternative technology
to the above ground storage technology shall require an amendment to the Agreement.
-14-
4.1.5 The Proponent will provide the other Parties with written notice of the
decision of the relevant authorities with regard to the environmental assessment and in
the event that what has been decided upon the completion of the environmental review
is not that which was previously consented to by the Parties pursuant to Article 4.1.3,
unless otherwise agreed in writing, the Parties shall have 60 days to consult, following
which each Party shall have a further 30 days to decide if it does not wish to proceed
with the Project, or an Element of the Project and to notify Canada. In the event that a
Party does not notify Canada, it shall be deemed to have agreed to proceed in
accordance with the decision of the relevant authority.
4.1.6 Upon the Parties decision to proceed with the Project, or an Element of
the Project, Canada will then proceed as expeditiously as possible with the regulatory
review, to be followed by the second phase of the work.
4.2 Dispute Resolution Exception
Article 10 shall not apply to a matter addressed in Article 4.1.
4.3 Costs of Participation
i
4.3 If, in the course of the environmental assessment the Project, or an
Element of the Project, is referred to a review panel, and in the event that a Party after
first consulting with Canada, or the FOA, determines that it should participate as a
party, or otherwise, Canada agrees to reimburse the Party its reasonable costs of doing
so, which costs may include but are not limited to legal costs, costs of preparation and
costs of retaining experts to participate to testify.
ARTICLE 5
i
PROJECT MANAGEMENT
5.1 Federal Operating Agency (FOA)
5.1.1 Canada may establish an FOA, accountable to the Minister of Natural
Resources, and in the event Canada establishes an FOA, Canada may designate the
FOA to act on Canada's behalf to fulfill some of Canada's obligations pursuant to this
Agreement.
5.1.2 Without limiting the generality of Article 5.1.1, Canada may designate the
FOA:
(a) to be the Proponent for the Project for the purposes of the Environmental
Assessment and Regulatory Review; and
i
-15-
(b) to perform all of the cleanup work.
5.1.3 Canada will require the FOA to do the following:
;(a) in all of its work, give full consideration to the health impact of the Project
on the local residents;
(b) develop a protocol for carrying out its work, which protocol shall be in
accordance with the provisions of Schedule 2;
{c) perform its work in accordance with proper construction practices and
shall, to the extent practicable, return any cleanup site and related work
area to their original conditions; and
(d) endeavour, to the extent practicable, to minimize the impact of the work
on the local residents.
5.1.4 Canada will require the FOA, when established, to maintain the principal
Project office within the Town of Port Hope.
i
5.1.5 Pending Canada's establishment of the FOA as provided for in Article
5.1.1, Canada may designate the LLRWMO to act on Canada's behalf as a FOA on an
interim basis and Canada shall impose on the LLRWMO the same requirements
Canada shall impose on the FOA pursuant to this Agreement.
5.1.6 In the event that Canada does not establish a FOA, or does not appoint
the LLRWMO to act as the FOA, Canada shall perform all of the obligations intended to
be performed by the FOA in accordance with the standards set out in this Agreement.
5.2 Communications by the Parties with respect to the Project Management
5.2.1 Given the shared objectives of the Parties, the Parties also share the view
that in order to attain the highest level of success in the completion of the Project, the
Parties must develop and maintain excellent communications and professional working
relationships throughout the life of the Project. The Parties agree to work together and
to take such actions as may be necessary to achieve this objective.
5.2.2 Canada shall forthwith establish a comprehensive communications
program in order to provide information to the public and to receive public input on the
Project. Without limiting the generality of Canada's commitment, the communications
activities set out in Article 5.2.3 shall form part of the communications program.
-16-
5.2.3 Without limiting the generality of Article 5.2.2, the Parties more specifically
agree:
(a) the Town of Port Hope, the Township of Hope and Clarington may each
establish a Community Advisory Committee (CAC) which will be
responsible to the respective municipal councils. Each CAC shall be
organised as decided by the Municipality, with a mandate as established
by the council, in consultation with Canada, and shall report to the council.
(b) Each CAC shall be responsible to maintain, on behalf of the respective
councils, liaison with Canada regarding all aspects of the work being
undertaken for the Project and shall provide public-input on the Project
planning and implementation and to assist the FOA in communicating with
the public.
(c) Canada and the CACs shall meet following the creation of the CACs in
order to establish a mutually satisfactory basis for procedure and establish
a regular schedule of meetings.
i
(d) Canada shall, on an ongoing and timely basis, provide to each CAC,
copies of all studies and reports which Canada has prepared in regard to
the Project, including any monitoring reports on any of the work.
i
(e) Canada and each Municipality and/or each CAC will meet at the start of
each year in order to plan the liaison work for the year and to develop a
budget for each CAC for that year. In the event of unforeseen
circumstances or issues, Canada and each Municipality and/or each CAC
may meet to consider revisions to the budget. Canada agrees to provide
funding to each Municipality to reimburse reasonable expenses of the
CAC provided that the expenses or costs are within the agreed budget.
(f) Each Municipality may at any time, reorganise its CAC, discontinue its
CAC, or directly assume the function of the CAC and shall notify Canada
upon doing so.
(g) If a Municipality decides not to appoint a CAC, it shall perform the
functions of a CAC as set out in clauses (a) to (f) inclusive with all the
necessary changes being made to give effect to the intent of this clause.
5.3 Complaints
5.3.1 Canada shall, as soon as possible following the signing of the Agreement,
in consultation with the CAC or the Municipality, establish and maintain a process to
expeditiously address complaints related to the Project or any Element of the Project.
-17-
5.3.2 Canada shall, as part of the communications program referred to in Article
5.2.2, make information about the complaint process known to the public.
5.3.3 Canada shall also regularly advise the Municipalities of the number and
nature of the complaints submitted to it and notwithstanding Canada's general
obligations, Canada shall, within fifteen days, reply to a request from a Municipality for
information on complaints, including information on the number of complaints, the
nature of the complaints and the status of each complaint.
5.4 Consultation and Cooperation
5.4.1 The Parties shall consult on a regular basis; and, shall cooperate and take
appropriate action necessary to expedite the completion of the Elements of the Project
in accordance with the intent of this Agreement.
5.4.2 The level and methodology for consultation required to effectively consult
will vary during the course of the Project and the Parties will establish a protocol for
consultation.
5.4.3 In order to ensure full consultation, notwithstanding the protocol
established for consultation, any Party may call for a meeting of the Parties within 15
days following the giving of a notice and the Parties shall meet within 15 days to consult
to address the concern or issue raised by the Party calling for the formal meeting to try
to resolve the matter.
i
5.4.4 Without limiting the generality of the Parties agreement to cooperate,
following are examples of what the Parties will do in this regard:
(a) the nomination or dedication of staff to work together to coordinate and
expedite the Project, or any Element of the Project;
(b) the timely provision of information, such as municipal engineering records,
required to facilitate the completion of the Project, or any Element of the
Project;
(c) the provision of reasonable access to municipal lands necessary for the
completion of the Project and the restoration of the lands or equipment to
its pre-entry condition, or any Element of the Project, following reasonable
notice that access is required;
(d) the undertaking of work on municipal lands in compliance with applicable
by-laws and regulations; and
-18-
(e) the expedition of any permits and by-laws Canada may request in order to
undertake the Project, or any Element of the Project in order to comply
with applicable by-laws and regulations.
5.5 Monitoring of Facilities
5.5.1 Canada shall monitor the various phases of the Projects or Elements of
the Project in compliance with the applicable laws and as part of its agreement to
communicate fully with the affected Parties shall provide to the Parties full and timely
information.
5.5.2 Without limiting the generality of the foregoing, Canada will, in
consultation with the affected Municipality, or its CAC, establish and maintain a
monitoring plan for each Facility which plan will be consistent with the conditions of
licence for the Facility. Canada shall regularly provide each Party a copy of the
monitoring reports for the Facility in their respective Municipality forthwith after they
have been filed with the CNSC.
ARTICLE 6 �
PROPERTY ACQUISITIONS FOR FACILITIES
6.1 Town of Port Hope
6.1.1 The New Town of Port Hope Waste Management Facility is to be located
on property within the area of land outlined in Schedule 3 - Property for the New Town
of Port Hope Waste Management Facility.
6.1.2 The Parties entered this Agreement with the following shared
understandings:
(a) by By-Law No. 24-90 passed on October 24, 1990, the Council of The
Corporation of the County of Northumberland adopted a waste
management plan and assumed the waste management powers of,
among others, the Town of Port Hope pursuant to section 209a of the
Ontario Municipal Amendment Act,1989, S.O. 1989, C-43, s.2;
(b) under subsection 209a(15) of the Municipal Amendment Act, 1989, the
effect of the passing of this by-law, inter alia, was to transfer the Town of
Port Hope's right to and in the Highland Drive landfill site to the County of
Northumberland;
(c) in order to acquire ownership of the lands required for the New Town of
Port Hope Waste Management Facility, Canada will have to acquire (1) all
-19-
or part of the Highland Drive landfill site from the County of
Northumberland, (2) certain lands from Atomic Energy of Canada Limited,
(3) certain lands from Cameco, and (4) certain adjoining lands owned by
the Town of Port Hope including part of an unopened road allowance
extending into part of the site required for the New Town of Port Hope
Waste Management Facility; and
(d) to authorize the sale and transfer to-Canada of part of this unopened road
allowance, the Town will have to comply with the procedural and process
provisions of the Ontario Municipal Act which are applicable to the closure
and sale of unopened road allowances. The precise boundaries.of the
lands now owned by the Town of Port Hope which will be required for the
New Town of Port Hope Waste Management Facility cannot be
determined with certainty until the plans for the Facility have been
completed.
6.1.3 Forthwith after this Agreement is executed by the Parties, Canada will
proceed to make agreements with the County of Northumberland and Atomic Energy of
Canada Limited and Cameco to acquire the lands owned by them which are required
for the New Town of Port Hope Waste Management Facility, its construction and its
operation, all on mutually satisfactory terms and conditions to the Parties to the sale
transactions.
6.1.4 In the case of the acquisition of the Highland Drive landfill site by Canada,
the Town of Port Hope shall encourage the County of Northumberland to transfer the
Highland Drive Landfill site to Canada for the New Town of Port Hope Waste
Management Facility.
6.2 Cameco Lands
6.2.1 The New Welcome Waste Management Facility is to be located on
Cameco's property in the Township of Hope.
6.2.2 The New Port Granby Waste Management Facility is to be located on
Cameco's property in Clarington.
i
6.2.3 Canada will forthwith proceed to make an agreement with Cameco which
agreement shall enable Canada to acquire good title to the property necessary for the
proper construction and operation of the two new Facilities on terms satisfactory to
Canada.
6.3 Good Title
6.3.1 For the purpose of this Article, good title shall mean:
-20-
(a) if the land is registered under a registry system, the vendor shall transfer,
grant, convey and assign to Canada, good title which title shall be fee
simple title, satisfactory to the Attorney General of Canada, free and clear
of all reservations, tenancies, encroachments, easements and
encumbrances, including without limitation, all taxes, charges, liens and
rates of every kind.
(b) if the land is registered under a registry system of land titles, the vendor
shall deliver to Canada, good and marketable title, free and clear of all
reservations, tenancies, encroachments, easements and encumbrances,
including without limitation, all taxes, charges, liens and rates of every kind,
satisfactory to the Attorney General of Canada, registered in the name of
Her Majesty the Queen in right of Canada.
(c) provided that with respect to the lands for the New Port Hope Waste
Management Facility, part of the property is a municipal landfill site and is
qualified accordingly.
(d) provided that with respect to the New Port Granby Waste Management
Facility and the New Welcome Waste Management Facility; the property is
a waste management site and the description of good title shall be qualified
to include this use.
6.4 Escrow
i
It is the intent of Canada to negotiate the acquisition of the properties as
soon as practicable so that all of the deeds or transfers may all be held in escrow
pending the satisfactory completion of the Environmental Assessment and Regulatory
Review so that upon that happening, Canada will be able to take title to the properties
and expeditiously proceed with phase two of the Project.
6.5 Canada's Inability to Acquire Property
6.5.1 In the event that Canada:
(a) after proceeding in good faith and extending reasonable effort for a period
of three years commencing on the date of this Agreement to try to
conclude an agreement with a property owner whose property is required
for the construction and operation of any Facility and within such period is
not able to make an agreement to acquire good title to such property, and
as a result is prevented from proceeding with the construction and
operation of the Facility; or,
-21-
(b) having made the agreements referred to in Article 6.5.1 (a) above, is not
able to subsequently acquire the good title to the property as provided for
in the agreements,
the provisions of this Agreement respecting that Facility, except for the provisions of
Article 7 and whichever of Schedules 7, 8 and 9 is applicable to the Municipality in which
the Facility in question is to be located, shall terminate and neither Canada nor the
Municipality in which it was to be located shall have any further obligation under this
Agreement in respect of that Facility, and this Agreement shall be deemed to be
amended to refer only to the Facility or Facilities for the acquisition of which Canada has
been able to conclude an agreement with the property owner or owners concerned
pursuant to this Article.
6.6 Payments in Lieu
6.6.1 Following Canada's acquisition of lands for a Facility, payments in lieu of
taxes will be dealt with in accordance with the Payments in Lieu of Taxes Act, S.C. 2000,
C.8.
ARTICLE 7
HOST COMMUNITY FEE
7.1 Upon the approval of this Agreement by the Treasury Board, Canada's
signature of the Agreement and the appropriation of funds by the Parliament of Canada
for the purposes set out below, Canada agrees, in order that the Municipalities will be
enabled to address, as they see fit impacts of the presence of long-term waste
management Facilities within their communities, to make the following payments:
(a) A payment of Ten Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars to the Town of Port
Hope;
(b) A payment of Ten Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars to the Township of
Hope; and,
(c) A payment of Ten Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars to Clarington.
7.2 For the purposes of Article 7 and Schedules 7, 8 and 9, each of the
payments referred to above may also be referred to as the "Fund" or "Funds" and the
Parties agree that the Funds shall be dealt with in accordance with the additional terms
and conditions as set out in Schedules 7, 8 and 9.
-22-
ARTICLE 8
PROPERTY VALUE PROTECTION PROGRAM
8.1 The efforts to manage the Wastes as provided for in this Agreement creates a risk
of bringing about some financial disadvantage, on an interim basis, to property owners in
the communities, especially those property owners in close proximity to the proposed
Facilities.
8.2 The Parties are desirous of trying to mitigate certain interim economic effects for
the period from the signing of the Agreement through to the time at which the new waste
management Facilities are in a state of long-term surveillance, and consider such costs
to be part of the cost of the Project.
i
8.3 They are desirous of putting an equitable scheme in place, referred to by the
Parties as a "Property Value Protection Program" (PVP Program), which would provide
compensation or"Property Value Protection" (PVP) to property owners especially in
regard to any diminution of property values and the effect that such diminution may have
on mortgage renewals or the sale of the property.
i
8.4 Consequently, Canada will consult with the Municipalities and will develop an
optional PVP Program to protect property owners which will reflect the following
principles: I
1. the PVP Program will be established as soon as possible and not later than
six months after the signature of this Agreement.
2. the PVP Program will compensate property owners in each of the three
Municipalities for financial losses sustained by those property owners as a
result of this Project and relating to: a) any diminution of property value
realized on the sale of property; b) loss of rental income; and, c) mortgage
renewal difficulty.
3. PVP Program will continue in each Municipality until two years after the
date that the relevant Facility in that Municipality reaches a long-term state
of surveillance and monitoring.
4. the geographic area covered by the PVP Program is defined in Schedule 4
to this Agreement.
5. property owners must prove a diminution of their property values from the
day before the relevant day in 11 below.
i
i
-23-
6. in the case of a sale of the property, Canada may refuse to pay
compensation and offer to purchase the property at its undiminished fair
market value.
.7. Canada in consultation with each Municipality shall appoint one or more
independent qualified persons who regularly reside or conduct their
business or profession in one of the three Municipalities as Compensation
Officers whose services will be paid for by Canada.
8. claims for compensation must be made in writing to Canada and address
the factor or factors which are relevant to the claim and include the relevant
day for establishing fair market value.
9. claims must be filed at the office of the FOA in one of the three
Municipalities and a copy of the claim provided forthwith to the
Compensation Officer.
10. all claims for compensation must be accompanied by a letter or written
report of a qualified local realtor or appraiser.
I
11. in establishing diminution of property value, the property owner must first
prove the fair market value of the property on a relevant day such as any of
the following days:
(a) October 5, 2000
i
(b) the day before the date of Canada's signature of this Agreement;
(c) the day before the earliest relevant environmental determination or
regulatory approval for the Facility;
(d) the day before the announcement of the making of an application to
the CNSC for a construction licence for the relevant Facility;
(e) the day before the commencement of construction of a particular
Facility; or
I
(f) the day before the commencement of implementation of a particular
Element of the Project.
12. all claims will be processed as quickly as possible.
13. claims relating to the sale of residential units or mortgage renewals will be
dealt with on an expedited basis such that within 15 business days of the
-24-
filing of the claim, Canada shall endeavour to file a notice with the
Compensation Officer either accepting the Claim or objecting to it.
14. if the expedited claim is accepted, Canada shall either pay the amount
claimed to the property owner within 30 calendar days following the giving
of the claim in exchange for a release executed by the property owner or
shall deliver to the property owner an executed offer to purchase the
property for its undiminished fair market value.
15. where a claim for property value protection is made in respect of a property
for which compensation has been paid previously there will be no double
recovery and any subsequent compensation will take into account any
amount previously paid.
I
16. if the claim is objected to, a Compensation Officer shall arrange a meeting
of the claimant and Canada to mediate, if possible, a resolution of all
issues in a written agreement.
�I
"17. in the case of an expedited claim, the mediation meeting shall be held
within 30 calendar days following the giving of the claim to Canada.
18. if mediation results in agreement, Canada shall pay the amount of
compensation set out in the agreement to the claimant within 15 business
days following the date of the agreement.
19. if mediation does not result in an agreement, a Compensation Officer shall
act as a single arbitrator and determine all issues in accordance with
appropriate standards and rules.
i
20. if the arbitrator awards compensation to the claimant, Canada shall pay
that amount to the claimant within 15 calendar days following the date of
the award.
21 . the costs of mediation and arbitration including the reasonable costs of the
property owner, shall be paid by Canada unless the mediator or arbitrator
decides that the claimant's position was unreasonable.
22. with the consent of the claimant and Canada, a Compensation Officer who
acts as mediator may act as an arbitrator of the issues between the parties.
23. if compensation is paid pursuant to a mediated agreement or an arbitration
award, the payment by Canada shall be made in exchange for an executed
release with respect to the subject claim from the claimant.
-25-
24. if Canada elects to purchase the property of a claimant, similar procedures
shall apply in respect of the determination of the fair market value of the
property in question which shall be the price to be paid by Canada for the
property.
ARTICLE 9
PROTECTION FOR DIMINISHED MUNICIPAL TAX REVENUE
9.1 The efforts to manage Wastes as provided for in this Agreement also
creates,,a risk of bringing about some financial disadvantage, on an interim basis, to the
three Municipalities, in that if assessed property values are reduced, the Municipalities'
tax revenues associated with affected properties could be diminished.
9.2 For the period from the date of Canada's signature of this Agreement until
one year following the date upon which a Facility is licenced for long-term surveillance
and monitoring, Canada will provide compensation to the Municipalities to mitigate
against diminished property tax revenues as a result of the reduction of the assessed
value of properties caused by the Project, or any Element thereof.
9.3 A Municipality may claim compensation and in so doing shall clearly
demonstrate to Canada:
(a) property within the Municipality has been reassessed for tax purposes and
the reassessment has resulted in a reduction in the property taxes paid to
the Municipality by the owners; and
(b) the reduction in the assessment results from the Project, or any Element
thereof.
9.4 The Parties agree that the maximum amount of compensation that Canada
may be required to pay to a Municipality pursuant to this Article for any one year is
limited as follows:
Town of Port Hope - $50,000.00
Township of Hope $15,000.00
Clarington $5,000.00
9.5 For greater certainty, claims shall be restricted to the year to which the
assessment reduction relates.
-26-
ARTICLE 10
DISPUTE RESOLUTION
10.1 Negotiation - Mediation -Arbitration
10.1.1 In the event of a dispute between two or more Parties as to the proper
interpretation of this Agreement, or an issue arising out of the Agreement, the Parties
agree to meet to pursue resolution through negotiation, mediation or arbitration in
accordance with this Article and Schedule 6.
10.1.2 All information exchanged during this meeting or any subsequent dispute
resolution procedure, shall be regarded as "without prejudice" communications for the
purpose of settlement negotiations and shall be treated as confidential by the Parties
and their representatives, unless otherwise required by law.
10.1.3 If a dispute relating to this Agreement arises and the Parties do not resolve
some or all of the dispute through discussions then:
(a) Written notice, containing a request to negotiate, shall be given by either
party to the other(s). This notice shall be given promptly in order to prevent
further damages resulting from delay and shall specify the issues in
dispute.
i
(b) Negotiations shall occur between representatives of the Parties.
(c) If the representatives do not resolve some or all of the issues in dispute
i
within 90 days after notice has been given, then the Parties agree to
attempt to resolve the dispute through mediation, in accordance with the
Terms of Mediation set out in Part A of Schedule 6 to this Agreement.
(d) If the Parties do not resolve all of the issues in dispute through mediation,
then within 90 days from the date of the mediator's report, the Parties shall
submit those issues to binding arbitration pursuant to the Commercial
Arbitration Act and Commercial Arbitration Code annexed thereto (R.S.C.
1985, C-17 (2"d Supp.) as am.); and,
(e) The Parties agree to the specific Terms of Arbitration as set forth in Part B
of Schedule 6, to this Agreement.
10.1.4 The Parties agree that the representatives selected to participate in the
dispute resolution process will have the authority required to settle the dispute or will
have a rapid means of obtaining the requisite authorization.
-27-
ARTICLE 11
RIGHTS PRESERVED
11.1 Subject to Article 10, nothing in this Agreement is intended to, nor shall it,
limit or restrict a Party's or a third party's right to apply to an appropriate court for an
appropriate remedy.
ARTICLE 12
GENERAL PROVISIONS
12.1 Notices
Any consent, waiver, approval, notice, request, direction, response,
determination or other communication (collectively "notice or other communication")
required or permitted to be given or made pursuant to this Agreement shall only be
effective if in writing and shall be sufficiently given or made if:
(a) delivered during normal business hours on a business day and left at the
relevant address set forth below; or
(b) telephoned or faxed;
To Clarington:
The Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington
40 Temperance Street
Bowmanville, Ontario
L1 C 3A6
Attention: Chief Administrative Officer
Telephone: (905) 623-3379
Facsimile: (905) 623-5717
To the Township of Hope:
The Corporation of the Township of Hope
P.O. Box 85
Port Hope, Ontario
L1A 3V7
Attention: Chief Administrative Officer
Telephone: (905) 753-2229
Facsimile: (905) 753-2434
-28-
To the Town of Port Hope:
The Corporation of the Town of Port Hope
56 Queen Street
P.O. Box 117
Port Hope, Ontario
L1A 3V9
Attention: Chief Administrative Officer
Telephone: (905) 885-4544
Facsimile: (905) 885-7698
To the LLRW MO:
The Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Office
67 John Street, Suite 104
Port Hope, Ontario
L1 A 2Z4
Attention: The Director
Telephone: (905) 885-9488
Facsimile: (905) 885-7458
To Canada:
Natural Resources Canada
580 Booth Street
Ottawa, Ontario
K1A OE4
Attention: Director General, Energy Resources Branch
Telephone: (613) 995-0138
Facsimile: (613) 992-8730
To the FOA:
(as to be later determined and specified by Canada)
Any notice or other communication so given or made shall be deemed to
have been given or made on the same day and to have been received on the day of
delivery if delivered as aforesaid or on the day of receipt of same by telex or telefax, as
the case may be, provided such day is a business day and that such notice is received
by the person notified prior to 3:00 p.m. local time, and, if not, on the first business day
thereafter.
-29-
Each Party may change the person, the address, telephone and facsimile
number referred to above, by notice to the others pursuant hereto.
12.2 Assignment
Except as otherwise provided for in this Agreement, no Party may assign
its interest in whole or in any part of this Agreement except with the consent of the other
Parties.
12.3 No Partnership, Joint Venture or Agency
Nothing in this Agreement, nor the conduct of any Party, shall in any
manner whatsoever constitute or be intended to constitute one Party as the agent or
representative or fiduciary of another Party, nor constitute or be intended to constitute a
partnership or joint venture between or amongst the Parties but rather each Party shall
be responsible, liable and accountable for its own obligations under this Agreement, or
any conduct arising therefrom and for all claims, demands, actions and causes of action
arising directly or indirectly therefrom.
Neither Party shall have the authority to make nor shall it make any
statements, representations or commitments of any kind, or take any action, that will
f bind the other Party, except as expressly provided in this Agreement, or as otherwise
authorised in writing.
i
12.4 Further Assurances
Each of the Parties shall, from time to time, at its own cost and expense,
execute or cause to be executed all such further documents and do or cause to be done
all things which are necessary to give effect to the provisions of this Agreement.
12.5 Entire Agreement
This Agreement embodies the entire agreement between and amongst the
Parties with respect to the Project and comprises all matters relating to the financing,
management, design, planning, engineering, procurement, construction, commissioning,
completion, leasing, ownership and operation of the Project. Unless otherwise expressly
stated, this Agreement, supersedes all prior agreements, understandings or writings
among the Parties, whether written or oral and whether legally enforceable or not in
respect of the Project. Subject to applicable laws, no Party shall be bound by or be
liable for any statement, representation, promise, warranty, inducement, agreement,
obligation or understanding of any kind or nature not set forth in this Agreement.
-30-
12.6 Conflict of Interest
It is a term of the Agreement that no person who is not in compliance
the provisions of the Conflict of Interest and Post-Employment Code for Public Office
Holders or the Conflict of Interest and Post-Employment Code for the Public Service,
shall derive any direct benefit from this Agreement.
12.7 Members of the House of Commons or Senate of Canada
No Member of the House of Commons or Senate of Canada shall be
admitted to any share or part of this Agreement or to any benefit.arising hereunder.
12.8 Appropriations
The payment of any money by Canada pursuant to this Agreement is
subject to there being an appropriation for such payment by the Parliament of Canad;
for the fiscal year in which such payment becomes due. In the event that no
appropriation is made for three consecutive years, The Town of Port Hope shall have
option to withdraw from its obligations under this Agreement.
12.9 Entry into force
This Agreement shall enter into force on the date on which the last Part
signs the Agreement.
i
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, this Agreement has been duly executed by authorizE
representatives of the Minister of Natural Resources Canada and has been duly
executed by the Corporation of the Town of Port Hope, the Corporation of the Townst
of Hope and the Corporation of the Municipality of Clarington, and their respective
corporate seals affixed hereto by its duly authorized officers, on the dates noted by ea
signature.
SIGNED AND DELIVERED.
The Corporation of the Town of Port H pe
per: Ri yor Michael Rostetter,
Chief Administrative Officer / Clerk
December -Qi 7:) 2000
-3t-
The Corporation of the Township of Hope
per.
i
Ian W. M. Angus, Reeve
9 � Frances Aird,
Chief Administrative Officer/ Clerk
December ( , 2000
The Corporation of the Municipality of Clarin
per:
J n Mutton, Mayor Patti arri unicipal Clerk
December 2000
Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada
as represented by the M: er of Natural Resources
per:
' 2001
-32-
SCHEDULE 1
PART A
Description of the Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Project
The Project includes all work necessary and incidental to the achievement of the
following:
(a) the completion of all socio-economic, engineering and environmental research
necessary to acquisition of an approval, permit, licence or other such
authorization or the reaching of a required determination under applicable federal
or provincial legislation;
i
(b) the submission of the design of each Facility and the process for carrying out the
Elements of the Project within the community in order to comply with the
environmental assessment requirements;
(c) the finalization of the design of the New Town of Port Hope Waste Management
Facility, the New Welcome Waste Management Facility and the New Port Granby
Waste Management Facility, and the process for carrying out the Project in order
to comply with the regulatory requirements;
i
(d) the submission of each finalized design of each new Facility and the process for
carrying out the Elements of the Project within the community for applicable
regulatory approvals;
(e) the acquisition of all properties necessary for the construction and operation of the
new Facilities;
(f) the operation of the Welcome Waste Management Facility and the Port Granby
Waste Management Facility following Canada's acquisition thereof;
(g) the construction and subsequent operation of the new Facilities;
i
(h) the Cleanup of Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste at the sites in the Town of
Port Hope as identified in the Port Hope LLRW Management Policy Review
Committee's Report titled Report on Conceptualization of Low-Level Radioactive
Waste Storage Facility Designs in the Town of Port Hope, dated March 1999 and
the relocation of the Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste to the New Town of
Port Hope Waste Management Facility;
(i) the acceptance of the Cameco Decommissioning Waste at the New Town of Port
Hope Waste Management Facility;
-33-
(j) the Cleanup of Industrial Waste at the sites in the Town of Port Hope as
hereinafter identified; and,
(k) the completion of all surface remedial work and landscaping associated with the
completion of the construction of the new Facilities.
PART B
Without limiting the generality of the above description, the Project includes all
work necessary and incidental to the achievement of the components set out below.
Town of Port Hope
The construction of the New Town of Port Hope Waste Management Facility.
Location:
the Facility will be located at the Pine Street North Extension and extend to both
the east and the west of that roadway covering an area of roughly 8-hectares
(approximately 20 acres)
f
Materials to be accommodated:
the Facility will accommodate approximately 535,000 cubic metres of Low-Level
Radioactive Waste and non-radioactive Industrial Waste, consisting of three
categories presently situated in the Town of Port Hope:
1. Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste —This type of Low-Level
Radioactive Waste comprises approximately 345,000 cubic metres of
material situated at licensed sites in the Town of Port Hope operated by the
Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Office, at major known sites,
including those identified on the table following, and at known and
unknown small-scale unlicensed sites.
-34-
MAJOR KNOWN SITES OF HISTORIC LOW-LEVEL RADIOACTIVE WASTE
IN PORT HOPE
PORT HOPE HARBOUR ALEXANDER RAVINE
HIGHLAND DRIVE LANDFILL HIGHLAND DRIVE SOUTH RAVINE
PINE STREET N. CONSOLIDATION PINE STREET N. STORAGE SITE*
SITE*
MILL STREET SOUTH WATERWORKS SITE
PINE STREET N. ROADWAY STRACHAN STREET CONSOLIDATION
SITE*
CN/CP VIADUCTS SITE SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT
TEMPORARY STORAGE SITE*
HIGHLAND DRIVE ROADWAY JOHN STREET SOUTH SITE
i
* these are temporary storage sites licenced by the CNSC.
in addition, the Facility will accommodate additional Historic Low-Level Radioactive
Waste located in other sites within the Town of Port Hope including those identified by
past or future surveys performed by LLRWMO or the FOA.
2. Cameco Decommissioning Waste — This type of Low-Level Radioactive Waste
comprises Cameco-owned materials in the Town of Port Hope and includes an inventory
of 3,822 cubic metres of Low-Level Radioactive Waste materials that have been in
storage at the Cameco facility since prior to 1988 and materials that would result from
the decommissioning of Cameco-owned and/or operated processing facilities and
associated properties utilized by Eldorado in the Town of Port Hope prior to 1988. This
includes Low-Level Radioactive Waste at the main plant site at 1 Eldorado Place and the
Dorset Street East warehousing facilities (117,000 cubic metres) and at the Centre Pier
property (30,000 cubic metres). The estimated total volume is approximately 150,000
cubic metres.
3. Industrial Waste — This category includes non-radioactive materials that the Town
of Port Hope identified in its proposal to the government as wastes that it wants included
in the Facility. The category consists of (i) waste material (including sludge) at a former
wastewater lagoon site at Lake Street, (ii) dried sewage sludge currently stored in an
engineered facility at the Lake Street Sewage Treatment Plant, (iii) wastes from a former
coal gasification plant adjacent to John Street between Park and Alexander Streets and
(iv) waste from the former Crane Sanitary Company located at the Center Pier and at the
Lions Recreational Centre Park. The estimated volume for the first three of these
components is approximately 40,000 cubic metres. Industrial Waste from the former
-35-
Crane Sanitary Company are included with the Centre Pier property volume above.
Conceptual design:
the conceptual design is described in the Final Report of the Port Hope LLRW
Management Policy Review Committee entitled, Report on Conceptualization of Low-
Level Radioactive Waste Storage Facility Designs in the Town of Port Hope, March 15,
1999 as Approach 3.
the conceptual design involves:
removal of municipal landfill wastes covering low-level radioactive wastes within
the landfill and placement of the excavated landfill waste on the unexcavated
landfill
the construction of a Waste containment mound that is partially below-grade with
an appropriate liner and cover system to house all excavated Low-Level
Radioactive Waste, marginally contaminated soils, and miscellaneous Industrial
Waste
placement of clean cover material on the municipal landfill site
final designs will be completed after the detailed engineering and technical studies which
will commence at the signing of this Agreement
Project costs:
- the Proponent agrees to pay or absorb the Project costs, including:
survey for contamination and, if required, cleanup and restoration of roadways,
including infrastructure, and properties not specifically identified in the Town of
Port Hope conceptual approach where there is reason to believe that Historic
Low-Level Radioactive Waste may exist
improvements to infrastructure required for the construction and operation of the
Facility including:
all reasonable capital costs related to road improvements, including
extensions, widenings, replacements, and resurfacing of roads as a result
of the development and operation of the site including transportation routes
to or from the Facility;
- all reasonable capital costs related to providing or improving other services
to the site including sewage, water, and lighting;
-36-
development of the new Facility in the manner reflected in the conceptual design,
including post-closure recreational elements, the construction of which may be
staged; and,
establishing an ongoing communications program to fully-inform residents about
the Project
Additional cleanup of Port Hope Industrial Waste:
Canada agrees to pay the costs of removal of certain Industrial Waste within the Town of
Port.Hope, as earlier described in Schedule 1, the transportation of those wastes to the
New Port.Hope Waste Management Facility, the restoration, the backfilling and
landscaping of the site from which the wastes were removed
i
Administrative costs:
- Canada agrees to reimburse to the Town of Port Hope, reasonable future administrative,
legal, and external communications expenses incurred from the date of the signing of
the Agreement for the duration of the Project
- following the signing of the Agreement, Canada and the Town of Port Hope will establish
a process whereby such administrative expenses will be identified, quantified, and paid
Township of Hope
- The construction of the New Welcome Waste Management Facility.
Location:
I
- the Facility will be located at the site of the Welcome Waste Management Facility
Material to be accommodated:
- the Facility will accommodate approximately 650,000 cubic metres of Cameco Waste -
Welcome.
- in addition, the Facility will accommodate any Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste
located within the Township of Hope as identified by surveys to be performed by Canada
Conceptual design:
- the conceptual design is described in the Final Report of the Township of Hope Low-
Level Radioactive Waste Ad Hoc Committee entitled, Report on Concept Design Options
for a Low-Level Radioactive Waste Storage Mound at the Welcome Site, September 10,
1998 as Conceptual Approach 1 C
-37-
- the conceptual design involves:
the construction of a waste containment mound that is partially below-grade with
an appropriate liner and cover system
- final designs will be completed after the detailed engineering and technical studies which
will commence at the signing of the Agreement
Project costs:
- Canada agrees to pay or absorb the Project costs, including:
- improvements to infrastructure required for the construction and operation of the Facility
including:
all reasonable capital costs related to road improvements, including extensions,
widenings, replacements, and resurfacing of roads required for the development
and operation of the site;
all reasonable capital costs related to providing or improving other services to the
site including sewage, water, and lighting;
- survey and, if required, cleanup and restoration of roadways and properties where there
is reason to believe that Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste may exist
- development of the New Welcome Waste Management Facility as a site that is
conducive to passive and active recreational uses such as soccer fields and baseball
diamonds;
- establishing an ongoing communications program to fully-inform residents about the
Project.
Administrative costs:
Canada agrees to reimburse to the Township of Hope, reasonable future administrative
and legal expenses incurred from the date of the signing of the Agreement for the
duration of the Project;
following the signing of the Agreement, Canada and the Township of Hope will establish
a process whereby such administrative expenses will be identified, quantified, and paid.
Clarington
The construction of the New Port Granby Waste Management Facility.
-38-
Location:
- the Facility will be located at or approximate to the site of the Port Granby Low-Level
Radioactive Waste Management Facility
Materials to be accommodated:
the Facility will accommodate approximately 500,000 cubic metres of Cameco Waste -
Port Granby at the Port Granby Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Facility,
including approximately 100,000 cubic metres of calcium fluoride, neutralized raffinate
and marginally contaminated soils and contaminated industrial trash from the East
Gorge of the current site
in addition, the Facility will accommodate any Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste
located within the Municipality of Clarington as identified by surveys to be performed by
Canada.
i
i
Conceptual design:
- the conceptual design is described in the Final Report of the Port Granby Low-Level
Radioactive Waste Advisory Committee entitled, Report on Conceptualization of On-Site
Low-Level Radioactive Waste Storage Facility Designs for the Port Granby Waste
Management Facility, June 28, 1999 as Concept Design B, Option 2 as endorsed by
Clarington Council
- the conceptual design involves:
the construction of a groundwater diversion trench and perimeter barrier wall on
the eastern, northern, and western perimeters of the existing Port Granby Waste
Management Facility;
the construction of an on-site mound for roughly 100,000 cubic metres of material
from the East Gorge of the current site;
installation of an appropriate cover on the existing waste facility;
bluff stabilization and the construction of a toe berm to retard further erosion
- final designs will be completed after the detailed engineering and technical studies which
will commence at the signing of the Agreement
Project costs:
- Canada agrees to pay or absorb the Project costs, including:
-39-
improvements to infrastructure required for the construction and operation of the
new Facility including:
all reasonable capital costs related to road improvements, including
extensions, widenings, replacements, and resurfacing of roads required for
the development.and operation of the site;
all reasonable capital costs related to providing or improving other services
to the site including sewage, water, and lighting;
survey and, if required, cleanup and restoration of roadways and properties where
there is reason to believe that Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste may exist;
development of the re-engineered Facility as a site that is appropriate for natural
heritage and passive recreational uses, including the Waterfront Trail;
- establishing an ongoing communications program to fully-inform residents about
the Project
Administrative costs:
- Canada agrees to reimburse to the Municipality of Clarington, reasonable future
administrative and legal expenses incurred from the date of the signing of the Agreement
for the duration of the Project
- following the signing of the Agreement, Canada and the Municipality of Clarington will
establish a process whereby such administrative expenses will be identified, quantified,
and paid
Other conditions:
- in the consideration of Concept Design Option B2 as an alternative in the environmental
assessment process, Canada in consultation with the Municipality of Clarington will
retain consultants to examine and prepare reports on, among other issues, the following:
the concentration of thorium-230 in the wastes located in the East Gorge;
groundwater flow through the East Gorge and contact with the wastes deposited
in the middle till and lower sands area;
potential impacts of shoreline erosion control measures on other shoreline
properties in the area; and,
a contingency plan for the relocation of the wastes, including marginally
contaminated soil, in the event of system failure
40-
SCHEDULE2
CLEANUP APPROVAL PROCESS AND METHODOLOGIES
Introduction
The Agreement and Schedule 1 of the Agreement set out the scope of the cleanup work
that is to be done in the Township of Hope, the Town of Port Hope and the Municipality
of Clarington.
Given the objectives of the cleanup and the cleanup work to which Canada has agreed
pursuant to the Agreement, Schedule 2 sets out the Parties' understanding as to the
cleanup methodology and verification procedures which Canada will apply to work that
will be done in the three Municipalities
Cleanup Methodology and Verification Procedures
In May of 2000, the legislation creating the new Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission
(CNSC) came into force. The CNSC is the successor to the Atomic Energy Control
Board (AECB) and has the power to regulate all aspects of the development, production
and use of nuclear energy and the production, possession and use of nuclear
substances. The CNSC has recently indicated its intent to develop criteria which would
form the basis for all regulatory decisions in regard to radioactively contaminated sites in
Canada. This would include any decisions by the CNSC to approve future cleanup work.
i
Prior to the creation of the CNSC, the Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Office
(LLRWMO) complied with the Atomic Energy Control Act and Regulations and followed
other relevant Canadian and international guidelines in regard to the cleanup of low-level
radioactive waste. From the experience gained from cleanup activity at a number of
sites across Canada, the LLRWMO developed a methodology for characterizing
contaminated sites, conducting cleanup work and confirming the cleanup. This
methodology, which includes elements that are subject to the scrutiny and approval of
the regulator, is summarised below.
A new Federal Operating Agency (FOA) is intended to become the successor to the
LLRWMO. Over the next months the LLRWMO and the FOA will be initiating
consultations with the CNSC's staff and the Municipalities in order to facilitate the
CNSC's establishment of its requirements for the Project. The methodology(ies) which
have been developed by the LLRWMO for the cleanup of the existing waste
management facilities and typical properties in Port Hope will be put forward as a basis
for the consultations to establish the methodology(ies) which will be applied to future
cleanups.
-41-
In regard to any subsequent formal application to the CNSC, or any other regulator, for
licences and approvals to undertake the construction of the new Facilities and to
undertake the cleanup work, Canada will, prior to the submission of the formal
application, consult with the CNSC's staff and the Municipalities in regard to the content
of the applications for the licences.
Following the issuance of,any licence, Canada will continue to consult with the CNSC's
staff and the Municipalities as to the work that is being undertaken.
LLRWMO Methodology
The methodology which has been applied to previous cleanups by the LLRWMO in Port
Hope, and elsewhere in Canada, is comprised of five steps. Because of potentially
unique circumstances at sites, relevant elements of the methodology would be
presented or reported to the regulator to seek its advice or approval prior to their
application at the particular site.
i
The methodology is described as follows:
A) The delineation and characterisation of nature and scope of contamination.
• property owner is to be notified of any survey or sampling work to be done on their
property,
• gamma radiation surveys are undertaken, both on the surface and at subsurface levels,
in order to identify potential contamination
• where there is contamination, or some indication of contamination, samples of surface
and subsurface soils are taken for further laboratory analysis of the soil samples
• laboratory analysis of the soil samples is undertaken and the results of the analysis are
further reviewed
• further sampling and analysis is undertaken as required
• if contamination is found, a definition of the contaminated site is developed which sets
out the nature of the contaminants, the levels of concentration, the soil types, the scope
of the contaminated area and the potential risks
• the property owner, the Municipality and the applicable regulatory agencies are given full
and timely notice of any contamination found on a property.
B) The development of a work plan for the removal of the contamination.
• a review process is undertaken to determine the optimum method for accessing and
removing the contamination.
• a draft work plan is developed for the removal of the contamination, which plan has a
comprehensive health and safety component to address the safety of the construction
work itself, acid any additional health and safety factors to the workers, the public and the
environment related to removal of the contaminants.
-42-
® the FOA consults with the property owner in order to implement a cleanup plan for the
specific property that wherever possible takes into account the property owner's
concerns.
C) The development of the cleanup verification protocol
• sampling and testing protocols appropriate to the contaminants involved and the
characteristics of the properties affected are developed or adopted in consultation with
the regulatory authorities and the Municipalities in order to verify, both as the work
progresses and at the final stage of the work, that the contamination is removed.
• this includes the development or adoption of a testing protocol which will address such
elements as: the sampling pattern or grid to be used at the site, the number of samples
to be taken, the depth of samples, the analytical procedures to be followed in regard to
the samples
D) The cleanup work in accordance with approved plan and methodology.
• the owner of the property is notified of any cleanup work that is proposed to be done.
• the actual cleanup work is done
E) The confirmation that the cleanup work has been done in accordance with agreed
plan and methodology.
• this involves the taking of soil samples and the analysis of the samples and the further
analysis of the result of the soil analysis in order to determine that the contaminants
have been removed.
• the regulator will independently make verification inspections and tests as it deems
necessary or appropriate in the circumstances
• a report will be prepared setting out the results of the analysis in order to demonstrate
that the cleanup has been completed
• the verification report will be submitted to the regulator to seek the confirmation of the
regulator that the cleanup has been achieved
• if during the verification review, the results are not satisfactory, more cleanup work will
be undertaken until the work is completed and a satisfactory final analysis is obtained
evidencing the removal of the contaminants.
PROPERTY FOR THE NEW TOWN OF PORT
HOPE WASTE MANAGEMENT FACILITY
.N 18WIS edoH
S
PJ
J
c
o
Q U
U)
O � O
co
O �
Z {� o
E
cm
----------- ----- -------• ...__ c
i 45 auk.. quid
x CJ
V p q
Ca E O
d U y�
V Q
UJ 4.
0
I
� � z
T Q
_ a
o c�
c
�32J�C 2IJOj�ln .� c�
cs -�
� U
-44-
SCHEDULE 4
GEOGRAPHIC SCOPE OF THE PROPERTY VALUE PROTECTION PROGRAM
the property value protection program will cover the area within the three Municipalities
bounded by the following limits:
- on the east, the eastern boundaries of Port Hope and the Township of Hope with
the Township of Hamilton;
- on the north, a line 300 meters north of the north limit of county roads #2 and #74;
- on the west, a line 300 meters west of the west limit of Newtonville Road; and,
- in the south, the shoreline of Lake Ontario.
this area is illustrated in the map on Schedule 5.
I
i
SCHEDULES
MAP OF THE AREA OF APPLICATION OF THE
PROPERTY VALUE PROTECTION PROGRAI1
:XN
.. \ \ \\\
CL
LL
Lu
MY,
Li
LL
�, i f\` \\\. 'fir :: •/ ,,
_ 1, \ - •. � � �`� ?
X
� (T( ,J.1 -/ 1 111 '-)-.� :`-'�-\.\ \ ..�`, •\\\ ,\�\'\` \ \ `\`� �/�
Q 11J ,
I , del - .- r, "" r.`�`9- � �•^, \\ \ \ \
U
-46-
SCHEDULE 6
PART A
TERMS OF MEDIATION
Notice: If a dispute relating to this Agreement arises and the Parties do not resolve some
or all of that dispute through negotiation, then either party to the dispute may promptly
submit to the other Party(ies) a notice of intent to mediate. This notice shall be in writing
and shall specify the issues in dispute.
Selection of Mediator: The parties agree to mutually select a mediator. If the Parties
cannot agree on the choice of mediator within 60 days from the date of the notice of
intent to mediate, then a mediator will be chosen, upon application by the Parties, by the
Arbitration and Mediation Institute of Canada.
I
Location: The mediation shall be held at Port Hope, Ontario
Exchange of information: The Parties agree to an exchange of all information upon
which they intend to rely in any oral or written presentation during the mediation. This
exchange shall be complete no later than ten (10) days prior to the date set for the
mediation.
Costs: The Parties agree that they will each be responsible for the costs of their own
legal counsel and personal travel. Fees and expenses of the mediator and all
administrative costs of the mediation, such as the cost of the mediation room, if any,
shall be borne equally by the Parties.
Schedule: The Parties shall jointly select a date for the mediation that is no later than 90
days from the date of the notice of intent to mediate.
Confidentiality: All information exchanged during this entire procedure shall be regarded
as "without prejudice" communications for the purpose of settlement negotiations and
shall be treated as confidential by the Parties and their representatives, unless otherwise
required by law. However, evidence that is independently admissible or discoverable
shall not be rendered inadmissible or non-discoverable by virtue of its use during the
mediation.
47-
Caucusing: The mediator is free to caucus with the Parties individually, as he sees fit to
improve the chances of a mediated settlement. Any confidential information revealed to
the mediator by one party during such caucusing may only be disclosed to the other
Party(ies) with the former Party's express permission.
Prohibition against Future Assistance: Unless otherwise agreed by the Parties, it is
agreed that the mediator will neither represent nor testify Y
on behalf of an of the Parties
in any subsequent legal proceeding between the Parties or where they are opposed in
interest. It is further agreed that the personal notes and written opinions of the mediator
made in relation to this mediation are confidential and may not be used in any
subsequent proceeding between the Parties or where they are opposed in interest.
Termination: Any Party may terminate the mediation at any time.
Mediator's Report: In the event that no agreement is reached, or is reached on some
issues only, the mediator shall promptly provide a report to the Parties stating only that
no agreement was reached on some or all of the outstanding issues. Provided further
that if the mediator determines that a Party's position was unreasonable, the mediator
may include in the Report, an award of an amount for the other Party's reasonable costs.
No New Steps: During the course of the mediation, the Parties agree to take no new
steps in any legal action between them which concerns the same matter as is the
subject of this mediation.
i
i
PART B
TERMS OF ARBITRATION
Notice: The Party requesting arbitration shall do so by written notice to the other
Party(ies).
Commencement of the Proceedings: The arbitral proceeding commences on the date
of receipt of the notice to arbitrate the dispute.
Selection of Arbitrator: The Parties agree to mutually select an arbitrator. If the Parties
cannot agree on the choice of arbitrator within 60 days from the date of commencement
of the proceedings, then an arbitrator will be chosen, upon application by the Parties, by
the Arbitration and Mediation Institute of Canada. The arbitrator will be chosen, upon
application by the Parties, by the Arbitration and Mediation Institute of Canada.
Location: The arbitration shall take place at Port Hope, Ontario.
-48-
Costs: The Parties agree that they will each be responsible for the costs of their own
legal counsel and other costs incurred in preparing each party's case for arbitration. The
administrative costs of the arbitration, such as the expenses and fees for the arbitrator,
the cost of the hearing room, if any, shall be borne equally by the Parties. Provided that if
the arbitrator determines that a Party's position was unreasonable, the arbitrator may
include in the Arbitral Award an amount for the other Party's reasonable costs.
Statement of Claim: Within 30 days of the selection of the arbitrator(s), the claimant
shall submit a statement of claim to the arbitrator(s) and other party(ies) containing a
written statement of facts, issues in dispute and remedies sought.
Statement of Defence: Within 30 days following the receipt of the statement of claim, the
respondent(s) shall submit a written statement of defence to the arbitrator(s) and
claimant.
Hearing Date: The Parties shall jointly select a date for the hearing that is no later than
60 days from the date following the submission of the respondent's statement of
defence.
Exchange of Information: Each party shall deliver to the other party(ies) and to the
arbitrator(s) no later than 10 days prior to the date set for a hearing, a copy of all
documents and other materials on which the party intends to rely during the arbitral
hearing.
Arbitral Award: The arbitrator(s) shall make every reasonable effort consistent with
article 18 of the Commercial Arbitration Code to complete the proceedings and render
the award within six months of the commencement date. The arbitral award shall be in
writing and include reasons for the decisions.
Governing Law Clause: The arbitrator(s) shall resolve this dispute in accordance with
the laws of Ontario.
i
Judgment: Judgment upon any arbitral award rendered may be entered in any court
having jurisdiction thereof.
f
Prohibition against Future Assistance: It is agreed that the arbitrator(s) will neither
represent nor testify on behalf of any of the Parties in any subsequent proceeding
between the Parties or where they are opposed in interest. It is further agreed that the
personal notes and written opinions of the arbitrator(s) made in relation to this arbitration
are confidential and may not be used in any subsequent proceeding between the
Parties, or where they are opposed in interest.
i
-49-
SCHEDULE 7
TOWN OF PORT HOPE FUND
1. Subject to the following provisions, Port Hope agrees to hold Canada's payment of Ten
Million ($10,000,000.00.) Dollars in trust for the exclusive benefit of the ratepayers of the
area that comprises the geographic area of Port Hope as of the date of October 6, 2000.
2. The principal of the Fund may be invested by Port Hope in its discretion in any
investment permitted by law. Any income earned from investing the Fund may be
expended by Port Hope from time to time in its discretion for any purpose permitted by
law.
3 Port Hope shall pay Canada an amount equal to the opening capital of theFund, Ten
Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars, on the last to occur of both:
(1) the day on which a licence is refused by the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission to
construct the New Port Hope Waste Management Facility as contemplated by this
Agreement; and,
(2) the first day after the Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste and the Cameco
Decommissioning Waste which are identified in Schedule 1 as wastes to be
accommodated in the New Port Hope Waste Management Facility have been cleaned
up in accordance with the intent of this Agreement and removed from the Town of
Port Hope and Hope.
4. If a licence to construct the New Port Hope Waste Management Facility is granted by the
Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, on the date of the issuance of the licence Port
Hope's obligations in favour of Canada regarding the investment and use of the fund
shall terminate.
I
i
i
-50-
SCHEDULE 8
TOWNSHIP OF HOPE FUND
1. Canada will pay to the trustee ("Trustee") appointed by Hope Township Council, a grant
in the amount of Ten Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars (hereinafter referred to as the
"Opening Capital" or the "Fund") which, subject to the following provisions, shall be held
in trust for the exclusive benefit of the ratepayers from time to time of the area that
comprises the geographic area of Hope Township as of the date of October 6, 2000.
i
2. The principal of the Fund shall be invested by the Trustee in any investment permitted by
law that the Trustee in its discretion considers likely will produce an increase in the net
value of the Fund comprising a blend of capital appreciation and income of at least ten
(10%) per cent in each calendar year ("Growth").
3. After first deducting and appropriating to the Trustee's use from the income earned from
the investment of the Fund the amount required to indemnify the Trustee against the
Trustee's reasonable costs incurred in administering and investing the Fund, the Trustee
shall apply an amount equal to up to eight (8%) per cent of the Fund in the previous
calendar year to defray the lower tier municipal taxes or levies which otherwise would be
payable by the ratepayers of aforesaid geographic area of Hope Township provided that
the opening capital of the Fund shall not be encroached upon by the Trustee.
4. If any portion of the growth in the Fund in any calendar year is not required to be
expended to discharge the aforesaid lower tier municipal taxes or levies, the portion shall
be invested as aforesaid, and the other provisions of this Schedule shall apply with all
necessary changes being considered to have been made in order to give effect to the
intent of sections 2 and 3 above. Provided that the Trustee shall not pay out any amount
to defray lower tier municipal taxes or levies that will reduce the net value of the Fund
below the amount of Ten Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars.
5. The Trustee appointed by Hope Township Council to administer the Fund in accordance
with the above sections, shall have at least fifty (50) times the amount of the Fund under
administration during the period in which he will act as Trustee of the Fund.
6. Hope Township Council from time to time may terminate the appointment of the Trustee
on terms considered to be appropriate by the Council in its discretion and thereupon
shall appoint another Trustee who is qualified as aforesaid to act as Trustee of the Fund
during the period of the appointment. The Trustee so appointed from time to time shall j
be deemed to be the Trustee for the purposes of this Agreement. Except in appointing
and terminating the Trustee of the Fund from time to time, Hope Township Council shall
have no authority over the investment decisions made by the Trustee.
-51-
7. For greater clarity, "lower tier municipal taxes or levies" are the annual taxes or levies
imposed by Hope Township or by its successor on ratepayers who own assessed
property within the geographic area of Hope Township as it exists as of the date that the
Township of Hope signed this Agreement. The term "lower tier municipal taxes or levies"
does not include general county or upper tier taxes or levies, special county or upper tier
taxes or levies, and education taxes or levies.
8. The Trustee shall pay,Canada an amount equal to the opening capital of the Fund being
Ten Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars on the last to occur of both:
(1) the day on which a licence is refused by the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission to
construct the New Hope Township Waste Management Facility as contemplated by this
Agreement; and,
(2) the first day after the Cameco Waste -Welcome has been removed from the
Township of Hope and the site of the Welcome Waste Management Facility has been
cleaned up in accordance with the intent of this Agreement including, without limitation,
Schedule 2.
9. If a licence to construct the New Hope Township Waste Management Facility is granted
by the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, on the date of the issuance of the licence
the Trustee's obligation in favour of Canada regarding the use and investment of the
Fund shall terminate.
-52-
i
SCHEDULE 9
CLARINGTON FUND
1. Subject to the following provisions, Clarington agrees to hold Canada's payment of Ten
Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars, hereinafter referred to as the "Fund", in trust for the
exclusive benefit of the ratepayers of the area that comprises the geographic area of
Clarington as of the date of October 6, 2000, provided that if after the date of this
Agreement, the geographic area of Clarington is reduced, the fund shall be'held in trust
for the exclusive benefit of the ratepayers of the remaining geographic area of
Clarington.
2. The principal of the Fund may be invested by Clarington in its discretion in any
investment permitted by law. Any income earned from investing the Fund may be
expended by Clarington from time to time in its discretion for any purpose permitted by
law.
i
3. Clarington shall pay Canada an amount equal to the opening capital of the Fund, Ten
Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars, on the last to occur of both:
(1) the day on which a licence is refused by the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission to
construct the New Clarington Waste Management Facility as contemplated by this
Agreement; and,
(2) the first day after the Cameco Waste - Port Granby has been removed from
Clarington and the site of the Port Granby Waste Management Facility has been cleaned
up in accordance with the intent of this Agreement including, without limitation, Schedule
2.
4. If a licence to construct the New Port Granby Waste Management Facility is granted by
the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, on the date of the issuance of the licence
Clarington's obligations in favour of Canada regarding the investment and use of the
fund shall terminate.
i
i
i
t
i
i
AMENDMENT TO
AN AGREEMENT FOR THE CLEANUP
AND THE LONG-TERM SAFE MANAGEMENT OF
LOW-LEVEL RADIOACTIVE WASTE
SITUATE IN THE TOWN OF PORT HOPE,THE TOWNSHIP OF HOPE
and THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON
AMONG
THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF PORT HOPE,
A Municipal corporation pursuant to the Ontario Municipal Act
(hereinafter referred to as the "Municipality of Port Hope")
OF THE FIRST PART
THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON,
A Municipal corporation pursuant to the Ontario Municipal Act
(hereinafter referred to as the "Municipality of Clarington")
OF THE SECOND PART
AND
f
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN RIGHT OF CANADA
as represented by the Minister of Natural Resources
(hereinafter referred to as "Canada")
OF THE THIRD PART
i
WHEREAS the Municipality of Port Hope, the Municipality of Clarington, and the former
Corporation of the Township of Hope entered into An Agreement for the Cleanup and the Long-
Term Safe Management of Low-Level Radioactive Waste Situate in the Town of Port Hope, the
Township of Hope, and the Municipality of Clarington on March 29,2001 (hereinafter referred
i to as the "Original Agreement");
AND WHEREAS. as a result of municipal restructuring in the Province of Ontario, effective
January 1. 2001; the Corporation of the Township of Hope became a part of the Municipality of
Port Hope;
AND WHEREAS, the Municipality of Port Hope has requested that Schedule 8 of the Original
Agreement be amended to provide that the Township of Hope Funds may be administered by an
Investment Counsellor as an option;
i
AND WHEREAS this amendment will provide the Municipality of Port Hope more opportunities
for investment of the grant provided by Canada;
i
AND WHEREAS the Municipality of Clarington and Canada have approved the requested
P 9
amendment to the Original Agreement;
NOW,THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants contained herein, the
Municipality of Port Hope. the Municipality of Clarington, and Canada agree to amend the
Original Agreement as follows:
1. Schedule 8 of the Original Agreement is replaced with Schedule 8 attached hereto.
2. This amendment may be signed in counterpart.
I
IN WITNESS WHEREOF this Amendment has been executed on behalf of the Municipality of
Port Hope, the Municipality of Clarington, and Canada by duly authorized representatives.
i
i
The Municipality of Port Hope
per:
RiA A sfih'-. M'- Wor Frances Aird, Clerk/Deputy CAO
V19Uftff-XXXbft October 7, 2003
The Municipality of Clarington
per:
John Mutton, Mayor P ti i unicipal Clerk
September 2_1, 200')
George Anderson
Deputy Minister of
Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada Natural Resources Canada
per:
Ric Cameron, Assistant Deputy Minister Peter Brown,' hector General
Energy Sector, NRCan Electricity Resources Branch
September ,200')
SCHEDULE8
TOWNSHIP OF HOPE FUND
1. Canada will pay to the trustee ("Trustee") appointed by Hope Township Council,
a grant in the amount of Ten Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars hereinafter referred to as
the "Opening Capital" or the "Fund" which, subject to the following provisions, shall be
held in trust or, after the appointment by.Council of an Investment Counsellor, on the
terms set in the Investment Policy of the Municipality for the exclusive benefit of the
ratepayers from time to time of.the area that comprises the geographic area of Hope
Township as of the date of October 6, 2000.
2. In the event that the Fund is managed by a Trustee, the principal of the Fund
shall be invested by the Trustee in any investment permitted by law that the Trustee in
its discretion considers likely will produce an increase in the net value of the Fund
comprising a blend of capital appreciation and income of at least ten (10%) per cent in
each calendar year ("Growth").
3. In the event that an Investment Counsellor is appointed to manage the Fund, the
terms of that Contract and the Municipality's Investment Policy shall apply.
4. In either situation, after first deducting the fees negotiated and approved by
contract from the income earned from the investment of the Fund, the Trustee or the
Investment Counsellor shall apply an amount equal to up to eight (8%) per cent of the
j Fund in the previous calendar year to defray the lower tier municipal taxes or levies
which otherwise would be payable by the ratepayers of aforesaid geographic area of
Hope Township provided that the opening capital of the Fund shall not be encroached
upon by the Trustee or the Investment Counsellor.
5. If any portion of the growth in the Fund in any calendar year is not required to be
expended to discharge the aforesaid lower tier municipal taxes or levies, the portion
shall be invested as aforesaid, and the other provisions of this Schedule shall apply with
all necessary changes being considered to have been made in order to give effect to
the intent of sections 2, 3 and 4 above. Provided that the Trustee or the Investment
Counsellor shall not pay out any amount to defray lower tier municipal taxes or levies
that will reduce the net value of the Fund below the amount of Ten Million
($10,000,000.00) Dollars.
6. The Trustee or the Investment Counsellor appointed by Hope Township Council
to administer the Fund in accordance with the above sections, shall have at least fifty
(50) times the amount of the Fund under administration during the period in which he
will act as Trustee or Investment Counsellor.
7. Hope Township Council from time to time may terminate the appointment of the. .
I
!I'
i
Trustee or the Investment Counsellor, on terms considered to be appropriate by the
Council in its discretion and thereupon shall appoint another Trustee or Investment
Counsellor who is qualified as aforesaid to act as Trustee or Investment Counsellor of
the Fund during the period of the appointment. The Trustee or Investment Counsellor
so appointed from time to time shall be deemed to be the Trustee or Investment
Counsellor for the purposes of this Agreement. Except in appointing and terminating
the Trustee or Investment Counsellor of the Fund from time to time, Hope Township
Council shall have no authority over the investment decisions made by the Trustee or
the Investment Counsellor.
8. For greater clarity, "lower tier municipal taxes or levies" are the annual taxes or
levies imposed by Hope Township or by its successor on ratepayers who own assessed
property within the geographic area of Hope Township as it exists as of the date that
the Township of Hope signed this Agreement. The term "lower tier municipal taxes or j
levies" does not include general county or upper tier taxes or levies, special county or
upper tier taxes or levies, and education taxes or levies.
9. The Trustee, if appointed, or the Municipality, shall pay Canada an amount equal
to the opening capital of the Fund being Ten Million ($10,000,000.00) Dollars on the
last to occur of both:
(1) the day on which a licence is refused-by the Canadian Nuclear Safety
Commission to construct the New Hope Township Waste Management Facility
as contemplated by this Agreement; and,
(2) the first day after the Cameco Waste - Welcome.has been removed from the
Township of Hope and the.site of the Welcome Waste Management Facility has
been cleaned up in accordance with the intent of this Agreement including,
without limitation, Schedule 2.
10. If a licence to construct the New Hope Township Waste Management Facility is
granted by the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, on the date of the issuance of
the licence the Trustee's obligation in favour of Canada regarding the use and
investment of the Fund shall terminate.
I
I
i
AMENDMENT #2 TO
AN AGREEMENT FOR THE CLEANUP
AND THE LONG-TERM SAFE MANAGEMENT OF
LOW-LEVEL RADIOACTIVE WASTE
SITUATE IN THE TOWN OF PORT HOPE, THE TOWNSHIP OF HOPE
and THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON
AMONG
THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF PORT HOPE,
A Municipal corporation pursuant to the Ontario Municipal Act
(hereinafter referred to as the "Municipality of Port Hope")
OF THE FIRST PART
THE CORPORATION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF CLARINGTON,
A Municipal corporation pursuant to the Ontario Municipal Act
(hereinafter referred to as the "Municipality of Clarington")
OF THE SECOND PART
AND
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN RIGHT OF CANADA
as represented by the Minister of Natural Resources
(hereinafter referred to as "Canada")
OF THE THIRD PART
WHEREAS the Municipality of Port Hope, the Municipality of Clarington, and the
former Corporation of the Township of Hope entered into An Agreement for the
Cleanup and the Long-Term Safe Management of Low-Level Radioactive Waste
Situate in the Town of Port Hope, the Township of Hope, and the Municipality of
Clarington on March 29, 2001 (hereinafter referred to as the "Original
Agreement");
AND WHEREAS, as a result of municipal restructuring in the Province of
Ontario, effective January 1, 2001, the Corporation of the Township of Hope and
the Corporation of the Town of Port Hope became the Municipality of Port Hope;
AND WHEREAS the parties amended the Original Agreement on October 7, 2003;
i
I
AND WHEREAS in the context of an environmental assessment of the long-term
management of low-level radioactive wastes in the Municipality of Port Hope, an
assessment of alternative means of carrying out the project has resulted in the
recommendation that wastes in the former Township of Hope and Town of Port
Hope be consolidated at one site within the Municipality of Port Hope,
AND WHEREAS the Municipality of Port Hope, by resolution NO. 91/2005,
provided written consent, as set out in Section 4.1.3 of the agreement, for the
recommended consolidation option to be submitted for federal review,
AND WHEREAS the consolidation requires amendment to the Original
Agreement as set out in Section 4.1.4 of the agreement;
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants contained herein,
the Municipality of Port Hope, the Municipality of Clarington, and Canada agree
to amend the Original Agreement as follows:
1. Section 1.1 of the Original Agreement is amended as follows:
In the definitions of "Element", "Facility" and "Low-Level Radioactive Waste
Management Project", the references to "New Welcome Waste Management
Facility" and "New Town of Port Hope Waste Management Facility" are replaced
with "New Port Hope Waste Management Facility" in each definition.
The definitions of "New Welcome Waste Management Facility" and "New Town
of Port Hope Waste Management Facility" are revoked and replaced with the
following definition:
"New Port Hope Waste Management Facility" means the activities and structure
contemplated in the "Description of the Preferred Option", attached as Schedule
6 to the Municipality of Port Hope Resolution NO. 91/2005, dated April 19,
2005."
2. Section 1.17 of the Original Agreement is amended by revising the Schedule 3
title to read "Property for the New Port Hope Waste Management Facility".
i
3. Section 3.1.1 of the Original Agreement is amended by replacing the references
to "New Welcome Waste Management Facility" and "New Town of Port Hope
Waste Management Facility" with the single reference to the "New Port Hope
Waste Management Facility".
4. Section 6.1 of the Original Agreement is revoked.
5. Sections 6.2 and 6.3 of the Original Agreement are amended by replacing any
references to "New Welcome Waste Management Facility" with "New Port Hope
Waste Management Facility", and revoking Section 6.3.1 c).
i
i
i
6. Schedule 1 Part A and B of the Original Agreement is replaced with Schedule 1
Part A and B attached hereto.
7. Schedule 3 of the Original Agreement is replaced with Schedule 3 attached
hereto.
8. Schedule 8 (as amended October 7, 2003) is amended by replacing any
references to "New Hope Township Waste Management Facility' with "New Port
Hope Waste Management Facility".
IN WITNESS WHEREOF this Amendment has been executed on behalf of the
Municipality of Port Hope, the Municipality of Clarington, and Canada by duly
authorized representatives.
The Municipality of Port Hope
I
per:
Vick ustin, ayor
Connie Martinell, Deputy Clerk
Steer 18, 2006
�►uyus`r
The Municipality of Clarington
per: i
John qutton, Mayor
C. Anne Greentree, Deputy Clerk
SeptemberM, 2006
i
Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada
per:
Cass' J. yle, D ty Minister
Natu I R ources nada
e+ er
2o. 2006
I'
i
A2 - 1
SCHEDULEI
PART A
Description of the Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Project
The Project includes all work necessary and incidental to the achievement of the
following:
(a) the completion of all socio-economic, engineering and environmental research
necessary to acquisition of an approval, permit, licence or other such
authorization or the reaching of a required determination under applicable,
federal or provincial legislation;
(b) the submission of the design of each Facility and the process for carrying out the
Elements of the Project within the community in order to comply with the
environmental assessment requirements;
(c) the finalization of the design of the New Port Hope Waste Management Facility
and the New Port Granby Waste Management Facility, and the process for
carrying out the Project in order to comply with the regulatory requirements;
(d) the submission of each finalized design of each new Facility and the process for
carrying out the Elements of the Project within the community for applicable
regulatory approvals;
(e) the acquisition of all properties necessary for the construction and operation of
the new Facilities;
(f) the operation of the Welcome Waste Management Facility and the Port Granby
Waste Management Facility following Canada's acquisition thereof;
(g) the construction and subsequent operation of the new Facilities;
(h) the Cleanup of Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste at the sites in the former
Town of Port Hope as identified in the Port Hope LLRW Management Policy
Review Committee's Report titled Report on Conceptualization of Low-Level
Radioactive Waste Storage Facility Designs in the Town of Port Hope, dated
March 1999 and the relocation of the Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste to
the New Port Hope Waste Management Facility;
(i) the acceptance of the Cameco Decommissioning Waste at the New Port Hope
Waste Management Facility;
I
i
A2 - 2
(j) the Cleanup of Industrial Waste at the sites in the former Town of Port Hope as
hereinafter identified; and,
(k) the completion of all surface remedial work and landscaping associated with the
completion of the construction of the new Facilities.
PART B
Without limiting the generality of the above description, the Project includes all
work necessary and incidental to the achievement of the components set out below.
Municipality of Port Hope
The construction of the New Port Hope Waste Management Facility.
I
Location:
- the Facility will be located just south of Highway 401 and west of Baulch Road at
the site of the current Welcome Waste Management Facility.
Materials to be accommodated:
the Facility will have a capacity of approximately 1 .9 million cubic meters of Low-
Level Radioactive Waste and non-radioactive Industrial Waste, consisting of
three categories presently situated in the Municipality of Port Hope:
1. Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste —This type of Low-Level
Radioactive Waste comprises approximately 577,500 cubic metres of
material situated at licensed sites in the former Town of Port Hope
operated by the Low-Level Radioactive Waste Management Office, at
major sites, including those identified on the table following, and at small-
scale unlicensed sites.
I
'i
I
A2- 3
MAJOR KNOWN SITES OF HISTORIC LOW-LEVEL RADIOACTIVE WASTE
IN PORT HOPE
PORT HOPE HARBOUR ALEXANDER RAVINE
HIGHLAND DRIVE LANDFILL HIGHLAND DRIVE SOUTH RAVINE
PINE STREET N. CONSOLIDATION PINE STREET N. STORAGE SITE*
SITE*
MILL STREET SOUTH WATERWORKS SITE
PINE STREET N. ROADWAY STRACHAN STREET CONSOLIDATION
SITE*
CN/CP VIADUCTS SITE SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT
TEMPORARY STORAGE SITE*
HIGHLAND DRIVE ROADWAY JOHN STREET SOUTH SITE
* these are temporary storage sites licenced by the CNSC.
in addition, the Facility will accommodate additional Historic Low-Level
Radioactive Waste located in other sites within the former Town of Port Hope
including those identified by past or future surveys performed by LLRWMO or
the FOA.
2. Cameco Waste
a) Cameco Decommissioning Waste — This type of Low-Level Radioactive
Waste comprises Cameco-owned materials in the former Town of Port Hope and
includes an inventory of 3,822 cubic metres of Low-Level Radioactive Waste
materials that have been in storage at the Cameco facility since prior to 1988
and materials that would result from the decommissioning of Cameco-owned
and/or operated processing facilities and associated properties utilized by
Eldorado in the former Town of Port Hope prior to 1988. This includes Low-
Level Radioactive Waste at the main plant site at 1 Eldorado Place and the
Dorset Street East warehousing facilities (117,000 cubic meters) and at the
Centre Pier property (30,000 cubic meters). The estimated total volume is
approximately 150,000 cubic meters.
b) Cameco Waste - Welcome —Approximately 620,000 cubic metres of waste
located at the Welcome Waste Management Facility.
3. Industrial Waste — This category includes non-radioactive materials that
the former Town of Port Hope identified in its proposal to the government as
wastes that it wants included in the Facility. The category consists of (i) waste
material (including sludge) at a former wastewater lagoon site at Lake Street, (ii)
A2 -4
dried sewage sludge currently stored in an engineered facility at the Lake Street
Sewage Treatment Plant, (iii) wastes from a former coal gasification plant
adjacent to John Street between Park and Alexander Streets and (iv) waste from
the former Crane Sanitary Company located at the Center Pier and at the Lions
Recreational Centre Park. The estimated volume from these four components is
approximately 51,250 cubic metres.
Conceptual design:
- the conceptual design, originally described in
a) the Final Report of the Port Hope LLRW Management Policy Review
Committee entitled, Report on Conceptualization of Low-Level Radioactive
Waste Storage Facility Designs in the Town of Port Hope, March 15, 1999 as
Approach 3, and
b) the Final Report of the Township of Hope Low-Level Radioactive Waste Ad
Hoc Committee entitled, Report on Concept Design Options for a Low-Level
Radioactive Waste Storage Mound at the Welcome Site, September 10, 1998 as
Conceptual Approach 1 C,
has been revised and now involves the consolidation of the waste at a single
long-term waste management facility as described in Schedule B of the
Municipality of Port Hope Resolution NO. 91/2005, dated April 19, 2005.
the conceptual design involves:
- the construction of a waste containment mound that is partially below-
grade with an appropriate liner and cover system to house all excavated
Low-Level Radioactive Waste, marginally contaminated soils, and
miscellaneous Industrial Waste
- the remediation of contaminated sites and the transfer of the
contaminated material to the new waste management facility
the integration of the waste at the Welcome Waste Management Facility
into the new waste management facility
final designs will be completed through the detailed engineering and technical
studies which commenced at the signing of this Agreement
Project costs:
Canada agrees to pay or absorb the Project costs, including:
survey for contamination and, if required, cleanup and restoration of
roadways, including infrastructure, and properties where there is reason to
believe that Historic Low-Level Radioactive Waste may exist
' T /
I�
A2 - 5
improvements to infrastructure required for the construction and operation
of the Facility including:
all reasonable capital costs related to road improvements, including
extensions, widenings, replacements, and resurfacing of roads as a
result of the development and operation of the site including
transportation routes to or from the Facility;
all reasonable capital costs related to providing or improving other
services to the site including sewage,water, and liggting;
development of the New Port Hope Waste Management Facility, in a
manner consistent with the original conceptual designs, including post-
closure recreational elements, the construction of which may be staged;
and,
- establishing an ongoing communications program to fully-inform residents
about the Project
Additional cleanup of Port Hope Industrial Waste:
Canada agrees to pay the costs of removal of certain Industrial Waste within the
Municipality of Port Hope, as earlier described in Schedule 1, the transportation
of those wastes to the New Port Hope Waste Management Facility, the
restoration, the backfilling and landscaping of the site from which the wastes
were removed
Administrative costs:
Canada agrees to reimburse to the Municipality of Port Hope, reasonable future
administrative, legal, and external communications expenses incurred from
March 29, 2001, the date Canada signed the Agreement, for the duration of the
Project i
following the signing of the Agreement, Canada and the Municipality of Port
Hope will establish a process whereby such administrative expenses will be
identified, quantified, and paid
Clarington
i
The construction of the New Port Granby Waste Management Facility.
i
i
I
I
A2 -6
Location:
the Facility will be located at or approximate to the site of the Port Granby Low-
Level Radioactive Waste Management Facility
Materials to be accommodated:
- the Facility will accommodate approximately 500,000 cubic metres of Cameco
Waste - Port Granby at the Port Granby Low-Level Radioactive Waste
Management Facility, including approximately 100,000 cubic metres of calcium
fluoride, neutralized raffinate and marginally contaminated soils and
contaminated industrial trash from the East Gorge of the current site
i
in addition, the Facility will accommodate any Historic Low-Level Radioactive
Waste located within the Municipality of Clarington as identified by surveys to be
performed by Canada.
Conceptual design:
the conceptual design is described in the Final Report of the Port Granby Low-
Level Radioactive Waste Advisory Committee entitled, Report on
Conceptualization of On-Site Low-Level Radioactive Waste Storage Facility
Designs for the Port Granby Waste Management Facility, June 28, 1999 as
Concept Design B, Option 2 as endorsed by Clarington Council
i
the conceptual design involves:
I
the construction of a groundwater diversion trench and perimeter barrier
wall on the eastern, northern, and western perimeters of the existing Port
j Granby Waste Management Facility;
the construction of an on-site mound for roughly 100,000 cubic metres of
material from the East Gorge of the current site;
- installation of an appropriate cover on the existing waste facility;
bluff stabilization and the construction of a toe berm to retard further
erosion
final designs will be completed after the detailed engineering and technical
studies which will commence at the signing of the Agreement
Project costs:
- Canada agrees to pay or absorb the Project costs, including:
i
A2- 7
improvements to infrastructure required for the construction and operation
of the new. Facility including:
I
all reasonable capital costs related to road improvements, including
extensions, widenings, replacements, and resurfacing of roads
required for the development and operation of the site;
all reasonable capital costs related to providing or improving other
services to the site including sewage, water, and lighting;
survey and, if required, cleanup and restoration of roadways and
properties where there is reason to believe that Historic Low-Level
Radioactive Waste may exist;
development of the re-engineered Facility as a site that is appropriate for
natural heritage and passive recreational uses, including the Waterfront
Trail;
establishing an ongoing communications program to fully-inform residents
about the Project
Administrative costs:
Canada agrees to reimburse to the Municipality of Clarington, reasonable future �I
administrative and legal expenses incurred from March 29, 2001, the date
Canada signed the Agreement, for the duration of the Project
following the signing of the Agreement, Canada and the Municipality of
Clarington will establish a process whereby such administrative expenses will be
identified, quantified, and paid
Other conditions:
in the consideration of Concept Design Option 62 as an alternative in the
environmental assessment process, Canada in consultation with the Municipality
of Clarington will retain consultants to examine and prepare reports on, among
other issues, the following:
the concentration of thorium-230 in the wastes located in the East Gorge;
groundwater flow through the East Gorge and contact with the wastes
deposited in the middle till and lower sands area;
potential impacts of shoreline erosion control measures on other shoreline
properties in the area; and,
i
1 1•n y
I
A2— V
a contingency plan for the relocation of the wastes, including marginally
contaminated soil, in the event of system failure
i
I
1
I
I
I
Y}1d a• { F i`k 9 1FF
ayt r+':L ^'�j
�,r fit"+r r,111�11��' Ja � 3
� .� � �• {� ,r�� ���i� � a ,'t?y t{r rF xt,�r£x ; i a �s <
'`F� I • 4.?.• '#4�a'i.i��'r� '7'}s 4 .. :. s t�v�l� I �'.': $ `,�'- ..{�L
£ 7�- ' • jLs�` � r 5 F L lCl
R
..
1 }.+z-4"'" • vy y+yF� r}S'a �.��r Y szxt� t P7-f� ;3 i J ° rt✓ s!
g1 r '._ f � j4 Yt f n'
p[Y 31 3
}� W:r,� r. ..r - � ,! c34 ,�H%� 't
IN S��Y ", at
Y n N
F"
vao•' Ips"- a :v-.� �' � �{tea�` r#a +' f:- ;_ ��wr o 'sf-a-.
Q?9r t�z: to •k - _
f
Ike
L U, :s- ; • rev f tom.»-� �r� a
; x #
"1- E t r p
YMf rr vR
-
F
rte:'.
�'L �' r�S I ttE�t'�• o @t�g ��.�.�z7,t�Y�lrt '��{1 � '� � �Y e t � A�J� ����� .,' ��
f tt11 „s 4
,4
t.
'
�^ f
1 t t } i; w `s
Y }Sari
LTWMF • Boundary d y ) b y§
LTWMF T7Er ti{tyti •— • _
• • ' 4
ZZll,, tom'